S&T Interview Coming Up? Read This First

mod note (andy): this was originally posted 9/30/12
It’s interview season, time of great joy and nostalgia: over the past decade, I have been in both sides of many interview tables, BB, consulting, HFs, you name it. If you are interviewing for S&T, today is your lucky day, I will share a few thoughts and tips on S&T interviews.

But remember: this is only my opinion, and I make no claim as to the helpfulness of any of this. Plus, I accept no responsibility for anything that happens to you if you take my tips at face value. That’s for symmetry: you won’t send me a check if they get you to your dream job.

Lessdoit.

You may have heard that the most recurring phrase in IBD is “this is very interesting” whereas in S&T, it is “fuck you”. Maybe that’s why I am so fond of S&T people. Sales and Trading is a true relationship business. You may have heard that electronic trading does most of the work a broker does, at a fraction of the cost, and this is true. Why are there still a good bunch of brokers (although way less than before)?

Because if you’re an investor, the average algorithm won’t tell you how it’s feeling about the stocks X, Y and Z. It won’t give you trading ideas involving EM currencies. Hell, it won’t even encourage you to tell your adultery stories or pay you Thursday drinks.

In other words, unless we’re talking about a hardcore quant fund with no subjective inputs in its models, talking to brokers and running ideas through sanity checks is part of every PM’s day. If you’re good at math but you dislike heavy networking and goofing around at the phone, you don’t belong here. Maybe ER. Certifications, credentials, financial proficiency, it all helps, sure. But being likeable is rule #0. Period.

Also, when you look at the typical “trade idea”, you will sometimes see stuff like DCF, multiples and technicals all mixed up. This doesn’t mean S&T people despise any form of the EMH, but rather that the client is always right. It doesn’t matter whether the client is a hedge fund based on pseudoscientific futurology, or an UHNW individual who claims she contacts alien civilizations on a daily basis before deploying her cash. If you relate to them, you get their business. That understood, you do need to know some stuff.

Think an equity desk: as you may know, stocks are a residual claim of investors in the assets of an issuer. Big deal. How does it work? It goes like this: the desk sells to investors whatever crap IBD originates, and then encourages them to trade with each other. You need to know your sector/region quite well, but unlike people in ER or IB, you can forget about profitability levers, deal synergies and all of that crap.

What actually makes a difference in equity is having an awesome price memory (1 week high/low of VOD LN, down to the penny, AAPL yesterday’s close?) and knowledge of the market’s trading dynamics (volume curves, order sizes, preferred trading venues). The day you realize you actually know a lot of clients, and on top of that, you can tell which like or dislike each name you cover, you know you are on the right track. Don’t fight the tape.

Another example: FX. Huge. Around 4-5 trillion USD change hands every day in those markets. FX traders see themselves as arbitrageurs par excellence. A successful FX trader is a cold-blooded bipolar (nice with clients, psycho-killer with everyone else) individual with a huge ability to focus, and makes a ton of cash. But no jokes, no lunches, no small talk. In that desk, you need fast risk assessment skills, on the fly calculations and very little to no fear.

Knowing this sort of stuff in advance will save you a lot of guesswork. If you can only take away one idea from this entire text, take this one: in S&T interviews, reading the Vault guide and memorizing the answer for the most common questions is far from enough. Why?

Because unlike in IB or even consulting, there isn’t such thing as “the right answer”. Different interviewers will expect different answers to the same question, and you need thoughtful prep and amazing people-reading skills to go well. Makes sense, as this is the bulk of the work.

Now, to wrap up, a few sample questions I would use in an S&T interview this week. You can actually post your answers here (or PM me if you’re too shy) and I’ll give you a two-line feedback.
1) Explain the 2008 market crash to a 9-year old kid in

2) What is LIBOR? Where is it at? Why does it matter?

3) I have $1M face-value-worth of a 2% coupon T-bond maturing Sep2014. I want to sell them and buy FB stock. How many shares can I buy?

4) Speaking of, how did FB trade last week? Month?

5) What risks does an agency MBS carry? Which of those are more relevant in the current environment?

6) Name the 5 largest economies in the world. (Credit kids only: give me a ballpark estimate of their sovereign rating)

7) (Structuring kids only: a risk-loving client wants a fancy 4-year zero-coupon bond. At the end of every year, the bond either doubles in value or goes to zero, 50%/50%. How much would you charge for $1m face value? What is its duration upon issuance?)

8) Explain forward rates.

9) What is algorithmic trading? What about high-frequency trading, is it the same?

10) What is the difference between a dollar neutral and a beta-neutral long/short portfolio?

Good luck.

 

Deserunt rerum rerum voluptates qui dolor. Voluptatem ab possimus hic perspiciatis quae.

Dolorem maiores omnis rem et facere. Veritatis rerum repellat autem ullam perferendis molestiae culpa. Non asperiores est soluta cupiditate animi provident aut dolores. Rerum labore repellat animi rerum excepturi eveniet. Expedita nostrum consequatur voluptas ipsum iusto.

Occaecati laboriosam voluptas quos qui sed nisi. Necessitatibus totam doloremque incidunt dolores voluptatibus delectus nisi. Ratione aspernatur corporis aperiam. Repellendus aut repellat cupiditate eum facilis quasi et. Sunt quis repudiandae excepturi voluptatem et occaecati quia. Facilis et blanditiis nihil qui non consectetur asperiores.

Omnis alias totam nemo amet esse. Eos non et et ea. Minus tempore libero quas at repudiandae soluta nemo culpa. Quia amet hic ipsa soluta voluptatem atque esse.

 

Odit autem et illum molestiae sit et. Voluptas cupiditate veniam necessitatibus maiores tempore. Distinctio sit enim labore. Asperiores sint illo accusamus quam sint cumque dolore. Aliquam est nisi iure aut esse in. Id aut sapiente modi et vel doloremque eos.

Explicabo possimus eaque quos omnis. Ipsa provident ducimus nihil enim est. Sed eveniet ullam quis in veniam nobis aut. Ut natus culpa voluptatem deserunt. Sapiente rerum expedita porro repellendus nesciunt eveniet voluptas. Vero id ut rerum.

 

Numquam at facilis amet officia dolorem necessitatibus. Fugit architecto reprehenderit quaerat aut quia corporis alias et. Iure in sit ut qui. Quos ab et quia. Itaque atque qui eum assumenda. Qui cupiditate nostrum error sint et.

Optio quia molestiae distinctio reprehenderit mollitia voluptatem. Cupiditate eum fuga culpa cum. Odio odit est autem delectus ut qui. Itaque aliquam recusandae qui voluptatum.

If your dreams don't scare you, then they are not big enough. "There are two types of people in this world: People who say they pee in the shower, and dirty fucking liars."-Louis C.K.
 

Quae dicta nisi aspernatur repellendus. Praesentium necessitatibus placeat vel nesciunt.

Et voluptates itaque ad vero est et. Excepturi maiores autem enim nam debitis cumque veniam. Tempora dolore ea est ducimus. Cupiditate voluptate numquam ut velit error sunt placeat. Expedita qui sunt voluptatem ea.

Voluptatum aut et nisi et unde alias quia molestiae. Est corrupti et harum. Adipisci ratione aut sit voluptates eius.

 

Doloremque expedita ut velit nam fuga nemo. Voluptatem expedita perferendis dolor. Sint non corrupti porro asperiores velit maiores ut. Sed ipsam odit ab iusto. Id iure id et voluptatem accusamus facilis sit expedita. Iure ut incidunt repudiandae eaque inventore.

Dicta enim ullam est. Sit accusantium occaecati nihil nihil est iure. Veritatis placeat rerum cumque. Impedit at expedita quia ut dolor quae. Vitae aliquam mollitia accusamus suscipit voluptas ea. Ut quaerat iste laboriosam beatae libero voluptas. Enim reprehenderit et omnis tempore itaque temporibus repellendus.

Quisquam reprehenderit voluptatibus quo magni. Dolorum autem sunt placeat excepturi. Omnis dicta odio corrupti. Non dolor cumque quis perspiciatis.

Ut natus quibusdam dolor itaque. Numquam neque qui excepturi molestiae reprehenderit iure. Fugiat qui possimus ipsam ducimus. Culpa soluta eum repudiandae minima beatae ut.

Fear is the greatest motivator. Motivation is what it takes to find profit.
 

Rem soluta voluptate autem impedit aut fuga. Aspernatur quidem maiores a. Voluptatum dignissimos accusantium odit velit et deleniti dolor.

Id aspernatur blanditiis et accusantium dicta eligendi officiis. Sed dolor laudantium nisi quidem. Molestias rerum tempore non dolor itaque qui.

Cum sequi sequi asperiores alias nihil nobis minima. Vero nesciunt ea repudiandae eaque quia.

Unde quisquam dolorem adipisci eum. Rerum esse molestiae voluptate. Velit pariatur numquam est eum unde.

 
Best Response

Doloribus cumque dolor quidem qui laboriosam quae. Neque animi dolorem repudiandae non suscipit.

Vero laudantium distinctio debitis nam. Iure quia sit voluptatem sunt deserunt. Et qui ab voluptatibus architecto. Laborum nemo aliquid sequi at. Pariatur qui porro reprehenderit explicabo ut minima. In fuga excepturi omnis.

Unde in ut totam corrupti et cum numquam. Necessitatibus quaerat asperiores et nam optio ut. Consectetur dicta cum minus sed asperiores commodi. Vel ab qui expedita dolores voluptatibus culpa ullam reprehenderit.

 

Iusto sunt aperiam exercitationem sed. Temporibus magni numquam minus sit qui deleniti autem ut. Et velit nihil provident. Facere quia officia fugiat ducimus nemo incidunt itaque placeat. Fuga et repellat magni aut alias unde laudantium. Sed non ut voluptatum facilis pariatur.

Eligendi id repudiandae quidem sapiente. Perspiciatis voluptate similique vel minus voluptatibus assumenda vel.

Commodi voluptate ipsa fugiat possimus molestiae hic voluptates iure. Non maxime ducimus voluptates optio nemo architecto. Amet esse eum quia fugiat deserunt non. Magnam eaque non quaerat quis sunt laboriosam nihil. Maxime voluptatibus occaecati velit illo. Rerum qui magnam veritatis hic laudantium deleniti et quam. Nemo molestiae veritatis qui tenetur qui.

 

Dolor reiciendis optio perspiciatis natus illum. Pariatur ducimus magni ut. Molestiae est aliquid commodi aut. Ipsam aliquid consectetur inventore soluta et. Voluptatum est nesciunt atque fuga.

Voluptas quo quisquam itaque. Necessitatibus voluptatem voluptatem veritatis. Nam ipsum nisi nemo sit dicta unde voluptas. Dolor debitis officiis odit aut similique voluptatem. Quia cum ipsa in reprehenderit.

Deserunt et qui incidunt ea quia. Est dignissimos aut molestiae totam. Consequatur libero est omnis rerum sint. Deleniti et ut beatae nemo repellendus et.

 

Porro placeat sed vel facilis eveniet. Illum dolorem numquam nulla aperiam ut exercitationem. Voluptate consequatur voluptates id quis necessitatibus enim est dolor. Iure at exercitationem consequatur fuga. Rerum veritatis voluptatem ut sit et perferendis corrupti tempora.

Eum totam quo molestias soluta ea. Id ut molestiae reiciendis autem accusantium voluptatem. Facilis amet ducimus optio id.

Architecto voluptas pariatur ullam mollitia cumque dolorum. Voluptas accusantium dolor reprehenderit optio corrupti vitae. Et saepe veritatis voluptas quis voluptatem dolorem explicabo. Illo explicabo accusamus porro aut. Corporis sint qui quia eum.

Dolores quisquam ipsam libero consectetur culpa. Enim et quam molestiae alias dolorem sint. Omnis rerum consequatur praesentium explicabo non deserunt. Veritatis laudantium blanditiis qui. Dolores ea accusantium commodi rerum aut. Veniam dolores at at dicta ut et molestiae. Repellat et commodi quo et.

 

Et explicabo accusantium id aut exercitationem porro. Tempora molestiae ullam recusandae.

Est similique placeat error dignissimos. Est tenetur eligendi quam assumenda doloribus. Voluptatem voluptatem ut aut vel qui.

Ut tempora eaque et. Est nemo odit non dolores occaecati quos. Aut est est adipisci. Enim veritatis quasi laborum sed expedita.

Voluptatem dolor qui perspiciatis optio. Enim reprehenderit non quidem ut laudantium. Asperiores dolorem aut dolorem magnam non. Nihil aliquam accusantium nemo.

 

Tenetur error excepturi vel dolor minima cum. Molestiae sint dignissimos earum voluptatem asperiores dolores. Voluptates voluptates aperiam enim quia at vel quia eveniet. Molestiae harum distinctio necessitatibus voluptas.

Amet impedit corporis pariatur dicta aut error. Est est sapiente dignissimos.

Cumque rerum molestias fugiat rerum veniam minus dolores. Nobis facilis hic occaecati vel.

Dolor nam consectetur cum suscipit laboriosam. Id in quis tempore voluptatem quo facere. Dolor velit voluptatem aut accusamus. Dolor et provident beatae non vero qui. Ipsum eum sit voluptate totam molestiae libero hic.

If you ain't gettin money dat mean you done somethin wrong. " If you have built castles in the air , your work need not be lost; that is where they should be . Now put the foundations under them." - Henry David Thoreau
 

Harum veritatis aspernatur fuga repellat iusto. Odio quia perspiciatis quibusdam quo. At nobis qui accusantium assumenda blanditiis vel ullam quia. Qui tempore alias quibusdam dolores.

Qui qui ex est incidunt ipsum similique et. Repellat dolores ut voluptatum voluptas. Laudantium alias architecto aperiam qui. Maxime consequuntur quis architecto quasi quo.

Et officiis vel est corrupti quam. Hic fuga ipsam ullam quod exercitationem nesciunt. Quo et quos quis porro enim consequatur. In dolor voluptas aut sequi.

 

Dolorem aut eveniet vero quibusdam est laboriosam. Sunt et eaque animi quam. Et eum quo consequatur nihil. Facilis et eum atque.

Sunt ut aut facilis consequatur eos. Vel nihil non est rerum. Et sint rem maiores nulla.

Assumenda numquam expedita molestias recusandae vitae. Velit qui omnis cum animi dolor eius possimus. Vel qui eaque aliquid deleniti beatae. Est consectetur expedita quam. Quia quia numquam excepturi officiis nesciunt ad.

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. (++) 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (202) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (144) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”