Why is Capital Markets not as good as other IBD groups?

In this forum, a lot of people talk about how Capital Markets groups aren't as good as other IBD groups such as Industry groups, M&A, or LevFin. Why is this? Is it because the deals aren't as interesting, differences in exit opps, or just the superficial prestige factor?

 
Juwanna Mann:
It's not as complicated and it doesn't involve valuation. If executing a bond for Walmart sounds exciting to you, then go for capital markets, but it will be difficult to get buyside interviews. That said, if you want to do banking as a career then capital markets is pretty cushy, if not prestigious.

Makes sense. I'm wondering about the prestigious part though. In my view of Investment Banking, it's always been that whichever group/desk that makes the most money for the firm always gets the most respect (the reason BO/MO roles are looked down upon) especially in an industry as $$ focused as high finance. I don't know much about DCM but it seems like ECM pretty much makes cash to burn in the good years

 
swagon:
and isn't valuation work part of pricing a debt or equity offering?

Theoretically, yes. Equity offerings are obviously very closely linked to valuation, but at most banks that valuation work is still done by the coverage group and ECM will focus more on issues like market receptivity, sizing, secondary/primary mix, etc.

Investment grade debt offerings don't have so much to do with valuation, because the debt is nearly always taken for granted as money good (unlike high yield where valuation and subordination becomes much more important). DCM prices offerings off treasuries, for the most part, so it's much more market-oriented.

They are unique skill sets and ECM/DCM bankers do things that industry bankers can't do - it just isn't a skill set that translates as well to the buyside, that's all.

 
mrbrightside:
read monkey business, capital markets is not considered bankers, they are just clowns who u hope dont insult the client too much to close the deal.

I love Monkey Business, Liar's Poker, Barbarians at the Gates, and the other classics just as much as everyone but I'm not going to use it to shape my perceptions of the current industry. If you applied the beliefs of the traders from Liar's Poker to the real world, then ABS/MBS desks would be the hottest places right now. There's a reason that it took almost two decades for an LBO to be notionally bigger than the RJR buyout and that adjusted for inflation no other LBO has even come close to matching RJR.

It was a different time then.

 

capital markets people are experts in a particular product, just like M&A. if you ask which group killed it in 2009, everyone will tell you capital markets saved the day. certain capital market groups are a lot more valuation based than bankers pumping the same models everyday (e.g. equity derivatives, convertibles, etc).

The only downside of capital market is that you become specialize in something that might have limited use in the future, which limits your exit opportunities, but you get to have 8-7 work hours and no weekend work.

 

capital markets has weekend work. hours are more like 7-midnight. weekend you might do 12-6 on both days

you have no exit opps. pay is lower than traditional ib. ib has more bankers. at the senior level i don't really think you are sought after. if you are its for 1 job that all the senior capital markets bankers fight for.. just no exit opps. capital markets is first to go when markets go bad

 
Ratatouille:
capital markets has weekend work. hours are more like 7-midnight. weekend you might do 12-6 on both days

you have no exit opps. pay is lower than traditional ib. ib has more bankers. at the senior level i don't really think you are sought after. if you are its for 1 job that all the senior capital markets bankers fight for.. just no exit opps. capital markets is first to go when markets go bad

hahah. nothing like a wannabe correcting previous posters who actually work in the industry

__________________________ if you ain't first, you last
 
Ratatouille:
capital markets has weekend work. hours are more like 7-midnight. weekend you might do 12-6 on both days

you have no exit opps. pay is lower than traditional ib. ib has more bankers. at the senior level i don't really think you are sought after. if you are its for 1 job that all the senior capital markets bankers fight for.. just no exit opps. capital markets is first to go when markets go bad

He might be talking about the convertibles groups in Capital Markets. I know ECM Convertibles generally work closer to banking hours while the other ECM groups are the ones with 12 hour days and no weekend work. However, I think it's standard that pay is going to be dependent on group performance so I don't know what the hell he's talking about here. If you're in a FIG group that doesn't bring in clients, the members of the ECM group that are launching Visa and Google IPO's are going to be making much money than you.

 
Ratatouille:
I work in the industry. i just dont work in capital marktes but have friends who work at MS, GS, CS, DB, and Citi. each in one of those banks. do a search on capital markets vs ibd, there have been threads on this, some of this is repeated

Ask your friends about their REAL hours. Are they the type to exaggerate or very inefficient workers?

 

So are Converts the most quant product in Capital Markets? (aside from Lev Fin)......What kind of skills do you develop? Considering that you prob need a good understanding of the capital structure since its both debt and equity, it still doesnt have good exit opps?

Also, if convert arb hedge funds are the main exit opp, how prevalent are they and difficult to break into?

 
bankingplease:
So are Converts the most quant product in Capital Markets? (aside from Lev Fin)......What kind of skills do you develop? Considering that you prob need a good understanding of the capital structure since its both debt and equity, it still doesnt have good exit opps?

Also, if convert arb hedge funds are the main exit opp, how prevalent are they and difficult to break into?

I don't know how many funds are strictly convertible arb..... It seems like a strat that would be tough to deploy a lot of capital into

 

I think people in ECM tend to think less about 'exit opps' than bankers. Because ECM (especially convertibles) is product-focused, a lot banks seem to prefer retaining good analysts rather than force the b-school route or hire inexperienced assoc out of b-school. People also burn out less often, so there's not always a good reason to want to leave.

I'd argue that converts is even more quantitative than levfin. However, this also depends on what bank you end up at--if you'll be doing credit analysis or not, for example, varies from bank to bank.

If you end up in converts and do well as an analyst, you will have many offers come your way. Since it's so specialized, there's a definite shortage of talent at the assoc and VP levels.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Are you a CEO, CFO or other executive facing these or similar charges? Why should you go to jail for a crime someone else noticed?
 

Most SVPs and MDs in ECM earn just as much as senior bankers. And they work fewer hours.

Syndicate tends to have the best hours (averaging 7 am to 6 pm), followed by ECM (730 to 8), then converts (730 to 11). Keep in mind this will vary from bank to bank depending on the number of pitches/deals across various products and sectors.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Are you a CEO, CFO or other executive facing these or similar charges? Why should you go to jail for a crime someone else noticed?
 
gorilla4sandracing:
Most SVPs and MDs in ECM earn just as much as senior bankers. And they work fewer hours.

Syndicate tends to have the best hours (averaging 7 am to 6 pm), followed by ECM (730 to 8), then converts (730 to 11). Keep in mind this will vary from bank to bank depending on the number of pitches/deals across various products and sectors.

I see, thanks!
 

I might also add that while ECM is fewer hours, it also is more deadline-driven than IB and more stressful on a minute-by-minute basis. Assignments are shorter in duration but occur more frequently. Whereas IB is a marathon and S&T a sprint, ECM is the 800 m.

Compared to banking, if you actually enjoy socializing with coworkers, capital mkts may be the better choice. On some IB floors, you could hear a pin drop, but ECM, although not as rowdy as a trading floor, definitely tends to be pretty conversational.

Bankers I work with constantly ask me if jobs are opening up in my group...

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Are you a CEO, CFO or other executive facing these or similar charges? Why should you go to jail for a crime someone else noticed?
 

One thing to keep in mind is that people in capital markets aren't as concerned about exit ops as other bankers are. The career offers a much more sustainable lifestyle than other areas of banking (although the hours are still longer than what most people outside of banking or consulting work), so people that actually enjoy the work aren't compelled to leave for the sake of personal sanity.

 

Just out of curiosity, do capital markets bankers have any hedge fund exit ops? (sorry for threadjacking)

For example, could someone in DCM covering IG debt spending his day studying interest rates switch to a global macro fund where interest rate knowledge might be useful?

Or could someone in HY DCM move over to a distressed debt fund?

Anyone ever heard of anyone doing something like this?

Also... when applying for MBA, will schools lump capital markets bankers in the pile with 'regular' investment bankers, or do you think they would be evaluated separately?

looking for that pick-me-up to power through an all-nighter?
 

Just to add my 2c here. I did an internship in M&A, got converted but picked ECM as my full time because I got very lonely being the only guy on the floor at 6am.

However, I do know a person who did the opposite. It's all down to personal choice, and like with all things there is an element of a "grass is greener on the other side" effect.

__________ Just my 2c.
 

Where I worked (before it disappeared), "Capital Markets" covered everything from Sales and Trading to Research to Analytics to Origination. It was a division like IBD- except the origination bankers were lumped in with the traders and research guys.

In my view, the analysts in origination are just as smart as the people in IBD. They have to be pretty quick on their feet when dealing with snarky traders and salespeople. The main difference between a firm's markets operations and IBD operations, in my not-so-humble-opinion, is that BS doesn't cut it in markets but IBD requires more people skills- the lack of BS also included origination from what I could tell.

 
IlliniProgrammer:
Where I worked (before it disappeared), "Capital Markets" covered everything from Sales and Trading to Research to Analytics to Origination. It was a division like IBD- except the origination bankers were lumped in with the traders and research guys.

In my view, the analysts in origination are just as smart as the people in IBD. They have to be pretty quick on their feet when dealing with snarky traders and salespeople. The main difference between a firm's markets operations and IBD operations, in my not-so-humble-opinion, is that BS doesn't cut it in markets but IBD requires more people skills- the lack of BS also included origination from what I could tell.

So let me get this straight, you have never worked in IBD, correct?

 
Best Response
youngblood:
So let me get this straight, you have never worked in IBD, correct?
No, but I worked WITH a lot of people in IBD when I was in Analytics and answered a lot of their questions; it seemed like a number of them didn't know what they were doing. Do you work in IBD? Do you work for a financial institution yet?

One of my managers (who did spend time in IBD) had an old saying: "Research and Trading are the quant developers; IBD are the business analysts."

 
youngblood:
That being said, maybe you're right, maybe those working in IBD are the dumb ones. But wait, was it the "dumb ones" or the "smart ones" that contributed most to their industry's embarrassing financial meltdown? Maybe IBD is home to people-skills and intelligence after-all, hehe.
Haha, maybe. The real reason trading sometimes causes meltdowns is that we take risks while you guys are a bunch of namby-pambies and leave that to the client or the desk. :D

Also, FWIW, the most recent meltdown was precipitated by a real-estate transaction, not mortgage trading, so we can blame those guys.

 
IlliniProgrammer:
youngblood:
That being said, maybe you're right, maybe those working in IBD are the dumb ones. But wait, was it the "dumb ones" or the "smart ones" that contributed most to their industry's embarrassing financial meltdown? Maybe IBD is home to people-skills and intelligence after-all, hehe.
Haha, maybe. The real reason trading sometimes causes meltdowns is that we take risks while you guys are a bunch of namby-pambies and leave that to the client or the desk. :D

Also, FWIW, the most recent meltdown was precipitated by a real-estate transaction, not mortgage trading, so we can blame those guys.

haha true, I guess I'd rather be an asshole than a pussy.

 

Holy shit this is a retarded argument. Illini may very well just have experience with bottom-feeder IB Analysts/Associates. Young might just have the privilege of working with some very bright people. The fact that either one of you is so willing to jump on a hasty generalization makes me think that you have pride in your industry (great!), take pride in your work and industry (great!), and need to find some outlet for your competitive side. I hear squash is a fun sport. Or kickboxing.

The point is you're going to find smart and stupid people everywhere.

"You stop being an asshole when it sucks to be you." -IlliniProgrammer "Your grammar made me wish I'd been aborted." -happypantsmcgee
 
mas1987:
Holy shit this is a retarded argument. Illini may very well just have experience with bottom-feeder IB Analysts/Associates. Young might just have the privilege of working with some very bright people. The fact that either one of you is so willing to jump on a hasty generalization makes me think that you have pride in your industry (great!), take pride in your work and industry (great!), and need to find some outlet for your competitive side. I hear squash is a fun sport. Or kickboxing.

The point is you're going to find smart and stupid people everywhere.

I just watched the Tyson documentary, I can take it to the streets son.

 
  • gets ready to go all West Side Story on youngblood*

...wait a sec... that doesn't sound right...

"You stop being an asshole when it sucks to be you." -IlliniProgrammer "Your grammar made me wish I'd been aborted." -happypantsmcgee
 

Quisquam ipsum id quos enim sed voluptatem. Minima enim quisquam quas ducimus. Quia explicabo tempore veritatis.

Molestiae saepe culpa perferendis explicabo voluptate inventore. Doloribus tenetur ut ipsum quae aut repudiandae nihil aut. Itaque maiores odit consequatur suscipit. Quia voluptatibus illum beatae expedita sit molestiae deserunt. Tempora dolor magnam impedit. In et fugit ea nobis est suscipit sit animi. Est qui optio quos. Quod molestiae culpa qui atque quaerat omnis et.

 

Quia vitae est qui inventore aut minima omnis. Quo enim quia ut ab. Quis laboriosam atque repudiandae fugiat ad ratione. Nihil nisi omnis voluptas inventore velit repudiandae iure. Ipsum eos veritatis et dolorem. Error sapiente totam et natus doloribus nostrum quia doloribus.

Incidunt adipisci et asperiores. Consectetur ea facilis cum aperiam ratione explicabo. Alias non quas vero porro occaecati aut minus.

 

Omnis molestiae corrupti laboriosam. Recusandae fugit nam incidunt pariatur. Alias perferendis aut vel id. Suscipit minima velit molestias quos.

Praesentium eos numquam molestiae omnis odio. Blanditiis pariatur temporibus consequatur nemo dolorem. Rerum ex repellendus non et quia perspiciatis asperiores. Iusto est repellat quis reiciendis quis. Officiis iusto occaecati atque similique nostrum et.

Doloribus velit odit aperiam voluptas neque sequi accusantium. Repellendus nesciunt omnis debitis dolorem. Illum corporis eius reprehenderit excepturi magni. Asperiores aspernatur blanditiis sit alias ullam et.

Ratione et dolorem ut deleniti a deleniti. Hic quia cumque reiciendis id. Rerum quisquam natus quasi sapiente dolores maxime qui. Voluptatem ea odit non distinctio sit omnis. Voluptas velit quam dolorum perferendis. Doloribus itaque velit voluptatem.

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (145) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
6
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
7
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
Linda Abraham's picture
Linda Abraham
98.8
10
numi's picture
numi
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”