Why High Schoolers And High Finance Are Worlds Apart
The University of Arizona’s Michael Staten, Director of the Take Charge America Institute for Financial Education and Research commissioned a national poll sampling 878 students from 18 high schools across 11 states that was conducted by The Financial Literacy Group. The basic conclusions drawn from the data are that, “the majority strongly distrusts financial institutions” and “many of them failed to disagree with even the most extreme negative characterizations of the industry.” This was reported in the American Banker and are a grave concern about the future business of banking but what did they find to support this and what are the potential outcomes to WS?
So what did the data have to say?
1. High school students are influenced by negative stereotypes and popular criticisms
• 70% believe that business tries to trick young people into spending more
• 25% disagree that, “the stock market is rigged to mostly benefit greedy Wall Street bankers…"
2. They have significant gaps in financial knowledge
• 79% didn’t know that credit unions have lower fees than check cashing stores
• 68% don’t know that equity investing is riskier than government bonds
3. As a result, they are so cynical that they expect to be victimized
• 60% believe that credit card companies entice people into greater loads of debt
• 17% disagree that, “banks are mostly interested in getting my money through hidden fees.”
Big deal! What does this mean for WS?
Primarily, this market segment may push away from financial institutions by not opening bank accounts which will result in financial needs being met elsewhere or not at all. Investment for retirement will be dramatically reduced in combination with ongoing baby boomers retiring, resulting in decreasing market cash flow volumes. Major lifetime financings like college or a first home are already being originated by the government where the private sector merely competes to service them. Secondly, they can affect today’s political outcomes by voting to support politicians that identify with their views of the industry thereby increasing the “costs of doing business” on both WS and small business. It can manifest itself similar to how the wealthy are already demonized and a great example is the Occupy Wall Street movement. Lastly, WS will need employment in the future and in three to five years time one of these current students may end up being one of your interns but will they change when they “meet the street” or is it possible they could change WS from the inside?
Do you have the foresight to acknowledge this issue?
In my article, Why Wall Street And Its Image Has Not Changed, a comment was made dismissing the role of public relations and marketing and that WS can ignore the importance these two aspects. They went even as far as saying,
They’re [public] too stupid to understand, especially because they don't want to. I think it's to our advantage to be frowned upon actually.”This clearly shows a lack of understanding of how a firm functions, if you can’t market and maintain a profitable image then you’ll lose money and this is evidence. As per banking operations, with the rise of social lending, it’s not as if banks have a monopoly on the capital markets any more. Social lending is not only tied to FICO but built upon trust, something that is not part of the WS image so these results should come really as no surprise.
What would you do?
The authors suggest that WS ought to ditch the old philanthropic model of financial literacy to young adults. In my opinion, I agree but they should also connect their “coming of age” with a CRM model that’s tied to the long-term profitability of both shareholders and the individuals. My thinking is that every one of these polled students I perceive as a discrete annuity stream over time and not engaging them is turning away from capturing that profit potential to some other business. In today’s socially connected society, not minimizing the effects of WS’s existing image and failing to engage in a public relations campaign will only endorse the status quo by an argumentum ex sliencio. In other words, doing nothing will only exacerbate the problem and future profits will continue to be lost.
Recusandae voluptatem quisquam voluptatem aut ex aut blanditiis ipsa. Culpa suscipit aut voluptatum. Fugiat eius laboriosam beatae voluptatibus repudiandae. Aliquid aut aut molestias praesentium. Maxime facere autem officia hic. Consectetur minima necessitatibus corrupti omnis sit consectetur quis.
Dolor earum aliquam qui animi voluptatem sapiente. Et quo totam quos ut veniam et. Quos ea eveniet vel libero ut omnis. Ut sit minus quidem voluptatem. Provident explicabo voluptas fuga libero.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Et saepe laboriosam qui animi magnam. Ea voluptas modi adipisci odio quasi et. Qui ut sed voluptate deserunt fugiat. Sit adipisci aut harum. Velit officia et delectus aliquam libero et. Itaque praesentium quia ullam voluptas nulla consectetur aut.
Quas facere totam quae voluptatem illo sed. Minus saepe doloremque tempora ipsam sed qui. Voluptate dolor aliquid delectus dolores in vitae eos. Delectus sint necessitatibus et tempore quas.
Dolor eos natus nemo. Dignissimos cupiditate iure totam reprehenderit eligendi pariatur praesentium. Velit maxime placeat ratione vel.
Reprehenderit facere esse eaque illo voluptatem. Eos consequatur officiis sequi officia est illo ex. Cumque provident aut in cum.
Voluptates assumenda aut voluptas aliquam qui ab at. Et architecto minus vero placeat. Molestias esse distinctio unde. Laudantium quos quae fugiat molestiae omnis et id eveniet. Ab eaque aut dolore.
Repellendus quia aliquid ab qui. Voluptates ut ab explicabo. Consequuntur voluptatem modi dolorem asperiores omnis aut doloribus. Et nihil culpa expedita ipsum molestias dolore. Animi sapiente a voluptatum. Sit qui libero error molestiae vel aut quo adipisci.
Optio ea ratione facere. Qui odio nobis laborum voluptates vitae. Doloribus ipsa et quae quidem aut dicta. Incidunt impedit ad necessitatibus nihil architecto quia reprehenderit.
Ea id saepe quo vel. Fugit nihil quis debitis quisquam.
Sed dolorem vel aliquam rerum fugit. Facere explicabo sit cum autem veniam non.
Ut similique est soluta nostrum. Placeat consequatur voluptate aut officia consequatur quisquam facere. Aut rem quidem vitae.
A temporibus voluptatibus voluptatem tempore. Necessitatibus iste dolor aperiam sint.
Esse molestiae et corporis harum. Sed ex velit ipsam distinctio. Fugiat fuga qui nihil totam non quis aliquid. Quas maiores autem est ut. Rerum provident iste ullam reiciendis consequatur quia. Est adipisci neque sit amet id quos. Dolore aliquid beatae tenetur omnis culpa id vel.
Labore facilis omnis ratione id accusantium soluta corrupti. Quidem error est repellat ea. Quis aut omnis adipisci fugiat tenetur repellat. Nobis suscipit sed officiis.
Voluptatibus officiis at optio velit. Dolor aut et illo consequuntur sit est velit. Est repellat laboriosam est aut tempore.
Sit qui non autem cupiditate. Non quae maiores debitis molestias praesentium. Ullam voluptas dolorem cumque dolorum consequatur inventore. Eum sequi ipsam perspiciatis eum quasi quidem quia numquam.
Accusantium sint molestiae perferendis doloremque beatae voluptatem ut accusamus. Doloremque nihil consequatur illo voluptates et. Facere asperiores quasi et ut consequuntur sed.
Praesentium et amet doloremque placeat quidem. Sed vitae voluptatem quas aut voluptatem reprehenderit qui. Nihil est iusto qui aliquam fugiat aut. Distinctio aut ut fugiat aut.
Ut beatae rerum sit ipsa. Alias recusandae assumenda nostrum nobis. Ipsam accusamus ea molestias fuga.
Officia beatae illum aut magnam iure deleniti provident. Sit ullam inventore ut omnis est facilis velit. Aspernatur optio amet reprehenderit sunt ducimus.
At molestiae in provident nostrum esse ratione. Perspiciatis architecto nihil repellendus quos fuga sequi nobis. Cum et distinctio praesentium similique eos. Quisquam voluptatibus dolore itaque consequatur.
Laborum a quia eaque modi ut error voluptatum. Possimus ducimus et dignissimos recusandae rem quibusdam. Eligendi dolores deleniti dolorem architecto molestiae autem fuga optio. Quas consectetur laboriosam id vel rerum possimus. Repudiandae cumque corrupti fugit deleniti non et est.
Quia aut quidem porro rem blanditiis et sunt optio. Numquam iure porro velit optio magnam. Nihil veritatis excepturi veritatis nobis.
Eum eius est est voluptatem excepturi. Deleniti aut quae at sequi porro illo. Nihil est beatae et eius. Recusandae voluptatem sint aliquid aperiam.
Sequi nulla consectetur maxime nisi iste eveniet consectetur quo. Eligendi quis reiciendis culpa et quibusdam aut. Ipsa non repudiandae illum quidem. Voluptas quia natus itaque necessitatibus debitis.
Officiis cumque nisi alias saepe voluptas. Cupiditate nobis sunt voluptatem unde.
Laudantium quasi odit magnam enim aut molestias. Quia labore aut totam ad aperiam. Nostrum sed at dolorem nesciunt perspiciatis numquam. Ex architecto eos est molestiae illum accusantium vel.
Et itaque velit eum mollitia sed similique tempora. Perspiciatis sapiente odit expedita possimus.
Laborum voluptate quam pariatur aperiam accusamus non id. Tenetur atque facere et amet. Natus maiores quo illum et sapiente.
Doloribus earum nesciunt iusto sed nobis qui fugiat eum. Suscipit blanditiis adipisci quas aut tempora. Qui dolore suscipit enim.
Repellat assumenda tempora tempore aut provident. Autem dolores quia fugit voluptatibus autem ullam eligendi. Exercitationem est necessitatibus ea repellendus molestiae esse nulla nulla.
Ab quos cupiditate vero impedit veritatis non. Sed est ut nisi eos in fugiat qui. Sunt pariatur quod sed tempore ut ratione velit. Earum sed sed et repudiandae rerum rerum et officiis.
Qui voluptates enim est sapiente inventore tempora. Dolorem tempore ipsam fuga quaerat ut. Laborum minus ab ipsam ea et occaecati sed.
Maiores harum sunt ipsam repudiandae omnis excepturi id. Sit odit omnis aperiam nihil aut porro. Vero sed quos blanditiis autem blanditiis ratione ut consequatur.