WallStreetOasis.com » Forums » Industry Specific » Consulting Cabaret
ChelseaFC85's picture

Getting a McKinsey Interview

McKinsey is interviewing at my school, and I was hoping to get a feel for my shot at an interview. I've previously gotten first rounds w/ Bain and Bcg, but I hear McKinsey is more selective than even them.

I was a summer analyst at MS, and I did get an offer. I've got a 3.6 and solid, but not spectacular, ECs at a semi-target. I've also got the diversity thing going, if that matters at all. I'm faily certain that I can destroy the case; I just need the opportunity.

Given that McKinsey has like a 3.7-3.8 gpa cutoff, should I expect to still get on the closed list, or should I just forget McKinsey? Sweet, thanks guys.

No votes yet
computerblue's picture

If you can get interviews

If you can get interviews with BCG and Bain, you have a high, high probability of getting a McK interview--it's not as if each company is looking for a different skill set. The diversity thing does help. How many non-Asian minorities do you see at MBB events? Very few. Probably 1 out of every 50 people.

The GPA cutoff is just BS. None of the firms you mention has a strict GPA cutoff. Personally, I think that's bandied about by students who don't get interviews so that they can feel good about themselves when they find out that they didn't make the cut. It just so happens that grades and test scores are valued by MBB more highly than they are by banks. But so what? That doesn't mean that if you don't have a 3.7 you won't get an interview.

ChelseaFC85's picture

Thanks for the insight. The

Thanks for the insight. The posting actually explicitly has 3.75 listed as the cut-off, but then again your average 3.6 guy didn't spend this past summer working on billion doller m&a transactions. We'll see, I suppose.

computerblue's picture

Whoops, must be a thing for

Whoops, must be a thing for semi- and non-targets then. The target I went to had no explicit cutoffs. I have never heard of it occurring at other schools. I find it odd that McK has an explicit cutoff for your school, but Bain and BCG don't. Sorry about the error and good luck with the app.

xenowang's picture

While I don't recall an

While I don't recall an explicitly mentioned cutoff either, it seemed to be a fairly widely accepted notion among interviewing students last recruiting season. It may be as you mentioned earlier about kids rationalizing why they didn't get an interview with McK, but I and many others I know interviewed for Bain and BCG but never had a spot to interview for McK.

qonnect.me's picture

This is definitely not the case

The cutoff is just listed there; it really means nothing. I know many with 3.3s who interviewed with McKinsey. Honestly, there is too much misinformation out there, and people tend to believe "cutoffs" too easily. I have personally reviewed resumes, where 3.75 was the cutoff, but I would let the guy/girl through cause he had good experience. It's just the way it happens; always assume there is no GPA cutoff: if you do, how can it hurt you?
----
http://www.qonnect.me
Qonnect.me - a simple resume consultation service for entry-level jobs in finance and technology

oasising's picture

From my school, a

From my school, a semi-target for banking, a kid with a 3.3 got a McKinsey offer. He was otherwise a stellar candidate.

nfg05's picture

I'm with xenowang here.

I'm with xenowang here. Getting an interview at one of MBB does not mean you will get others.

ihavenomoneynow's picture

i will chime in. got both

i will chime in. got both bain and bcg first rounds on campus. did not get a mckinsey first round, despite top internship experience and 3.9+. ironically enough i was one of the kids invited to apply early to mckinsey (interview date of sept. 5), but chose to forgo it for more preparation time

ihavenomoneynow's picture

yea

"Even though McK started e-mailing me the summer before recruiting and had myself and one other kid from my school come to meet people at the office, I did not even get a first round interview. That other kid did, so who knows."

lol... my thoughts exactly. visited their office 3 times during the summer... two for panel sessions, 1 exclusive one where it was me and 3 other kids. constant contact with my hr recruiter and NO mckinsey interview. i was initially pretty pissed off

big unit's picture

nfg05, was your offer for a

nfg05, was your offer for a Southern Bain office? I think that might explain why you got Bain but not McKinsey. I think for like Atlanta they take slightly more kids from certain targets (non-Ivies, etc.)

ChelseaFC85's picture

just wanted to announce that

just wanted to announce that I GOT A FIRST ROUND WITH MCKINSEY! Now I have a week to prep for their problem solving test and case interview.