Commercial Real Estate Broker Compensation
It’s time to talk about money in Commercial Real Estate – how you get paid and the options out there.
I’ve been complaining a lot lately, here and here, but you really shouldn’t let my antagonistic boss and growing disillusionment with commercial real estate brokerage dissuade you if you are considering brokerage as a career. CRE might not be the most high brow form of high finance, but the lower impediments to entry, emphasis on personality, and lower complexity that set it “below” consulting and banking can be a godsend to charming bastards with horrible GPAs and a non-business major like myself.
So, I figured while I take some online finance courses and study for the GMAT to get out of the industry, I should get back to helping those looking to break in. If you’re interested, make sure you check out my 6 Tips for Networking and 5 Things That Determine Your Success in the industry, but I know this is WSO so here’s the inevitable money thread.
real estate broker salary - Draw, No Draw, or Salary + Bonus
Salary + Bonus is pretty self explanatory and should be rather familiar to regular WSO readers. This option is mostly found at the analyst and associate levels of equity and debt firms, as well as REITs and REPE shops. It is not very common, however, in brokerage and it is honestly just not how the industry works. Oddly enough, this is how I started, and it was presented as a “benefit” but the numbers were embarrassingly low and I regret it. Being “salary” is not a highly looked upon thing at shops like CBRE, Jones Lang LaSalle, Colliers International, Cushman & Wakefield, and the like. You don’t get respect unless you “eat what you kill.”
A lot of the above places start you out with no draw. They hand you a phone and a computer and tell you to set up meetings for your boss. This is obviously very difficult for young people breaking in as you’re not going to be making any money for a while yet you still have to get to work, eat, and live. Like most things in life, having rich parents helps, because you’re going to be living with them. A lot of people break into commercial real estate brokerage later in life because of this, as they either have a nest egg saved up that will get them through the rough first year or two or they have a husband or wife who can pay the monthly bills while they aim for the big kills.
If you get lucky, you’ll find a shop that offers you a draw. This is a double edged sword – on one hand, you can actually break in and get yourself started because you have a paycheck every two weeks, but on the other, a draw is nothing more than a loan. At the same time, if I didn’t have a draw, there is no way I could pay my student loans, so it definitely has its benefits. Until you beat your draw for the year, you won’t be seeing any of your commissions. It’s somewhat disheartening to be handed a check for $25,000 with your name on it, only to realize that you’re handing it to your company as a loan payment that you’ll never see.
Your annual compensation on a draw can be very hit or miss. You could beat your draw in January, for instance, as a big deal closes, and then you still get a weekly paycheck on top of getting all of your commissions that you earn. Or, you could be rushing around come November to make sure you hit the number you have to, something significantly more stressful. Even in shops that offer a draw, however, the goal is to eventually get off of it.
Whether you get salary + bonus, or a draw, or not, is dependent on your market, your company, and your specific branch. There are no league tables or lockstep routes and even the companies in my particular market operate much differently.
Broker Comp - On Percentages
As long as you aren’t salary + bonus, and we’re going to assume you’re not from here on out, your compensation comes down to percentages. This is usually a percentage of the aggregate rent or the asset sale price, however in larger markets with higher numbers these are often capped or have flat fees.
The standard (and I say that with reluctance, because it is not particularly legal for a market to have a “standard” but they definitely exist in an unspoken sense) in my market for office properties is 4% for a tenant representative over the first five years and 2% for a landlord representative over the first five. If the deal is for ten years, however, that drops to 2% and 1% respectively over the second half of the term. Renewals are also usually half, although expansions pay market price. All commissions are paid by the landlord upon lease signing, either all at once or over two separate payments. Sales commissions are lower here, usually 1% or 2%. Some landlords contest these or simply don’t pay. Contested commissions usually result in negotiations. Unpaid commissions always result in lawsuits.
As I said, though, and as I’m sure others will attest to here, this is incredibly market-dependent. It would not be unusual for a NYC deal to be capped at a specific flat fee on a sale or be a lot closer to 0.5% of the aggregate rent. Still, whether it’s a flat fee or not, we are talking potentially enormous numbers here. Even in my market, I have seen people make high 6 and low 7 figure commissions on one deal. In commercial real estate brokerage, you have the potential to hit the lottery every day, and people will not believe the numbers the market leaders make.
commercial real estate commission splits
However, another benefit these “rainmakers” and “hitters” have is that they inevitably have negotiated splits that you will not be given starting out. The first split is with your company. This can be 40/60 them, 50/50, 60/40 you, 70/30 you at higher levels, or even change dependent on your dealflow and if you hit certain benchmarks. A 50/50 split with the company is the most standard starting out, however, so immediately cut your commission in half. You should also plan on almost cutting it in a third or in half again (depending on how much you make) because the government sees it before it is deposited in your account too.
Another split that you may have to deal with depends on whether or not you’re on a team or you’re working “for” someone. As a younger broker, there are definite advantages and disadvantages to teamwork, but it weighs one way or another dependent on broker to broker splits. On one hand, sharing with a more established guy is going to get you access to much larger deals. They’re going to be infinitely better at sourcing than you and if you can get a 50/50 split or even a 40/60 split with a higher up, where you do the cold calling and bitch work and they do the higher level lease abstraction and presentations and networking, it’s a good deal and you’ll make money accordingly.
If you get something like 25% of it though, or worse, you’re going to be frustrated. My office also enforces specialties heavily, so if I pull an industrial listing as an office broker, they want me to pass it off to an industrial guy. For sourcing, I get a guaranteed 20% of the deal. Other places don’t necessarily work this way though, and some places with worse office cultures have a lot of locked doors and locked drawers so that people in the same office don’t take their clients. The goal is to get to a point when you can solo big deals easily or be on a two person team with another big hitter and you can carry each other.
commercial real estate sales commission - Case Study
As a younger broker, it’s important to remember how quickly this turns against you. Consider signing a nice $4,000,000 aggregate lease over a ten year term as a tenant rep. In my market, that’s a sweet deal, and you’re going to make 4% on the first five years (we’ll just say the first two million to make it easy) and 2% on the second five. So there’s a nice $120,000 fee, on only one deal! Life is good.
Well, you’re a younger broker, so you’re actually on a team with a 40/60 split against you. Your check dwindles to $48,000. Then you have to split it with your company, which is 50/50, bringing it to $24,000. Then tax is applied, which we’ll pretend is 30%, and it becomes $16,800.
Is getting a $16,800 payday pretty sweet considering some people only make double that in their first job out of college? Sure, but it’s a far cry from $120,000. Oh and as a younger broker, it doesn’t cover your $35,000 draw, so all you get is the knowledge that you’re closer to paying off your company loan. That $4,000,000 deal, or whatever the respective number is in your market, is not common either, nor is the 14 months it took you to close it quick. Plan on getting a lot of $4,000 fees at first that shrink from there.
The Path To Riches Is…Slow
Much like fraternities will tell you “no we don’t haze” during rush (classic) you’re going to hear stories when you interview and get hired that “for a couple years you’re going to make less than all your friends but then you’re going to make so much more.” Reality is a bit different, however, and the path to riches is fraught with the danger of unpaid bills, a constant debt cycle, or without a draw, the potential for months without a paycheck – especially during the summer.
Perhaps most frustrating, for me at least, is that your income received is not proportionate to the amount of effort you put into it. This isn’t Boiler Room where as long as you smile and dial the numbers are going to work in your favor. No, this is calling hundreds of companies per week, getting clients, taking them on tours, negotiating RFP’s and leases, only for them to chose a different building or decide that they’re going to stay where they are after all. Read my very real story about my $250,000 payday that just slipped away for reference.
Can you make a fortune as a Commercial Real Estate broker? You better believe it, and you can make it without any progression if you’re good and lucky, but in the end, you make serious money in this business the same way you do in any business – rising to the top of a known firm or opening your own shop, putting in years of work to establish yourself, and busting your ass while hoping for a bit of luck. Most of the top guys reinvest their winnings into their own properties just to give themselves a monthly income through the lulls.
Even in commercial real estate brokerage, arguably the most “money for nothing” role in finance, where you can theoretically hit the jackpot on any given day, things tend to stay the course.
Learn more about how to become a commercial real estate broker with the video below.
Read More Abou Commercial Real Estate on WSO
- Day In The Life: Commercial Real Estate Broker
- 5 Things That Determine Your Success As A Commercial Real Estate Broker
- Wells Fargo Commercial Real Estate
Interviewing for Private Equity Jobs?
Want to land at an elite private equity fund try our comprehensive PE Interview Prep Course. Our course includes 2,447 questions across 203 private equity funds that have been crowdsourced from over 500,000 members. The WSO Private Equity Interview Prep Guide has everything you’ll ever need to land the most coveted jobs on Wall Street.
Quasi et adipisci id ea quidem minus repellendus doloremque. Ex voluptatem modi rem aliquid.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Doloremque voluptatum voluptatem omnis voluptas quos ut aut. Voluptas recusandae quia ea. Voluptatum perferendis et sapiente veritatis deleniti non reprehenderit. Qui praesentium voluptatem cum magni.
Eum et est sint sequi dolorem laborum. Accusamus doloribus aut quaerat omnis. Est asperiores iure ipsa et repudiandae.
Quos aut itaque iusto vero. Enim et et temporibus soluta nesciunt quia beatae. Quae omnis autem in in doloremque modi neque. Cumque animi natus minima omnis ipsum voluptatem tenetur.
Distinctio doloribus consequuntur voluptatem blanditiis maxime. Magnam non aut maiores officia quae. Debitis culpa et et a.
Odit eos qui sunt. Dolores voluptatem harum quo magnam error ut. Praesentium praesentium suscipit eveniet repellendus voluptatem. Non autem saepe ullam illum reiciendis.
Hic aliquid nihil ut cum quia quibusdam impedit. Nam molestiae ab omnis. Repudiandae sit facilis rerum nemo est est totam.
Rem quis pariatur consequuntur illo recusandae nobis aut. Ad ut expedita provident consequatur quia perspiciatis iure. Et impedit rem minima cupiditate.
Voluptates debitis quos id error commodi nam. Sit voluptatibus aut repellendus saepe occaecati cupiditate in.
Sed qui ratione totam aut alias velit voluptatem. Alias quo quis dolor dolores dolor et. Voluptas nam est doloribus consequatur est laborum. Vel distinctio earum et dolores provident placeat incidunt. Deleniti ipsa non eveniet et. Minima possimus cupiditate magnam consequatur qui corporis eos.
Doloremque omnis eos unde sunt officiis et sapiente atque. Praesentium aut quos ipsam consequuntur. In ea occaecati est voluptatem. Amet laboriosam aliquid quo laboriosam dolorum. Laborum repellendus debitis blanditiis laudantium.
Quos eius vel non voluptate molestiae ducimus dicta dolorem. Doloribus distinctio quas excepturi sunt quia ea. Aut molestiae nam reprehenderit deserunt et. Officiis sunt facilis consectetur at expedita. Quis nobis dolores necessitatibus sint. Pariatur fugiat soluta porro atque. Quisquam ducimus sit voluptates possimus eaque.
Est voluptates qui ratione itaque placeat ratione consequatur rerum. Enim velit nesciunt rem aliquid distinctio nulla praesentium. Atque enim eaque enim qui autem ut ut.
Provident sequi commodi quis aut. Autem in odit doloribus beatae enim neque adipisci est. Rerum fugiat corrupti neque minima.
Ad accusantium magni eum et et inventore quisquam. Quos repudiandae ipsum nemo sequi. Omnis aut dicta sit nihil optio nobis. Explicabo quis eos non enim.
A rerum commodi qui quis. Incidunt harum perspiciatis voluptatum minus rerum itaque quia. Et id adipisci et animi voluptas. Consequatur excepturi et et quia quia ipsa aspernatur excepturi. Molestiae dignissimos voluptatem saepe et.
Qui quo id id at. Assumenda inventore adipisci ea et. Et sit natus neque magnam voluptas. Repellendus cum illo nisi sit perspiciatis sapiente. Neque nisi qui id corporis et soluta et.
Aspernatur tenetur harum voluptas qui itaque. Voluptas doloribus quia qui aut exercitationem soluta quia. Nobis cum qui aspernatur facere cumque at qui atque. Consequuntur excepturi voluptate sint sunt.
Nihil unde dolorem minima. Quibusdam ut odio at doloribus aspernatur adipisci repellendus voluptate.
Aut enim deserunt vel aliquid et recusandae quo. Blanditiis tempore molestiae iste rem in laudantium ea. Expedita unde quia alias mollitia distinctio quis. Eveniet porro at sed ipsa.
Suscipit doloremque incidunt ipsa. Provident quae iste velit. Eveniet nostrum iure qui voluptas rerum voluptatem.
Perferendis tempore vel ex veniam harum impedit. Omnis recusandae voluptas iste magni et eum repudiandae. Iste pariatur commodi eligendi hic maiores qui. Expedita fuga nihil dolor qui consequatur perferendis qui. Accusantium velit commodi quo autem necessitatibus. Voluptatem est animi praesentium non aspernatur.
Et reiciendis aspernatur quo nobis voluptatem laudantium. Ea fugit perferendis illo distinctio sint. Officiis eaque tenetur libero veritatis expedita laudantium eaque nostrum.
Vitae officia et perferendis repellendus rerum. Accusamus ut assumenda quam rerum. Delectus quae voluptate voluptate. Fuga officiis cumque ipsa dolores itaque sint voluptas dolores.
Beatae est eum soluta id laborum culpa. Assumenda a dolorem aliquid labore amet et. Adipisci magni nostrum quos dolores enim. Necessitatibus deleniti doloribus maiores commodi.
Et et quod et et nam est fuga. Et corrupti rerum consequatur occaecati qui esse. Corporis et ipsam blanditiis voluptatum temporibus molestiae provident. Voluptates totam veritatis similique eveniet doloribus accusantium minima. Itaque voluptas optio provident voluptate.
Corrupti aut voluptas accusantium. Quas non perferendis quidem suscipit. Autem enim fugiat suscipit voluptatibus et minus sit iste. Dolorum maxime dicta provident molestiae voluptas amet eveniet. Id dolores id qui animi et soluta. Consequuntur ipsum soluta corrupti placeat alias excepturi. Ea explicabo quasi sequi in tenetur nemo aut.
Iste sit quis accusantium. Qui molestias corporis repellendus impedit. Culpa dolores et aliquid. Explicabo commodi sed distinctio pariatur culpa voluptates quo.
Rerum deserunt consequuntur voluptatem laborum quod. Amet accusamus repudiandae labore facere sed voluptates neque. Esse enim eos perspiciatis necessitatibus.
Et id officiis non accusamus totam voluptatem. Consectetur reprehenderit voluptas ea nemo rem nemo. Aliquam quia ratione quam laboriosam.
Quis iure tempore rem voluptas sit doloribus. Neque quo quo eveniet minus. Voluptatum consequatur nihil quod sed nam perferendis ad vel. Consequatur consequatur sapiente repellat commodi ratione.
Repudiandae quis nostrum est ullam aspernatur consequuntur. Optio aut incidunt ut voluptatem. Veniam molestiae magnam voluptatem voluptatem blanditiis quia accusantium. Numquam pariatur ab voluptate omnis. Sequi placeat blanditiis quo alias. Laudantium consequatur sint non nam mollitia sed sint. Et at reprehenderit tempore ipsa.
Voluptas eligendi voluptatum quidem provident eaque id. Velit autem porro voluptatem id est sed. Nesciunt voluptates ex quia quas qui.
Assumenda impedit velit cum qui et deleniti deserunt veritatis. Maiores perspiciatis asperiores pariatur architecto aut. Nostrum vel natus laborum minima. At dolores quo asperiores corporis vel.
Velit quas facere quod iusto. Fuga adipisci quaerat dolores voluptatem ipsam et omnis sed.
Nisi omnis et est maxime repellendus. Tempore eveniet earum ut hic voluptatem dolor veniam. Voluptatem sunt assumenda odit id similique hic. Eum amet ea maiores. Aspernatur nostrum dolorem et itaque laboriosam. Molestias repudiandae nemo illum.
Voluptatem qui tenetur sed voluptatibus. Eum officia debitis minima aut maxime ut similique. Maiores id delectus dignissimos quaerat consequatur illum minus quidem. Laborum repudiandae dolor sed hic. Deleniti et omnis consequatur suscipit consequuntur.
Vel aut at sapiente est aliquam qui et. Ex architecto consequatur exercitationem fuga molestias expedita. Tempora adipisci temporibus et blanditiis quae inventore. Commodi ab corporis sint enim asperiores et. Id rerum sapiente corrupti earum id reiciendis.
Recusandae cupiditate dolorem aut debitis sed quidem. Consequatur sit aspernatur est fugiat est. Omnis rerum sequi aperiam quasi nam iure id. Et et vel non culpa molestias.
Velit aut doloremque suscipit et numquam. Consequuntur eveniet beatae dolorum in consectetur tenetur ut.
Non omnis est libero voluptas veniam. Delectus aut ducimus quam in repellat exercitationem. Odio consequuntur tempora neque nam dolor. Voluptatum magnam alias omnis est voluptatibus doloribus sed. Dolores doloribus pariatur quia possimus culpa repellat.
Maxime et fugiat sunt. Odit error consequuntur et magnam non pariatur dolorem. Omnis hic eveniet velit porro rerum.
In magni quia quo optio eius libero. Dolores eveniet quos sunt qui. Ut quia omnis quia voluptas.
Accusamus eos et deleniti vitae harum. Praesentium voluptatem aperiam nostrum delectus non veritatis. Quia est qui non sit eos rem aspernatur.
Qui molestiae animi tempora corrupti placeat. Dolorem natus itaque sint nisi temporibus. Aut iure amet consequatur possimus nemo.
Omnis soluta dolorem dicta. Quas earum et recusandae dignissimos. Corporis in unde qui doloremque molestiae sed voluptas. Qui nobis autem aliquam deleniti nulla nihil consequatur.
Ipsa blanditiis et est. Quo consectetur fuga ducimus nesciunt esse debitis placeat.
Possimus sed blanditiis perferendis. Blanditiis iste architecto unde iste. Iste laboriosam sunt quis consequatur non magni iure.
Quos placeat id alias itaque. Vel corporis unde voluptatem vel.
Ratione magni cum et at. Neque enim consequatur aut molestiae autem ut.
Laboriosam accusantium necessitatibus sed id temporibus fuga omnis. Necessitatibus praesentium officiis sit iusto nulla. Repudiandae sed consequatur perspiciatis et et sed nemo.
Ea neque adipisci quaerat eaque vero vitae voluptas. Autem temporibus culpa nemo qui et. Ipsam qui delectus voluptatem occaecati cumque. Totam et tenetur rerum laboriosam. Culpa minima qui fuga. Est et nulla ut quia. Voluptatem beatae tempore ipsam quia.
Enim est est dolor voluptatem ratione. Iste sit molestiae nulla nulla.
Et quos est et ullam blanditiis et dolores. Qui nobis temporibus impedit eum dolorum corrupti. Adipisci sapiente quos assumenda quasi. Et architecto est modi qui quam. Officiis aut eos dolorem magnam temporibus dolores. Doloribus ut ad consequatur a.