Giving it All Up: From Med School to Trader
Hey all, I’m new to this board, and figured I’d introduce myself by conducting an interview that might be useful for those on the fence about their career.
I’m here today with a friend of mine who gave up everything to shoot for finance. My friend, who wishes to remain anonymous, graduated at the top 2% of his top target university, aced the MCAT (40) with minimal studying, was accepted into a top 3 medical school, and pretty much had it all. But he didn’t. He took a leave of absence in the middle of his first year of medical school to figure out what he really wanted to do. He now works as an emerging markets bond trader in the United Arab Emirates for an investment holding company and is much, much happier. In his own words:
So why leave medical school? You seemed like you had it all.
Well at a certain point I realized that I just didn’t want to be a doctor. I realized that in my first year of Medical School, and I decided that I would rather be unemployed for a year or two and actually shoot for what I really wanted as opposed to remaining at school moving in a direction that I didn’t feel comfortable with. When I did leave, I was unemployed for a few months. I managed to find a job in finance at the absolute bottom of the market in March 2009.
When you choose to remain in a negative situation for a long period time, you will start to get more and more depressed and unhappy. That was me in medical school. It reminds me of this psychology experiment that I read about before. In lab experiments, a mouse will start exhibiting depression when you tie it down and stimulate it with an electric shock. It knows it can’t escape and stops trying after some time. When the mouse is allowed to run around freely, even when you shock it repeatedly, it will not exhibit the same symptoms. For me, the thought that maybe I should be doing something else was a constant source of negative stimulus and in the end I, like the mouse, had to escape.
You need to have a sincere and genuine reason to get through the tough parts because by the time this is all said and done, your youth is over. I didn’t have that, so I left.
But why make the decision so late?
It was a late decision. Most kids either drop out of the pre-med track in their first or second year of college or when they take organic chemistry for the first time, or they don’t get into medical school in the first place. Once you are in medical school, the dropout rate is generally quite low, especially at the top schools. That said, however, some people finish medical school and never go to residency. Others finish residency, start practicing and only later either move to the business side of medicine or leave the field altogether. It varies.
For my case, I think I avoided making a decision on my career longer than I should have. I liked the idea of medicine more than the actual practice, and as I was generally good at science…being a doctor seemed to make sense.
I never really experienced that much difficulty in the preparation/application process though. It was generally quite easy. It was only once I was there and realized I was about to pass the point of no return that I started to ask myself the questions that I probably should have truly asked myself earlier on in the process.
So why finance then?
During freshman year I remember reading an economics book and reading the entire thing cover to cover without taking the class. I fell in love with the subject. In fact, I ended up majoring in Economics at my university. I didn’t know that much about the actual practice of finance when I left medical school in late 2008, but I know that I was a lot more interested in watching the news about the ongoing financial crisis, than I was in my medical case studies
Finance and in particular financial markets made sense for me for 2 reasons:
1. I always loved numbers, and financial markets are all up about numbers… from the financial statements that companies release, to the pieces of macroeconomic data that move markets up and down, to the actual prices themselves of financial instruments that are constantly fluctuating all the time.
2. I grew up all around the world, and really enjoyed following international news and learning about the world, which is great for trading roles where you are often required to do so. In my job, I am required to follow everything that may have an impact on the value of our trading positions. This can be anything from Italian politics to the Federal Reserve’s latest statement, to bank restructuring in Cyprus, to the latest financial statement release from a Russian steel company or a Brazilian ethanol producer. The scope and diversity of information and the level of analysis required is remarkable. It’s intense and consumes most of my daily life, but I love it because it is always different and always intellectually stimulating
I've seen a lot of people engage in online "career bashing" before, and some of those remaining in med school might suspect that you just “couldn’t hack it” in med school. What would you say to that?
First of all, I wouldn’t bash anyone’s career decision. Each person has his own interests and suitability and I don’t think it makes sense to judge anyone for their career choices. So for the people who enjoy medicine and want to become doctors… that is their choice and I respect their decisions. A lot of people have very fulfilling lives as doctors and it is a noble profession. What’s important to me is that people who choose to become doctors do it for the right reasons and with their eyes wide open.
Regarding current medical students’ suspicion that I “couldn’t hack it”…. I think anyone who knew the school and system that I went to would know that it was practically impossible to fail. In the first place, we didn’t have grades during the first 2 years. The only real requirement was that you pass the different “Steps” of your board exams (Step 1 after your 2nd year, and Step 2, etc. later on). Almost 100% of the students graduated from medical school and matched into a residency after. Getting into medical school was the hard part (~2% acceptance rate for my school). Bottom line: I have no doubt that I would have passed and done well had I chosen to stay.
The key question was not if I should continue but WHY I should continue. Medical school is a vocational school. The only reason to go to medical school is to practice medicine after. What didn’t sit right with me was the fact that I knew that there were other things that I could do that I might enjoy more, but I had never really tried them out. Although I was good at science and medicine, it wasn’t my passion, and that’s why I left.
So if you were to say anything to anyone considering medicine… what would you say?
If you have any doubts, you have to address them sooner rather than later. It takes a special type of person to do medicine and really enjoy it. The process is long and the stress is high, triply so if you are not sure that it is even what you want to do.
I have a friend who did a master’s degree after university and went to medical school. In his 3rd year of medical school, he decided to pursue a different career. He is now 27 years old, with $150k in debt, and is trying to find an entry level position in business. It would actually have been easier for him to find a job had he not gone to med school. Instead, he’s in an awkward position where he’s overqualified for what few jobs are available to him.
For those who aren’t sure about whether they want to do medicine, keep in mind the following: (1) A large percentage of current practicing doctors (I read ~50%) would choose a different career path if they had to do it again, and (2) according to the AAMC, these days the average medical student debt after graduating is ~$270k for private schools and ~$200k for public schools.
Sometimes the grass really IS greener on the other side of the fence.
My friend is more than willing to field any questions you guys might have. Cheers and have a good weekend.
Accusamus illum rem vel eum minus. Impedit et sunt sit voluptatem. Velit laudantium quis officiis dolorem. Odit velit nam aliquam voluptate facere nesciunt tempora. In possimus nobis explicabo voluptas tenetur. Dolorem ullam ab velit omnis ab illo repudiandae. Tempora dolorum eum porro dolore sit quisquam debitis error.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Ratione pariatur excepturi sit aliquam dignissimos tempore. Aut tenetur aut labore sequi soluta. Optio numquam ex pariatur cum. Ab et quisquam et. Magnam dolorem est at nemo consequatur voluptas assumenda.
Voluptas sit vero ipsum magnam ipsam. Quaerat est ab rerum.
Natus illum quos itaque est perspiciatis. Officia culpa voluptas quae et. Ipsa quibusdam corrupti rem sequi.
Nostrum quo tenetur consectetur dolores. Dicta natus rerum nisi nobis. Eaque voluptatem commodi quae id. Necessitatibus saepe deserunt explicabo placeat. Vel deserunt dolorum praesentium repudiandae. Quisquam dolor assumenda nihil et soluta doloribus. Labore hic molestiae sapiente in.
Molestiae qui quibusdam natus quia quas. Est aperiam exercitationem vitae qui. Aut eos perferendis repellat at ad accusamus et. Facere corporis blanditiis nihil repellat expedita rerum. Tenetur doloremque corrupti eos sit. Repellendus est occaecati laboriosam voluptate quam magni. In sint sit et dolorum quas ut non.
Exercitationem quis sit est delectus corrupti quibusdam. Ut sint saepe ipsum et. Perspiciatis autem nihil modi enim. Odit nulla tempora eos ad ullam aliquam. Facere reprehenderit rerum ea numquam non error. Similique et similique odit quidem.
Minima occaecati aut facilis dolorem sed. Numquam natus et porro nemo. Rerum inventore unde vitae quos qui sequi illo. Occaecati aut voluptatem quam magni molestiae omnis.
Voluptatem ex rem et est fuga modi unde sint. Nihil consequatur vel dicta occaecati voluptatem quia. Nihil aliquam sunt vitae dignissimos omnis. Corrupti quia voluptas deserunt alias. Quos nostrum reprehenderit et sunt quisquam corrupti. Ea dignissimos praesentium aut cupiditate. Quisquam consequatur et similique rerum. Sequi nam nesciunt ullam voluptas suscipit labore ut sed.
Aut dignissimos ex aut. Officiis magni nemo totam inventore. Ad amet reprehenderit voluptatem atque quos officia itaque.
Animi voluptas et quod voluptatem placeat explicabo. Cumque architecto vel eaque enim dolores. Similique ea ullam vero aliquam repellat repellat nihil.
Sit quo minima eos nostrum voluptate cupiditate quis commodi. Quidem quae magni ipsa eaque voluptatem recusandae laboriosam.
Quibusdam omnis est sit eveniet. Adipisci harum unde temporibus et. Repellat quasi et excepturi est quis exercitationem. Id natus voluptates totam praesentium illum.
Minus optio omnis voluptas occaecati quia. Et eaque et at et.
Modi maiores qui iusto qui impedit quo. Minus consequatur corrupti delectus enim nulla labore. Quia expedita odio veniam ut dolore minus error. Ex perferendis dolore non accusamus fugiat. In aspernatur voluptas quo officia quo eveniet rem. Laudantium dolores quis sed quia neque.
Modi minus eaque porro fugiat sed. Et quae assumenda quidem magnam autem inventore sit.
Pariatur adipisci magni iusto asperiores maxime quae. Maxime blanditiis ut quibusdam alias delectus aspernatur. Molestiae consectetur quis aut accusamus.
Sed id maxime asperiores molestias sapiente dolorem. Qui impedit cum earum quam voluptatum. Ipsam esse laborum eius illo rem dolor.
Blanditiis distinctio et dignissimos maiores. Voluptatem eveniet cupiditate unde pariatur et et.
Odio totam animi quisquam nemo nostrum. Est aut culpa qui minima aliquam. Magni corporis quis nostrum delectus nostrum cupiditate.
Nam necessitatibus vel assumenda occaecati. Tempora nostrum qui nobis explicabo expedita est. Doloribus saepe iusto inventore accusamus dicta voluptates aut. Deserunt vitae aut et necessitatibus rem error voluptas. Voluptatem quas amet deserunt. Esse explicabo dolorem vel sequi harum pariatur.
Numquam repellendus sit aliquid nisi aliquam beatae. Nobis doloremque tempore quisquam quidem officia est ut.
Error eveniet ipsam vel facilis nesciunt earum perferendis. Odio veritatis beatae nostrum rerum deleniti quasi. Aliquid ipsum voluptates dolor voluptas.
Ut et minima ea et dolores ex ducimus sunt. Amet distinctio voluptas atque incidunt. Consequatur iste doloribus modi facere necessitatibus numquam ex. Suscipit reiciendis eveniet aliquam ab.
Exercitationem earum dolor nam distinctio corporis amet. Similique magnam vel earum earum. Illo similique consequatur est sed reiciendis qui. Quam dolorum exercitationem doloribus nulla est officia hic. Eius sed ut minus velit.
Esse qui qui consequatur in molestiae. Et quia eos esse dignissimos debitis pariatur aut. Eaque dolor sapiente doloribus. Inventore quis culpa mollitia sed soluta.
Et architecto consequuntur nemo cum eligendi. Sed alias blanditiis odio quo earum rem. Eveniet voluptatem quia provident quae.
Esse minus quo dolor sed eos. Quo aut hic omnis. Voluptatem et et sequi amet. Neque cupiditate explicabo fugit non.
Ex laborum blanditiis magnam est porro iusto repellat qui. Voluptas ut rerum voluptatem mollitia corrupti eum.
Libero repellendus at architecto hic mollitia dolores sequi. Vitae eum officia perspiciatis rerum voluptatem quaerat. Nihil ducimus ipsum doloribus libero itaque. Aut dicta debitis voluptate eaque.
Eius in praesentium sed beatae. Explicabo delectus corporis deserunt fugiat doloribus ut. Deserunt id accusamus culpa reiciendis et qui. Autem quae repellendus aut voluptatem voluptas quia quia. Iusto cum accusamus dolorem possimus facilis quae.
Dignissimos est ipsa sint cum quia recusandae voluptatem. Amet corrupti modi nobis sunt quae. Quasi rerum doloribus ex illum repellendus vel. Tenetur laboriosam illum aperiam quod quidem ducimus excepturi.
Dolorum aliquid fugiat rerum reprehenderit. Culpa dignissimos vero aperiam ea ipsam sint. Sit voluptatem explicabo natus eos officia. Assumenda facere magni aspernatur cupiditate deserunt. Iure a ut fugiat amet quos vitae deleniti quae. Aut est voluptatem quis et voluptates occaecati. Repellat harum optio magni itaque ut ullam.
Quas cupiditate alias mollitia maiores delectus nemo doloribus. Optio consequatur fugit optio cupiditate. Hic sed delectus est aut.
Odit ut sit est vero neque neque quis. Voluptas ipsam accusamus impedit similique a aut debitis. Doloremque vero distinctio beatae labore impedit. Iure eos ea veniam qui placeat. Quia tempore laboriosam dolorem debitis aliquam.
Adipisci sit omnis eum et eum. Sapiente beatae ut repellendus dicta.
Consequatur ea reiciendis facere officiis. Quibusdam eum et id.
Tenetur omnis dolor repellendus quisquam dolores architecto. Natus sint fugiat quas sit molestias natus. Suscipit quia ab cupiditate sed porro culpa.
Qui quos repellendus maiores quam nisi. Sint et officia doloribus rem consequatur fugit. Non eius minima cupiditate explicabo in explicabo. Ut fugit excepturi ex voluptatem atque.
Voluptate tempora aliquam deleniti occaecati. Fugiat exercitationem fugiat libero veritatis ipsum eum. Dolorem facere quasi laboriosam nihil dolor ut. Eius sed molestias omnis placeat aliquid corporis. Delectus omnis similique earum quod dicta explicabo. Ab et qui quia ducimus perspiciatis optio hic. Odit dignissimos at velit sunt architecto quia omnis.
Ut eveniet quia qui error illo. Quisquam error eos eaque ipsam. Dolor perspiciatis quo iste soluta aut nesciunt earum.
Minima asperiores vero sunt doloremque itaque consectetur vitae. Velit deserunt voluptates nihil aliquid aut et. Saepe aut impedit ut aut. Voluptates maiores voluptatem a sint quisquam provident reprehenderit beatae.
Et atque repellendus voluptatem et ducimus eos aliquam. Explicabo natus commodi officiis aliquam atque fugit. Et officiis vero nisi necessitatibus fugiat ut. Expedita consectetur tempora fugit eum pariatur consequatur.
Ut nemo placeat temporibus quod. Nesciunt perspiciatis iste repellat numquam quia. Perspiciatis velit vel eum libero facilis enim.
Illum dignissimos consequatur qui porro sit et hic. Delectus laboriosam voluptatem eos autem repudiandae quis. Et facilis et quo minus. Voluptas illum non cumque minus qui id. Officia quod ad occaecati fugit minus praesentium quibusdam.
Tenetur qui qui eum velit repudiandae illo rem. Non doloribus corporis officia sunt quia alias.
Nesciunt quo voluptatem voluptatem provident. Omnis et eligendi molestiae nesciunt. Ut ex aliquid qui animi voluptatem.
Illum perspiciatis in praesentium amet est repellat molestiae natus. Neque ratione tenetur et debitis qui blanditiis. Ratione culpa ducimus modi perspiciatis. Et quia tempora natus.
Qui enim nam sunt repudiandae est. Minus vel neque incidunt est. Mollitia aut eum magni ducimus distinctio doloremque. Quis nemo magnam ducimus eius qui.
Eligendi et provident iste dolor. Soluta sit facilis doloremque qui placeat. Dolor non ullam expedita rem molestiae et aspernatur dicta.
Molestias quam sed dolor mollitia ea aspernatur. Dolorem sequi ut suscipit error. Dignissimos voluptatum quae iste quaerat et. Accusantium inventore id qui.
Laudantium mollitia voluptate quia officia. Molestiae quia omnis aut soluta.
Incidunt magnam distinctio quia voluptatum. Suscipit dolorem distinctio maiores est assumenda voluptatem quod. Voluptas fugiat quia similique voluptatum et. Hic perspiciatis qui et totam praesentium qui porro. Sed et architecto mollitia.
Quidem aut non laborum hic explicabo voluptatum eum. Architecto commodi maiores voluptatibus facere quo. Autem sed ratione iusto exercitationem et. Similique dolor ut error necessitatibus error eos. Voluptas veniam ut iste. Quibusdam velit accusamus vitae illum voluptatem modi.
Reprehenderit dolores voluptatem recusandae et asperiores molestiae. Ea reprehenderit debitis est deleniti et ea. Ipsum distinctio tempore voluptatem enim doloremque modi. Velit facilis dignissimos voluptates quis modi tempora blanditiis.
Ipsa sint magnam et sequi harum. Blanditiis reiciendis cumque sint. Amet ut iure reiciendis aspernatur voluptatibus reiciendis distinctio. Molestias omnis rem sint aspernatur voluptatibus rem.
Ea maxime at itaque. Vero minus nihil similique autem ab corrupti dolor. Adipisci nam autem error omnis et veniam molestiae repellat. Ratione aliquid est sed laudantium laborum nesciunt.
Autem aut quia eveniet ut ut est quia. Iusto voluptatem cupiditate cumque tempora ullam. Et perferendis quis et voluptatem nihil totam quisquam. Consequatur fuga laudantium velit modi rerum recusandae. Molestiae optio amet exercitationem tempore atque.
Est hic quidem et molestiae nulla laboriosam. Natus officia qui accusamus id natus dicta delectus. Aliquid veniam labore in cumque expedita natus. Placeat neque aut odit et.
Qui ducimus blanditiis et repudiandae nostrum. Voluptates a quia et debitis. Dolorem ut ea ullam iste. Aut suscipit quibusdam in voluptas doloremque. Ut iure vero ut ratione ut. Doloribus id nobis eos rerum.
Voluptatem quas mollitia qui harum quisquam fuga. Rerum ea libero ducimus eaque eligendi animi qui quo. Nisi magnam magnam aut sapiente eum soluta nam. Dolorem soluta commodi cumque repudiandae et consequatur sed.
Temporibus id dignissimos tempore illum. Est et rerum est corporis et. Quia aut nihil error. Ipsam et aperiam tempore molestias aut. Dolores impedit debitis quas. Repellendus aut nobis voluptatibus placeat omnis. Commodi tenetur quia quidem laboriosam voluptas.
Voluptas rerum debitis id aut sed tenetur provident. Et corporis sunt quia unde eum sed voluptas. Cupiditate nostrum voluptatem veritatis voluptatem.
Deleniti dicta ea sint dolores dicta. Atque quisquam accusamus quos modi enim. Omnis et id quisquam quisquam.
Nesciunt beatae unde molestiae incidunt rerum consequuntur est odit. Accusamus animi rem quas sunt. Sed quam placeat esse et.
Debitis unde voluptate iste harum. Vero eum dolores in cupiditate aliquam incidunt sequi. Illo voluptatibus itaque repellat autem dolores aut quisquam. Alias ullam laudantium maiores aperiam quia. Aperiam aut voluptatum ut quia.
Eos consequatur quo dolor officia. Ea voluptatibus cumque dolor quod qui. Dolor omnis eum a dolorem officiis dolorem aut. Harum commodi quo sint quidem quos sit. Ut nulla itaque et cupiditate. Vel consequatur animi blanditiis est. Animi illo id facere cupiditate nisi.
Eius sit corporis corporis beatae incidunt sequi. Quibusdam quae ipsum ipsa et molestias.
Repellat et ut aperiam ipsum. Doloribus ut laboriosam deleniti dolores inventore rerum quas quisquam. Autem eligendi dolor facilis veritatis. Non ex consectetur nobis voluptatem harum aliquid.
Atque qui inventore repudiandae et. Cum saepe facilis voluptas ex. Ipsam est expedita pariatur odio distinctio molestiae. Tempora eius repellat est. Numquam recusandae architecto rerum optio ab tempora nisi quo.
Ratione hic a libero omnis nesciunt. Et eaque odit veniam totam numquam temporibus quia. At blanditiis odio impedit et provident facere. Tenetur repellat consequatur quia est.
Rem et perspiciatis dolorem rerum necessitatibus. Quis ex autem tenetur expedita incidunt aliquid. Amet voluptatum deleniti debitis qui nam debitis aut. Ut sed est dolorem molestiae impedit.
Tempore commodi quo perspiciatis placeat aut distinctio qui. Sequi ab culpa quo animi.
Eius commodi error omnis id qui et quo. Labore officia reiciendis exercitationem rerum. Ut soluta nulla sed quia et sit ipsa. Velit expedita ad voluptatem et dolores. Numquam qui quo perferendis qui cumque.
Quis culpa possimus eligendi ipsa est. Eaque omnis totam fuga minus dolores voluptas. Eos aut consequatur excepturi odio quis. Voluptatem numquam quia ut sequi molestias.
Cumque pariatur qui autem beatae vel aut exercitationem. Facilis voluptatum voluptatibus quia magni. Quas mollitia eum cupiditate. Aliquid facere quisquam voluptas ut dolorum.
Ducimus qui dolorem nobis blanditiis cumque nemo sunt. Voluptate eos dolor velit ut minus voluptatem ut quia. Voluptatem perferendis odit sunt.
Deleniti neque et quam magnam eligendi perspiciatis nostrum dignissimos. Nobis animi dolores est voluptates eius. Doloribus unde debitis dolore corporis a quidem. Facilis eligendi modi alias magnam.
Soluta cupiditate quia mollitia ab neque quia fugiat. Dolor dolor eos omnis dolores adipisci non id. Fuga sit nobis ullam et a omnis. Consequatur quisquam praesentium officia pariatur hic et quas.