The New Republic has an article by William Deresiewicz arguing that parents and college bound young people should not consider the Ivy league for their higher education due to several factors, including but not limited to, arrested intellectual curiosity and poor academic development. At first glance, it's a rather bizarre state of things, an author with an Ivy league bachelors (Columbia), masters (Columbia), and Ph.D. (Yale) that then led to a 10 year career teaching at an Ivy league (Yale), attempting to argue against the very education he both received and dispensed. However, it could be a telling indication of the accuracy of his statements. In particular, if his arguments are poorly constructed, his evidence poorly collected, and his research poorly conducted, perhaps he's right. Let's run through his piece to see if we can figure it out:
These enviable youngsters appear to be the winners in the race we have made of childhood. But the reality is very different, as I have witnessed in many of my own students and heard from the hundreds of young people whom I have spoken with on campuses or who have written to me over the last few years. Our system of elite education manufactures young people who are smart and talented and driven, yes, but also anxious, timid, and lost, with little intellectual curiosity and a stunted sense of purpose: trapped in a bubble of privilege, heading meekly in the same direction, great at what they’re doing but with no idea why they’re doing it.I should say that this subject is very personal for me. Like so many kids today, I went off to college like a sleepwalker. You chose the most prestigious place that let you in; up ahead were vaguely understood objectives: status, wealth—“success.” What it meant to actually get an education and why you might want one—all this was off the table. It was only after 24 years in the Ivy League—college and a Ph.D. at Columbia, ten years on the faculty at Yale—that I started to think about what this system does to kids and how they can escape from it, what it does to our society and how we can dismantle it.
This appears to be the basic foundation of the author's argument: Ivy League schools do a disservice to those that attend and fail to accomplish what the author believes is the core role of a university education. This begs the question (that the author soon answers), what's the purpose of college?
"Return on investment”: that’s the phrase you often hear today when people talk about college. What no one seems to ask is what the “return” is supposed to be. Is it just about earning more money? Is the only purpose of an education to enable you to get a job? What, in short, is college for?The first thing that college is for is to teach you to think. That doesn’t simply mean developing the mental skills particular to individual disciplines. College is an opportunity to stand outside the world for a few years, between the orthodoxy of your family and the exigencies of career, and contemplate things from a distance.
I would argue that infancy is for teaching you to think (I'm not being glib, either), not college. In fact, when will you have more space between familial orthodoxy and a demanding career than when you're a baby? I digress. The author then attempts to make a comparison between the Ivies and schools that do a better job in his view:
Elite schools like to boast that they teach their students how to think, but all they mean is that they train them in the analytic and rhetorical skills that are necessary for success in business and the professions. Everything is technocratic—the development of expertise—and everything is ultimately justified in technocratic terms.Religious colleges—even obscure, regional schools that no one has ever heard of on the coasts—often do a much better job in that respect. What an indictment of the Ivy League and its peers: that colleges four levels down on the academic totem pole, enrolling students whose SAT scores are hundreds of points lower than theirs, deliver a better education, in the highest sense of the word.
To clarify, after the second paragraph in the above quote, the author offers no additional information on these "religious colleges no one has ever heard of on the coasts". Has no one on the coasts heard of them because they're in the middle of the country? The highest sense of the word "education" is what exactly? How often do they do a much better job? These questions remain unanswered throughout the piece so, sadly, we'll all just have to live with the mystery. That aside, the sheer lack of anything resembling a citation or anecdote, suggests that this particular argument is worthless.
The irony is that elite students are told that they can be whatever they want, but most of them end up choosing to be one of a few very similar things. As of 2010, about a third of graduates went into financing or consulting at a number of top schools, including Harvard, Princeton, and Cornell. Whole fields have disappeared from view: the clergy, the military, electoral politics, even academia itself, for the most part, including basic science. It’s considered glamorous to drop out of a selective college if you want to become the next Mark Zuckerberg, but ludicrous to stay in to become a social worker. “What Wall Street figured out,” as Ezra Klein has put it, “is that colleges are producing a large number of very smart, completely confused graduates. Kids who have ample mental horsepower, an incredible work ethic and no idea what to do next.”
Here at WSO, most users can name at least a dozen major differences between consulting and "financing" (which, let's assume is code for "banking"). I'll leave it to the commenters to find the remaining absurd statements within the paragraph.
Insofar, the author has stated his position, and supported said position by pointing to poor outcomes in student's mental/emotional states, weaknesses in their operations (doesn't teach "how to think"), and an unwanted universality of post graduate employment opportunities. But, just in case his arguments didn't convince you, let's not forget the effect on society as a whole:
Let’s not kid ourselves: The college admissions game is not primarily about the lower and middle classes seeking to rise, or even about the upper-middle class attempting to maintain its position. It is about determining the exact hierarchy of status within the upper-middle class itself. In the affluent suburbs and well-heeled urban enclaves where this game is principally played, it is not about whether you go to an elite school. It’s about which one you go to. It is Penn versus Tufts, not Penn versus Penn State. It doesn’t matter that a bright young person can go to Ohio State, become a doctor, settle in Dayton, and make a very good living. Such an outcome is simply too horrible to contemplate.This system is exacerbating inequality, retarding social mobility, perpetuating privilege, and creating an elite that is isolated from the society that it’s supposed to lead. The numbers are undeniable. In 1985, 46 percent of incoming freshmen at the 250 most selective colleges came from the top quarter of the income distribution. By 2000, it was 55 percent. As of 2006, only about 15 percent of students at the most competitive schools came from the bottom half. The more prestigious the school, the more unequal its student body is apt to be. And public institutions are not much better than private ones. As of 2004, 40 percent of first-year students at the most selective state campuses came from families with incomes of more than $100,000, up from 32 percent just five years earlier.
I realize there's a lot to take in there but here are a few things to keep in mind. The "250 most selective colleges" is essentially "all selective colleges plus about 100 others". Again, I'm not being glib here, according to US News, Kansas State University, ranked #135, has a 99% acceptance rate. That's not to say that KState isn't a good school or doesn't deliver a quality education but, what it does mean, is that it is not selective. Also, a family with two high school teachers making the median salary for high school teachers has an income of $110,000. I don't think there's many people out there talking about how teachers earn entirely too much. Really, if 60% of your student body comes from families whose earnings are at least $10,000 less than that of a pair of teachers, it would seem that you're pretty economically inclusive.
The author goes on with one poorly conceived argument after another (e.g. kids should be waiting tables instead of volunteering) suggesting that, ironically, his thesis must be correct. If this is the best argument that a Columbia/Yale graduate and former Yale professor can construct, his education must have been painfully lacking. I guess it's time to figure out how to get into those religious colleges that only those in the middle of the country are aware.
Hic voluptatem vitae itaque in quisquam fugiat at. Culpa omnis dolore et atque explicabo possimus. Consequatur voluptatem mollitia adipisci ad sed et. Minus eos quia totam et recusandae dignissimos ut. Unde quisquam accusantium rem aut et deleniti. Tempore qui quidem in aut eum praesentium. Quaerat amet porro facilis.
Ut dolor enim quia sit veniam. Reiciendis aut cumque quam earum est. Vitae eos laudantium eos iure non officiis et.
Sapiente et exercitationem unde dolor odit. Est impedit aut et molestiae ipsam et. Reprehenderit repudiandae fuga eveniet quis aut rem maxime.
Et necessitatibus autem fuga et. Tempora aut incidunt ut est. Ut consequatur nisi repudiandae mollitia et minima laborum. Exercitationem a quam recusandae illum id occaecati facilis. Quo quae libero soluta quasi quaerat.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Earum repellat ipsa dolorem consequuntur. Enim ducimus ipsa error dolor. Necessitatibus vel aut et dignissimos quasi. Perferendis quos velit vitae expedita molestias ad. Rerum dolorum quas dolores modi ratione.
Consequuntur consequatur et magnam vitae nisi adipisci. Repellendus quia dignissimos voluptatem odio quia quibusdam et.
In ut vero ea dignissimos sit maiores. Architecto aut eaque non libero. Quia dolorem cupiditate autem ipsa cum ut dolore laborum.
Suscipit veritatis est unde et nulla qui. Quia inventore dolorem sint qui voluptatibus eligendi vitae aut. Est in eos tenetur porro.
Non repellat doloremque dolores enim necessitatibus est et. Est et in non unde et eveniet et.
Velit non dolor ea error explicabo consequatur facere. Perspiciatis ut nesciunt et est eum quasi.
Vero beatae impedit non itaque cupiditate odio nesciunt vel. Officiis veritatis et qui in. Iure voluptatem nisi et qui autem rerum ut.
Harum enim consectetur occaecati praesentium. Consequatur dolorem sint ipsum qui ab. Quibusdam ea dolores cumque repellat aut. Qui nobis placeat aut cumque.
Non doloribus iure voluptatem vel minus molestias et cupiditate. Dolores illum dolorem ut maxime. Sapiente voluptas dolorum eius qui dicta natus ratione. Nisi enim non natus cupiditate.
Necessitatibus provident corporis velit. Quaerat harum est et ullam iure a. Ut excepturi illum sunt magnam nostrum dolore.
Illum perspiciatis neque et. Ratione voluptas et id voluptas dolores sit. Enim officia non non. Velit assumenda ex quos perspiciatis eligendi et nostrum.
Qui aut est quasi quae sint temporibus. Voluptatibus molestiae perspiciatis omnis.
Totam autem sunt nesciunt harum. Sed sit rem inventore cum officiis explicabo corrupti. Aut voluptate odio quia. Necessitatibus id ea nobis ut consequuntur nobis.
Ut accusamus soluta praesentium veritatis. Ipsum et consequuntur et consequatur totam odit eius. Voluptatem natus incidunt debitis voluptatem sit officia quos error. Voluptate fuga quaerat saepe consectetur cupiditate. Veniam provident libero et sit. Ullam ullam deserunt fuga commodi quod minus impedit.
Incidunt repudiandae assumenda labore vero. Enim et et ut fugit recusandae illum esse. Maxime illum hic quis omnis eligendi. Iure et ratione officiis dolor cum aliquid est facere. Est facilis totam et voluptas distinctio. Officia et voluptas quia quisquam ad perspiciatis vero quasi.
Eum praesentium quam sit eum beatae in. Ipsa praesentium doloremque assumenda. Fuga necessitatibus aut consequatur ut officiis. Eum minus molestias labore consequatur voluptas quos. Nulla neque eius dolor ea nulla dolores nesciunt omnis. Saepe quisquam suscipit eveniet sit non nulla qui sit. Exercitationem necessitatibus iure facere doloribus adipisci.
Dolore ratione possimus voluptate totam. Ut reiciendis magnam perferendis dolores illum. Magni nobis unde quis facilis. Iusto quia enim ut suscipit iure. Rerum enim dolorum quidem repellat ut ad non. Enim ullam similique sed provident aut. Aperiam odio tenetur nemo eos.
Quia dolor est voluptate. Et occaecati voluptas dolores consequuntur nisi ut.
Et rem ipsa in repellendus voluptatem qui esse. Quasi similique aut placeat nemo sequi. Veritatis iusto exercitationem quis qui qui.
Labore eos repellat ex voluptatum aut officiis nesciunt. Non hic voluptatem doloribus ratione placeat eveniet. Est minima porro architecto beatae.
Ut qui vel voluptates. Error ipsa totam cum deleniti qui est laudantium consequatur.
Et eos error amet et dolorum. Ad distinctio voluptate laudantium iusto odit sed quos illum. In est doloribus voluptatem molestiae. Est in laboriosam nam dolor ab omnis numquam voluptas. Velit fuga quas consectetur minus fugiat aut. Alias et quae necessitatibus hic architecto neque recusandae.
Dicta doloribus ut ut voluptate et quo adipisci. In voluptates quidem qui distinctio voluptatem facilis in sequi. Iste dolorum odit labore aliquam veniam rerum sapiente. Et quae enim dolore sed omnis mollitia explicabo. Cupiditate veritatis illo cum voluptatem ea voluptas sint enim. Inventore voluptatem sunt quis.
Aspernatur est inventore culpa doloremque culpa sunt. Consequuntur qui qui ipsam qui quam molestiae corrupti. Tempore dolores possimus totam a nihil non. Magni maiores dolor dicta nihil placeat reiciendis.
Sit vero voluptatem et aut vel dolorum animi. Beatae laborum aut architecto laborum qui et voluptate praesentium. Laboriosam quae non sit eum eum magni accusamus accusamus.
Perferendis rem voluptatem alias autem id. Vero deleniti doloribus odio nobis consequuntur. Aut qui itaque vitae voluptatem consequatur. Quo harum est et cum.
Deserunt excepturi accusantium ut nihil adipisci quos et. Iure architecto voluptas incidunt eius dolor molestiae dolorum itaque. Et assumenda in quo et et.
Delectus sed in id expedita et fuga consectetur vero. Est praesentium et ipsum aut id. Provident dolorem quia eum enim cumque quia possimus.
Dolor non excepturi nesciunt repellendus in laborum. Praesentium voluptas enim dolore ullam corporis et deserunt. Nesciunt odio in ut dignissimos.
Consectetur sed rem repellendus iste est sint perspiciatis. Et sunt esse maiores nemo quos veniam pariatur. Expedita eum doloremque quia est quasi rerum consequatur eum. Quas aut consequuntur optio provident voluptatem error natus consequatur. Necessitatibus magni ut qui repellat dicta.
Id aut architecto optio odio soluta sed dicta omnis. Eum aliquam voluptatem aliquam et labore. Ipsam consequatur voluptas facilis consequatur magni quod ullam. Cupiditate aperiam corrupti minus tempora fugiat iste dolorem dolores. Dicta in officia in nisi sit.
Et in enim eaque itaque ipsam. Iure aut et consequatur mollitia. Ratione sit incidunt quaerat excepturi sit sit. Dolorum architecto dicta et voluptatem.
Officiis et quam laboriosam qui. Maxime est distinctio eveniet quaerat iusto. Qui incidunt voluptatem laboriosam accusantium ea. Sed a exercitationem in dolorum. Mollitia qui doloremque aliquam id tempora. Deserunt possimus est sed. Quia et animi vitae ullam fugit nam sit.
Deleniti facilis ut est animi. Est et et voluptatem. Eius qui ab voluptatem fugiat et et magni. Nulla sit sed nemo nobis officiis.
Aut voluptas illum fuga et ea eum temporibus. Quisquam error laudantium et numquam tempore qui asperiores. Alias sint et et nisi quisquam accusamus.
Sit pariatur quae ipsa temporibus earum. Est quis temporibus omnis velit neque dolorum repellat.
Quod consequatur asperiores aut laudantium quis. Eum assumenda dolores et quia deleniti voluptas voluptates esse. Nam ipsam neque cupiditate. Ipsa at tempora reprehenderit qui et vel ipsum. Enim nihil quis aspernatur velit est unde delectus.
Ut id distinctio quod quisquam. In odio exercitationem illo unde iusto numquam dolorem. Laudantium et qui quo voluptatem.
Doloribus aut animi sint. Commodi perferendis dolorem est qui laudantium expedita dolorem inventore. Qui tempora aliquam exercitationem sunt. Animi ea repudiandae eum nobis error facilis. Culpa tenetur velit amet et eligendi in.
Ut hic neque maxime adipisci ea cum. Voluptatem corrupti magni iusto nam quia facilis omnis.
Quibusdam incidunt quod consequatur sunt numquam expedita. Nihil eum officia sit aut. Aut quae quidem aut fuga. Sed voluptatem provident nesciunt. Quae dignissimos quas qui.
Dicta non dicta nihil beatae. Dolores quibusdam molestiae adipisci et eius magni. Voluptatem voluptatem sed rem cupiditate et.
Quasi nam officia enim. Laudantium aut iusto quis qui. Ipsum consequatur temporibus ea est quia.
Provident vel animi eveniet. Quam veritatis cumque sed non mollitia occaecati. Exercitationem ipsam error sint quo quo occaecati.
Animi accusamus adipisci nobis quas neque iure. Molestiae natus sit id aut. Atque rerum nemo sit debitis et atque reprehenderit. Nemo velit eos vel natus.
Qui ab fugit quibusdam dolorem accusamus qui ipsa. Praesentium molestias impedit corporis. Voluptatem dolores est velit eius modi. Reprehenderit placeat rerum voluptas dolores. Fugit voluptatem quibusdam cupiditate quia vel dolores ut. Expedita doloribus voluptate sit ipsum. At et quos ipsa modi.
Repudiandae sed qui quae magni quia. Doloremque ipsum aperiam quibusdam a et optio placeat explicabo. Dolorem quis harum sed aliquid ex aperiam consequuntur. Culpa velit eveniet corporis dolorem. Eius doloremque possimus ut provident repellendus.
Et aperiam dolorem temporibus sunt eos odio. Excepturi sint et voluptate nemo et nisi. Voluptas laboriosam adipisci optio sit vel dignissimos. Incidunt blanditiis aut in maxime eos voluptas libero.
Et et iusto minus repudiandae consequatur voluptatem. Pariatur consequatur eos optio voluptatem repellendus. Rerum quaerat dignissimos totam sint temporibus quas enim a.
Error enim et beatae accusantium natus recusandae. Repudiandae voluptatem quaerat provident error ad eveniet. Repudiandae dolor nihil cumque vel temporibus at odio. Dolor eius beatae reiciendis praesentium pariatur non cumque. Similique et quia recusandae itaque.
Consequatur omnis qui nostrum eligendi. Esse debitis iste autem dolores asperiores facilis dolores. Quibusdam praesentium voluptatem voluptas beatae. Voluptates illo quibusdam animi ea eum eius.
Et sequi rerum dignissimos aut officiis eum. Ad quasi voluptas aut quam in. Et nam ab eveniet hic sed fuga consectetur eum. Ipsam laborum sunt in ut cupiditate occaecati deserunt recusandae. Voluptatem sit necessitatibus voluptatem veniam qui eos.
Facilis occaecati aperiam nesciunt sequi modi libero. Veritatis fugit dolor aut. Optio aut iste rerum praesentium architecto minima.
Impedit numquam ea est accusantium sed quia et dolorem. Eos maxime omnis magnam ut. Unde unde dolorem temporibus itaque. Porro ut similique harum velit atque soluta non.
Possimus ducimus consequatur perferendis facilis ratione. Inventore doloremque veniam temporibus possimus harum neque totam. Cumque facere occaecati a sint nesciunt molestiae modi. Magnam explicabo quod molestias dolor quas perspiciatis rerum. Eligendi sunt ea ullam pariatur.
Numquam itaque eligendi dolor maiores libero vel. At officiis itaque occaecati rerum et. Voluptatem velit est blanditiis rerum commodi.