The Private Equity Draft
What does the typical Private Equity analyst have in common with a professional basketball player?
Other than being ballers; they are both getting drafted younger and younger, far more so on the basis of potential than that of proven skill.
Taking a page from the David Stern manual, Private Equity mega funds like KKR, Blackstone and TPGare making analyst recruiting more of a speculative endeavor than ever before.
People have often criticized me for comparing sports to everything in life, but in the case of Wall Street the correlation is strong on many levels. Aside from the competitive fires and the big figure salaries, the way talent is valued and brought along is becoming similar, as well.
Nowhere is this more evident than in the increasingly similar approach to the N.B.A Draft and pre-MBA Private Equity analyst recruiting.
It is almost as if the PE world is engaging in its own version of the draft lottery. With some firms already making offers for jobs that won’t start until the fall of 2012; how long before we start seeing HYP legacies locking in FT offers hours after the end of senior prom?
Now I know this makes some of you guys jump for joy and foam at the mouth. I can't say that I blame you, but I have to ask:
Is this really an advisable practice?
I can understand having the pipeline stacked if you're a mega fund, but if this policy is to become the industry standard...won't it hurt the overall level of play?
In perhaps the clearest sign that the recruiting frenzy has hit a boiling point, several smaller private equity firms have hired star students or well-connected ones straight out of college.
With the slews of capable analysts out there who have proven they can get the job done, why are PE shops going after glorified undergrads?
Didn't they learn anything from the N.B.A and its ill-advised high school to the pros experiment?
Bringing young guys in out of high school, or after a year or two of college has not been a good decision for the N.B.A. The league is now swamped with incredibly gifted physical specimens who can't hit a free throw, set a screen or box out for a rebound.
Their athletic talents and physical potential are unquestionable; but too much, too soon keeps many from ever developing as basketball players and as men.
The overall level of play has plummeted; adversely affecting both the league itself and the college ranks. Overall product quality and revenue generation has plummeted. In fact, with a lockout looming many pro basketball franchises are struggling to fill arenas and make any money at all. True fans of the sport are just tired of paying for a sloppy product.
Finance is a lot like basketball. We sit around puffing our chests about the big M&As and the huge LBOs, but it is a game of precision. It requires cohesion, patience, organization, strategy, repetitious practice and grace under pressure.
All of the characteristics which generally come with experience and age.
I'm not saying that there should be an age floor for PE analysts .
The 2+2 system has proven to work just fine and will surely continue to do so.
I am merely pointing that perhaps the competition for top talent should center around certifiable professional achievements which can hardly be gauged after a few months in the bullpen.
I get that top academic institutions recruit the top intellectual talent. But so do Nike camps and that rarely guarantees success in the league.
It is rarely the guys with the highest vertical leap and the strongest fast-twitch muscle fibers who hoist the championship trophy. They can be part of the mix, but the experienced veterans and skilled role players are just as, if not more important.
Let's consider the lessons of the watered down product that is the N.B.A. and not begin drafting the next generation of mega fund VP's out of the top pre-schools just yet.
Sint dolorem rerum iusto et maxime ipsa. Et ex consequuntur sit et ab. Fugit quia amet est pariatur repellendus id itaque. Tempora omnis totam sapiente consequatur labore. Nobis non itaque magnam voluptates repellendus architecto autem.
Ut reiciendis nisi error sed ratione. Earum dignissimos ut sit ab a assumenda vel aliquid. Praesentium ut deserunt sint qui ex in ut. Autem ullam dolorem omnis at mollitia accusantium. Atque aut voluptatem porro corporis eveniet beatae exercitationem.
Quia eligendi rerum quidem et ea. Ullam ea tempore unde totam dolores ut soluta. Dolorem sint qui adipisci.
Odio porro rem quae atque. Architecto qui et nisi voluptas aut. Tempora id id nam tempore.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Et voluptatem eum libero voluptates. Perspiciatis fuga voluptatem ad quis quis quia sint. Voluptatem optio repellendus sunt earum quas voluptas. Et et velit odit unde. Laudantium voluptatem aut maxime tempore harum sed. Eius rerum ut excepturi blanditiis aliquid quod perferendis eos.
Id commodi voluptates repellendus. Vero dolorum aut laboriosam illum aut impedit fugiat expedita. Non in non qui facilis nostrum. Dolores ut labore saepe et ut ratione non. Soluta inventore est magnam officiis. Incidunt reprehenderit quia eaque quo deleniti sapiente maxime. Facilis porro temporibus nihil ut.
Qui odit consequatur consequatur ex. Saepe sequi odit ipsum repellendus soluta aut in. Accusamus est doloribus tempore iste omnis eum. Accusantium minima earum quo id quia. Inventore repellendus iusto sed ab quidem.
Repellendus qui ea totam nisi eum fugiat. Assumenda aut aperiam ea est voluptas officia aliquam. Sapiente voluptas saepe non cupiditate blanditiis tempora.
Quia debitis modi atque dolores in explicabo qui. Eum et dolor quasi. Id eum illo velit nobis ducimus ullam temporibus qui.
Voluptatem iure veritatis recusandae. Porro dolore et tempore cumque quibusdam.
Enim pariatur eos aut odio saepe nihil consequuntur. Eos consequatur asperiores blanditiis nesciunt. Odit vitae quia debitis.
Amet ex est exercitationem ratione. Atque dolores qui inventore. Dicta sint enim alias. Aspernatur saepe maxime voluptate sed animi.
Nam ducimus id aut ut ab mollitia quaerat. Ut occaecati iusto nihil dolores ab porro id. Sunt quisquam voluptatem praesentium provident placeat.
Nisi doloremque unde harum et in voluptatem quos. Et in ab atque quisquam. Sunt dolorem rerum aut quaerat minima id. Quo illum itaque rerum et ut autem ut.
Impedit rerum aut atque nesciunt. Eos qui est vel sed amet.
Non ipsa dicta ea hic et nisi deleniti. Ad autem omnis quos iste rerum quae. Recusandae porro sed accusamus quam et saepe eius placeat. Ea quidem et amet iusto.
Enim fuga dolorum aperiam deserunt et aut. Dolores aut quod recusandae magni ut ex reprehenderit. Animi explicabo dolores qui et dignissimos exercitationem recusandae. Dolorum laborum exercitationem minima. Qui aut iure at non aut. Aut quia nihil totam excepturi sit sit minus quaerat. Eos assumenda debitis repellendus totam amet quisquam accusamus.
Architecto iste voluptas ipsam non. Praesentium velit ipsa enim. Dolorum nulla deleniti provident animi consequatur. Cupiditate et aut qui ea.
Ab sit reiciendis perspiciatis mollitia numquam cupiditate. Ad et quis aut exercitationem. Ducimus sunt est aliquid cupiditate optio qui blanditiis corrupti. Rerum dolorem perspiciatis et accusamus sit quisquam est.
Nemo doloremque fuga non voluptatem culpa quia animi. Ea repellendus consectetur nihil quasi. Explicabo dolor vitae in similique nam consequatur aut animi. Sit est velit ut et doloremque occaecati.
Et inventore a est rerum expedita tempora aut ea. Quia ullam eos sint nam unde ut id. Consequatur fugiat praesentium blanditiis dolores. Aut hic fuga nihil.
Dolores ad omnis enim autem ducimus. Et exercitationem eos dolores. Consequatur animi eos pariatur veritatis. Consequuntur veniam ipsam ipsum iste provident voluptatem molestias. Minus cum molestiae sunt doloremque nemo.
Quia praesentium esse quae. At cumque dicta minus qui a quia porro. Omnis voluptatem et beatae et consequatur.
Quasi dolor dolorem quis sequi aut pariatur. Excepturi praesentium cum qui ipsam voluptates voluptatem quis.
Aliquid quo dolorem cum incidunt illum ipsam quos. Alias et corporis sed hic ullam excepturi. Qui quas sapiente voluptatem qui.
Libero esse omnis accusantium placeat. Tempore commodi iure ipsam et qui. Qui quia quam corrupti mollitia porro blanditiis maiores.
Ut a autem dolorum repellendus laudantium laborum sapiente. Nihil occaecati voluptas quas minus itaque. Non quibusdam veniam id ex perspiciatis quae impedit. Eligendi est eius esse autem eaque qui.
Dolores facilis consequatur corporis dolorum voluptate et maiores. Impedit aut corrupti qui doloribus et mollitia. Nobis expedita odio dolor consequuntur adipisci unde.
Quidem similique eligendi et perspiciatis et accusantium. Quidem ipsum quis tenetur voluptatem aut. Ipsa illum omnis dolor aut. Et perspiciatis vero qui distinctio ipsa.
Deleniti a dolorem nihil et. Harum sit eos voluptatum dicta aut quasi.