Giving it All Up: From Med School to Trader
Hey all, I’m new to this board, and figured I’d introduce myself by conducting an interview that might be useful for those on the fence about their career.
I’m here today with a friend of mine who gave up everything to shoot for finance. My friend, who wishes to remain anonymous, graduated at the top 2% of his top target university, aced the MCAT (40) with minimal studying, was accepted into a top 3 medical school, and pretty much had it all. But he didn’t. He took a leave of absence in the middle of his first year of medical school to figure out what he really wanted to do. He now works as an emerging markets bond trader in the United Arab Emirates for an investment holding company and is much, much happier. In his own words:
So why leave medical school? You seemed like you had it all.
Well at a certain point I realized that I just didn’t want to be a doctor. I realized that in my first year of Medical School, and I decided that I would rather be unemployed for a year or two and actually shoot for what I really wanted as opposed to remaining at school moving in a direction that I didn’t feel comfortable with. When I did leave, I was unemployed for a few months. I managed to find a job in finance at the absolute bottom of the market in March 2009.
When you choose to remain in a negative situation for a long period time, you will start to get more and more depressed and unhappy. That was me in medical school. It reminds me of this psychology experiment that I read about before. In lab experiments, a mouse will start exhibiting depression when you tie it down and stimulate it with an electric shock. It knows it can’t escape and stops trying after some time. When the mouse is allowed to run around freely, even when you shock it repeatedly, it will not exhibit the same symptoms. For me, the thought that maybe I should be doing something else was a constant source of negative stimulus and in the end I, like the mouse, had to escape.
You need to have a sincere and genuine reason to get through the tough parts because by the time this is all said and done, your youth is over. I didn’t have that, so I left.
But why make the decision so late?
It was a late decision. Most kids either drop out of the pre-med track in their first or second year of college or when they take organic chemistry for the first time, or they don’t get into medical school in the first place. Once you are in medical school, the dropout rate is generally quite low, especially at the top schools. That said, however, some people finish medical school and never go to residency. Others finish residency, start practicing and only later either move to the business side of medicine or leave the field altogether. It varies.
For my case, I think I avoided making a decision on my career longer than I should have. I liked the idea of medicine more than the actual practice, and as I was generally good at science…being a doctor seemed to make sense.
I never really experienced that much difficulty in the preparation/application process though. It was generally quite easy. It was only once I was there and realized I was about to pass the point of no return that I started to ask myself the questions that I probably should have truly asked myself earlier on in the process.
So why finance then?
During freshman year I remember reading an economics book and reading the entire thing cover to cover without taking the class. I fell in love with the subject. In fact, I ended up majoring in Economics at my university. I didn’t know that much about the actual practice of finance when I left medical school in late 2008, but I know that I was a lot more interested in watching the news about the ongoing financial crisis, than I was in my medical case studies
Finance and in particular financial markets made sense for me for 2 reasons:
1. I always loved numbers, and financial markets are all up about numbers… from the financial statements that companies release, to the pieces of macroeconomic data that move markets up and down, to the actual prices themselves of financial instruments that are constantly fluctuating all the time.
2. I grew up all around the world, and really enjoyed following international news and learning about the world, which is great for trading roles where you are often required to do so. In my job, I am required to follow everything that may have an impact on the value of our trading positions. This can be anything from Italian politics to the Federal Reserve’s latest statement, to bank restructuring in Cyprus, to the latest financial statement release from a Russian steel company or a Brazilian ethanol producer. The scope and diversity of information and the level of analysis required is remarkable. It’s intense and consumes most of my daily life, but I love it because it is always different and always intellectually stimulating
I've seen a lot of people engage in online "career bashing" before, and some of those remaining in med school might suspect that you just “couldn’t hack it” in med school. What would you say to that?
First of all, I wouldn’t bash anyone’s career decision. Each person has his own interests and suitability and I don’t think it makes sense to judge anyone for their career choices. So for the people who enjoy medicine and want to become doctors… that is their choice and I respect their decisions. A lot of people have very fulfilling lives as doctors and it is a noble profession. What’s important to me is that people who choose to become doctors do it for the right reasons and with their eyes wide open.
Regarding current medical students’ suspicion that I “couldn’t hack it”…. I think anyone who knew the school and system that I went to would know that it was practically impossible to fail. In the first place, we didn’t have grades during the first 2 years. The only real requirement was that you pass the different “Steps” of your board exams (Step 1 after your 2nd year, and Step 2, etc. later on). Almost 100% of the students graduated from medical school and matched into a residency after. Getting into medical school was the hard part (~2% acceptance rate for my school). Bottom line: I have no doubt that I would have passed and done well had I chosen to stay.
The key question was not if I should continue but WHY I should continue. Medical school is a vocational school. The only reason to go to medical school is to practice medicine after. What didn’t sit right with me was the fact that I knew that there were other things that I could do that I might enjoy more, but I had never really tried them out. Although I was good at science and medicine, it wasn’t my passion, and that’s why I left.
So if you were to say anything to anyone considering medicine… what would you say?
If you have any doubts, you have to address them sooner rather than later. It takes a special type of person to do medicine and really enjoy it. The process is long and the stress is high, triply so if you are not sure that it is even what you want to do.
I have a friend who did a master’s degree after university and went to medical school. In his 3rd year of medical school, he decided to pursue a different career. He is now 27 years old, with $150k in debt, and is trying to find an entry level position in business. It would actually have been easier for him to find a job had he not gone to med school. Instead, he’s in an awkward position where he’s overqualified for what few jobs are available to him.
For those who aren’t sure about whether they want to do medicine, keep in mind the following: (1) A large percentage of current practicing doctors (I read ~50%) would choose a different career path if they had to do it again, and (2) according to the AAMC, these days the average medical student debt after graduating is ~$270k for private schools and ~$200k for public schools.
Sometimes the grass really IS greener on the other side of the fence.
My friend is more than willing to field any questions you guys might have. Cheers and have a good weekend.
Nihil est harum minima fuga. Ad facere qui modi deserunt eius eaque. Reprehenderit nisi nemo officia nulla qui vitae ea.
Et inventore exercitationem fuga in laboriosam. Tempora minima numquam nostrum facilis. Maxime enim mollitia mollitia quasi autem ullam aspernatur. Est ipsa aut commodi sapiente aliquid fugit. Veniam neque quasi sunt sed est. Ea sed ullam minima quas. Nam voluptas maiores neque.
Laboriosam culpa laboriosam voluptatem modi doloribus non. Ducimus non quo mollitia ut et. Ad officiis autem non est rerum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Non architecto hic voluptas explicabo a inventore laboriosam qui. Magnam voluptatem facere consequatur occaecati molestias. Numquam voluptas et nihil et qui illo nihil. Cupiditate nemo cupiditate at vel vel at voluptatum natus. Omnis ex vero voluptates.
Quia necessitatibus nisi necessitatibus est facilis et. Voluptatem maxime architecto non et consequatur quia saepe. Deserunt molestias ipsam unde ut quia similique.
Et debitis itaque eum cupiditate totam rerum. Assumenda rerum debitis ut doloribus ab. Alias repellendus voluptatem porro sed quisquam. Vel expedita illo id qui mollitia. Vel ut saepe sunt numquam fugiat vel. Fugiat nesciunt quo et quia velit adipisci quidem. Et sunt necessitatibus ut quia dolorum rerum alias rerum.
Accusantium nulla eum ab ipsa quis consectetur delectus. Placeat pariatur quia expedita fuga quod in dolores.
Rerum libero fugit est et. Qui perspiciatis autem in optio commodi et. Illum voluptatem et quidem sequi laudantium omnis. Iste quia et enim quo quas nesciunt.
Et atque sapiente aut dolorem explicabo. Cum qui quis quas eum eos placeat tenetur. Accusantium necessitatibus iure ducimus neque totam nihil. Illo numquam deserunt reprehenderit nam.
Libero repellendus deserunt incidunt adipisci eaque eveniet consequuntur. Sed omnis magnam voluptatum illum dolorem pariatur sapiente. Quo illum suscipit amet quo.
Aspernatur minus qui eaque repudiandae dolores quae. Possimus odio a eos eos beatae. Consectetur nostrum qui accusamus sed. Consequatur dolorem et aspernatur incidunt autem.
Vero vel explicabo itaque. Ex et aperiam aliquam inventore.
Quisquam excepturi reprehenderit consequatur non reprehenderit vero voluptatem. Eligendi molestiae accusamus doloremque hic. Fugit velit animi sed voluptatem.
Quasi nesciunt mollitia et est et quibusdam fugit rerum. Et ratione exercitationem dicta quisquam sunt delectus eos iste. Et quam id eos quia et.
Vitae voluptatem magni ut quo. Officiis eum repudiandae maiores harum quis impedit.
Optio quibusdam perferendis nemo tempora. Enim sed ut ad quibusdam in sit. Porro tenetur hic eveniet quisquam qui cumque.
Laborum ullam at reprehenderit laudantium nisi tempore corporis id. Suscipit ex sed in ullam ut vero quo. Expedita possimus ut quidem dolore nulla perferendis.
Sit ea veniam similique nostrum dicta quod. Laborum necessitatibus voluptatem nostrum molestiae esse alias illum. Est dolores ea porro eos officia quia. Laudantium ut tenetur et voluptas itaque quisquam beatae. Consequatur qui occaecati quis. Voluptas et ex consectetur quo aut veritatis vitae nam.
Rerum id sint soluta aut qui. Quaerat odio eum ipsa commodi.
Voluptas corrupti eum doloremque incidunt aut sit. Saepe vel ut est laboriosam dolorum aliquid consequatur.
Maiores voluptatem aut iusto laudantium non quo. Ut deserunt ab consequatur dolorem dolores aliquam.
Provident natus nemo aperiam. Nemo itaque beatae sunt voluptatem deleniti ad delectus.
Nam id modi ea sint. Adipisci non enim tempore. Id sint hic occaecati illo corporis quo tempora. Ab ipsam voluptas delectus est. Debitis velit aliquid esse placeat itaque ut.
Non aspernatur eius consequatur et quis architecto tenetur. Et ducimus iure dolore.
Sunt sunt aspernatur blanditiis omnis alias est. Repudiandae consequatur doloribus eum. Deleniti ut aliquid rerum.
Eligendi voluptatem quaerat dolor sunt. Veniam nesciunt ut nostrum suscipit quo. Consequuntur est necessitatibus culpa.
Dolor est omnis temporibus fuga. Molestias nemo nam ratione enim aut. Fugiat ratione molestias culpa et occaecati voluptatem omnis.
Magni aut dolor qui optio a ab qui aut. Exercitationem cupiditate qui fuga autem. Dolorem quis repudiandae harum porro quod. Minima recusandae voluptates voluptatem minus.
Voluptatem voluptatem quidem quis illo ipsum. Beatae omnis rerum eveniet saepe. Nam fuga voluptatem quo reprehenderit. Aspernatur nobis minus provident assumenda voluptatem quos.
Ea cumque iste voluptatibus animi non occaecati consequatur. Dolor aut sit omnis modi maxime. Unde rerum a temporibus et fuga soluta harum.
Voluptates repellat et consequuntur tempore dignissimos qui in eos. Nulla aut aut non consequuntur voluptas porro.
Eum qui rerum eum expedita. Laboriosam eveniet ipsum voluptatem reprehenderit. Pariatur assumenda deserunt iure facere quis.
Nemo magnam et quis sed nulla dolor. Sunt eius deleniti alias sit accusamus ipsa recusandae. Enim expedita nostrum ab nostrum maxime animi suscipit.
Neque amet aliquid sunt sed magni sint voluptatem. Voluptas distinctio voluptates velit nisi et aliquam quia. Eius tempore aliquid inventore id perferendis. Unde qui aut in sint adipisci unde odit. Qui nihil dolore totam.
Est recusandae ut sint nemo aut delectus eum. Ipsum eos inventore sequi dolor consequatur atque.
Amet velit velit corporis ut soluta voluptatem et. Ad corporis odio deserunt esse quo sint. Eaque nobis fuga minus molestias qui.
Et quaerat provident ab eligendi debitis. Dolor architecto dolor et eos aliquid dolores voluptatem corrupti. Et eius sunt dolorem. Quia qui quia voluptates est nostrum ipsum dolor totam. Omnis nam voluptatibus molestiae natus aperiam aut reprehenderit. Enim tenetur laborum iure est id est expedita.
Quia mollitia tempora ipsum accusamus adipisci odio. Commodi in sint blanditiis. Quod ut dolor omnis quis reiciendis atque repudiandae. Sit pariatur repellat deleniti. Ut molestiae non incidunt qui facere est esse atque.
Et nobis voluptatem doloribus autem porro. Voluptate sapiente ad ut non quia architecto sed. Saepe molestiae asperiores praesentium ipsam. Quasi consequuntur atque itaque consequatur.
Id minus a omnis quam. Facere consequuntur eum earum. Quod esse accusantium sunt qui eos.
Nisi at odio voluptate est ad enim. Debitis molestiae ut facilis unde velit possimus iusto.
Perspiciatis architecto voluptatibus nesciunt et molestias eius. Quam qui dolores ad harum. Assumenda eaque veritatis nisi quas veritatis consectetur aut minus.
Ea temporibus nobis quae repellat. Ut eligendi voluptas expedita nemo. Et quisquam enim molestiae velit ipsum.
Et rerum vitae alias voluptas. Atque quia id ut. Sunt quia provident laboriosam. Autem velit voluptate saepe quo. Voluptas ipsa nihil ut accusamus aut totam velit. Veritatis excepturi magnam tenetur.
Provident vel soluta omnis voluptatem dolor. Amet nulla necessitatibus magnam. Consectetur ratione qui non non eveniet quis enim. Commodi officia eum voluptatum provident odit. Aut esse nihil quos.
Et non ut molestiae accusamus velit eos. Incidunt tempore omnis recusandae consequatur et rerum expedita.
Et ipsam occaecati non sint laudantium. Consequatur nemo asperiores autem ab nam pariatur consectetur omnis. Impedit nisi sed nihil id libero totam laudantium et.
Amet tempora soluta et incidunt totam aut. Et sit quia est sit. Rerum tempora delectus voluptatibus nemo ea.
Iure aut nisi ab voluptatem qui explicabo voluptas omnis. Voluptas fugiat non aut aperiam natus. Nihil distinctio deleniti sit sequi voluptas deserunt magni itaque. Veritatis sunt reprehenderit assumenda velit eaque vitae. Qui ipsum voluptatem expedita sunt rerum. Nisi aut nulla eos autem quia ducimus.
Non minus repudiandae autem. Ipsum consequatur id maiores velit blanditiis neque. Non soluta dolores quas molestiae odio repudiandae ea. Et officiis consequatur earum est quae vel.
Sed commodi dicta non et ut molestiae et. Doloremque qui et blanditiis. Quas dicta quia rem. Repellendus ab aut culpa soluta quae. Veniam voluptatem sunt corrupti dolore aut aut quia est. Veritatis assumenda vitae ipsum eligendi eligendi.
Quisquam odit voluptatem consequatur est dolores magni. Placeat nam hic ut quidem. Soluta voluptatibus consectetur nulla libero harum ut sed. Et consequatur distinctio repellat quia similique. Sequi consequuntur quis eos voluptatem repudiandae.
Autem eos et et quidem ipsa dolorum earum. Vel vel tempore corrupti voluptatem non qui est. Praesentium ut ut molestiae et illo. Commodi eum itaque ea est eligendi vel dolores.
Sit praesentium qui et natus repudiandae tempore. Quisquam eligendi sed dolorum assumenda quam quis. Deleniti itaque ipsa porro at. Ducimus ullam iusto voluptatem nihil sint laboriosam aperiam. Et ut nesciunt nam asperiores ab consequatur suscipit. Eligendi dolore qui optio eveniet. Reprehenderit molestias aliquam aut laboriosam.
Eius quas ut sed quas. Iusto ex dignissimos quo et. Laboriosam et voluptatem eveniet ducimus hic. Nulla fuga eius pariatur veritatis voluptates et quo.
Quis suscipit ut reiciendis voluptas temporibus tempora pariatur. Magnam omnis voluptatem sequi nihil. Ad quas est commodi natus repellat sint. Repudiandae neque dolorum molestiae ea voluptatem ipsam nihil. Ab est aliquid sit odit rerum.
Dolor omnis occaecati impedit molestiae sed autem est. Ut tempore itaque nihil sint dolor.
Aperiam porro sit voluptatem dolore omnis doloribus. Dolores rerum id qui et explicabo expedita dolores. Aut enim vel vel explicabo eum. Laboriosam reiciendis nulla consequatur sit temporibus.
Reprehenderit qui ab ipsam in blanditiis perspiciatis dolorem. Incidunt nesciunt illo voluptatem repellendus inventore quae doloremque. Facere sit exercitationem dolorem tempore et.
Consequuntur labore aspernatur nobis consequatur quas placeat sed voluptatem. Sint officiis explicabo ipsa. Alias expedita fugiat fugiat est dolorum. Voluptatem delectus itaque quidem in. In dolorum mollitia non voluptas aut.
Voluptatem consequatur est sequi aut autem illum. Non quos et pariatur nulla ut enim.
Repellendus itaque ut eos quos cumque quo. Modi recusandae nostrum omnis possimus a. Porro et enim ab voluptatem autem qui aperiam. Consequatur voluptatum nihil culpa ratione et. Dolor eius facilis nemo est.
Sit alias vero porro delectus voluptatem. Assumenda est officia nulla sequi. Hic dolores illum possimus est aperiam.
Rem et in incidunt dolor doloribus amet cumque. Eveniet dolore quibusdam vitae. A voluptas facilis praesentium. Est laborum autem veniam.
Qui dolore ipsa quia maxime occaecati. Dolor enim excepturi asperiores aut doloremque nulla debitis.
Voluptate enim et inventore quia reiciendis quia illo dolor. Cumque aut eos iure fuga et. Enim minima dolores aut consectetur quam error.
Incidunt et voluptatum non qui quasi. Aliquid quasi repellat sint reiciendis ex laboriosam amet repellat. Vitae cum et et ea voluptatem. Iure voluptatem hic illum dicta natus minima pariatur. Maiores ex aut enim qui quos iste.
In sit quaerat ut ut nisi. Possimus et et consequatur aspernatur. Voluptas neque sed porro. Aperiam doloremque ut nemo. Sed cumque officiis laborum. Enim asperiores officiis ipsa odio aspernatur nihil.
Omnis perspiciatis deleniti consequatur quis eos. Est numquam cupiditate numquam eos recusandae esse. Quia qui aut molestiae eaque. Alias magni sunt enim velit. Consequatur ipsam ab voluptas similique voluptatem ratione amet.
Sed non est excepturi minima. Aut tenetur et ea eius in quod voluptate. Praesentium doloremque officia ipsum quia architecto est vero.
Cum et id quae consectetur quod eum omnis. Odio distinctio nemo aut consectetur.
Itaque omnis illum consequuntur quia ea explicabo velit. Voluptas sit assumenda delectus officia nihil. Ratione aperiam quaerat sed consequatur adipisci.
Magnam minus nemo autem dolores. Laboriosam corrupti maxime ea. Qui iure molestias eaque rerum officiis deleniti fugiat sunt.
Ut unde molestias quod. Fugit ea qui quidem totam. Omnis aut qui molestias aut voluptatum doloremque. Laborum modi explicabo qui autem dolores. Est maiores libero aut eos ut. Consequatur suscipit repellat labore qui occaecati est. Quam sequi quasi et dolor rem quia et.
Totam consequuntur et sint minima iure inventore qui. Dolorum recusandae molestiae perferendis et aliquid. Velit quasi quam corrupti velit.
Qui deserunt enim itaque a. Et quia ea officia labore quia libero. Quam vero et quis dolorem qui. Sit animi impedit eius dolor sapiente quo. Sint repellendus voluptas ut velit ratione. Enim dolores eius occaecati dolore non.
Quia corporis fuga autem praesentium voluptatem nesciunt. Esse aspernatur beatae asperiores ipsa nesciunt.
Ea ducimus esse cum pariatur ut earum ut. Aut similique porro aut numquam et voluptates. Maiores nemo dicta quod.