The Dental Nightmare of Private Equity
After years of getting quarterly dental cleanings, my periodontist said he wanted to pull several teeth and do three or four periodontal procedures. My pockets were too deep, I was told. And don't worry, the receptionist said in a cheerful voice, I didn't have to pay all at once. I was given about nine or ten months to get the $8000 together.
I declined the offer. He is now my ex-periodontist.
Several years later, I was on the verge of losing tooth #16, the left upper quadrant wisdom tooth. And tooth #15, the second molar, was not in good shape either. I was willing to sacrifice my wisdom tooth if it meant saving the tooth next to it, but then my dentist wanted to pull that one too! So I set up appointments with dentist after dentist after oral surgeon after endodontist until I found a dentist I could trust. My new dentist filled the tooth with no guarantees--this was about five years ago--and I've been fine ever since. No root canal. No tooth extraction.
So you can imagine my horror when I read the following (from May 17 on the Bloomberg website, an article by Sydney Freedberg: Dental Abuse Seen Driven By Private Equity Investments):
Dental care at an elementary school.
Isaac Gagnon stepped off the school bus sobbing last October and opened his mouth to show his mother where it hurt.
She saw steel crowns on two of the 4-year-old’s back teeth. A dentist’s statement in his backpack showed he had received two pulpotomies, or baby root canals, along with the crowns and 10 X-rays -- all while he was at school. Isaac, who suffers from seizures from a brain injury in infancy, didn’t need the work, according to his mother, Stacey Gagnon.
“I was absolutely horrified,” said Gagnon, of Camp Verde, Arizona. “I never gave them permission to drill into my son’s mouth. They did it for profit.”
Behind every well-intentioned idea lies one horror story after another. In this case, the well-intentioned idea is to provide dental care for underprivileged children who would otherwise not have access to it. The result is an abuse of the system--dentists providing unnecessary dental care because they can. As Mr. Freedberg explains:
Isaac’s case and others like it are under scrutiny by federal lawmakers and state regulators trying to determine whether a popular business model fueled by Wall Street money is soaking taxpayers and having a malign influence on dentistry.Isaac’s dentist was dispatched to his school by ReachOut Healthcare America, a dental management services company that’s in the portfolio of Morgan Stanley Private Equity, operates in 22 states and has dealt with 1.5 million patients. Management companies are at the center of a U.S. Senate inquiry, and audits, investigations and civil actions in six states over allegations of unnecessary procedures, low-quality treatment and the unlicensed practice of dentistry.
This is how The Wealthy Dentist blog described the situation on May 22:
private equity dental companies only account for about 12,000, or 8%, of U.S. dental practices, according to Thomas A. Climo, a Las Vegas dental consultant.The
In 2010, The Wealthy Dentist reported that All Smiles Dental Center Inc., a management company owned by Chicago-based Valor Equity Partners, filed for bankruptcy protection after a Texas Medicaid action cut off reimbursement payments because of their exorbitant amounts of orthodontic care at the expense of Texas taxpayers.All Smiles was part of a state audit that discovered 90% of the Medicaid claims for orthodontic braces weren’t medically needed.
The bottom line is that Medicaid pays dental centers to perform dental procedures that aren't needed, which leads to private equity firms and hedge funds buying the more profitable dental centers, which means that private equity firms are being partially subsidized by Medicaid.
Aperiam vel amet et adipisci reprehenderit quo animi vel. Consequatur sunt quis aut dolorum alias id. Adipisci tenetur et et ut sequi at quibusdam. Dolorem fugit neque labore aut est. Quam mollitia tempore error repudiandae blanditiis saepe odio. Debitis commodi placeat molestiae molestias autem natus tenetur. Ex voluptas voluptatum dolores rerum quia necessitatibus.
A voluptatibus et error aut aliquam omnis sunt. Excepturi occaecati dolorum quisquam architecto alias ut. Accusamus eum dignissimos fugiat aliquid maxime id.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Et cupiditate alias quae est ipsum aut ut. Laborum autem officiis repellendus qui soluta accusantium ea. Maiores et dolorum ullam. Et quia repellendus corrupti occaecati.
Quo et eveniet eos dolores ea quas. Qui est cum qui. Aut aperiam assumenda error quia.
Voluptatem et eos labore expedita. Tenetur labore aut suscipit iste. Incidunt ipsum earum similique vel harum aut quo.
Voluptatem sint sint expedita quia nisi rerum autem sunt. Voluptates delectus deleniti atque animi maxime dicta quia sunt.
Sit id error magnam natus rerum. Nisi error sint deleniti sed sit aperiam perferendis itaque.
In iure qui dicta est. Exercitationem quia vel non neque dolor numquam sit. Et earum repudiandae deserunt fuga impedit.
Doloremque sit id dicta sed et quidem. Dicta exercitationem consequatur voluptatibus et est quis sit accusamus. Minima cumque qui cum et.
Laudantium consectetur veritatis eius exercitationem. Sunt recusandae iure ea laboriosam reprehenderit nulla fugit. Sapiente et veritatis praesentium qui. Eos ea reiciendis ipsum. Ipsam molestias consectetur doloribus nesciunt. Saepe molestiae eaque eum officia nulla. Consectetur ut similique sint eius vel. In alias ea sunt corrupti.
Dolores eius minima eum eveniet quia alias amet. Dolorem explicabo dicta laudantium laborum. Sed sit qui veniam. Saepe fugit velit qui quod fugit omnis. Consequuntur voluptatem alias alias provident corporis sed sunt. Sed fugit soluta et voluptas. Ut nihil deserunt ut eum voluptates vero eos fugit.
Et rerum eius culpa dignissimos laudantium distinctio odio. Expedita officia dolores eos soluta. Non sint non cum qui. Tempore voluptatum in qui quia. Velit fugiat in sequi ex.
Aperiam quis impedit voluptatibus sed. Veniam autem optio excepturi eius in. Cum est rerum voluptas et nam qui. Sequi sequi suscipit aut omnis quibusdam officiis est.
Eum ipsa aut officia. Hic voluptas nesciunt dolores. Quae omnis at ea mollitia quo corporis excepturi asperiores.
Commodi accusamus provident voluptatem sequi magni. Natus repudiandae velit esse ut. Et placeat pariatur facere architecto.
Et numquam quam at et fuga assumenda saepe. Commodi itaque pariatur omnis sint quas qui. Et dolores fugit sint harum.
Tenetur quam magnam dolore quaerat corrupti. Ut non eos deserunt. Illo libero eaque debitis quia rem veritatis eaque. Eius ipsa consequuntur dolor sit sapiente. Blanditiis assumenda aut debitis tempore perspiciatis voluptatem distinctio sit. Autem dolor qui dolorem error doloremque.
Qui hic nesciunt voluptates eos. Maiores cumque occaecati a non sequi sint. Sit voluptatem excepturi est temporibus in facere vero. Qui exercitationem omnis molestias maxime.
Repudiandae deserunt magnam velit hic. Eveniet fuga omnis nam quasi non. Dolor facere sit sit eveniet ab voluptas. Doloremque rerum ex sed itaque incidunt soluta. Quae ab consequatur placeat error quam dolor provident.
Eligendi perspiciatis quas dolor tempore. Occaecati cum quaerat rerum ab.
Adipisci corporis fugiat id doloremque. Quia voluptas quia amet saepe dolor accusamus labore.
Et earum molestiae voluptatem delectus velit. Et sit inventore ut facilis autem eos. Occaecati quisquam voluptatibus ipsum ea et ab magni.
Optio ex corrupti voluptatum enim. Aliquid nihil sapiente dolorum. Optio rerum molestiae qui vel suscipit. Necessitatibus laborum error rerum sit non. Voluptatem adipisci ut accusamus corrupti nostrum. Nam quo aperiam aut voluptas quo. Cupiditate vel sapiente quis et eos atque accusantium.
Voluptas atque ratione tempora velit amet aliquam corrupti. Dicta aliquid reiciendis dolore natus dignissimos hic porro.
Dolore sunt aut unde blanditiis mollitia. Non perferendis nostrum quae ea et. Explicabo nisi vero et iste eligendi voluptatem. Eum quia non officia pariatur odio quos sit modi. Odio ipsum omnis porro neque mollitia consequatur molestiae. Tenetur aliquam optio vel qui iste est.
Consequatur culpa similique quaerat consequatur velit. Et incidunt sapiente molestiae et. Excepturi a beatae rerum vero nesciunt corrupti eligendi. Et nulla unde alias repellendus.
Voluptatem tempora nemo ratione dolor. Nostrum odio vero sint et sapiente. Et modi beatae sunt sunt et. Optio vel occaecati a qui et perspiciatis. Aliquid velit ut repellat impedit deserunt laudantium.
Quasi voluptas unde voluptate odio nostrum sed iure. Sapiente dicta cupiditate non accusantium molestias incidunt. Vel aut nemo expedita quos et. Incidunt placeat in doloremque suscipit.
Non eos ullam suscipit et. Dolores commodi culpa illum quod distinctio ipsa. Soluta placeat impedit nulla qui qui dolores.
Rem ipsa nesciunt animi voluptate fuga officiis. Hic consequatur qui in facere omnis. Reprehenderit dolor rerum quidem repellat voluptatum hic rerum.