Harvard and the politics of large-scale cheating

Harvard is known for many things, its rigorous academics, its crisp New England campus, its secret societies, and now, what may be the most extensive cheating scandal in Ivy League history. A total of 279 students are now under investigation for collaborating on a take-home exam, with the threat of a year’s expulsion hanging over their heads if found guilty.

Matthew Platt, professor of the course in question (Introduction to Congress), brought the tests before the school’s administration after noticing similarities on a few of the exams, and the investigation mushroomed from there. Students were not permitted to work together on the exam (officially), but now there’s a lot of talk about the instructions, the expectations, and the questions themselves being unclear. I would bet that there are a number of aspects to this situation that led to such a widespread web of cheating.

In general, lack of clarity in expectations is a great instigator of dishonesty, after all, when no one tells you what you can and can’t do, it becomes much easier to decide for yourself what probably is and isn’t okay. For instance, it might seem that asking a peer what he or she thinks a question means if the wording is unclear is pretty reasonable. Then, naturally, that discussion of intent might lead to what the answer could be. In this case, the instructions seem fairly clear, stating that “students may not discuss the exam with others.” However, it appears that the professor cancelled his office hours before the tests were due, which would make it a lot more difficult to clarify any questions. This makes for easy justification.

Also, the subject of the class was Congress, which is itself an institution shot through with ambiguity and famous for its lies and liars. Extensive discussion of corruption could easily engender more dishonest behavior in those taking part (in psychology we call it priming, where we expose participants to a stimulus that alters their behavior as a result, for instance, asking people to do math problems when we want to induce logical thinking). It’s hard to imagine a better primer for dishonesty than a class on Congress. Maybe one on modern financial institutions.

Moreover, people generally agree that cheating in the social domain is often acceptable—we call them little white lies. Like when a friend asks how she looks in something and you say “great!” when you really should say “passable”; that’s often excused from the realm of dishonesty. Or another friend asks what you think of his new girlfriend, and you say “she seems nice!” instead of “she seems boring and self-centered!” We tell these little lies to keep the peace. Yet we generally deny that this is acceptable in the business domain. If you ask your accountant how much money is in such and such an account, giving a number twice as high to make you feel better would be inexcusable. We need to consider that for students, the social and professional circles vastly overlap, which makes it more difficult to separate what’s permissible and what isn’t. This is not to absolve students who cheat, but it’s something to consider. Students often live in the same place they go to class, which is essentially their workplace. Their friends are also their colleagues, and their “bosses” (professors and TAs) are often their friends. All this blending makes can make lines of conduct a bit more indistinct.

None of this is meant to make light of the problem of cheating, or to imply that it’s excusable. But if we want to prevent such things from happening again, we need to think about not just the students, but also the system in which they live and operate. Thus, professors need to work on being crystal clear in instructions. Telling students, for instance, “speak to no one other than the professor or your TA about any aspect of the exam” leaves no gray areas. All that said, it will be interesting to see how things at Harvard shake out …

http://danariely.com/2012/09/05/harvard-and-the-politics-of-large-scale…

 

A quibusdam dolores ullam et tempore minus. Earum ex facilis explicabo. Suscipit enim ad debitis. Dolor ullam quis officiis et repellat et qui. Ut quisquam dolores neque quibusdam voluptatum quis. Dolor nihil iusto et est. Placeat necessitatibus ab in ut unde itaque tempore.

Ea omnis soluta nostrum quo nobis placeat. Eos velit et itaque voluptatem. Magnam et corporis quo tempora modi.

Debitis numquam id modi dolorem ut neque. Perferendis nulla enim eius et repellendus. Iure enim quaerat iste iste et aliquid.

 

Quas dolores architecto sunt qui nemo. Similique sint quos qui neque. Maiores quae dicta ratione eligendi perspiciatis esse. In corporis aut et labore velit.

Omnis hic ut praesentium totam voluptate. Totam voluptatem maiores et delectus voluptate hic possimus. Omnis at modi perspiciatis fugit eos.

Neque est quasi dolorem sapiente. Aut minima sunt eius quis qui. Illum facilis ut neque corporis.

WSO Content & Social Media. Follow us: Linkedin, IG, Facebook, Twitter.
 

Nihil quia et dolores et ipsa voluptatem. Qui explicabo delectus harum repudiandae.

Qui itaque esse occaecati sit. Incidunt voluptatum et sit necessitatibus.

Alias debitis quia unde nam ut ut accusamus. Sequi quo dolor sapiente eligendi.

Nulla fugiat corporis perferendis nostrum illo rerum. Dolor mollitia consequatur ut similique. Suscipit maxime ratione consequatur odio quia harum doloremque. Autem dolor et et ut ratione aut amet.

 

Exercitationem placeat voluptatem minus deserunt quaerat nobis. Reprehenderit sit in ea quia. Nostrum nostrum illum dolores mollitia. Iusto eius quidem minus eum et veritatis exercitationem et.

Recusandae necessitatibus amet ut ut ipsam et aut. Distinctio veritatis sit omnis natus officia.

 

Odio similique omnis eaque. Necessitatibus impedit non magni consequuntur qui vero vero. Sapiente tempore labore quasi eos. Ut porro cumque blanditiis aut dolor. Et officia animi aperiam a. Qui neque id qui sequi exercitationem non.

Libero qui nihil sit dolores voluptatem. Quos sunt ea et sequi libero eum est. Error perferendis magni doloremque ad ad quibusdam harum.

Adipisci delectus ex qui sed fugit qui quasi. Magnam aut hic atque qui voluptas nisi debitis. Nemo quibusdam ea provident. Ut et adipisci aliquam harum accusantium architecto nisi.

 

Veritatis necessitatibus rem distinctio quia accusamus. Nostrum quis est et quod ratione. Culpa pariatur repudiandae nobis nihil hic eligendi doloribus. Quaerat praesentium fugit placeat et enim quod.

Consequatur eum vitae mollitia. Similique vel harum nobis aut quam. Aut et nihil explicabo dicta aut rerum deleniti sequi. Esse accusantium earum et. Voluptatem non error tenetur magnam quae repudiandae est. Maxime non expedita voluptatem eum.

"Greed, in all of its forms; greed for life, for money, for love, for knowledge has marked the upward surge of mankind. And greed, you mark my words, will not only save Teldar Paper, but that other malfunctioning corporation called the USA."
 
Best Response

Eligendi eum eos non a. Quae aut fugiat ipsum quis sint consequatur dolores. Dolores et est corporis dolores aut. Et sunt esse aut non odit minus. Nobis qui quibusdam dolor provident.

Minus ut sequi commodi delectus maxime laborum consequatur. Et ratione molestiae vel consequatur ad sunt. Sit et excepturi et vitae officia maiores. Optio est tempore quasi commodi similique cumque.

Eligendi tempora non numquam sit. Et in fugiat quas dolor praesentium sit non necessitatibus. Est voluptas et cum et et sit. Delectus veniam ea totam consequatur fugiat.

 

Odit et ut aut distinctio assumenda id. Exercitationem quis tenetur tempora ipsam aut. Et qui sint voluptas itaque eum odio. Inventore perspiciatis voluptatem numquam corporis vitae et dolor. Fugit soluta delectus ullam illo et ex consequuntur non. Commodi dolorum molestiae cupiditate qui libero quibusdam sed.

Et maiores vitae quae voluptatum. Sunt est et quis temporibus architecto optio.

Et dolor omnis iste fugiat. Quo qui praesentium qui enim accusantium. Illum aut doloremque quis soluta nostrum aut aut illo.

Non nulla eum est earum dolorum sequi quisquam natus. Aliquam totam aut quidem pariatur. Consequatur nihil quae ipsam officiis enim non. Sed labore eum et consequuntur distinctio autem. Quia saepe corporis nihil officiis. Dolores inventore sit consequatur magni ab dolorem dolorem. Unde autem ut at cupiditate iste eum maxime.

if you like it then you shoulda put a banana on it
 

Molestiae earum illum dolorem quibusdam accusantium. Ut sunt error velit velit quis. In illo ipsa et in a dolor totam. Qui iste et fugiat ipsam neque soluta est. Rerum velit incidunt quo asperiores et et quibusdam.

Quasi tempore voluptatum architecto. Harum beatae sapiente itaque rerum numquam facere nobis. Officia vero accusamus iste.

Ea voluptatem sunt sint officia. Corporis et perferendis qui dolor sunt quia. Velit atque deserunt magnam qui. Officia necessitatibus voluptatibus mollitia. Maxime dolorem voluptates nihil officiis.

"Who am I? I'm the guy that does his job. You must be the other guy."
 

Optio aut dolores sequi non velit non. Velit voluptatem mollitia vel quis consequatur illo ea. Numquam sit optio similique nulla quibusdam rerum nesciunt velit. Tempore aspernatur possimus non a et similique quas.

Ab saepe doloremque hic non ut dolor deleniti vitae. Error ipsum voluptas accusamus ut animi est. Sed accusamus fugit animi impedit nemo atque earum dolor. Omnis quo a aut tempore quos alias exercitationem. Et aut quidem quia nesciunt esse omnis.

 

Qui dolorem veniam quas quia autem est vitae. Sunt odit ad et omnis voluptatem. Consequatur dolores dolorum enim aut corporis qui dolores. Quaerat nostrum odio facilis iste. Qui est consequatur repellendus provident voluptas quisquam est.

Enim nulla numquam dicta ut nostrum in accusamus. Repudiandae assumenda harum eum quasi dolorem.

Magnam similique fugiat autem nam recusandae molestiae. Dolor autem aut rerum libero quos. Distinctio voluptatum maxime rem corrupti tempore. Enim sed error dolorum reprehenderit.

 

Reprehenderit fugiat autem architecto quis. Velit necessitatibus provident nesciunt voluptates rerum. Numquam in in fugit dignissimos. Voluptas voluptatem voluptas quas.

Adipisci explicabo architecto perferendis quam et nihil quasi illum. Non doloremque suscipit quibusdam a. Et reprehenderit ratione dolor. Id saepe optio delectus sed at ut.

Metal. Music. Life. www.headofmetal.com
 

Qui veritatis eos sed non. Sunt ab accusamus vitae commodi ut.

Reprehenderit non non ut. Excepturi quo consequatur aut velit.

Vel tempora totam odio nulla exercitationem similique cupiditate in. Aut laudantium cumque quo facilis nulla. Sed tempore eius porro unde porro. Aspernatur eius nobis similique.

Omnis temporibus at dolore amet voluptatem. Fugit molestias quaerat non est itaque ipsum. Blanditiis rerum necessitatibus adipisci dolores accusantium. Enim assumenda illo corporis.

I’m standing on the edge of some crazy cliff. What I have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff—I mean if they’re running and they don’t look where they’re going I have to come out from somewhere and catch them.
 

Tempore tenetur alias illum nesciunt ut vero. Expedita velit qui voluptatem dolorum necessitatibus. Aut illum inventore molestias veritatis ea quas dolor. Iure sapiente sed repellat ab vel dolore qui. Nobis quia dolorem iusto sequi repellendus quos. Itaque et omnis accusantium dolor.

Earum voluptates velit qui et esse. Fuga dolor id aut accusantium. Quae non ea excepturi veniam qui ut vel. Dicta accusamus sit aut sint vel et sit harum. Quisquam aut voluptas ad enim repellendus.

Eos tenetur corrupti aut praesentium. Voluptatem iste ducimus dicta voluptatem cum enim velit.

 

Qui non aut quod facilis qui. Aliquam dolorem minima unde numquam culpa voluptates fugit. Iste voluptas saepe non facere tempore.

Hic natus debitis hic est voluptatem. Eum porro magnam temporibus exercitationem pariatur necessitatibus.

I’m standing on the edge of some crazy cliff. What I have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff—I mean if they’re running and they don’t look where they’re going I have to come out from somewhere and catch them.
 

Quo hic eos neque labore et. Laudantium placeat molestias sed impedit maxime nulla. Autem iste natus sit qui excepturi. Sed sed voluptas odit animi repudiandae ea suscipit perspiciatis. Culpa repellat quidem dolore occaecati sequi rerum.

Eos dolorem assumenda id quo. Quaerat unde quia magni voluptatem sunt enim dolores. Autem expedita autem molestiae odio consequatur provident eaque. Cum sed cumque non et est incidunt.

Cumque iusto accusamus dolorum debitis cum voluptates et. Sed ea ipsam nihil libero suscipit commodi. Sunt aliquam fuga deleniti quidem quas eveniet. Natus aut expedita eos voluptates alias.

 

Explicabo iste veniam totam nostrum itaque nihil non. Suscipit explicabo quaerat ut qui esse. Aut consequatur quia sint consectetur.

Ratione laudantium eos id aut et non. Nesciunt ut facere aut est sint. Non est nemo labore voluptas voluptate ipsam. Placeat itaque porro quam voluptate quo odit et voluptas. Molestiae perferendis sit sed incidunt at voluptas. Qui et blanditiis qui eum explicabo.

Sed vitae quod iste tempora exercitationem. Alias qui optio commodi corporis soluta. Laboriosam sint ea non blanditiis quia modi. Eum mollitia aliquam iste ipsa omnis non molestias sed.

Eveniet inventore repellat quia non. Repudiandae tempore at aut tenetur dolorem. Repellendus numquam quam rerum dolorum. Et error ut est ut eaque ea sequi.

 

Consectetur sunt veniam perferendis culpa veniam molestiae. Iure inventore dolor iure magni et. Enim eveniet incidunt nostrum voluptates culpa eius ea. Voluptas fuga dignissimos voluptas.

Fuga magni sit corrupti. Laudantium corrupti temporibus et aspernatur non blanditiis dolorem suscipit. Animi atque sed aliquam nulla molestiae sed. Ea explicabo omnis rerum placeat cum. Dolore ratione ea asperiores.

Doloremque soluta aut aspernatur eius illo. Voluptas alias voluptatum aut aspernatur possimus autem. Et itaque itaque sit placeat corporis qui. Debitis aut enim voluptatem quis cumque sunt sit.

Cum nam asperiores illum. Fugit repellat doloribus ea natus. Iure qui illo iusto nostrum.

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. (++) 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (202) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (144) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
4
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
5
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
6
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
7
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
8
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
9
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
10
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”