Fighting the Good Fight -- for too long?

I went to a target school, met an outside political radical my sophomore year -- got suspended because I thought I was invincible -- came back a year late, and failed a few classes before I graduating with a liberal arts degree. (3.34 in the end)

This was 9 years ago now. Since then I have taught in inner city schools, run some grassroots political campaigns, did a brief accounting stint where I learned some Excel -- but I never took any classes on economics then or since.

I started reading the FT for political education (know your enemy) a year ago, and now I am finally looking back at my peers from university and high school -- and many are setup with MBAs at investment banks.

Since, evidently, the revolution has not occured, and I'll need more money than a school teacher's salary -- is it still possible to make a late entry into banking with a gap-filled primarily-teaching resume and a BA from one of the best universities?

It's still a point of pride, or confusion and shame at my own poverty that keeps me from asking my friends and alumni for advice or connections to enter finance.

I'm writing for encouragement, or discouragement -- I felt an obligation to pursue justice outside the system for as long as possible, and, well, I don't even see how to do it anymore and I am stuck working crappy tutoring jobs helping people try to get into the university I attended and then succeed.

Feel free to tear me down, or build me up -- whatever is appropriate, or whimsical to you. I've lived such an unorthodox (or failed life) that I know little where to turn --- I always considered myself above "networking" or even bothering to make money in such a soul-less capitalist world.

But, yes, I am feeling the pain of having a natural intelligence that is quite high, now being ground down in meaningless tasks -- and the critical acumen I developed may never turn into a salary.

I've made a masochism out of reading about your successes, and I don't want to suffer more -- but I fear it is too late -- 32, "target" gradute", Failed Idealist.

 
Best Response
IdealistStill:
It's still a point of pride, or confusion and shame at my own poverty that keeps me from asking my friends and alumni for advice or connections to enter finance.
Can't tell if serious, but I'll bite anyway.

First, I question why you want to break in and why now? Everyone else will want to know as well and you better have a good story.

Second, if you really do want to break in and you have connections (friends, alumni, etc.), you need to get over your pride and start calling them as soon as you have a good story and know what questions to ask. Almost every job in finance has an element of sales and you need to learn how to ask people for things you want if you have any chance of breaking in.

Third, get over being smart. You're not special. Almost everyone you meet is smart, so you need more than that to be successful. Which leads to my next point...

Fourth, what can you bring to the table? This needs to be crystal fucking clear because someone would be taking a huge risk in hiring you.

Fifth, you will likely get a ton of 'no' responses. Can you stay persistent when you are getting little or no encouraging responses?

Sixth, what do you even want to do? Saying you want to work in finance is like saying you want to work in health care......it's not very specific.

 

Your 3.3 isn't horrible - I got into b-school with a lower GPA than you - and I know some people who went the "vagabond" route and got in.

Honestly though, I think you've missed the bus for banking - I do know a few people in my class in their mid 30s from nonprofit/government jobs who rebranded themselves and got post-MBA associate positions at bulge brackets, but they had exceptional pre-MBA work experience. But finance isn't the only thing out there - there are plenty of people from nonprofit backgrounds who rebrand themselves and get six figure jobs in consulting or at big tech companies.

But before you take on some more debt, if you have any close friends (or used to be close) in industries you might want to work at, forget about your hang ups and just hit them up for career advice. I remember reading some research that showed that friendships that have gone dormant are the most powerful for networking, since these people run in different circles and have been exposed to different ideas and opportunities, but are still willing to go the extra mile to help you.

And if you do decide bschool is right for you, try to find more "manager" type roles in your field like the administrative side of TFA or a charter school. And lose the whole superiority and above it all attitude. Networking isn't going to work if you are just barely suppressing your contempt and bitterness towards people's livelihoods.

 

You want some more $. Some routes other than finance: Go to grad school in education administration. You'll have more salary and do something that probably aligns with your personal values. Try to get into education corporation like Apollo group (might need just business experience like waterboy suggested or possibly MBA). You might have some issues with for-profit education but they way non-profit institutes charge students isn't exactly charity either....

 
Financier4Hire:
You say you are smart:
  1. What is your IQ ? Almost anywhere in the world you can get tested (for about $40)...

You say you are smart, then answer this one simple question:

  1. What's the first rule of finance ? If you don't know (or have it wrong) I'll let SirTrades answer it...

Good luck !

When I think of smart, Im generally not thinking of people with the highest IQ. Lots of people have high IQ's. Its the people who are able to make changes to their environment, behaviors and attitudes in such a way that allows them to achieve their objectives that I think is the greatest real measure of intelligence, regardless of IQ.

Op, your new gods are these men:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Bartmann http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Kovner

I personally wouldve chosen a different route if you wanted to fight evil outside the system, though. Batman, Im thinking of you.

“...all truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident.” - Schopenhauer
 
seabird:
When I think of smart, Im generally not thinking of people with the highest IQ. Lots of people have high IQ's. Its the people who are able to make changes to their environment, behaviors and attitudes in such a way that allows them to achieve their objectives that I think is the greatest real measure of intelligence, regardless of IQ.

Op, your new gods are these men:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Bartmann http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Kovner

I personally wouldve chosen a different route if you wanted to fight evil outside the system, though. Batman, Im thinking of you.

Any special reason you bring up Kovner? Bartmann is one of my heroes. Also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_H._Murdock

 
Financier4Hire:
You say you are smart:
  1. What is your IQ ? Almost anywhere in the world you can get tested (for about $40)...

You say you are smart, then answer this one simple question:

  1. What's the first rule of finance ? If you don't know (or have it wrong) I'll let SirTrades answer it...

Good luck !

First rule of finance club:

You do not talk about finance club.

 

Assuming not a troll, you were a relatively average guy who "made it all the way to college" (like millions do each year) just to realize the whole "system" is "unfair/unjust" or some shit. So you felt you didn't need to work hard & build a career and that your natural "intellect" would carry you through life? Work on your pitch.

 

I'll probably get flamed for saying this but here goes:

I think you have almost zero chance of making a productive switch to finance at 32 with no experience and no (meaningful) educational background in finance / economics (it's cool that you read the paper, but that doesn't count for much to be honest). Besides the fact that you are not qualified, you have the emotional and physical baggage of being older (why would I hire a 32 year old when I can hire a 22 year old that I can terrorize and abuse for the same or less money?), a lot of people in finance aren't going to want to hire some kind of Occupy Wall Street burn out -- whether you actually fit that stereotype or not, accept that people will judge you.

That said, I think you could be an excellent candidate for a rebranding via MBA. I almost never suggest MBAs to people because I think they're largely a waste of time, but in your case, I think if you could get into a top school you would have a chance to make the switch, albeit likely starting out late and near the bottom.

By the way, everyone in this business is smart -- I have yet to meet anyone that I wouldn't consider significantly above average intelligence in the investing business. Corporate managers, that's a different story, but in investing, everyone's a killer.

 
Ravenous:
I'll probably get flamed for saying this but here goes:

I think you have almost zero chance of making a productive switch to finance at 32 with no experience and no (meaningful) educational background in finance / economics (it's cool that you read the paper, but that doesn't count for much to be honest). Besides the fact that you are not qualified, you have the emotional and physical baggage of being older (why would I hire a 32 year old when I can hire a 22 year old that I can terrorize and abuse for the same or less money?), a lot of people in finance aren't going to want to hire some kind of Occupy Wall Street burn out -- whether you actually fit that stereotype or not, accept that people will judge you.

That said, I think you could be an excellent candidate for a rebranding via MBA. I almost never suggest MBAs to people because I think they're largely a waste of time, but in your case, I think if you could get into a top school you would have a chance to make the switch, albeit likely starting out late and near the bottom.

By the way, everyone in this business is smart -- I have yet to meet anyone that I wouldn't consider significantly above average intelligence in the investing business. Corporate managers, that's a different story, but in investing, everyone's a killer.

not sure why you'd get flamed; you broke it down, kept it real, and offered a reasonable alternative

 
Ravenous:
I'll probably get flamed for saying this
no, you probably won't. What you laid out is the most likely case.

You can't fail if you don't try. He's too afraid of failing, so I doubt he ever calls his contacts for advice on breaking in to the field. I doubt even more he can overcome his long odds, he just does not project an attitude that inspires confidence.

 

For having so much "natural intelligence" and being a "target graduate", you come across as being super snobby and entirely devoid of common sense (the basics). If you want to switch careers, ask your friends for help or get a top MBA...that's what they're for, and that's what like half of all those TFA kids do. However, if your only motivation for entering the "soul-less capitalist world" of finance is dollars and cents, and you hate doing "meaningless tasks", if you do enter, you're in for a rude awakening.

Also do you actually have any legitimate reasons for pursuing finance in particular? There are plenty of careers out there, and fit is crucial. What about political consulting/research/journalism, like working for The Hill for example, or a think tank. Seems like you would enjoy something like that a lot more, and I'm guessing it pays better than being a grade school teacher.

 

So you're basically a libtard who realized what he loves money? You get no sympathy from me.

"The HBS guys have MAD SWAGGER. They frequently wear their class jackets to boston bars, strutting and acting like they own the joint. They just ooze success, confidence, swagger, basically attributes of alpha males."
 

A "finance" job you could probably get right now is probably something sales-oriented/commissions based. If I were you, I would take something like that. You could then look for other finance work and be applying to B school.

 
I am what I am:
A "finance" job you could probably get right now is probably something sales-oriented/commissions based. If I were you, I would take something like that. You could then look for other finance work and be applying to B school.

Actually yeah, you could just get in via sales. Sales kind of sucks though. But I think b-school is going to be really really tough, right? I don't think the top schools take very many 32 year olds.

 
STIBOR:
I am what I am:
A "finance" job you could probably get right now is probably something sales-oriented/commissions based. If I were you, I would take something like that. You could then look for other finance work and be applying to B school.

Actually yeah, you could just get in via sales. Sales kind of sucks though. But I think b-school is going to be really really tough, right? I don't think the top schools take very many 32 year olds.

Ridiculous response

"Now go get your f'n shinebox!"
 

School administrators make some good money and still get the cushy benefits and work/life balance. Why not get a masters degree so that you can become an administrator?

This to all my hatin' folks seeing me getting guac right now..
 
Cruncharoo:
School administrators make some good money and still get the cushy benefits and work/life balance. Why not get a masters degree so that you can become an administrator?

Crunch, we are on the same page today. I do a lot of work in the for-profit education space and can tell you that even the mid level administrators at large schools are making quality money. There just isn't much talent out there and schools (or their PE-backers) are willing to shell out some dough for decent administrators (this probably goes for non-profits as well).

"For I am a sinner in the hands of an angry God. Bloody Mary full of vodka, blessed are you among cocktails. Pray for me now and at the hour of my death, which I hope is soon. Amen."
 
IdealistStill:
I went to a target school, met an outside political radical my sophomore year -- got suspended because I thought I was invincible -- came back a year late, and failed a few classes before I graduating with a liberal arts degree. (3.34 in the end)

This was 9 years ago now. Since then I have taught in inner city schools, run some grassroots political campaigns, did a brief accounting stint where I learned some Excel -- but I never took any classes on economics then or since.

I started reading the FT for political education (know your enemy) a year ago, and now I am finally looking back at my peers from university and high school -- and many are setup with MBAs at investment banks.

Since, evidently, the revolution has not occured, and I'll need more money than a school teacher's salary -- is it still possible to make a late entry into banking with a gap-filled primarily-teaching resume and a BA from one of the best universities?

It's still a point of pride, or confusion and shame at my own poverty that keeps me from asking my friends and alumni for advice or connections to enter finance.

I'm writing for encouragement, or discouragement -- I felt an obligation to pursue justice outside the system for as long as possible, and, well, I don't even see how to do it anymore and I am stuck working crappy tutoring jobs helping people try to get into the university I attended and then succeed.

Feel free to tear me down, or build me up -- whatever is appropriate, or whimsical to you. I've lived such an unorthodox (or failed life) that I know little where to turn --- I always considered myself above "networking" or even bothering to make money in such a soul-less capitalist world.

But, yes, I am feeling the pain of having a natural intelligence that is quite high, now being ground down in meaningless tasks -- and the critical acumen I developed may never turn into a salary.

I've made a masochism out of reading about your successes, and I don't want to suffer more -- but I fear it is too late -- 32, "target" gradute", Failed Idealist.

Best advice is to start a company and make $$$. It'll be reallllllly tough to break into a high-paying career in finance now (like hedge funds, VC, investment banking), because there are a lot of other people who are hungrier than you and who have a 12 year head-start. The HYP halo persists so you could raise money to start a company, and quite frankly you're still really really young at 32 (I'm 26), so you can do pretty much anything you want in the world - except hedge funds/ibanking/PE, which proportionally isn't really that limiting.

 

IMO, don't redefine yourself. you are an experienced teacher, how can you spin that I to something useful for bankers/finance? well, you can work part time at some of these education startups. bringing in big data and cloud, and mobile accessibility to education industry is a real thing. and there are many young companies doing so who are backed up by vcs and foundations. also, some like kahn academy are filled with ex consultants and backed by bill gates. try to get into a BD role part time or intern this upcoming summer.

don't try the traditional path, it's an uphill battle and of worth the effort. the opportunity costs and the risk of destroying your teaching career doesn't make sense to me. that way my big mistake In college, I had a big plan based on redefining my goals and skills. I should've just focused on moving up one step at a time. don't get ahead of yourself

 

I hate people who try and do that. Steve Jobs may have been a druggie hippie college dropout, but he had overriding intelligence and business acumen over those traits, (even though Wozniak is the technical skill). Literally look at any other druggie hippie college dropout and you'll find they're simply a druggie hippie college dropout.

It's like that talk this one guy gave at Harvard, "The 'C' student is often the revolutionary entrepreneur, but not today's 'C' student who wants to stay home, works at the Jiffy Lube, and still blows off work to smoke weed, but rather the student who has a 'C' because he's preoccupied with astounding extracurriculars in business. (subtracting sports and nonprofit work)"

ohstallion:
steve jobs was a druggie hippie college dropout, so anything is possible. you definitely need some lucky breaks and a clearer path of wherever you want to get to, but i wouldn't rule anything out. even seeing that "pursuit of happyness" movie can be pretty inspirational.

good luck.

 

are you retarded?

IdealistStill:
But, yes, I am feeling the pain of having a natural intelligence that is quite high, now being ground down in meaningless tasks -- and the critical acumen I developed may never turn into a salary.
 

There's no such thing as 'too late' for anything. You just have a different story that's all. At the end of the day, people want to work with others who they resonate with. There is a senior banker out there who would hear your story and take a chance on you. Maybe they see something of the moral wrestle you are dealing with in themselves, maybe an alumni of your school who realizes people can do lots of things in their life. Play your age as an advantage. There is no such thing as a 22 year old being ahead of you. Because they are 22 years old. Their perspective on everything is just not as deep as yours, simple as that. Don't listen to any twenty something when it comes to making big life choices. You are no different from someone leaving banking in their thirties to go pursue something else. That happens all the time. Just knock on as many doors as you can and have your story tight.

 
jonmorris:
There's no such thing as 'too late' for anything. You just have a different story that's all. At the end of the day, people want to work with others who they resonate with. There is a senior banker out there who would hear your story and take a chance on you. Maybe they see something of the moral wrestle you are dealing with in themselves, maybe an alumni of your school who realizes people can do lots of things in their life. Play your age as an advantage. There is no such thing as a 22 year old being ahead of you. Because they are 22 years old. Their perspective on everything is just not as deep as yours, simple as that. Don't listen to any twenty something when it comes to making big life choices. You are no different from someone leaving banking in their thirties to go pursue something else. That happens all the time. Just knock on as many doors as you can and have your story tight.

SB to you.

"Now go get your f'n shinebox!"
 

I would give you this advice. Going to HYPS does not guaranteed success and does not mean you are smarter than everyone else. You are problem is that you still think you are smarter than everyone else because you went to a great undergrad but look at half your classmates and I can tell you that a lot of state school kids ( or even high school dropouts) are doing better than a lot of them.

I went to one of the top three school and work in IB / PE and yet my girlfriends inlaw became a car tech and did some good real estate investment when things where good and use profits to open three cat shops and makes more money than I do. Yes he is an exception and got pretty lucky but in the real world he is smarter than you and me.

My advice to you is to stop thinking you are smart and start networking and producing.

 

hell of a troll!

I know your faking, but in case you're not, I'll take the opportunity to insult you.

You are an entitled douche whose parents probably had to much money for your own good.

I hope you fail

┌∩┐(◕_◕)┌∩┐

Because when you're in a room full of smart people, smart suddenly doesn't matter—interesting is what matters.
 

I have always believed that "crafting a story" is a bit of an oxymoron. I'd much prefer someone to sit down in an interview room with me and be real: tell me your real story, not some narrative you wound together about why you want to "break in". People are allowed to change their minds about life.

That said, there's no way I would hire you after the "soul-less capitalist" comment. Sounds like you have an entitlement problem and blame your perceived lack of success on "the system" rather than on your poor decisions. What makes you think that your lack of solid career-change options is unjust, given 10+ years of decisions that led your life in an entirely different direction?

"For all the tribulations in our lives, for all the troubles that remain in the world, the decline of violence is an accomplishment we can savor, and an impetus to cherish the forces of civilization and enlightenment that made it possible."
 

This.

NorthSider:
I have always believed that "crafting a story" is a bit of an oxymoron. I'd much prefer someone to sit down in an interview room with me and be real: tell me your real story, not some narrative you wound together about why you want to "break in". People are allowed to change their minds about life.

That said, there's no way I would hire you after the "soul-less capitalist" comment. Sounds like you have an entitlement problem and blame your perceived lack of success on "the system" rather than on your poor decisions. What makes you think that your lack of solid career-change options is unjust, given 10+ years of decisions that led your life in an entirely different direction?

 

You don't sound very intelligent, I'd like to know what you think is soo soulless bout capitalism? You seem to have no idea what you're even saying. When you say enter "banking" do you mean investment banking? What exactly do you find soulless about helping companies and individuals raise capital for business ventures? I don't think you have a grasp on the reality of the financial industry. From your post you sound like a complete loser who has watched one too many Michael moore movies.

 

And This.

Randianhero:
You don't sound very intelligent, I'd like to know what you think is soo soulless bout capitalism? You seem to have no idea what you're even saying. When you say enter "banking" do you mean investment banking? What exactly do you find soulless about helping companies and individuals raise capital for business ventures? I don't think you have a grasp on the reality of the financial industry. From your post you sound like a complete loser who has watched one too many Michael moore movies.
 

Aspernatur non sint tempora dolore error. Dolorem voluptatem quia itaque aut quo. Sed dolor fugit possimus omnis reiciendis. Praesentium consequatur nostrum nobis inventore. Culpa ducimus in quas cupiditate minima.

Fugit repudiandae minus deleniti ab sed ipsum. Perferendis est sunt placeat sed. Dolores ipsam rerum occaecati in.

 

Autem sit ea et consequatur recusandae. Dolorum eos beatae eum eum.

Qui id eligendi animi blanditiis voluptatibus vitae et. Id quae quidem voluptatem in nobis et repellendus. Et et error corrupti nostrum. Dicta iure autem blanditiis ut animi dignissimos qui. Inventore molestiae minima sit omnis adipisci ut. Quaerat molestiae fuga id rerum dicta eum magni voluptas.

"He that hath a beard is more than a youth, and he that hath no beard is less than a man." ― William Shakespeare, Much Ado About Nothing

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (14) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (145) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
4
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
5
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
6
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
7
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
Linda Abraham's picture
Linda Abraham
98.8
10
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”