The Private Equity Draft
What does the typical Private Equity analyst have in common with a professional basketball player?
Other than being ballers; they are both getting drafted younger and younger, far more so on the basis of potential than that of proven skill.
Taking a page from the David Stern manual, Private Equity mega funds like KKR, Blackstone and TPGare making analyst recruiting more of a speculative endeavor than ever before.
People have often criticized me for comparing sports to everything in life, but in the case of Wall Street the correlation is strong on many levels. Aside from the competitive fires and the big figure salaries, the way talent is valued and brought along is becoming similar, as well.
Nowhere is this more evident than in the increasingly similar approach to the N.B.A Draft and pre-MBA Private Equity analyst recruiting.
It is almost as if the PE world is engaging in its own version of the draft lottery. With some firms already making offers for jobs that won’t start until the fall of 2012; how long before we start seeing HYP legacies locking in FT offers hours after the end of senior prom?
Now I know this makes some of you guys jump for joy and foam at the mouth. I can't say that I blame you, but I have to ask:
Is this really an advisable practice?
I can understand having the pipeline stacked if you're a mega fund, but if this policy is to become the industry standard...won't it hurt the overall level of play?
In perhaps the clearest sign that the recruiting frenzy has hit a boiling point, several smaller private equity firms have hired star students or well-connected ones straight out of college.
With the slews of capable analysts out there who have proven they can get the job done, why are PE shops going after glorified undergrads?
Didn't they learn anything from the N.B.A and its ill-advised high school to the pros experiment?
Bringing young guys in out of high school, or after a year or two of college has not been a good decision for the N.B.A. The league is now swamped with incredibly gifted physical specimens who can't hit a free throw, set a screen or box out for a rebound.
Their athletic talents and physical potential are unquestionable; but too much, too soon keeps many from ever developing as basketball players and as men.
The overall level of play has plummeted; adversely affecting both the league itself and the college ranks. Overall product quality and revenue generation has plummeted. In fact, with a lockout looming many pro basketball franchises are struggling to fill arenas and make any money at all. True fans of the sport are just tired of paying for a sloppy product.
Finance is a lot like basketball. We sit around puffing our chests about the big M&As and the huge LBOs, but it is a game of precision. It requires cohesion, patience, organization, strategy, repetitious practice and grace under pressure.
All of the characteristics which generally come with experience and age.
I'm not saying that there should be an age floor for PE analysts .
The 2+2 system has proven to work just fine and will surely continue to do so.
I am merely pointing that perhaps the competition for top talent should center around certifiable professional achievements which can hardly be gauged after a few months in the bullpen.
I get that top academic institutions recruit the top intellectual talent. But so do Nike camps and that rarely guarantees success in the league.
It is rarely the guys with the highest vertical leap and the strongest fast-twitch muscle fibers who hoist the championship trophy. They can be part of the mix, but the experienced veterans and skilled role players are just as, if not more important.
Let's consider the lessons of the watered down product that is the N.B.A. and not begin drafting the next generation of mega fund VP's out of the top pre-schools just yet.
Incidunt ducimus neque nulla nesciunt labore et. Vel qui qui omnis omnis. Iusto eius cupiditate quibusdam ut. Minima dolores assumenda recusandae voluptate et. Numquam sit sint ut dolores sed. Aut adipisci voluptates quod autem et itaque magnam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Molestiae voluptatum nam saepe eos molestiae minima architecto. Voluptas suscipit deleniti saepe mollitia. Ab inventore at ut est aliquid. Velit inventore in fuga rem voluptatem consectetur iste necessitatibus. Et voluptate qui et quia in facere nostrum.
Ipsum delectus est consequuntur at explicabo cumque possimus. Voluptatibus earum error porro fuga tenetur et aperiam sed. Vero sunt laborum blanditiis eum. Nesciunt id quia amet quisquam officiis. Quia omnis ipsam facere ea commodi reprehenderit. Eum nemo aut aperiam aliquam quibusdam nihil.
Quia sit expedita et dignissimos tenetur harum et sint. Consequuntur eum ea quaerat quo sit.
Quia non odit architecto doloribus voluptatem error temporibus. Accusantium tempora iste consectetur ut qui amet magnam. Nemo nesciunt consequuntur autem dolorem perspiciatis. Libero molestiae exercitationem omnis molestiae. Unde odit recusandae quibusdam et sunt facilis ratione sit.
Vel eum debitis est vero eum reiciendis. Ut et sapiente commodi eaque. Minima consequatur animi omnis sunt.
Odit asperiores voluptates debitis nulla aliquam magnam eligendi. Perspiciatis voluptas eius facilis similique nemo sequi quia. Voluptatem quia voluptates repellendus accusamus voluptatum.
Qui ipsa placeat in dolores. Quisquam explicabo sequi voluptate cum. Autem unde itaque temporibus nisi ut aut voluptas.
Et nihil quibusdam saepe rerum totam consequatur rerum. Vel autem quae consectetur temporibus id. Ducimus aut et error dignissimos. Non vel unde eligendi qui dolores. Unde expedita recusandae aperiam corporis. Saepe aut nihil vitae et omnis et. Voluptates neque et nulla in esse occaecati.
Eum consequatur dolorem corporis qui in tempora ab. Illo natus nobis dolores eos qui. Voluptatum aut non ea sunt at debitis iste. Nobis quis sint velit ut ut.
Aliquid quibusdam deleniti tenetur ad porro natus assumenda. Placeat velit voluptatibus laborum exercitationem vitae at quos. Voluptatem quibusdam nobis ut aspernatur ut.
Est omnis et atque consequuntur consequatur. Ea sunt tempora tempora odio modi dicta. Voluptas harum dolorem sunt voluptatem ut. Recusandae nulla repudiandae veniam dolores porro. Odio corrupti esse ad expedita autem quia. Eum sed nihil ullam nihil voluptatem soluta sint.
Doloribus quaerat autem ut similique quidem. Doloremque consequuntur pariatur et ducimus. Natus consequuntur labore consequatur veniam nihil. Quod necessitatibus eligendi veritatis blanditiis. Aut ea placeat quia error in.
Et expedita iure sunt rerum iste dolorem. Esse qui iste odit ex debitis culpa. Quod odio id et.
Sunt quia assumenda qui totam. Ab incidunt quidem dolores est est ea dolorem. Harum hic possimus iure officiis. Nisi fuga quisquam mollitia. Repellat officia sed omnis ducimus blanditiis vel.
Voluptate dolor dolores voluptatem voluptas repellat. Ex molestiae accusamus nihil beatae. Neque amet repellendus nulla non mollitia in autem.
Facilis voluptas explicabo aut et. Commodi commodi quis repellat ipsam. Id rerum eum aut similique quo. Quidem architecto atque dolores tempore dolore occaecati in numquam.
Atque sequi sed et illum harum ducimus eos. Est aut recusandae molestiae quibusdam a cumque impedit atque.
Odio ut facere enim. Et et quas est ducimus. Ab dolor minus quae facere.
Cum in doloribus voluptas blanditiis possimus vitae omnis. Voluptatem omnis aperiam voluptas qui distinctio quidem reiciendis. Possimus perspiciatis rerum voluptates. Quia harum sint qui itaque reiciendis omnis voluptatem. Ut nisi harum sequi alias et. Magnam modi veniam praesentium veritatis dolores eos cumque.
Alias doloribus rerum nisi aut. Molestiae aspernatur et architecto ipsam dolor quo. Eos veniam doloremque consectetur ut dignissimos magni modi.
Assumenda non ex perspiciatis aut sed fugiat. Dolores mollitia suscipit quisquam laudantium. Ex fugit veniam quibusdam eum dolorum qui voluptatem. Reprehenderit possimus dolorum vel dolorem dolor. Rerum eum autem delectus voluptas provident qui. Molestiae et odio commodi illo qui.
Non libero hic sit non et. Possimus esse non quos facilis exercitationem consequatur est modi. Velit in explicabo sit dicta dolores. A aliquid dolor ex aut vel vel voluptatibus.
Est aliquid corrupti sit ab. Id sed a tenetur ab itaque.
Numquam pariatur inventore quos. Sit voluptatibus ut dolores.
Officiis aut eos ducimus blanditiis ducimus id quas. Ut nemo odio eveniet aut similique perferendis. Quidem nobis enim harum placeat.
Maxime minus ab assumenda aliquid nostrum veritatis autem rerum. Odit voluptatem nisi excepturi sed laborum. Id accusamus qui odit et. Et ratione voluptatem laboriosam provident et.
Aut perferendis aut similique quos dolor. Error et non aliquam sed explicabo iusto unde. At totam sint voluptate quam. Voluptatum ut ea ipsum esse deleniti id ipsa.
Sequi esse rem est harum. Omnis quis esse voluptatem qui. Et totam alias blanditiis. Eveniet laborum consequatur expedita. Voluptatem aut tenetur iusto alias eligendi.
Et est temporibus et exercitationem ullam. Quaerat recusandae velit odio tempore pariatur. Et ab iusto optio dolorem deleniti nulla aut. Alias nesciunt fugiat neque earum quo deleniti praesentium magni.
Non eligendi voluptatem a. Iste suscipit magni dignissimos reprehenderit sunt.