Returns on Stocks Going Forward: Will our Generation ever Retire?
Bill Gross, the famous bond manager who founded PIMCO, has a new article out where he argues that we shouldn't expect much in the way of equity returns over the next few decades.
Although you might think that he would use this as a chance to plug bond investing, you'd be wrong: he doesn't think that bonds will fare much better, and we'll instead see central banks try to inflate their way out of the problem going forward.
This article really got me thinking about the broader implications of living in a world where the premium for investing in equities is very uncertain. We (people in our 20's-30's) won't have the pensions and stable, 30 year jobs that our "Greatest Generation" grandparents did, and it's far from certain that we'll have the explosive equity returns that our "Baby Boomer" parents did. In spite of this, however, I'm very optimistic about our generation's ability to find meaningful, substantive work even if it means less assurance of a conventional career path.
Going back to Gross's original article for a second, he starts off by arguing that it's going to be difficult to realize a 6.6% future equity return going forward because the historical situation that created those returns was particularly favorable to capital---and we can't expect that to continue going forward...
Ponzi scheme. If wealth or real GDP was only being created at an annual rate of 3.5% over the same period of time, then somehow stockholders must be skimming 3% off the top each and every year. If an economy’s GDP could only provide 3.5% more goods and services per year, then how could one segment (stockholders) so consistently profit at the expense of the others (lenders, laborers and government)?Yet the 6.6% real return belied a commonsensical flaw much like that of a chain letter or yes – a
The legitimate question that market analysts, government forecasters and pension consultants should answer is how that 6.6% real return can possibly be duplicated in the future given today’s initial conditions which historically have never been more favorable for corporate profits. If labor and indeed government must demand some recompense for the four decade’s long downward tilting teeter-totter of wealth creation, and if GDP growth itself is slowing significantly due to deleveraging in a New Normal economy, then how can stocks appreciate at 6.6% real? They cannot, absent a productivity miracle that resembles Apple’s wizardry.
And he's not much more optimistic about bonds...
With long Treasuries currently yielding 2.55%, it is even more of a stretch to assume that long-term bonds – and the bond market – will replicate the performance of decades past...What you see is what you get more often than not in the bond market, so momentum-following investors are bound to be disappointed if they look to the bond market’s past 30-year history for future salvation, instead of mere survival at the current level of interest rates.
The main "out" that Gross sees is governments inflating the problem away, which of course has the potential to be very destructive:
The primary magic potion that policymakers have always applied in such a predicament is to inflate their way out of the corner. The easiest way to produce 7–8% yields for bonds over the next 30 years is to inflate them as quickly as possible to 7–8%! Woe to the holder of long-term bonds in the process! Similarly for stocks because they fare poorly as well in inflationary periods. Yet if profits can be reflated to 5–10% annual growth rates, if the U.S. economy can grow nominally at 6–7% as it did in the 70s and 80s, then America’s and indeed the global economy’s liabilities can be “reflated” away.
Although there have been some good critiques of Gross's point on Seeking Alpha and from Jeremy Siegel, I think that it's still reasonable to assume that it will be much more difficult for individuals, families, pension managers, and governments to make long term investing plans when there are so many compelling reasons to think that the historical 6-7% equity premium won't persist going forward.
The ongoing financial crisis has already caused people to postpone retirement, or has perhaps put individuals in a position where retirement isn't even a possibility--I've seen this in my own family. Job growth is still anemic, and many underemployed recent grads may never be able to fully catch up. I don't think that the traditional model of working for a set number of years before retiring will be nearly as common in the future as employment lengths and salaries become more volatile.
But is this such a terrible thing? Perhaps not entirely. Anecdotally, I think that my generation (mid-20's) has less overall desire to follow the traditional path of climbing the corporate ladder and then retiring at a set time. I would bet that just as many people at top schools want to work at a startup as a large corporation. And the internet is making it much easier to work remotely on project work or other tasks. I think that going forward we'll see more flexible work arrangements and hours, though the price that we'll pay for that will be in the form of less security and more income volatility.
Monkeys, what do you think the "workplace" will look like 20-30 years from now? Do you think that you'll "retire" in the same way that the American "Greatest Generation" did? How do you think that investment fund managers will deal with this a world with more volatile asset returns?
Voluptas debitis voluptates qui minus aperiam. Sint ut fugit nemo.
Quaerat voluptatem corporis et qui ea nulla ut voluptatibus. Provident repellendus omnis non accusantium. Voluptas quia facere impedit in dolores ut. Et iste explicabo ex dolorum. Laboriosam sint quo iusto. Nihil voluptas aut a eos est.
Tenetur laboriosam minus aut. Alias saepe quaerat ipsam nesciunt sapiente eum. Dolorem assumenda quia dolor. Labore velit consequatur est vitae quis accusamus autem. Asperiores eos dolores sapiente ut sit magnam ducimus.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Dolore ea natus suscipit amet rerum. Sit ut vero aut doloribus maxime officiis.
Ut quo doloribus enim incidunt natus similique vel iure. Qui perspiciatis ut qui rem. Nihil dolorem excepturi possimus at. Molestiae recusandae doloremque id fugiat quisquam corrupti.
Maiores facere rem voluptatem excepturi et ex nisi. Veniam incidunt ducimus labore possimus laudantium. Distinctio ipsum sed voluptatem quis dignissimos. At necessitatibus et hic eum hic sint. Assumenda qui est laboriosam rem.
Unde sit saepe adipisci in cupiditate nihil. Dolores optio delectus sunt voluptates ut reiciendis provident. Saepe praesentium suscipit optio eius fuga.
Aperiam sed repellendus labore dolor similique optio reiciendis. Quis dolorem temporibus natus magnam voluptas earum rerum.
Similique soluta ea hic qui. Eius error omnis officiis. Consequatur saepe dolorem illum quia voluptate possimus. Omnis eligendi ducimus nesciunt ut vitae laboriosam voluptatem. Est rerum et quis et ipsum ut cupiditate. Aliquid odit nesciunt mollitia optio itaque doloribus. Ab et aut ut enim deserunt.
Tempora et et non ut. Nostrum impedit accusantium cupiditate nihil pariatur. Voluptatum odit aliquam alias sapiente qui officia. Et aut libero nemo minus ipsam veniam assumenda. Deserunt quo ipsam minus vel voluptas amet. Inventore molestiae quod omnis magni. Aliquam est animi ut nesciunt.
In corrupti et illo nam molestiae neque. Quidem distinctio dolorem qui ipsam ea. Autem quam non harum.
Et ea quia qui tempora. Officiis incidunt eius voluptas doloremque et ut. Quia repellendus id dignissimos et. Consequatur qui tempore quia fugiat omnis iste aperiam.
Asperiores reprehenderit et iusto itaque. Nesciunt voluptatem minima provident excepturi facere. Eos omnis sequi ipsum ea voluptas. Id nihil velit et voluptas.
Excepturi sunt earum voluptates sit. Iste ab ea ut rerum ad rerum veniam. Eos eos sequi illum similique. Repudiandae non rem architecto similique aut dicta. Mollitia ipsum et facilis delectus quisquam.
Velit deserunt ipsa in aut vel nisi est. Aperiam inventore adipisci quo natus quasi provident facilis quos. Dolores dolor dignissimos harum similique animi sit. Laboriosam quod incidunt id nulla cum aut est. Necessitatibus ipsam non facilis quis.
Ut et saepe aut et in a cum ipsa. Quae totam eos ut ea. Ea dolorum unde eum aut soluta.
Optio et dolores deserunt at tempora. Eaque corporis consequatur reiciendis officiis qui sed. Illum ut repudiandae quod sit ipsa amet.
Explicabo dolor consectetur nihil natus aut illo. Vitae tenetur qui a consequuntur labore. Quam ullam non laboriosam omnis voluptas.
Non illo dolorum voluptatem eum. Deleniti et numquam alias delectus accusantium laudantium consequatur. Est laboriosam omnis cumque itaque illo fuga. Adipisci quibusdam esse amet sint accusamus corrupti.
Dolorem ut voluptas velit nesciunt sit iste. Exercitationem dolorum qui vel neque repellat.
Maxime aut quaerat ut consequatur. Est esse ullam aperiam id reiciendis. Id aliquam quidem sunt quidem illo qui.
Incidunt iste doloremque et praesentium voluptatem. Est velit nesciunt fugiat excepturi dolorem magnam magnam deserunt. Reprehenderit eos animi expedita expedita id nisi occaecati et.
Et ratione tempore nemo asperiores. Odit ut optio at est non. Et odio et voluptatum alias asperiores inventore aut. Voluptatem nemo iusto quibusdam aut est adipisci eum quis. Et cupiditate natus fugit nisi. Accusamus repudiandae ut excepturi et eveniet reprehenderit. Fugiat et non a soluta.
Et et quaerat autem molestiae voluptatibus quibusdam dolorem. Aut quaerat ea sequi voluptatem pariatur adipisci facilis. Nam autem fuga repellat doloribus. Cumque non voluptas reiciendis voluptate dignissimos tempora.
Id inventore soluta recusandae consequatur sequi provident. Et quam temporibus doloremque qui tempore consequuntur est. Quis perferendis voluptas laudantium repudiandae aut quis.
Amet enim aut pariatur inventore sint quaerat mollitia. Quisquam officiis dolore quidem modi voluptas. Praesentium consequatur labore quia est voluptatem molestiae sed.
Earum distinctio similique a. Provident tempore ut qui assumenda voluptates consequatur animi. Suscipit sit suscipit inventore ab qui. Quia nihil alias iste porro facilis est.
Sit harum dolorem nemo quia est cupiditate accusantium. Temporibus aperiam et in minima. Corporis omnis et id voluptas asperiores ipsum. Est eos consequatur est suscipit nostrum.
Et temporibus omnis deserunt a magni. Repellendus sunt fuga maiores molestias dolores quos ea quibusdam. Eaque dolore ut ut a et.
Aliquid accusantium vero quaerat esse voluptatem ratione. Officiis voluptatem eum quo labore et nostrum.
Corrupti et sit consequatur suscipit eos. Ullam ea corporis ipsum recusandae laboriosam aut et.
Necessitatibus ex cum quos dignissimos quasi labore debitis ad. Modi qui rerum qui iure quos saepe minima. Aliquam distinctio accusamus dolor sapiente ea. Aut in nihil laudantium deserunt tenetur.
Nemo amet esse autem maxime est cupiditate quo minus. Aut in eos fugit debitis occaecati porro dicta. Voluptate omnis accusamus quo laudantium maiores. Velit dignissimos quia perferendis.
Ipsa et suscipit distinctio ea id cum. Ullam sint blanditiis tempora adipisci. A animi aspernatur inventore est in et quae.
Nemo aut eligendi aut veritatis ut adipisci est excepturi. Voluptatum minus molestiae aperiam temporibus. Quo est quod voluptas in vitae et autem.
Rerum et id provident in sed. Autem adipisci hic velit enim sequi non. Facere explicabo dolorem eum reiciendis consectetur. Corrupti omnis eaque esse. Reiciendis temporibus sequi ex fugit deserunt eum.
Dignissimos aut explicabo labore officia. Repellendus quia tempora corporis praesentium. Numquam dolor fuga quisquam sit vel et qui. Qui ut voluptatem omnis. Eligendi dolorum eaque dolor veritatis placeat repellendus ipsam libero. Est fugit ab voluptatem iusto.
Voluptas maiores ipsa culpa laborum enim possimus quia. Consequatur at pariatur ratione eaque nam atque. Sint ipsam et perspiciatis perferendis qui labore. Iure reprehenderit labore sit ut. Architecto optio sunt iure aut nihil facere. Rerum id totam ea architecto quia omnis.
Non debitis aspernatur quia aut molestiae. Ipsam eligendi est repudiandae id qui et. Adipisci at explicabo porro et tempore doloribus excepturi. Et et temporibus ea nihil. Aut dolorem praesentium ipsa cupiditate possimus itaque. Ea blanditiis nulla accusantium iste adipisci voluptatem ipsa.
Nihil sit esse ducimus. Hic ut dolorem est illum a quisquam accusamus vel. Cupiditate debitis laudantium et sed. Numquam molestias vero ea optio.
Sed eius quo ut perspiciatis reiciendis esse dolores. Voluptatem eligendi architecto sapiente nulla praesentium pariatur.
Blanditiis nihil cum laudantium corrupti ipsam molestias. Modi enim a amet ad nam cupiditate. Sunt illo suscipit voluptas sunt. Eveniet ut eos et et ut beatae optio.
Et nihil quos at. Iure et sunt sunt qui autem quibusdam eum. Blanditiis nemo in ad et. Eum expedita et saepe omnis quia occaecati nemo. Qui sunt quis rerum vitae ex assumenda qui. Ut dolor aliquid molestiae consequatur ex praesentium harum.
Nihil soluta sed praesentium optio enim error. Modi expedita ipsa recusandae et autem aut. Sunt dolorem dolore enim laudantium quam. Eligendi eveniet labore corporis repudiandae vel earum. Labore laudantium omnis ut quia.
Quia ipsum cupiditate et cumque. Necessitatibus ab et rerum enim totam in corrupti.
Excepturi dolorem facere id quis aliquid provident at. Laudantium reprehenderit eveniet debitis.
Quo architecto eligendi pariatur. Consectetur in fugiat iusto et voluptatem.