Macbook for banking?
Hey everyone,
I'm going to be starting FT next summer in banking. I'll have a Windows based desktop at home, but will need a laptop for when I travel. Does anyone know if its possible to use a Macbook to log-in via VPN / Citrix? Please only respond if you have first-hand experience (i.e. you interned this summer and actually saw bankers use a macbook, etc.).
I'm thinking about buying a Macbook Pro in the near future, but won't commit unless I'll be able to use it when I'm on the road.
macs are whack
Banks usually give you laptops.
If you plan on dual booting to a Windows OS from the Macbook then yes, this is a feasible idea. If you plan on using OSX (which is a fine OS for individuals) then I'll resist the urge to mock your knowledge of computers and just let you know straight up: no, this is not a good idea.
Two things:
1.) Your bank will give you a laptop, so this is irrelevant. 2.) I love my Mac. I use it every day, and I'm posting from it right now. That said - it is terrible for work. MS Office on Mac is terrible. No keyboard shortcuts, clunky interface. PowerPoint formats sometimes don't transfer exactly right. Plus most VPN clients don't work on OS X. If you want to get Excel/PPT work done, you'll need to dual boot Windows.
How certain are you that banks give laptops? Maybe it's because I was at a regional office, but at the BB that I interned at, everyone used their own laptops and logged in remotely. That might just be due to personal preference though.
IBM Thinkpad FTW
Lenovo (IBM) Thinkpad is the standard thing to use at work - at least in my experience. If you've got the spare $$$ get a macbook pro to use outside the office (because it's way better), but excel and other such things don't work as well on mac.
In a pinch - get an thinkpad (or get your bank/office to buy you one) and then get an ipad. With the ipad you can still enjoy the mac way of life / do most personal use things (especially if u get a keyboard), without paying 2G's for yet another huge and heavy laptop.
The new macbook air could be another viable option for a second computer. It's so small you could carry that and a small thinkpad (X sereis, etc) and it would be similar to carrying one regular sized thinkpad (like a T500 which is the one i have - it's powerful but heavy as shit).
I go with the t500 (company) and an ipad (personal). It's not ideal, but I can easily carry both in a normal sized briefcase and without throwing out my back every time i walk through an airport.
Windows
Dude, go install Linux. Their platfom is way more stable than Mac's OS and Windows. One thing people don't tell or just don't know is that when certain programs like Flash for example are installed on the computer, they actully cause certain programs to crash while working. I would have rather gone, gotten Linux for free, installed it on my old PC laptop than spending 2 grand on a Macbook. Just get Linux and invest the 2 grand.
You should buy a macbook, because they are good computers. You should not use a macbook for work, because they suck for work and your bank will give you a laptop. You stated that you will have a Windows desktop at home, so could VPN in with that. You would then presumably only be using a laptop when you travel. If you are travelling for work, you will be provided with a laptop. If you are referring to personal travel, firstly, that isn't happening, and secondly, you should not be worried about connecting by VPN while you're on vacation.
Hey everyone,
Should I bring a knife to a gunfight? Thoughts? I know guns are like more powerful, but like, this is totally a cool knife and and my friends have it.
Don't get the mac bro.
You can set up Boot Camp on a Mac and you basically have a PC. If you really like using the internet and other basic stuff (maybe even the media stuff like photos, videos, etc.) on the Mac, go with that and just set up Boot Camp. Best of both worlds and you can model all you want.
I guess maybe if you think it's possible to do anything practical with a mac keyboard, you could do that. Or you could stick a dirty shiv in to your kidneys
I had one while interning.
Firstly, Macs are shit, don't get one, even just for fun.
Anyway, Citrix worked. So did the Java remote access. However, there were serious problems with the keyboard - I had to buy an external windows keyboard because the slightly different format just completely screwed up the keys (ie. Shift, ctrl, alt) on remote access. I managed to get Shift working through Java, but still major problems with basic short cuts like ctrl c
I've logged in remotely with a friend's mac book several times, its fine but fuckin annoying because you cant right click, the F keys are annoying because you need to hit the function key, etc... its in general just fuckin clumsy. If you want to be non-graphics/media professional get a fucking PC, or if you're one of those homos who is dying for Steve Jobs to massage your prostate with his meat stick, then buy a PC laptop for work related stuff and a Mac Book to wack off to gay porn. Also, almost all banks have loaner laptops for traveling.
FYI... when I spent 4 days on a ski trip and had to log into work from my friends mac book, when I got back to work it took some getting used to back on a normal keyboard again. Just an FYI... I can't imagine it not impacting your speed and efficinecy, having to hop back and forth from PC to Mac.
Mac supports vpn. But you need to configure it properly. Read the following guide: bestvpnservice. com/blog/how-to-setup-vpn-on-mac-osx
Macbook Pro, not so? (Originally Posted: 12/03/2013)
So I'll be starting FT this june at a BB IBD, and I was curious to see what you monkeys use for your computing needs while away from the desk.
At my uni, everyone uses a variation on the Macbook- myself included. To be honest, I feel like all windows laptops are inferior and can't see myself switching over, but my one concern is being able to proficiently use excel at home once I hit the desk.
So monkeys, anyone making it by with a MBP or do you rock windows machines through and through?
You will not be able to use Mac. The XLS keyboard shortcuts do not translate to their machines, which make them useless for banking. All you need is a cheap laptop where you can log-in to your desktop machine via Java. Macbook Pro has a lot of firepower and software that you do not need. Just get a basic machine that can handle MS Office and surfing the net. Plenty of laptops like this are available on Amazon for $6-800.
Or keep your MBP, set up Bootcamp and get a Windows copy of Excel, best of both worlds!
P.S You may need an external keyboard but it's still better then using a PC!
I just started running Windows Excel on a macbook air with Parallels thanks to this forum. To those of you who have been running this setup for a while and have keyboard customizations dialed in, would you mind sharing those?
I've been using the old excel shortcuts forever so little things like not having the alt button beside the spacebar are throwing me off. Thanks in advance for sending over any keyboard customizations you made in Parallels Desktop > Preferences.
I am still a student but here are my two-cents: Any kind of key shortcuts exist on both windows and mac excel that I have ever need. That said, I am not a professional (yet hopefully!). It just means that you have to memorize two different sets of shortcuts.
Anyone tried running parallels? I would image that that works? You can turn on the F keys and I would assume all would be fine?
Depending on how you use it (since it is at home, perhaps it is not for work):
Windows: Any MS Office Products, Programming, Efficiency without a mouse
Mac: Anything else. Mac is great for music, browsing, photos, and general email use in the web browser.
Or set up parallels or boot camp on your mac, although Mac's are extremely expensive when it comes to performance per dollar, so it could be unnecessary. I have a Lenovo ThinkPad for on the go and work purposes and then a Mac desktop for at home general use.
If you got through college fine with a Mac, they did a horrible job teaching you Excel.
Haha, this is largely true. If you like using the stupid mouse to do everything, Mac is for you. If you are proficient in Excel, Mac is an absolute nightmare. A) Shortcut keys on Mac are nearly useless. B) Navigating the "palette" is one of the most time wasting, frustrating things you can do when you're used to flying through menial tasks.
Basically, you could probably get by with Mac. However, if you actually want to finish your shit in a timely manner, it's the most tedious activity ever. Substance > style IMO
Edit: I actually had an Excel class in a Mac lab once a week, so I figured out some of the "shortcuts", but the most efficient ones (read: PC) are just not there I think.
your bank should provide a laptop for when you work remotely so this should not be an issue. When I started in banking a few years ago,I purchased a windows laptop and never once used it once for work.
You're not using it for work, ever. No bank would allow that. Get whatever you want. You'll get a work laptop when you start.
Are work laptops for home-use monitored at all? My laptop got stolen a week ago, can I just use the work laptop for anything I want or do I need to buy one for personal use.
Windows XP dual-booting on a Macbook Pro. Can't beat it.
Side question, do any of you bring your laptop into the office?
There really isn't a major difference. PC will make you a lot more efficient and at a better price. You can make it work with a MAC if you're clever enough and willing to put in some extra time. There really isn't ever a reason to pay extra for a Mac except for preftige and better screen.
Both OS are horrible, 8.1 has been a disaster and Mavericks is designed for retards.
Win excel to mac excel is what a lambo to a honda accord is. The only way to use mac excel correctly is to use Bootcamp and a external windows based keyboard.
But again, your work will give you a company laptop.
Interesting idea about using Parallels/Bootcamp with an external keyboard. Has anyone tried that and found all the keyboard shortcuts to be recognized with no problem?
Thanks for the heads up guys. I'll try to dual boot for now.
Don't be a pussy and buy a Lenovo for like $600.
You don't want to get made fun of, do you?
NO. NO. NO.
Don't get a macbook. I'm assuming you're trying to remote in from home when you have 1-2 hours of work during the weekend, not for traveling purposes (like some mentioned above). Yes, you can request a laptop when you're traveling. Doing work remotely is already slow on a PC, so I would think running bootcamp and then remoting in will slow it down even more, though I've never tried. Just get a PC now and start getting used to playing around in excel. You can buy a cheap and decent one for ~$300 during the holidays. You don't want to be "THAT" guy who has no idea how to use a PC because he's been using a macbook his entire year. Save the embarrassment and go purchase a cheap laptop. If anything, you can keep your macbook for personal use and have a laptop on the side for whenever you have work, but I say that's just a waste of money.
... What? 1. A bank will issue you a laptop during training which you will be using while traveling or at home during weekends. You are never to use a personal laptop to work with a company's excel shells. 2. Have you worked in a bank? Trust me just because you use a MBP for personal use you will be perfectly capable of memorizing excel shortcuts as the 4 hours of personal MBP use on a weekend is not going to trump the 50 or so hours you spend in an office tinkering with models. Calling a person that uses a MBP for personal use "that guy" just makes you sounds clueless. 3. The new specifications on the MBP and even the prior generations of MBP were perfectly capable of running bootcamp no problems (The delay in remote access -- even though you would not use a personal computer to remote access an office computer -- would be hindered by internet connection most likely). I recall running a demanding device on AutoCAD 3D while running bootcamp on a prior generation of macbook air with only slight delay.
Your last sentence just makes you sound like a Windows fanboy. People are asking for credible information from people currently in the industry and really don't need misinformation from the original topic you misunderstood from the industry experience you don't have. I think the current question for anyone who has experience is can a MBP use bootcamp and an external USB keyboard to use windows based excel shortcuts?
lol @ dual-boot. So you want to run a copy of Windows @ 50% capacity on a system built to appeal to aesthetics, not function?
I don't understand why people are recommending OP dual-boot the Mac. Not like you're going to be dicking around on Excel models with your personal computer, and Office is literally the only reason I can think of for installing Windows.
Agree w/this. No reason to run parallels. Windows blows on Macs and you aren't going to be working remotely on a Macbook.
i'd advise you against it, just for the sole fact that you will use a PC at work. if you want to have some apple products anyway, go get an iphone and an ipad.
I know most of these posts are old, but just want to caution anyone reading this: do NOT assume that you'll automatically get a work-issued laptop. This is absolutely NOT the case at every bank.
Macbook Air? (Originally Posted: 07/18/2012)
So my 4 year old laptop finally crashed on me after a slew of problems. I'm thinking of getting an Macbook but Apple discontinued the standard model and now the only options are Macbook Pros and Macbook Airs.
I'm not trying to start a mac vs pc war here, I just want to know if anyone here has either of the newer models here and could vouch for them.
I'll be mainly using the laptop for school btw.
If you're in school and you don't own a Mac you are by definition lower-class / uncool. Is this even a question?
haha, don't buy a mac... get something that runs excel properly for half the price, you don't need to follow the hipster herd
As always, it depends on what you think you'll be using it for in school. I've used one (borrowed a friend's) and liked it a lot - very sleek, smooth, etc. It's easy these days to install Windows on one. For me, though, I just don't like the keyboard layout and prefer to get a better deal on a PC, especially because I like swapping parts out. I mean it really just comes down to you going to a store, trying different models, and seeing what you think is best for yourself, though.
I think Air is better if you're in school. Easier to carry around for classes. If you want to stay with windows, check out Sony Vaio Z series. A bit pricey, but it's definitely one of the top PCs out there.
If you have around $1k to spend on a laptop, I genuinely believe the Macbook Air is the best one on the market. It is the best combination of performance, portability, endurance and design. Yes there are many competing "ultrabooks" out there but the reason none of them has seen fantastic success is they simply aren't as good.
Note that Excel for Mac is terrible, but you can Boot Camp into Windows extremely easily (or Paralllels is even easier). The only argument against buying a Mac computer nowadays is the price, but all ultrabooks are priced around the same so even that argument goes out of the window.
When configuring your computer I'd recommend a few things: - You cannot upgrade anything in the future, so splash out a bit extra to future-proof your laptop. 4GB of RAM comes as standard nowadays but upgrading to 8GB for $100 is decent if you use a lot of applications at once
128gb of flash drive space is the minimum really, considering the OS takes up about 10GB. You will soon be able to buy an SD drive called 'Nifty' (search it on KickStarter) which looks fantastic and will add a lot of storage expansion space
If you're going for a 13" MBA, get an i7 processor. It will be worth it
The model I recommend is as follows: MBA 11" 2.0 GHz i7 processor (upgrade) 8GB RAM (upgrade) 128gb flash storage Total cost - $1,349
If you're willing to wait a few months, you might be able to pick up a refurb version for a 20% discount. Make sure it is a 2012 model though so you get the large benefits of the Ivy Bridge processors.
but couldn't i get a 13" macbook pro for lower price with a better processor and larger hard drive for less?
don't buy a mac
Get the Air. Excel for Mac just takes getting used to but isn't terrible (you can customize your shortcuts, which goes a long way.) The Air is seriously awesome and insanely light.
HP Envy, either Spectre the new 15" (I have one). No need for an air..get an ipad
Mac OS is retarded anyways
I got the Macbook Air a year and a half ago and it has been fantastic - I highly recommend it. I have taken it on various trips and haven't had a single problem.
Go for it. Windows laptops are just horrible, especially the trackpad.
I bought a late 2008 air and really liked it, size was good and relatively good processing power (at the time). The only main problem is that it tended to overheat often which results in the processor being throttled back slowing everything done. Would hope they've fixed this issue, but interested to hear if anyone with a new model notices the heat.
also if anyone has comments on 11" vs. 13" would be interested
how long did it last you? if i'm gonna drop 1 grand on laptop i want it to be able to use for more than 2 or 3 years
*a Macbook
Air. I have one and so does the GF. Fantastic machines.
Just bought the new 13'' MacBook pro a month ago, and I love it. For the few things I actually need Windows for, I run Fusion, and I don't have any complaints so far. (The MacBook pro I had before that lasted ~5 yrs.)
Got a Dell XPS 13 for $800+tax with i7, 256GB SSD and 4GB Ram. Refurbed with 25% off coupon. If you are looking for something light with decent built and cheap, just keep an eye out.
128 GB of hard drive space is a fail especially if you want to put Windows on it. There's one USB port. The ones I've dealt with had only 2 GB of RAM which is horrendous. Needless to say I find them to be severely underpowered. Of course Macs are insanely overpriced for the hardware and Airs are even worse than usual. Granted, I find they have the highest quality control for laptops, but that's saying a lot more about the other laptop manufacturers than Apple. Another plus is that Macs are perfect if you don't know anything about computers because you have an actual storefront to go to. The solid state hard drive is fast as hell, which is perfect for when you install Windows because you realize that OS X is a useless operating system. [When that day comes, don't be an idiot. Use Boot Camp.]. But $1k+ for a computer with a 1.7ghz processor and a 120gb hard drive is almost criminal. Another $100 will get you a MacBook Pro which, while still a rip-off by most standards, is a way better value and is lighter in weight than basically every other laptop.
Hackintosh, bro!
The air is so thin that it cuts my stomach if i use it while laying down.
How has the thinkpad been since IBM stopped making the hardware for it. Are Lenovo that good? We don't even get them down this way.
Mine's lying on my lap at the moment. No problems. My wrists sometimes though.
I've had a mac air since about november 2008. It was first gen, so it's had problems with the hinge which cost me $800 to fix, and the battery is now due for a reinstall. Also having problems with the microphone on it, and it couldn't handle photoshop well.
Besides that, it got me through business school and law school quite well, and it was lightweight, petite, and seriously, I still get complements on it years later. I would probably repurchase get one for my next laptop again, or a Samsung series 9.
I won't settle for anything less than a ultrabook with a flash drive now after having the mac, because I hate restarting my computer and downtime, and I like how light it is.
If you do end up getting one, make sure it has the samsung hardrive, and not the toshiba. Rumour is they shipped with both, and the samsung runs twice as fast.
Lenovo's thinkpads are great for business - running multiple processes/programs. Standard issue at pretty much every consulting firm, investment bank (the one's that issue laptops) and other finance roles. Look you'll realize it when you're having 6-7 internet windows open - scrolling through multiple SEC filings, internet news sites, research shizz while simultaneously running a model in excel, typing up a memo in word and putting together a PPT deck (multiple files of each program are open). You'll need the horsepower.
Main thing is this whether you're a student or business professional - this computer will last. You can even download music on this thing, hook it up to 2 LCD monitors, etc. All for a price that's less than the macbooks. Imagine that you're traveling for work or on vacation and you take your laptop with you, you get staffed while on vacay (it f*n happens), and all of a sudden you need to start cranking out presentations and models, you'll be glad you have the thinkpad. Also, average battery life is solid, but definitely shell out for the extended battery.. worth it..
I got my first Mac the MBA 2 weeks ago. Love it. Upgrade the RAM to 8 gigs and you should be set for some time.
get a thinkpad.. seriously bro get a thinkpad.. only get the mac if you're going to be a photographer or videographer or something artistic..
I have a 13" MacBook Air. I love it. I've always been opposed to the OS system, but we're at a point now where you can get nearly identical functionality out of Macs and PCs. From a hardware perspective, the MBA is unbeatable. It will not break (I've tried)! I think the MBA is the future of laptop computers, and eventually, the MacBook Pro and MacBook Air will become the same product (a year and a half from now). My MBA is more capable than the MacBook Pros of just a year ago.
I think the i5 processor is the way to go. If you search around the net, you'll see that the drop in performance between the i5 and i7 is minimal, and the i5's battery will last you 20-30% longer. I run the full Adobe MasterCollection Suite, with no hiccups. Any program loads and is ready to go in less than a second. I had to wait 30 seconds for some of the Adobe programs to load on my 2 year old Windows laptop.
If you wait a few months, I think there will be a newer generation of MBAs coming out with retina displays. However, we've pretty much reached the limit of processing capacity in terms of what processors will give you these days, so if you get the MBA today, you won't be in need of a new laptop for years to come.
Switching to a Macbook for work? (Originally Posted: 12/14/2014)
I am going to make a move out of PE for a while to work for a start-up (who doesn't nowadays right?), and face the decision whether to choose a Macbook (air or pro) or a Windows ultrabook as my new tool of the trade. This would be the 1 computer used for both work and personal stuff.
Have been reading some reviews, but seeing as nobody is more diligent than a banker, I would like to ask you guys for your opinion. I know the screens on the ultrabooks are better, but battery life on the macbook air is much better. Besides, everyone knows that using a windows laptop to pitch your startup is like wearing brown shoes to your BB interview.
Joking aside, my main concern with Apple is that I have been a Windows user my whole life (I actually even know how MS DOS works) and I am pretty hardcore when it comes to avoiding use of the mouse. I can already see myself ending-up working from a Windows partition on my Macbook and still being annoyed by all the keys being in different places.
Anyone similar who switched and can comment on this?
I am not even at your level in terms of windows/excel use (incoming IB analyst) and switched from a Macbook to Windows after my SA because I couldn't stand using excel on Mac after it. It truly sucks.
I've been using mac for personal use for the past 10 years. Pages and Keynote are actually great alternatives to Word and Powerpoint (which are also available on mac). Browsing the internet and trying to get research/emails/non-excel work done on a Mac is actually much faster and more intuitive. 13" Macbook Airs are really light, run really fast for their given specs and are the most aesthetically pleasing laptops out there (ignore the Pros). However, Excel on the Mac sucks big time. All the shortcuts are different, some functions behave differently and Data Analysis isn't built in. Solutions are: Either you partition the hard drive, which sucks because it takes up so much space for just one application, or you run Windows Excel via the Crossover app, which is tricky to do and not always stable (but still feasible for work). Oh, and Apple's attempt at Excel, called Numbers, is not worth ever opening.
delete
Excel on Mac is far less convenient than on WIndows. And Numbers (and other iWork apps actually) is more suitable for visual presentation than number crunching. Keynote beats PowerPoint anytime.
Excel on Mac is far less convenient than on WIndows. And Numbers (and other iWork apps actually) is more suitable for visual presentation than number crunching. Keynote beats PowerPoint anytime.
Before everyone gets on the boat of shitting on excel for mac. We should be asking just what in the hell you are going to be doing at your new job. Because if you don't have to use excel every hour at your job than it really comes down to personal preference. Forget the "look at how hipster I am I use a mac and work at a start up" image. I take pitches from start ups at least twice a week for funding. I couldn't care less what kind of computer they have. If they have the nicest computer out there but have a shit idea. I tell them to quit wasting my damn time. In other words who gives a fuck what people think of your computer choice. Just build a good product.
Relax amigo, I trust most people realized that part was a joke.
However you bring up a good point:
I have an iPhone and iPad so am well pulled into the Apple eco system and I like both devices so do not intend to switch. The hand-off / working together features will be nice.
Garageband (on iPad) is a hobby of mine so I am going to enjoy the higher power version on a Mac.
I like the way the Macbook looks and the keyboard/mousepad seem to be superior to any I have encountered on a Windows laptop.
Snow's reaction on everything non-excel being nicer on Mac is a very useful comment and might help tip the scale.
However part of my job will be tracking sales, growth, analysis, slicing/dicing of sales, keeping track of stuff (timelines, budgets, HR). Then there's pitches which will include some tables and graphs. All of this I cannot imagine doing with any other program than excel. So no, I won't be using it every hour (thankfully) but it will be an often used program if only for my unfamiliarity with any alternative.
Even for personal matters right? Budgets, tax shit, student debt amortization, investments, on and on all things I have used excel for. That excel is less convenient on mac is in my view an undeniable fact.
So a better phrasing of my question would be: "I would prefer to get a Macbook for various reasons but am concerned the productivity tools are so much less convenient that it negates the advantages. Who can comment from experience"?
You're not really in the Apple ecosystem until you have a Macbook to serve as your HQ. The best bang for your buck will come from a Mac, I'd personally recommend the 15" MBP. You can get a custom one from Apple with a 2.8ghz i7 and up to 1TB of flash storage. If having excel is THAT big a deal you can partition that disk, and you wouldn't need more than 200gb to install Windows 8.1 for when you need to use excel. (My MBP has 750gb storage, and I got my first ever notification about low storage after 3 years of use. 2gb left and there was literally no lagging or other problems BC of that).
If you don't want to do that, then you can always build a desktop yourself (for less than $800) that'd be a lean, mean, excel machine.
Other than that, the only Windows laptop I'd ever consider getting is the Yoga 2 with the i7 that can be overclocked to 3.0ghz.
For the kind of cash you drop on a Mac, it's worth it since you'll have it for AT LEAST 4 years. Can't really say the same about native Windows laptops, they'll crap out earlier than that.
LOL
I use VMWare fusion (get the home version) and can run windows simultaneously with Mac on my Air. I use windows only for MS Office but mac programs for every thing else. It works great.
I saw a colleague run something like this but never got around to asking.
Thanks for the heads up, but although I like Windows as an OS, I think Apple hardware just feels better overall in terms of quality.
Is it really that hard to install Windows on a Macbook?...
Takes less than 5 min to set up + whatever the install time on Win 8.1 is.
I've been running Mac's for more than 10 years and couldn't imagine going back. I also haven't personally been a heavy excel user (I really don't build models anymore), but the guys in my office who are the heavy excel guys don't seem to mind it. We do run Parallels so I don't know if running it in its native operating environment makes it run exactly like it would in Windows, but when I open it in OS whatever version it is now it seems to work well.
Other than that, the syncing between my iphone and ipad is simply too convenient to ignore and everything else on a Mac just works better.
I personally feel that if you trap yourself into any one ecosystem you might as well cut your own balls off because you now have 0 choice as to what you can buy. Kind of like getting married.
I bought a PC that I use solely for Excel. MB Air for everything else though.
This is tough. I have been using windows forever. I totally agree with you regarding MSDOS also. Remember Tandy and the only actual floppy disks?
Personally, if you have to do excel work and operate in a financial modeling type environment I would stick with windows. Get a thinkpad or something. I have an X61 that I have used reliably for 7 years. You just can't kill that thing. I just got an Mac Book Air and let me say this, for personal use I am 1000% a Apple convert. Like I was a huge hater of Mac. Not any more. I literally MIGHT get an Iphone again (although will most likely stay with Droid).
That being said, I used Windows at work and couldn't imagine being 100% Apple in work and outside.
If you're working at a startup and you see even the SLIGHTEST possibility of needing to jump in with code, you gotta go with an MBP, probably 15". Unix is just way more powerful.
I have a Mac for personal use and windows computer for excel only. Why do you have to have one over the other? Why not get both? That's my logic!
@"MBA_Junkie" hit on the head. I had been an avid Windows user until 2010 and bought a Macbook Pro. The current Macbooks are very slick machines and with VMWare it is the most stable Windows environment that I have experienced. I have Visual Studio, Office 2013, Project 2013 and Windows 10 beta installed. It is a little weird when utilizing advanced features on Office but you can get adjusted fairly quickly. Good luck!!!
Like you, I have been a Windows user my entire life and use shortcuts constantly in Excel. Also, IMO the Mac version of Excel just doesn't cut it.
I run Boot Camp with Windows 7 on a 15-inch MBP and couldn't be happier. It has taken some time for me to adjust to the keyboard, but it hasn't been THAT annoying.
If you do go this route, you might need Trackpad++ (cost: $15) to properly configure your trackpad. I found the trackpad to be unusable until I installed Trackpad++ , which allows you to use the Mac gestures will running Windows. Highly recommend it.
Windows + MBP = best software + best hardware
Like you, I have been a Windows user my entire life and use shortcuts constantly in Excel. Also, IMO the Mac version of Excel just doesn't cut it.
I run Boot Camp with Windows 7 on a 15-inch MBP and couldn't be happier. It has taken some time for me to adjust to the keyboard, but it hasn't been THAT annoying.
If you do go this route, you might need Trackpad++ (cost: $15) to properly configure your trackpad. I found the trackpad to be unusable until I installed Trackpad++ , which allows you to use the Mac gestures will running Windows. Highly recommend it.
Windows + MBP = best software + best hardware
I've faired pretty well doing everything I need to do on my Macbook Air. I use Sketch, which is a mac only app, for creating wireframes, workflows, and mockups and use google's spreadsheet app for any light excel work I need to do (everything is shared via google drive). If I want to do any serious excel work for a long period of time then I use VMWare to run Excel via Windows. I keep my laptop on a stand and use a regular keyboard and bluetooth mouse when I want to work on models. I do some digging around in the code base as well so I prefer to work in a unix environment when running new code from a local server.
Cannot stand Windows unless I have to use it...if you really need Windows Office that badly, as others have said, get an MBP and partition ~100 gigs for a Windows 8.1 install + office + whatever other stuff you need to put there. And then use OS X for everything else. Apple makes the best Windows computers after all. Personalty, I am a huge fan of OS X as it's just much more stable and user-friendly than Windows. Also more attractive.
I faced a similar dilemma to you & went with the Macbook Pro. I needed the Windows version of Excel since I didn't want to learn the Mac shortcuts, but also needed the Mac side for a bit of python coding. I'm very happy with my machine - the Mac runs Windows better than any Windows computer I've ever owned.
As others have said, it's incredibly easy to install Parallels to boot into Windows to use the Office Suite. In the current edition of Parallels, you can literally open Excel as if it was another Mac program. You can also adjust the keyboard so that things like alt & ctrl are in the same spot you're used to for shortcuts. If you set it up correctly, you won't know you're using MS Excel on a Mac. PM if you want any more info on this.
Personally having used both. The whole Apple makes the best hardware, is nonsesne. I have had just as many pcs die on me as I have had macs. Its not some magic dust they have over there at Apple, it is simply a matter of market share. When you have little market share you have less need to worry about malicious code that actually corrupts and "kills" a computer. Sub standard hardware is an issue but if you have any brains you would actually compare a MBP priced windows laptop and find that they have very similar quality hardware components. I would actually give the nod to the Windows laptop at an even dollar comparison because the windows ecosystem as a whole has lower profit margins thus has more expensive and better quality hardware inside.
I have had 2 PCs die on me and 2 macs die on me. The PCs had minor (failed ram) to mid major issues (hard disk failure). The Macs had mid major (hard disk failure) to a major issues (logic board failure i.e. the motherboard failed and took most of the other components with it). If you properly maintain your computer you will likely have just as many issues on both sides. With the huge success of the iOS environment in 1st world countries malicious code is now being produced to attack the Apple ecosystem iOS and OSX. Those days of my Mac doesn't get viruses is over. You are actually more likely to get malicious code on a Mac now because there aren't as many people looking out for new signatures and actively putting out patches for it.
Thanks everyone for your contributions. I'm going with Mac + parallels, see how it goes.
@"keg1797" I bet I can figure it out once I get my hands on the thing but if not I will definitely PM.
Are MacBooks appropriate for finance? (Originally Posted: 05/06/2015)
Whats the consensus on MacBooks for IB and related finance careers. Not sure if it matters, but I'm a man so it might make it even more emasculating. Again, not sure if the hipster option is safe here.
I'm really wondering if I can hold on to my MacBook Air from college or I better run to ThinkPad. You guys got any recommendations for computers, both for continued use in college and career wise?
Almost all of your work will be done on a company computer for security reasons. In my experience even when we had work from home it had to be done on a company issued laptop. For a personal computer just go with whatever you like more
Use whatever you want for your home computer. Your IB firm will give you a PC laptop with Windows for work. With respect to your college question, familiarity with Windows based excel is helpful, but not necessary.
man i let go of my bloody mac and got a Dell for windows before i started my stint due to advice on this site
havent used it the damn Dell for work even ONCE.
I once did a short modelling course on my mac after the screen fell off on my old Sony Viao. It was torture.
You won't use your personal computer.
Ps are sure you're okay with your masculinity?
OP eats really chocolatey foods, all the time
If you work in Texas and sport around suave Apple products from your college years, at least one out of two people is going to think you're a sissy boy
I'm an Apple man through and through.
That said...
Plan is to also have windows on my mac so if I ever have to use excel or some other windows program I'll have the right software anyways. Problem solved?
I downloaded the beta for MS Office 2016 and it's much closer to Windows. Pivot tables work fine but pivot charts are a disaster and VBA isn't even working right now, but at least you can now use the F keys and control instead of command. It's a work in progress and likely to really close the gap with the official release later this year, but it's not there yet.
Got a couple feedback points.
If you've got a job it's entirely irrelevant because you aren't going to use your personal laptop for work.
If you don't have a job yet then a strongly recommend against it for two reasons. As already mentioned, the Mac versions of Excel don't work all that well. Not only does some of the advanced functionality not work (which includes some that you need as an excel monkey), but the different keyboard/mouse functionality impacts the shortcuts that you're going to learn in any training course.
While you could install Windows it's a bit dicey. Me and my wife were LTR awhile during our engagement, so we had the bright idea to try to have some fun by playing a co-op puzzle game together. She tried loading Windows 8 in bootcamp on her computer to make it work. The result was that it bricked her laptop and she had to get a sibling who works in IT to wipe her hard drive in order to make it work.
Overall keep in mind how the systems are designed. Microsoft's ecosystem has historically been built to offer more capability to power users and high degrees of customization at the expense of stability, ease of use, and the user experience. Previously Apple catered to people who worked in graphics and media design, but more recent Apple designs lack the display quality, cooling capacity, and processing ability to compete with current PC-based systems.
The current incarnation of Apple computers are designed primarily for recreational users, which is something you need to be cognizant of when considering a purchase. That doesn't mean they're bad systems but neither the user interface nor the hardware is optimized for business or professional uses.
Everyone saying a Mac and Windows is a bad idea is full of shit. My 15" machine is running Windows right now and it runs better than on my Lenovo. You can dual boot or use a VM or use one as both (which is what I do). If you were born after the year 1984 and can figure out how to insert a pie chart into a PowerPoint, you'll be okay, believe it. The guy saying "wipe hard drive" like it's a feat of science fiction clearly doesn't know what it does.
Thanks Asshat. Since you're talking to a guy who assembled his first tower from the ground up at the age of ten and passed the certified technician exam (A+ certification) at age 11, you can bet your ass that he knows what a hard drive does. I also was responsible for tech support and security for the students in my section during college(without getting into details, it's a school that uses a system similar to MBA cohorts).
If you knew as much as you think you do you'd know that "wiping the hard drive" is almost universally used slang for reformatting a drive. The fact that you don't know that tells me that (most likely) you've never actually worked on a tech support issue with other people.
The point that it worked great for you also isn't the issue. We recently had a discussion on this in our MBA class's group, and there were a couple of people who tried it. A couple said it worked great, and about a third of the people posting said they experienced major problems attempting it. Admittedly your odds are better with the newer macs but you're still rolling the dice.
Now now, no need for the name calling. I meant that YOU don't know what wiping a hard drive is/does. If you did, you'd know that it takes 20 minutes to do and any high school freshman can do it. And no, the "odds" wouldn't be better with a newer Mac because basic filesystem technology hasn't changed much in the last 25 years.
And btw, touting the A+ at age 11 is like saying someone skipped the 7th grade. I got the A+ at 14. It's really not a big deal dude. Maybe even you could pass it. I guess my point stands: the naysayers don't know what they're talking about.
"it takes 20 minutes to do and any high shool freshman can do it"....while I'm busy bowing at how vast your intellect is compared to my cockroach-like mind, let me point out that you're vastly understating the hassle that goes along with what amounts to a factory reset.
That "20 minutes" is just how long it takes the machine to clear the hard drive. It does NOT countthe time to re-install and re-configure an OS, which can easily take another two hours if your setup is such that you have to download and install manufacturer provided drivers for your components. That figure in turn doesn't account for the time it takes to reconstruct specific user settings and re-install any programs that you use on a regular basis.
Second exactly what on earth does filesystem have to do with it? Who said it was a filesystem issue? From what I was told the problem had to do with a new version of whatever dual-boot solution they were using not liking old versions of MacOS.
Also: exactly how the hell did you conclude that I don't know what "wiping a hard drive" does? Saying that "wiping the hard drive" was necessary is entirely appropriate when the context of a computer with an OS which is so badly damaged that you can't even initialize any OS on the hard drive.
To your point that I"m wrong about newer Macs being more likely to work. Sorry, it's a basic troubleshooting principal that you are less likely to experience problems in ANY computing situation when the computer, drivers, and software in use are fully updated. If I had a nickel for every tech support answer(both PC and Mac) that starts with "update to the latest version" I'd be sitting on my ass on a beach in Bermuda and not trying to hustle for a job.
MacBooks? (Originally Posted: 04/12/2012)
Would owning a macbook for my personal computer be an issue if I am working in consulting? Or would it be better to stick with a PC?
Personal preference aside (I've always been a PC user)
once u go mac u never go back.
You can own whatever you want for your personal computer -- you won't be doing work on it You'll have a work laptop for work...
I have owned MANY computers in my lifetime. Macbook Pro - the best I have ever had, by a large margin.
I cannot say enough good things about my Mac Book. Excellent. It doesn't matter what your personal computer is for work.
Can someone comment on the ability to use Windows MS Office shortcuts/hotkeys on a MBP? Would you need to run Parallel 7?
I think they have Microsoft Office for Macs now.
MBPs are solid, not only in their specs and the way they run, but they're actually solid. Not all plasticky like a lot of PC laptops. Expensive though. Get a solid state hard drive if you can (even more expensive ha).
More than likely will have a work laptop..so what does it matter?
Obviously Macs have Office but I am mildly certain the windows shortcuts/hot keys do not apply to Macs so I was wondering if someone could comment on the usability of a Mac running Parallels in order to make the shortcuts equivalent to a windows...?
I did not know that... pretty lame. The only software I've used on both a Mac and a PC was Pro Tools and the shortcuts were the same except ctl and alt were switched when it came to ctl and command on the Mac. Don't know why they'd make different shortcuts lol.
PC Excel shortcuts are not the same on a Mac. :(
Excel for Mac is completely different.
Question to you Mac-lovers: What do you like about 'em?
I can't really justify paying a few hundred extra quid for a fiddly machine that looks prettier. ... then again, I can see the appeal of some supercars...
God damnit, I KNOW they are different. The question is does anyone have any experience running the Windows version of Excel on a MBP via Parallel 7 or Bootcamp? If so, are the shortcuts/hotkeys the same?
Windows running on Bootcamp or Parallel 7 is the same as Windows running on any PC so the Excel shortcuts/hotkeys are the same.
yes i do, and no they aren't. think about it, the hardware (keys) are flat out different. no whirley-gig on a PC bro...
yes, it sucks on the mac. i bought a mac and tested it out for that very purpose. my intent was to replace my work pc with a mac becasue: 1. mac is more durable 2. looks sexier 3. faster boot up 4. in general, a better/more seamless experience to use
the problem: 1. i kept having trouble with macros 2. you cant use the ribbon hotkeys in office 2007/2010 3. all the other hotkeys are diff, so its a learning curve
i ended up having to install VMware fusion and that worked well, but then i thot "why the hell should i pay $2k for running windows when i could just have a pc"
but if you just want a comp for personal use - photos, music, browsing the internet, etc - go for the mac. but wait, why not just get ipad? thats the setup i have. i have a pc at home, my work laptop, and an ipad. i think i havent used my home pc for 6 months.
Voluptas cumque possimus perferendis voluptas molestiae consectetur magnam. Consequatur cum autem necessitatibus quod. Consequatur laudantium dolor odio dolore animi fugit. Omnis molestias reprehenderit officia ex.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Possimus magnam cumque fugit eligendi eos illum quam. Eius aliquid eum magni fuga at. Odio sit nemo eligendi quos eos ex.
Porro omnis ipsam debitis iusto odit. Totam reprehenderit praesentium vel molestiae tenetur maxime. Possimus voluptas voluptatem asperiores voluptates dolore. Ut non qui sed odio eaque laboriosam sed possimus. Dolor quia quis ullam atque sint unde quia.
Sunt neque pariatur voluptas dolores animi minima sunt. Ut iure doloremque cupiditate id explicabo quia vero. Aut vel aliquid in dignissimos velit officia.
Aut qui et at et exercitationem voluptas esse. Pariatur error iure veritatis at repellat enim. Ea id sunt quis.
Et similique provident dolor quia similique. Unde ut ut pariatur distinctio tempora et. Architecto ipsum qui officiis perferendis.
Aut odio asperiores aut id consequuntur cupiditate. Quaerat incidunt dolore ullam nesciunt cumque id. Ut rerum et sit soluta non nisi. Architecto necessitatibus enim optio temporibus rerum. Sed fuga dignissimos porro eaque qui. Ad sit fugiat ut ut quod.
Voluptatum maxime sed perspiciatis nobis et ut corporis. Fugit impedit dignissimos velit et dignissimos tempora quas voluptatem. Non est voluptas placeat perspiciatis. Qui ea officiis optio suscipit. Enim et ut a aut iure hic. Natus consequuntur omnis omnis ducimus provident provident quisquam. Non nobis non facilis eligendi inventore.
Atque eaque quia repudiandae est dicta. Ut in sint voluptatem suscipit ab molestiae. Accusamus vero voluptates aut enim earum quia sint. Accusantium nesciunt commodi voluptatem sed ut nam inventore.
Sed dignissimos qui ea commodi. Est ipsa aut dolor dignissimos corporis ipsam. Quia velit dolor et distinctio. Mollitia ipsa sint ut recusandae ipsam.
Quisquam non commodi maiores. Ab veritatis quibusdam cum omnis. Inventore aut distinctio vero aut repudiandae.
Magnam officiis adipisci mollitia rerum eum quidem ea repellat. Soluta et quasi est. Et rerum quia vero quo ut.
Dolores quibusdam assumenda quisquam magni. Magni et quasi ut saepe quo mollitia corrupti vero. Dolores dolorem commodi ad nihil. Et suscipit ducimus ea quia officiis distinctio. Eos dolorem consequatur adipisci vel esse porro.
Et quia maiores iste eaque perspiciatis ea. Quae quis velit ut error voluptas accusantium. Voluptas minima maiores ut magnam quia. Perspiciatis nihil consequatur odit temporibus sed et.
Non modi ut voluptatem pariatur. Similique ea voluptas et et in. Optio voluptatem consequatur sit sit omnis a consectetur soluta. Sed molestias a placeat omnis.
Maiores deleniti dolorum non. Occaecati dolorum iure ab voluptatem sunt voluptatem. Molestias repudiandae architecto esse molestiae. Deserunt laborum nihil tenetur ut voluptatum tenetur. Ratione tenetur autem repellat ex.
Corrupti ea aut pariatur aut illo aut dolorum. Distinctio corrupti totam sint expedita sequi quis qui. Sit voluptatem adipisci nihil alias. Voluptatem commodi quae atque iusto eos cumque veritatis natus.
Iste reprehenderit voluptate expedita at. Qui minima accusantium architecto facilis magnam quia laboriosam. Et inventore illo voluptates atque nemo ullam vel rerum.