5/7/12 - 7:59pm

- illiniPride
- |1,171
- | Rank: King Kong

- CS
- Corporate Strategy - Manager

As penance for liberally beating a dead goat in the other Brainteaser thread, here is a fresh one that should be easy for many of you:

Does .9 repeated = 1?

Please prove mathematically and explain in English. SB for the first to do both.

Popular Content

- Are you experienced? Thoughts on growing olderIt’s been awhile since I’ve checked in on WSO. I hope 2016 has treated you all well and you’re now settling in for some well deserved rest and relaxation time over the course of the holidays. It may just be selection bias given I’m starting to get a little older myself (I just turned...
- 2017 Management Consulted Salaries OutWhat do you think? Just like last year, PwC and Strategy& are still not aligned. https://managementconsulted.com/consulting-salaries/2017-management-consulting-salaries-for-undergraduate-mba-interns/
- WSO Investment Banking Resume Template for College Students Released to the Public!Big Announcement: WSO Resume Template is Out in the Wild!: Mod Note (Andy): If you're looking for our resume for experienced IB professionals or a private equity resume template, click here.. For those of you looking to make sure your CV format is clean and make sure that your...
- My journey from no-name boutique to PE MFI have been a long time lurker and recent poster here, I have got so much from this community, I can say I would not have done it without you so I think it is time to give something back. I am sure you heard stories like min but I hope this can be inspirational to some of you. I come from a...
- More people are lonely than you may thinkIn today's social media dominated world, we only see edited versions of reality. Most likely, this is a result of human nature (the tendency for human beings to want to show off/be admired) and the apps themselves. After all, who wants to follow or watch someone who posts pictures of...
- Some Thoughts on Bitcoin, Part 1I haven’t written about Bitcoin on WSO for a long time, and I’ve seen a lot of questions about it on the site over the past few weeks due to the recent price movements. There’s a lot to cover so this might stretch into two posts. We’ll see how it goes. First, the recent price...
- What's your Top Stock Pick for 2017What is everyone's top stock pick to start off the new year? Explanation preferred if you throw up some no name or controversial stock. Once the year is coming to a close we could look back and see whose pick is doing the best and whose is absolute shit. As there has been a lot of...
- Trump Business Plan Donald Trump has finally released his plans for his business empire. Trump announced that he would turn over complete control to his sons as well as divert any foreign hotel revenue earned into the US Treasury. Trump was quoted as saying: [quote] Over the weekend I was offered $2 billion...
- A fatalistic view on life: Why most, if not all, of your success is from luckWSO's audience is incredibly motivated and driven to succeed, so I thought I'd reflect on success and the role that luck plays in it. My argument is that a significant portion, if not all, of one's success can be attributed to luck. This has been discussed on this forum before...
- Should I Be Getting a Divorce Or What?My first post garnered quite a few negative comments, as would be expected when I'm dealing with those in a situation similar to my husband's, defeated in life and ready to jump down the throats of the people you're disappointing. Thanks to those of you who understand what I mean...

Forum Topics

- Some Thoughts on Bitcoin, Part 2Here's a link to Part 1. Let's get right to it. Government Interference It's no secret that governments aren't crazy about Bitcoin. I'm convinced the only reason Bitcoin wasn't killed in the cradle...
- If you could ask a CEO one question to understand quality of his business what would it be? Hi there, Long-time lurker, first time poster. I was recently interviewed by a London Growth Fund - however, there was one question that really stood out: They asked if you could ask the CEO of a...
- Why Finance/IB? Dilemma of a quadruple major I had a lot of AP credits going into college (covered the bulk of university general studies), which allowed me to do a quadruple major (finance being one of them). I have done a few ib interviews...
- 10 Jobs that will be replaced by robotsAccording to this article, robots and AI software may drive out many jobs in the relatively near future. These are listed as the top ten jobs to be hit the hardest: 1. Insurance Underwriters and...
- DoT investigation finds Tesla Autopilot prevents crashes by 40%https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-19...
- Thoughts on ECM @ JP MorganWas wondering what people thought about ECM at JP Morgan in NYC. How does it compare with other groups for lateralling and do you gain the skills you'd need to lateral?
- Sales in sales and tradingI read that salesmen and traders are completely two different things yet training programs are listed as sales and trading as if they were the same thing. How do you get into sales and trading with...
- 2017 BonusesHow are bonuses looking this year? Sounds like Deutsche got hammered and Morgan Stanley was down 15%.
- Which Non-US City Would you do an International Rotation in and Why?I was curious how many people here have done international rotations (i.e. a stint of IB in Hong Kong, etc. through your bank/via externship) and how they liked it. Otherwise, I was wondering what...
- Experienced hires questionI've seen quite a few postings lately at strategy-geared firms that appear to be hiring at the entry level and 2-3 year level for experienced hires. It seems like the application process for these...
- NYC Monkeys-Where do you go to lunch?With so many of the readers on this site in NYC and working in a fairly close area to each other, I thought it might be helpful to create a thread so everyone could bounce ideas off each other and...
- Really unsatisfied with SA group placement and looking for advice?I received an IBD summer analyst offer from a top MM (borderline BB) bank in the fall which I happily accepted. However it was only a platform offer subject to later group and location placement. I...
- BABSON College IB****I heard people break into BNP Paribas with Babson according to the WSO Rankings Is this true?
- Can anyone concludes the capital structure effects on P/E & EV/EBITDA(EV/EBIT) in 2 sentences?Hi, guys I know that everybody knows P/E is capital structure dependent and EV/EBITDA & EV/EBIT are capital structure neutral. However, there are numbers of different reasons here for this...
- S&P Dow Jones Indices Offer - Should I take it or continue gunning for IB?Hi guys, I'm a Junior that just got an offer to work at S&P Global's Dow Jones Indices Finance/Analytics internship. However, what I really want is something in investment banking. Can anyone who...

Upcoming Events

- Jan 19 2017 - 7:30pm to 9:30pm
- Jan 20 2017 (All day) to Jan 22 2017 (All day)
- Jan 25 2017 - 8:00am to Jan 27 2017 - 5:00pm
- Jan 25 2017 - 2:30pm
- Jan 29 2017 (All day) to Jan 30 2017 (All day)

## Comments (43)

A Geometric series is probably easier.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

just construct a cauchy sequence

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

No.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

You can explain this without any fancy math, using the definition of numbers alone.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

x = 0.9

10x = 9.9

10x - x = 9

GBS

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

.9 repeated has a limit value of 1, but is never actually 1.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

If abs (x) <1, the infinite series sum(x^n) converges to 1/(1-x)

let x = (1/10)

finite sum = 1/(1-.1)

this gives you 1 + .1 + .01 + .001 ....

subtracting 1 and multiplying by 9 gives you .9 + .09 + .090 ....

solution = [1/(1-.1) -1] *9 = [10/9 - 9/9] * 9 = 1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

This statement makes no sense at it stands. If you mean to say constructing a sequence where each additional term is made by appending another 9, then yes, this sequence has a limit of 1. If you mean the number .9 repeating, well, it's a constant, so its "limit value" must be itself. By the way, that is most definitely 1.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

x = 0.9

10x = 9.9

10x - x = 9

9x = 9

x = 1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Because an infinite string of 0.9 will always equal 1? There is no number between 0.9 repeating and 1; they are the same number, represented differently.

0.25 = 0.24(9) repeating

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

I don't think your answer is correct.

10*.9=9

not 9.9, so in your equation x does not equal .9 like you said.

the short answer is no it does not equal 1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Wtf is this shit...

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

....

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

...

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

You just saw this on reddit didn't you

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Yes - my simplest 'explain in english' is that .3 repeating is generally known to equal one third, and 3 times one third equals 1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

That's a good way to explain it. Also if

1/3 = .3 repeating

2/3= .6 repeating

Add them together and you get

3/3=.9 repeating

1=.9 repeating

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Give it to this guy.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Let me also do it with math:

0.999 repeating equals x.

10

x equals 9.999 repeating equals 9 + xx = 9Subtract x from both sides

9

therefore x=1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Assuming you mean 10* .999 repeating = 9.999 repeating, this step is only true if the series converges (i.e it equals 1). In order to finish your proof you essentially assumed that what you were proving was true.

Are you retarded?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

All I'm doing is using that fact that the 9s go on infinitely. If they go on forever, then multiplying everything by 10 doesn't reduce the amount of 9s after the decimal point....they still go on forever (not forever - 1, because that value still equals 'forever')

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

JDimon is right. This is a legitimate proof. He's not assuming anything about the series convergence- all he assumes is the presence of infinite 9s (follows by the assumption of repeated 9s). Multiplication by 10 is a well defined operation- even for infinite decimal places- as a "place shifter".

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Oh Cola Coca got the answer first. Everyone who's disagreeing with him isn't taking the time to think about what it means for the decimal to be repeating indefinitely

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Here's my answer:

Yes. When you want a repeated decimal, you just take that number and divided it by 9.

0.7777.....=7/9

0.5555.....=5/9

Thus, 0.999999.....should theoretically equal 9/9, and 9/9 = 1.

Do I get the SB?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Gave it to Dimon, wasnt thinking of it that way but it makes sense.

You can prove this another way using negation

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

how can one number equal another number? even if a limit, it still doesn't technically equal it...

plz splain

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

This was how I thought of it:

If a <> b,

x exists where a < x < b or a > x > b.

If not, a=b

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

The answer is yes. There is a long mathematical proof that you learn in calc 2.

But the easy straightforward answer is...

1/3 = .3 Repeated

2/3 = .6 Repeated

Add the two previous

3/3 = .9 Repeated

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Wikipedia has a pretty cool proof with (Dedekind) cuts too! I didn't know that one since my analysis class skipped the construction of real numbers, but it was nice. I liked it!

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Assume that 9.999.../=10

Then you can list a number that is greater than 9.999... and less than 10.

Since you can't, 9.999...=10

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

1/3 + 1/3 + 1/3 = 3/3 = 1 and 1/3 is 0.33... so 0.3333..... + 0.3333..... + 0.3333.... = 0.9999 = 1

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Weird corollary imo: every terminating number has 2 equivalent decimal representations

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

One terminating and one non-terminating?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Models and bottles!

Did I get it right?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

I know why our financial system failed.

Because there are too many guys who think 0.9 is 1.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

There are several ways of showing this. An alternate version is using infinite series.

Let S(i) = i_Sum_k=1 .9*10^(-k)

And so .99 repeated is just Lim_(i--> infiniti) S(i)

But S(i) = .9* (1-10^(-i-1))/(1-1/10)

So Lim_(i--> infiniti) = .9*(1/(1-1/10)) = 1

-MBP

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Numbers are concepts. If the number isn't the same number, then it's not the same number. The idea of .9 repeating is that its as close as possible to 1 without actually being 1. Otherwise it would be 1. So I'm gonna ruin all the fun and say it's not possible based on the idea of what numbers are.

I hate victims who respect their executioners

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

No it's a fact that .9 repeating is another representation of 1. There are many proofs for it. It's not counterintuitive if you look at how the real numbers are constructed.

-MBP

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

MBP has it right. Any number has an infinite number of representations: for example, 1/2 can be written as 2/4, 3/6, etc..

.9 repeating is simply another representation of 1.

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

## Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits ?

Must Reads on Wall Street OasisRelated Content on Wall Street Oasis