Three job offers - which to take?
I just finished an internship with the government in the UK relating to economic development.
I have been made three job offers and I am not sure which one to take.
First is with Oxfam International, based in New York initially and then after 3 months, I would move to their head office in Oxford. Its unpaid but great experience as a legal intern at a huge NGO.
Second is with a reputable strategy firm in Berlin. They are very well respected in the field, and I would be working largely within the emerging economies market, something I am very interested in.
Third one is from one of the big 4. I would be working as a forensic service professional, dealing with financial irregularities and such.
Last two are paid and quite reasonably as well. My issue is I would like to go to b school eventually, and I gather adcomms loves stuff like the Oxfam position. However, the strategy firm in Berlin is both a great experience and is relevant to what I would like to do in the immediate future.
Granted it may be an easy decision for some, but I would love some thoughts on what you guys would do.





Strategy firm in Berlin. It
Strategy firm in Berlin. It looks as least as good as the others on an MBA-app and is the most relevant to what you want to do in the future. Seems like an easy decision to me.
Strategy firm in Berlin
Strategy firm in Berlin definitely.
See my other WSO blog posts>
If you have money saved up
If you have money saved up and could get by not getting paid for 2 years AND you BADLY want to get into an elite b-school, then you should take oxfam. Otherwise go with the strategy firm. The work sounds really interesting although Berlin is an awful city in my opinion.
Roland Berger or the strategy
Roland Berger or the strategy firm in Berlin.
Strategy in Berlin, no
Strategy in Berlin, no question about it.
wolfy wrote: Roland Berger or
Roland Berger or the strategy firm in Berlin.
Haha this is the only name that I can think of when he said "strategy firm in Berlin" :D
My formula for success is rise early, work late and strike oil - JP Getty
strategy firm in berlin
strategy firm in berlin
Brady4MVP wrote: If you have
If you have money saved up and could get by not getting paid for 2 years AND you BADLY want to get into an elite b-school, then you should take oxfam. Otherwise go with the strategy firm. The work sounds really interesting although Berlin is an awful city in my opinion.
Yeah, not to sound like a douche but money is not that big of a problem for me. I can stay with family in NYC and I lived in Oxford when I was an undergrad so have plenty of friends still around.
Interested to hear why you think Berlin is an awful city.
Quarterlife wrote: wolfy
Roland Berger or the strategy firm in Berlin.
Haha this is the only name that I can think of when he said "strategy firm in Berlin" :D
Haha, I didnt really disguise that too well. The big 4 firm is PWC for those wondering.
I appreciate everyone's
I appreciate everyone's thoughts.
Its definitely between Oxfam and Berger.
Can no one see the appeal of Oxfam for an MBA? Somehow I think I wont be able to leverage Roland Berger to the same level despite its stellar name. I would be just another one of those apps.
FinancialNoviceII
If you have money saved up and could get by not getting paid for 2 years AND you BADLY want to get into an elite b-school, then you should take oxfam. Otherwise go with the strategy firm. The work sounds really interesting although Berlin is an awful city in my opinion.
Yeah, not to sound like a douche but money is not that big of a problem for me. I can stay with family in NYC and I lived in Oxford when I was an undergrad so have plenty of friends still around.
Interested to hear why you think Berlin is an awful city.
Berlin is too grimy and industrial for my taste. But I know some people (especially hipsters, techno freaks, etc.) absolutely love it because it's reminiscent of NYC before gentrification.
Oxfam will definitely help your b-school chances more. With roland berger, you'll be competing against other consultants from elite firms like mckinsey/bcg/bain. Top b-schools LOVE non-profit and NGO types, so if money were not an issue, then i suggest oxfam. Provided that other parts of your application are in order, I would say you have a 70-80% chance of getting into HBS/Stanford/Wharton if you do oxfam.
FinancialNoviceII wrote: the
the strategy firm in Berlin is both a great experience and is relevant to what I would like to do in the immediate future.
I'm pretty sure you just answered your own question.
Speaking from personal experience:
Berger is as great a firm as you'll find in continental Europe.
Berlin is AAA+, especially if you're young and single.
Go with Roland Berger in
Go with Roland Berger in Europe. It is top 5 shop in Europe, and you can perhaps get a MBB exit op. Don't look back.
Don't do Big 4 consulting, ever. Unless it's Deloitte S&O, but then you'd enjoy it better at a Stroud Consulting in that same horizontal.
But, I'd like to learn more about the Oxfam thing from you guys -- and why it's so prestigious?
Just tell them...
Just tell them...
Why the hell would you work
Why the hell would you work unpaid for 2 years ?
Nouveau Richie wrote: Just
When she fucks with The Weeknd, I call her up on weekdays
wolfy wrote: Go with Roland
FinancialNoviceII wrote: and
My formula for success is rise early, work late and strike oil - JP Getty
Aviator wrote: Why the hell
Brady4MVP
24837
Quarterlife
24837 wrote: wolfy wrote: Go
This seems like a no-brainer
FinancialNoviceII
24837
24837
Roland Berger.
A lot of people do certain things to add days to their life. I do things to add life to my days.
FinancialNoviceII
Congrats on the multiple job