Wall Street Oasis logo


  • Recent
    • All Recent Content
    • Top WSO Bloggers
    • WSO Chat Room
    • Hot Topics - Week
    • Hot Topics - Month
    • Hot Topics - Year
    • Hot Topics - All Time
    • Top Comments - All Time
  • FAQs
    • Common Questions
    • Industry Specific
    • WSO 101
    • Education
    • Recruiting
    • Life in Finance
    • WSO Company Database
    • WSO Finance Dictionary
  • Forums
    • Post Forum Topic
    • Best Comments
    • WSO Chat Room
    • Job Search Advice
    • Investment Banking
    • Private Equity
    • Venture Capital
    • Trading
    • Consulting
    • Hedge Funds
    • Corporate Finance
    • Real Estate Finance
    • Equity Research
    • Asset Management
    • WSO Success Stories
    • Other Careers
    • Business School
    • Resume Forum
    • Wall St. Fashion
    • New User Intros
    • Monkey Around
    • WSO Products
    • Site Suggestions
  • Groups
    • Browse Groups
    • Create Group
    • My Groups
    • Non Target Networking
    • Energy Trading
    • State your salary
    • Read the Footnotes
    • Proprietary Traders
    • WSO Investment Forum
    • CFA
    • The Restructuring Group
    • Economics
    • RE Finance/Investments
  • About
    • About WSO
    • Press
    • Contact Us
    • RSS Sitemap
    • Advertise on WSO
    • WSO Discounts
    • WSO Store
  • Login
  • Sign Up!
  • Hot Topics
  • My Profile
  • Company Research
  • Modeling
  • Resume Review
  • Events
  • Interview Guides
  • Job Board
  • Intern Positions

6 Free Financial Modeling Lessons...and More.

Enter your e-mail below to get our Free Tutorials.

Wall Street Oasis » Blogs » Aswath Damodaran's blog
< previous | next >

Storms and Stocks: Dealing with Disruptive Shocks
 

Aswath Damodaran's picture
Aswath Damodaran
     
 
 
(Gorilla, 566
 
Points)
 on 11/19/12 at 1:00pm
sandy and stocks.png

Sandy, the super-storm that terrorized New York and its environs is now history, but it left a trail of destruction. As communities around the city and New Jersey dealt with power failures, gas shortage and transportation chaos, I was thinking about the lessons that I learned from the experience and their application to financial markets, which have been buffeted with their own storms for the last five years.

  1. Once is an accident, twice is bad luck, but three times is a pattern:

    For much of the time that I have lived in the United States, power failures were not only unusual but when they did occur, lasted at most for a few hours. However, in 2011, we lost power for several days twice, once after Hurricane Irene and once after a freak ice storm, and this year, we lost power again for a week. While it is entirely possible to attribute these occurrences to chance, it is also possible that weather systems have changed and that the last two years may be more the rule than the exception going forward. The last five years in financial markets have been characterized by “unusual” macro events (banking crisis, Greece, Spain etc.) but they are unusual only because we are viewing them through the lens of recent history (the prior six decades in developed markets). As with the weather, it is possible (and I think it is likely) that these macro crises are not an aberration but are part and parcel of markets for the foreseeable future, and that investment strategies and risk management systems have to be adapted accordingly.  

  2. History provides little guidance: When there is a disruptive shock (and the storm definitely qualified), it is human nature to use past history to fill in the gaps, even if it does not quite fit. Thus, my neighbors argued that since train service was up and running a couple of days after the storm last year or the terrorist attacks in 9/11, it was likely to be back up after this one too. In financial markets, investors have used the crutch of historical data (equity risk premiums from the past, PE ratios over time) to evaluate when and where to invest these last five years. In both cases, extrapolating the past would have yielded poor predictions. 
  3. Misinformation fills the news vacuum: In the immediate aftermath of the storm, there was an information vacuum where the power and transportation companies had no useful guidance to customers and rumors filled in the gap. With each macro crisis over the last few years, we have seen the same phenomenon in markets, where rumors of deals made and unmade have moved markets substantially. 
  4. It is good to have back up systems: About 15 months ago, none of the houses in my neighborhood had back-up generators, as the cost of installing one seemed to be well in excess of any potential benefits. After this storm, I would not be surprised to hear generators starting up at a third of the houses the next time we lose power. The problem, though, is that these generators are themselves dependent upon fuel (natural gas or gasoline) to work and may end up being idle in their absence. Risk managers (at companies and financial service firms) have devised their own back up systems to protect themselves against the “last” crisis but these systems may themselves break down, in the face of the next crisis. 
  5. But it is better to design resilient systems: One reason that this portion of the East Coast was hit so hard by the storm was that it was never designed to withstand it. In particular, large power-dependent houses with finished basements, power stations that are close to the ocean or rivers and overhead power lines are all rich targets for storms like Sandy. If these storms are the new norm, we have to think about building houses that are livable without power (those older houses have lower ceilings, unfinished basements and fireplaces for a reason) and a more defensible power system. In investing we have to think about a similar redesign of how we invest, with dynamic asset allocation (reflecting the constant shifts in the macro environment) and a stock selection process that is less dependent upon rules of thumb (many of which were constructed for a past that no longer applies). 

More generally, in the face of the increasing frequency of disruptive shocks, I would pick:

(a)Simpler over more complex systems: Over the last few decades, lulled by the growth of technology and access to data, we have built more and more complex systems (in both day-to-day living and investing) that are dependent upon both. Since disruptive shocks cut off both technology and data, simpler systems will survive and bounce back faster in the face of these shocks. I am glad that my investing strategy is based on intrinsic valuation and that I can value a company with an annual report and a calculator (or even an abacus) and that I am not dependent on access to real time data or computerized trading for investments. I am even happier that I could go two weeks without tracking either the market or looking at the investments in my portfolio, without fear of a meltdown. 
(b) Decentralized over centralized systems: The “hub and spoke” system, where you centralize resources does have its advantages, primarily related to efficiency, at least in normal times. The problem with these systems is that failures at the system’s center can shut the entire system down, as passengers on United and Delta discovered, when their hubs (Newark for United and LaGuardia for Delta) shut down during the storm. Decentralizing these systems may create more coordination headaches during normal time periods but allow for faster recovery after disruption.

I am glad that the storm has passed, that I have power and that I am able to type this post on my train ride home from work. At the same time, I realize that as an investor, there are more storms coming, both from within (the fiscal cliff) and from outside (Asia’s slowdown and the EU’s future) and that I need to become more agile to weather these storms. Time to get to work….

Professor of Finance at Stern Damodaran's Blog -- See my other wso posts
  •  
  •  
  •  
Tags:
  • hurricane sandy

Forum Topics

  • New
  • Active
  • Rank
  • Comments
  • Wall Street Oasis is looking for several hard working individuals to join our intern team to help with online-marketing tasks, specifically Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and link-building... ...
    Wall Street Oasis SEO Interns Needed NOW
  • I made a similar thread in the PE forum, but considering Real Estate is its own niche I figured I'd make a separate one here. If you already attended an target/ivy for undergrad, how necessary is an MBA for REPE? Do most shops expect you to get an MBA after 2 years as an associate, or do...
    MBA for REPE?
  • There have been several threads covering the value of an MBA in general in the past few months. Looking at input from experienced users on this site, it seems like the degree is most beneficial for people looking to either switch industries (Banking/Consulting), take a break, or re-brand themselves...
    MBA for PE?
  • Hey guys! Im 21, starting my last year of a non-target school in September, majoring in Economics:Finance( GPA not so good.. no really its pretty "f ing" bad, Im serious). By the time I turned 21 I got my series 7 (first shot) and 63. ( worked as a broker for your typical boutique...
    Hello, future wall street legend, (hopefully anyways)
  • Hello Fellow Monkeys, Could you help me with some suggestions of websites specially designed with market data for the pharmaceutical industry? Thanks in...
    Pharmaceutical Industry - News
  • Hey, guys i'm new to wso and i have a few questions that are very very basic to ask. What is consulting? What do consultants do? What do you do on a daily basis?...
    Very basic question about consulting?
  • Can you elaborate on life in corp...
    Banker00, the other corp banking thread went poof.
  • "payday loans are the devil!" as my mom adequately reminded me at 19 when I had to find a way to pay to get my car out of the shop. The solution? Former Google and CapitalOne exec's built this sweet little business using "big data" (everything but FICO) to determine...
    Tech + Finance = Zest?
  • <em>Mode note: Blast from the past - "Best of Eddie" - this one is originally from December 2010.</em> Monty09 may have gotten the best plug yet for his <a href="http://energyrodeo.com/">Energy Rodeo</a> in Houston next month, and it came from none...
    New York vs. Houston
  • Should I even bother with investment banking at the bulge brackets if I know that I need at least 5 hours of sleep every night in order to function properly?...
    If I NEED 5 hours of sleep to function......
  • Hi, I am looking to gain more knowledge about the structuring department and specifically the quant part. So I was wondering if anyone has any tips/start up models on where to start? Kind...
    Structuring modelling
  • http://blogs.hbr.org/fox/2013/05/just-how-useless-is-the-asset-.html Thoughts on this? Professors have been basically telling me to put my money in index funds. I think that one of asset management's roles is to pretty much make the markets more efficient through the...
    Just How Useless is the Asset-Management Industry? - HBR
  • Hi guys, I've been accepted to the schools listed above as a sophomore transfer student. I currently attend a semi-target public school and am looking to break into BB IB and eventually PE in east asia. I will be interning at a boutique ibank this summer and has done BB PWM during the school...
    Penn(CAS) vs Brown vs Northwestern
  • Currently I am a Personal Banker for Bank of America and I run my own online investment website. I also am finishing up my economics degree at San Francisco State. I want to get into wealth management or hedge funds. Any career advice on what I should...
    Career Advice for Personal Banker Looking to Get Into Corporate Finance
more

Upcoming Events

  • Advanced M&A Accounting & Tax Topics Webcast (Live)
    May 21 2013 - 6:00pm - 9:00pm
  • Boston WSO Happy Hour - Wed May 22nd, 6PM
    May 22 2013 - 6:00pm - 8:00pm
  • Financial and Valuation Modeling Boot Camp (Dallas)
    May 23 2013 - 8:00am - May 25 2013 - 5:00pm
  • Shanghai Happy Hour May 24th Friday 7:30PM - 10:30PM
    May 24 2013 - 7:30am - 10:30am
  • Hong Kong Networking Event - Happy Hour, May 24th, 7:30PM
    May 24 2013 - 7:30pm - 9:30pm
more

Highest Ranked Content

  • Week
  • Month
  • Year
  • All Time
  • Comments
I used to work with a guy that had everything on the surface, but absolutely nothing inside. The guy was 6 feet tall, good-looking, charismatic, multi-lingual, graduated from a top business school, and had made MD at a bulge bracket investment bank. Yet he couldn’t remember the last time he...
How to Develop a Personality
<em>Mod note (Andy): we vetted this user to confirm his identity/status and yes in fact he is who he says he is, and is eager to answer your questions :)</em> Bio: I decided to join WSO to help both students and young professionals advance in their Finance careers, whether that be...
I'm an MD and I run the Sales division: Ask Me Anything
I'm currently a Private Equity Analyst in Shanghai, China. Academically, I graduated from a target school majoring in Economics and Chinese. I also spent my time at college as the president of an on-campus student organization related to Finance and Economics and a volunteer for a local...
Ask me anything… I'm a Private Equity Analyst in Shanghai
You've just gotten that promotion and now you're in charge of a small team. Congratulations! And welcome to middle management. All the hard work and the knowledge you've developed about everything your firm does these past few years has been noticed. But, now you have a small...
7 Things I've Learned About Being A Manager
Assuming that you have access to no financial products such as FactSet, Bloomberg, CapitalIQ, Thomson or otherwise, thought it would be helpful to give a step by step guide on how to ramp up on a new company from your home computer. Using FaceBook as an example. Lets go ahead and start with the...
Basic Guide Ramping Up On A Company With Public Information (Part 1 of 3)
Fellow Primates, We are looking for 1-2 students on each campus to help WSO in its sales efforts to student clubs/career centers, and overall promotion at your school both online and on the ground. Below is a description of the position and benefits...thanks in advance for your help! <a...
WSO is Looking for Campus Reps For Summer/Fall 2013 (and beyond)
<em>“You know, In The Flesh,”</em> a WSO monkey told me at a recent Happy Hour, <em>“that gentleman’s book is the real deal. I ordered that shit on Amazon as soon as I read your review. It’s so right, man. I want to be like that: keep my word, honor my commitments, be...
Being A Gentleman, Revisited
<em>Mod Note: This is a syndication from Jared's Daily Dirtnap daily market newsletter. WSO readers qualify for a $100 discount...just email [email protected] and mention "WSO Monkey Discount" You can follow Jared on twitter at @dailydirtnap</em> There I go...
In Praise Of High Interest Rates
Hello - In the spirit of my previous <a href="http://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forums/practical-tips-for-entering-1st-year-ibd-analysts">post</a>, I've provided the below information. Note that the tips are geared toward IBD analysts recruiting for the buyside and are...
7 Practical Buyside Recruiting Tips for IBD Analysts
You guys are gonna have to get me caught up because I have literally been living in a cave for the past week. Well, several caves, but I'll get to that in a minute. I just got back from what was possibly the <em>least</em> relaxing (but most interesting) vacation of my life. In...
I Spent the Past Week in a Cave
more

Recent Jobs

  • M-Payments Start-up: Chief of Staff & Business Development Manager
  • Venture Capital Associate - Austin, TX
  • Associate - Philadelphia
  • Vice President, Investment Banking Credit Division
  • Fund Accountant - Chicago
more



Sell Tickets Online through Eventbrite

Poll

Why would you NOT go to the 2013 WSO Conference? :
View the current poll results.

Silver Banana Rankings

  • Silver Banana Leaders
  • Soiled Monkeys
UserSilver Bananas
Edmundo Braverman1112
TNA1094
CompBanker873
happypantsmcgee742
IlliniProgrammer715
UFOinsider628
TheKing620
BlackHat563
Nouveau Richie420
cphbravo96404
more

Top WSO Members

  • Total Bananas
  • Active Monkeys
UserBanana Points
Edmundo Braverman14318
TNA13467
WallStreetOasis.com12033
UFOinsider10300
happypantsmcgee9621
IlliniProgrammer9177
CompBanker8504
Siberian Husky5862
AndyLouis5784
monty095398
more

New Groups

  • Denver Professionals
  • Minneapolis Bankers
  • Non-Target Networking in NYC
  • Prep School Bankers
  • Commercial Real Estate
  • University of London
  • University of Cambridge
  • Atlanta Monkeys
  • German Monkeys
  • University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill
more

© 2006-2012 WallStreetOasis.com | All Rights ReservedAdvertise | About Us | Contact Us | FAQs | Site Map | Privacy Policy

As Seen In

Sister Site

Syndicate content