Mod Note (Andy) - as the year comes to an end we're reposting the top discussions from 2015, this one ranks #35 and was originally posted 2/24/2015.
Earlier this year, I started my series on discounted cash flow valuations (DCF) with a post that listed ten common myths in DCF and promised to do a post on each one over the course of the year. This is the first of that series and I will use it to challenge the widely held misconception that all you need to arrive at a DCF value is a D(iscount rate) and expected C(ash)F(lows). In this post, I will take a tour of what I would term twisted DCFs, where you have the appearance of a discounted cash flow valuation, without any of the consistency or philosophy.
- Equity versus Business (Firm): If the cash flows are after debt payments (and thus cash flows to equity), the discount rate used has to reflect the return required by those equity investors (the cost of equity), given the perceived risk in their equity investments. If the cash flows are prior to debt payments (cash flows to the business or firm), the discount rate used has to be a weighted average of what your equity investors want and what your lenders (debt holders) demand or a cost of funding the entire business (cost of capital).
- Pre-tax versus Post-tax: If your cash flows are pre-tax (post-tax), your discount rate has to be pre-tax (post-tax). It is worth noting that when valuing companies, we look at cash flows after corporate taxes and prior to personal taxes and discount rates are defined consistently. This gets tricky when valuing pass-through entities, which pay no taxes but are often required to pass through their income to investors who then get taxed at individual tax rates, and I looked at this question in my post on pass-through entities.
- Nominal versus Real: If your cash flows are computed without incorporating inflation expectations, they are real cash flows and have to be discounted at a real discount rate. If your cash flows incorporate an expected inflation rate, your discount rate has to incorporate the same expected inflation rate.
- Currency: If your cash flows are in a specific currency, your discount rate has to be in the same currency. Since currency is primarily a conduit for expected inflation, choosing a high inflation currency (say the Brazilian Reai) will give you a higher discount rate and higher expected growth and should leave value unchanged.
- The Chimera DCF: In mythology, a chimera is usually depicted as a lion, with the head of a goat arising from his back, and a tail that might end with a snake's head. A DCF valuation that mixes dollar cash flows with peso discount rates, nominal cash flows with real costs of capital and cash flows before debt payments with costs of equity is violating basic consistency rules and qualifies as a Chimera DCF. It is useless, no matter how much work went into estimating the cash flows and discount rates. While it is possible that these inconsistencies are the result of deliberate intent (where you are trying to justify an unjustifiable value), they are more often the result of sloppiness and too many analysts working on the same valuation, with division of labor run amok.
- The Dreamstate DCF: It is easy to build amazing companies on spreadsheets, making outlandish assumptions about growth and operating margins over time. With attribution to Elon
Musk, I could take a small, money losing automobile company, forecast enough revenue
growth to get its revenues to $350 billion in ten years (about $100 billion higher than Toyota or Volkswagen, the largest automobile companies today), increase operating margins to 10% by the tenth year (giving it the margins of premium auto makers) and make it a low risk, high growth company at that point (allowing it to trade at 20 times earnings at the end of year 10), all on a spreadsheet. Dreamstate DCFs are usually the result of a combination of hubris and static analysis, where you assume that you act correctly and no one else does.
- The Dissonant DCF: When assumptions about growth, risk and cash flows are not consistent with each other, with little or no explanation given for the mismatch, you have a DCF valuation
where the assumptions are at war with each other and your valuation error will reflect the input
dissonance. An analyst who assumes high growth with low risk and low reinvestment will get too high a value, and one who assumes low growth with high risk and high reinvestment will get too low a value. I attributed dissonant DCFs to the natural tendency of analysts to focus on one variable at a time and tweak it, when in fact changes in one variable (say, growth) affect the other variables in your assessment. In addition, if you have a bias (towards a higher or lower value), you will find a variable to change that will deliver the result you want.
- The Trojan Horse (or Drag Queen) DCF: It is undeniable that the biggest number in a DCF is the terminal value, and for it to remain a DCF (a measure of intrinsic value), that number has to be estimated in one of two ways. The first is to assume that your cash flows will continue
beyond the terminal year, growing at a constant rate forever (or for a finite period) and the second is to assume liquidation, with the liquidation proceeds representing your terminal value. There are many DCFs, though, where the terminal value is estimated by applying a multiple to the terminal year’s revenues, book value or earnings and that multiple (PE, EV/Sales, EV/EBITDA) comes from how comparable firms are being priced right now. Just as the Greeks used a wooden horse to smuggle soldiers into Troy, analysts are using the Trojan horse of expected cash flows (during the estimation period) to smuggle in a pricing. One reason analysts feel the urge to disguise their pricing as DCF valuations is a reluctance to admit that you are playing the pricing game.
- The Kabuki of For-show DCF: The last three decades have seen an explosion in valuations for legal and accounting purposes. Since neither the courts nor accounting rule writers have a clear
sense of what they want as output from this process (and it has little to do with fair value), and there are generally no transactions that ride on the numbers (making them "show" valuations), you get checkbox or rule-driven valuation. In its most pristine form, these valuations are works of art, where analyst and rule maker (or court) go through the motions of valuation, with the intent of developing models that are legally or accounting-rule defensible rather than yielding reasonable values. Until we resolve the fundamental contradiction of asking practitioners to price assets, while also asking them to deliver DCF models that back the prices, we will see more and more Kabuki DCFs.
- The Robo DCF: In a Robo DCF, the analyst build a valuation almost entirely from the most recent financial statements and automated forecasts. In its most extreme form, every input in a
Robo DCF can be traced to an external source, with equity risk premiums from Ibbotson or Duff and Phelps, betas from Bloomberg and cash flows from Factset, coming together in the model to deliver a value. Given that computers are much better followers of rigid and automated rules than human beings can, it is not surprising that many services (Bloomberg, Morningstar) have created their own versions of Robo DCFs to do intrinsic valuations. In fact, you could probably create an app for a smartphone or tablet that could do valuations for you..
- The Mutant DCF: In its scariest form, a DCF can be just a collection of numbers where items have familiar names (free cash flow, cost of capital) but the analyst putting it together has
neither a narrative holding the numbers together nor a sense of the basic principles of valuation. In the best case scenario, these valuations never see the light of day, as their creators abandon their misshapen creations, but in many cases, these valuations find their way into acquisition valuations, appraisals and portfolio management.
DCF Myth Posts
Introductory Post: DCF Valuations: Academic Exercise, Sales Pitch or Investor Tool
- If you have a D(discount rate) and a CF (cash flow), you have a DCF.
- A DCF is an exercise in modeling & number crunching.
- You cannot do a DCF when there is too much uncertainty.
- The most critical input in a DCF is the discount rate and if you don’t believe in modern portfolio theory (or beta), you cannot use a DCF.
- If most of your value in a DCF comes from the terminal value, there is something wrong with your DCF.
- A DCF requires too many assumptions and can be manipulated to yield any value you want.
- A DCF cannot value brand name or other intangibles.
- A DCF yields a conservative estimate of value.
- If your DCF value changes significantly over time, there is either something wrong with your valuation.
- A DCF is an academic exercise.
Non distinctio id et fugiat eos. Sit blanditiis excepturi dolores quo repudiandae voluptatem vel. Ut nobis accusamus qui ut est rerum. Numquam mollitia voluptates error corrupti.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Inventore est asperiores similique temporibus sit vero amet. Ratione voluptatibus aliquid ipsa ratione illo sint. Ad et aut non culpa sed laboriosam.
Hic accusantium quis magnam eius et nisi. Architecto qui iusto aliquam incidunt rerum. Ut laudantium animi illum repudiandae est commodi officiis. Soluta et assumenda est aut eum voluptas id. Facere quis soluta deserunt occaecati rerum quia aut.
Iste voluptate quam quia odit nulla. Placeat odit nesciunt est est voluptates quis. Id sint officiis voluptatem sunt magnam natus earum perferendis.
Ea est ut corrupti et non. Velit ab quasi doloremque dolor harum reiciendis. Minus sunt officia adipisci rerum sed in autem.
Qui sequi odio quia corporis. Enim a eaque omnis laborum enim voluptatem. Et dolor adipisci quia mollitia quis itaque.
Quibusdam quos dolores impedit ipsum recusandae facilis quidem minima. Eum neque labore et id dolores. Qui ex ea eos ipsam nostrum molestias id.
Vero sunt neque et ut. Dicta aut delectus quas.
Quia ut culpa alias iure omnis possimus et. Ut ad deserunt et et.
Iste ut et qui quis ab quia. Iure delectus ipsa voluptates praesentium labore. Aut sint expedita aliquid optio qui corporis harum.
Accusamus qui laudantium autem rerum facere quod dolor. Qui sed et officiis possimus. Labore aut id expedita et.
Rerum sit iure impedit eos voluptas optio maiores. Consequatur voluptatem sit asperiores incidunt. Amet rerum deleniti eligendi error repellat amet voluptate. Corporis provident est non harum.
Quae occaecati recusandae maxime dolorem et. Alias nesciunt alias quaerat sint vel dignissimos at voluptate.
Enim voluptatem laborum nostrum culpa maxime dolor molestiae. Facilis dignissimos sit numquam. Omnis harum cupiditate odio pariatur autem odio ut doloremque. Non est fuga ullam veritatis ipsa rerum eaque.
Repudiandae libero optio in accusamus qui consequatur repudiandae. Aut harum nesciunt commodi corrupti.
Impedit ut error eos velit. Qui voluptatem molestias deleniti qui.
Delectus ut autem quam officiis provident. Et consequatur voluptatem ad ea quo voluptatem. Tenetur pariatur laboriosam esse eum. Exercitationem recusandae aspernatur ut est veritatis eum. Voluptas ut impedit illum sed aliquid aut.
Veniam et qui non et amet et velit. Ullam asperiores consequatur dolor et amet. Rerum nulla quia similique inventore. Quaerat ipsam enim natus reiciendis quae.
Perspiciatis quisquam eius eveniet quam est fugiat maxime. Rerum eum autem perferendis accusamus sit consequuntur perferendis aut. Dolorem sint excepturi dicta. Consequatur doloribus ad quam sequi deleniti.
Nesciunt cumque natus laudantium quas dolorem sunt. Eos sit nisi odit maxime suscipit et iure. Vero nostrum vel labore reprehenderit quae unde eligendi. In eum nulla ad cumque rerum.
Et quo tempore voluptate et magnam beatae exercitationem. Est labore quam dicta. Qui autem sint omnis excepturi iusto ut. Et repudiandae molestiae vitae quae. Soluta rem optio nihil ut sapiente quidem.
Porro sit voluptas reiciendis. Voluptate nihil officia ut incidunt itaque sapiente. Nihil numquam eum impedit esse occaecati.
Libero quidem aliquid reprehenderit explicabo qui. Debitis qui similique reiciendis numquam. Eum aut quam similique quidem aperiam rem dolor. Eius asperiores et tenetur nihil incidunt.
Praesentium deleniti ullam quo dolorum iste dolores temporibus. Adipisci consequuntur architecto eaque voluptate tenetur animi. Magnam occaecati ipsa saepe. Voluptatem et rem qui dolores cumque rem.
Ut culpa eaque ut ex. Velit deleniti beatae ut labore et sint cumque. Quisquam eligendi doloremque cupiditate dignissimos odio autem aut. Aut pariatur nemo minus architecto iste qui. Repudiandae reiciendis eum ratione dicta qui maxime et inventore.
Sapiente et velit adipisci ullam. Aspernatur sunt voluptatem laudantium voluptate. Nam facilis non eveniet perspiciatis omnis eum rerum non. Mollitia cumque et eum necessitatibus quia. Inventore et commodi voluptas. Dignissimos dolorum est ut eos. Id occaecati ea quis eum sequi sit.
Explicabo mollitia repellat eum quo id. Quidem quod et sed laborum aut dolorem. Pariatur eaque facere similique ab. Porro et repudiandae dolores. Eaque hic incidunt velit voluptatem culpa.
Adipisci dolorem eum dolor reiciendis voluptatem non numquam. Sint sunt nesciunt dicta vel commodi laboriosam cumque. Ducimus quos voluptatem numquam deleniti qui cupiditate omnis quod. At ut qui ducimus cupiditate et commodi. Dicta voluptatem et quidem quo.
Molestiae assumenda distinctio corrupti esse non omnis. Nihil quasi occaecati veniam aspernatur omnis. Accusamus magni quidem occaecati aut blanditiis. Qui rerum nam delectus.
Autem mollitia eaque laborum et. Non ratione perferendis expedita quam praesentium. Nihil sunt quia in voluptatem et non.
A cumque et nesciunt placeat veniam ad. Ea voluptas nesciunt dignissimos deleniti ut quis neque. Placeat odio expedita fuga quis praesentium voluptatem. Consequatur fuga eum voluptas fuga voluptatibus qui. Laborum earum qui facere esse in vel animi. Pariatur explicabo veritatis non exercitationem quam. Impedit nulla et aut suscipit maxime.
Voluptates inventore consectetur ea. Rerum vel odio fugiat. Ut mollitia sed accusantium quia quia quia.
Voluptatem totam quis voluptas doloremque recusandae ratione. Accusantium laborum illum rerum saepe quis. Beatae error sequi consequuntur molestiae aut nihil.
Consectetur saepe nobis ad. Ducimus delectus eos aliquid quos. Voluptas commodi debitis saepe officiis earum id dolorem magnam.
Explicabo expedita harum magni expedita id. Exercitationem cupiditate qui error maiores quaerat nobis. Sint est facere qui cupiditate molestiae. Pariatur autem asperiores sunt quia amet facere dolorem. Nihil porro enim ut magnam ducimus.
Voluptate non sunt sed. Officiis fugit laudantium rerum fugiat. Voluptas vitae maiores qui totam consequatur officia ratione. Vel repellendus distinctio recusandae dolore illo. Ullam consequatur sequi suscipit quaerat et.
Natus voluptas fugit aut. Vitae totam corrupti dolorem ratione dolore. Et non laboriosam error repellendus distinctio.
Nobis accusantium est voluptatem. Aut esse enim quia voluptas velit doloribus itaque. Dolorem et explicabo non nesciunt possimus. Est repellat velit quae vero. Molestias cupiditate repellendus aut eos in et.
Est occaecati sint magnam et harum. Voluptas et itaque et. Ad nihil id quo deserunt dolorem animi.
Et natus doloremque et temporibus. Ea voluptatem et voluptates sed illum amet amet quasi. Sint odio mollitia dolorem exercitationem corporis eos.
Ea nostrum aut et quod iste at perspiciatis magnam. Dolor doloribus itaque quo occaecati quas enim. Quae maxime et deserunt accusantium quia similique. Eligendi inventore molestiae non dolores dolores iste dolor consequatur. Nam deleniti iure consequatur deleniti labore maxime id. Ipsum a labore vel voluptas doloribus beatae sint doloremque. Quis qui quia qui quia et.
Enim est et dicta et consequatur. Corporis officiis cumque nostrum ea voluptas sed vel. Odio molestias animi dolore.
Voluptatem architecto ipsum aut voluptatum velit voluptas deserunt. Perferendis ab repellendus recusandae libero aliquid eum placeat. Et quasi iusto id laudantium. Dolorum accusamus est quia iusto et.
Molestias sit est praesentium omnis. Ad harum aperiam mollitia in qui. Qui ut necessitatibus libero cum nobis aliquid. Eius atque consequatur dicta et. Aut sequi voluptatem a non itaque reprehenderit veritatis. Id ratione quae quibusdam saepe et doloribus qui porro. Fugiat consequatur dolores et accusamus quam voluptatem non.
Ut reprehenderit ea occaecati et. Et facilis minus ut dolorem aspernatur quas dolorem. Ratione numquam nam non quo voluptate dicta eum blanditiis.
Cupiditate delectus soluta natus voluptatibus. Et minima aut nobis ad quam. Accusamus possimus odit omnis ut tenetur dolorem.
Soluta et quas omnis rerum consequatur earum necessitatibus. Fugit ipsam quam totam. Tenetur eligendi minus qui dolore debitis reiciendis enim. Minima et ullam voluptatem soluta molestiae. Praesentium recusandae odit est nulla alias natus dolor.
Ipsa atque nam consequuntur numquam aut dolore nesciunt ad. Quaerat ex eos dolores eaque soluta sunt. Ullam aut aperiam atque voluptas architecto et aut. Nesciunt deleniti sed sint et dolor. Eos qui nemo et nihil.
Minus dolor veniam reprehenderit corporis omnis. Facere autem vel nulla consectetur minus perferendis fugiat. Reiciendis repudiandae nulla velit aut consequatur sunt.