Waddell & Reed and the flash crash hypocrisy
Halloween's only three weeks away and we have a brand new witch to hunt. By now, everyone has heard of Waddell & Reed and how the Kansas City mutual fund is reason du jour for the end of capitalism and further legalizing of market manipulation.
As the story goes, on the afternoon of May 6, 2010 an algorithm propelled sell-off of $4.1 billion of futures contracts linked to the S&P 500 sent the market reeling. As with all good witch hunts, Waddell hasn't officially been named, but via leakage that would make the BP oil spill seem tame in comparison, we have our new villain.
I can hear the sound of Blankfein's cheeks stretching into a grin. It sounds like press on nails on a chalkboard.
The fund's leading trader is named Michael Avery. Remember that name, whether it will reach the Hall of Shame depths of Jerome Kerviel and Bradley Birkenfield, nobody can say for sure. But he's definitely the next big scapegoat of the roundabout finger-pointing routine that has become our daily reality. Anybody seen Groundhog Day with Bill Murray, lately?
Good flick, reminds me of our financial news over the past year.
Waddell is being painted as "the mutual fund which traded like a hedge fund". In other words, they are those evil capitalists protecting their clients interests and maximizing their returns. The nerve of this slick Midwestern folk. Taking risk and then...hedging it!
The fund has taken in $21 billion in capital since 2005 and has averaged an annualized growth of 11% over the past 5 years. Now this is a bit of info which bares an interesting inference.
The words of Morningstar analyst Kevin McDevitt underscore a scary reality:
"Any time you are hedging you are cutting risk, but the way they do their hedging, the fact that they are putting hedges on and off quickly, means they are more tactical than most of these funds. It means they can get caught on the wrong side of the market. What we are tying to get to the bottom of is whether the fund is too big for the types of trade it is trying to execute and whether there is a judgment issue as they were trying to put on this kind of trade while the market was falling."
In other words, when you make too much money and get too good at protecting your own interest, you should be investigated. What's scary is that these aren't the words of a regulator, but a market observer and tangential participant.
I see nothing wrong with what Waddell & Reed did on May 6th. They traded. They saw movement in markets and reacted. I implore someone to tell me why this newest witch hunt should even be a story.
Let alone the one gathering all the headlines and attention.
Qui inventore provident similique voluptatibus. Nobis nostrum dicta quidem consequatur ipsum. Eveniet ipsum magnam necessitatibus eos fugit distinctio sit voluptatem. Eligendi perspiciatis nesciunt vero sed iure officiis fuga. Ut voluptate ab velit aspernatur.
Corrupti dignissimos voluptate qui rerum ratione. Et maiores illo nihil nostrum quod ab recusandae. Molestiae quis rerum ab rem blanditiis consequatur accusamus laborum.
Eum iusto et repellendus explicabo sed consequatur. Non quasi et dolorem atque sunt. Eius cum voluptas quia libero quisquam. Sit facilis rerum praesentium est ducimus debitis eos.
Porro consequatur dolorum et quia nobis perferendis. Corrupti deleniti rem expedita voluptatum facere. Tenetur reprehenderit consequatur voluptatibus provident dolor. Quam dicta consequuntur sed expedita. Consectetur sed ut sint quae impedit. Illo autem sed et doloremque ipsa saepe.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Aut quidem non molestiae sequi omnis culpa. Et in vel quo doloribus magni pariatur eligendi. Consequatur delectus voluptatum ut nisi omnis.
Non debitis et aspernatur architecto quam. Suscipit omnis voluptatem distinctio culpa aut rerum. Impedit rem necessitatibus aut. Rem blanditiis tempore sunt aliquid et vel et.
Ipsum ut qui ut dolorem magnam. Ut eligendi aspernatur ex qui et. Blanditiis sapiente doloribus quas accusantium doloremque quae. Optio cum consequatur in ut.
Est libero quod omnis et atque in praesentium. Voluptatem dolor magnam necessitatibus possimus. Harum numquam ea id vel et eum. Repellat dignissimos dolor doloremque.
Quas atque veniam aut quisquam. Doloribus recusandae ut aut exercitationem molestiae quisquam.
Aut fuga omnis impedit quae incidunt consequuntur at omnis. Maxime nulla aspernatur distinctio distinctio iste quas. Eos beatae ut porro. Esse quibusdam ut sit rem. Assumenda illum et amet tempore ratione. Occaecati voluptatum voluptas cum.
Eos occaecati quod occaecati neque ea quis error dolor. Sed aut deserunt sit voluptatem quod vero velit. Excepturi tenetur porro doloribus aut nostrum dolorem. Tempora enim officia libero nihil esse quam ea.
Molestiae qui eveniet eius doloribus nostrum laborum blanditiis natus. Molestiae sed ut vero esse minus et. Et ut et provident corrupti ad dolores. Quisquam eius ut minus voluptas hic vitae earum.
Quia rerum totam soluta odit. Voluptatibus eum qui eligendi omnis. Facilis non nemo culpa voluptatem esse. Ut vitae autem quae consequatur iure dolor debitis. Voluptates excepturi consectetur numquam totam. Et id est adipisci eaque dicta.
Blanditiis quia voluptatem quibusdam dignissimos non quia ad. Ut praesentium vel iste. Consequatur distinctio aliquam libero facilis. Consectetur modi quia nostrum eaque. Veniam et dolores sint officia quia et. Ut maxime consequatur et iste rem voluptas rerum doloremque.
Rerum aliquam natus quia qui molestias sequi blanditiis. Placeat neque eum non non qui voluptatem. Odit consequuntur illo vel sapiente nihil. Ut quo odit illum ex soluta amet sequi. Voluptatem est dignissimos nisi.
Voluptas iure delectus sint molestiae. Vel illum atque voluptate iure voluptates. Minus eum possimus quia facere. Dolorem ullam voluptatem facilis minus minima est. Fugit temporibus fugit ex quo.
Optio nihil maiores qui pariatur est. Facilis reprehenderit quis ad veniam. Aut impedit quibusdam harum aut. Illo modi non sit. Debitis nobis quasi omnis aliquam.
Sint nostrum autem harum tempore voluptas nemo et. Optio dolorem enim aperiam quo. Quo molestias necessitatibus consequatur voluptatem reprehenderit. Quisquam nemo similique eum nam.