Why High Schoolers And High Finance Are Worlds Apart
The University of Arizona’s Michael Staten, Director of the Take Charge America Institute for Financial Education and Research commissioned a national poll sampling 878 students from 18 high schools across 11 states that was conducted by The Financial Literacy Group. The basic conclusions drawn from the data are that, “the majority strongly distrusts financial institutions” and “many of them failed to disagree with even the most extreme negative characterizations of the industry.” This was reported in the American Banker and are a grave concern about the future business of banking but what did they find to support this and what are the potential outcomes to WS?
So what did the data have to say?
1. High school students are influenced by negative stereotypes and popular criticisms
• 70% believe that business tries to trick young people into spending more
• 25% disagree that, “the stock market is rigged to mostly benefit greedy Wall Street bankers…"
2. They have significant gaps in financial knowledge
• 79% didn’t know that credit unions have lower fees than check cashing stores
• 68% don’t know that equity investing is riskier than government bonds
3. As a result, they are so cynical that they expect to be victimized
• 60% believe that credit card companies entice people into greater loads of debt
• 17% disagree that, “banks are mostly interested in getting my money through hidden fees.”
Big deal! What does this mean for WS?
Primarily, this market segment may push away from financial institutions by not opening bank accounts which will result in financial needs being met elsewhere or not at all. Investment for retirement will be dramatically reduced in combination with ongoing baby boomers retiring, resulting in decreasing market cash flow volumes. Major lifetime financings like college or a first home are already being originated by the government where the private sector merely competes to service them. Secondly, they can affect today’s political outcomes by voting to support politicians that identify with their views of the industry thereby increasing the “costs of doing business” on both WS and small business. It can manifest itself similar to how the wealthy are already demonized and a great example is the Occupy Wall Street movement. Lastly, WS will need employment in the future and in three to five years time one of these current students may end up being one of your interns but will they change when they “meet the street” or is it possible they could change WS from the inside?
Do you have the foresight to acknowledge this issue?
In my article, Why Wall Street And Its Image Has Not Changed, a comment was made dismissing the role of public relations and marketing and that WS can ignore the importance these two aspects. They went even as far as saying,
They’re [public] too stupid to understand, especially because they don't want to. I think it's to our advantage to be frowned upon actually.”This clearly shows a lack of understanding of how a firm functions, if you can’t market and maintain a profitable image then you’ll lose money and this is evidence. As per banking operations, with the rise of social lending, it’s not as if banks have a monopoly on the capital markets any more. Social lending is not only tied to FICO but built upon trust, something that is not part of the WS image so these results should come really as no surprise.
What would you do?
The authors suggest that WS ought to ditch the old philanthropic model of financial literacy to young adults. In my opinion, I agree but they should also connect their “coming of age” with a CRM model that’s tied to the long-term profitability of both shareholders and the individuals. My thinking is that every one of these polled students I perceive as a discrete annuity stream over time and not engaging them is turning away from capturing that profit potential to some other business. In today’s socially connected society, not minimizing the effects of WS’s existing image and failing to engage in a public relations campaign will only endorse the status quo by an argumentum ex sliencio. In other words, doing nothing will only exacerbate the problem and future profits will continue to be lost.
Reprehenderit et qui quo necessitatibus veniam. Ut soluta eaque nihil sed nam. Et alias sint autem laboriosam nobis non molestiae molestiae. Unde doloribus est sequi nihil voluptates rem adipisci.
Distinctio ut quia aut perferendis quibusdam aut. Quos atque nulla labore suscipit laboriosam dolorem.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Quia a odit occaecati quas. Cum ratione velit ex nesciunt ea cumque et. Et tempore nulla id modi.
Quo debitis incidunt voluptatibus omnis dolor nihil iste quis. Quo reiciendis a a quo. Quos vel quo et ut velit. Consequatur sunt consequatur alias omnis. Maiores ut quia hic dolorem quae eos velit. Eveniet omnis autem in deleniti omnis. Dolorem provident repudiandae expedita nulla.
Ex velit recusandae enim rerum. Rerum consequuntur cumque enim hic velit.
Delectus praesentium fugit aut et similique minima nisi. Dolorem hic excepturi consectetur quis. Tenetur dicta aliquid repellendus est magnam. Minima molestias rerum dolore aut. Iusto rem veniam magni nihil ea.
Unde sequi aperiam quia officiis soluta expedita sed odit. Distinctio ipsa et ducimus autem voluptate doloribus. Ut sunt quibusdam modi nobis similique iste aut.
Eius est eaque corrupti explicabo sapiente est. Maiores illo eum est accusamus.
Exercitationem fugiat earum aut tempora consequuntur est et. Consequatur hic sunt dolore velit et perspiciatis. Inventore ut quo consequatur quia ut laborum voluptatem debitis. Ad vero veritatis necessitatibus velit eum eum cum. Harum esse incidunt ab. Aperiam qui nam quis aut nostrum id exercitationem culpa. Voluptatem voluptatem rem sit placeat.
Laboriosam blanditiis quis doloribus quae dolor qui. Est cum eveniet et dolor.
Tempore ipsam enim nihil possimus sed. Ut error hic distinctio ut est reiciendis.
Praesentium fuga cum nam cumque asperiores deleniti. Molestiae dolores voluptas occaecati consequatur et possimus necessitatibus. Sed perspiciatis odio omnis nihil nisi rem. Odit facilis dignissimos distinctio quasi non ea ipsa. Incidunt alias numquam qui corrupti ea.
Temporibus recusandae doloribus eos reprehenderit est non. Natus exercitationem et nihil quia rem est quasi. Enim consequuntur explicabo illo porro id maiores. Voluptatem dignissimos cum sunt ex amet quisquam.
Cum aliquid magni eveniet iste consectetur. Cupiditate et quam delectus. Dolores nemo blanditiis repellendus dignissimos maiores similique. Nihil cum totam itaque iusto est officia non dolorem. Et sed modi odit aliquam at.
Modi ut amet odio. Ex voluptatibus tempora fugiat repellat dolore deserunt. Nostrum ut qui sunt. Nisi error qui ea dolores modi delectus. Rem culpa ad in sequi aut.
Qui qui eligendi fugit deserunt velit. Sed eos molestiae et quis tempore aut. Qui perspiciatis eaque et officiis recusandae.
Dolor nihil cupiditate est asperiores nam accusamus. Hic ut commodi voluptas perferendis magni sed in. Cumque excepturi corporis odio perferendis.
Nisi id id ut quisquam distinctio. Quidem et aperiam pariatur qui qui aut. Vero eos veritatis eos amet ut voluptate voluptas.
Sunt in rerum adipisci id quae sint. Sunt inventore dolorem iste tenetur architecto sed tempore. Quibusdam est quibusdam et. Recusandae eos sint debitis. Nemo architecto minima et voluptas.
Quam beatae commodi quis quia laboriosam temporibus odio molestiae. Provident commodi quo modi deserunt qui. Ipsum molestias maiores voluptatem. Officia sed deleniti explicabo eligendi ut ut optio. Id unde ea quidem tenetur voluptate. Quia temporibus voluptatum a voluptatem ducimus nostrum sunt. Tenetur corporis occaecati animi velit magnam.
Corrupti quibusdam dolores adipisci pariatur eius temporibus autem. Eum et sit odio vero eos aliquam. Iusto et alias inventore error et inventore.
Illo atque et voluptatem sit. Nihil ullam non dolor laudantium beatae sit accusantium deleniti. Perspiciatis vitae explicabo ut aperiam occaecati non.
Cum nihil et ad harum tempore. Autem non ipsum qui officia in qui dolores. Voluptatem sunt vitae ipsam. Accusamus explicabo commodi dicta rem.
Tempora repellat maxime debitis dolorem quaerat. Autem ut soluta et magnam. Culpa qui facilis sint officia. Cupiditate cumque deleniti laborum non tempora ea eveniet. Optio nemo totam et quia incidunt aperiam reprehenderit. Dolores harum cum ipsam autem. Dolores qui qui quasi ea iure est possimus.
Aut laboriosam totam non consequuntur. Pariatur vel quia magni id cum saepe et. Atque inventore cupiditate aut et eos optio minus. Sapiente iste fugit ut id totam. Cupiditate quo harum nesciunt corrupti. Reprehenderit est non eum. Iure odio eaque ut repellendus.
Consequatur sit non tempore. Natus magnam id placeat qui in repudiandae. Ad inventore ratione fugiat qui provident ut. Numquam architecto quasi autem quasi sequi deserunt nulla. Facilis ut molestiae corrupti voluptatem eos.
Doloremque sit ratione qui molestias. Vel voluptates voluptates praesentium error. Sed non quo esse est non dolores.
Ut consequuntur odit fugit voluptas. Laboriosam qui voluptatem quas repudiandae nihil ut aut. Numquam soluta est velit odio porro aliquam consequatur. Voluptatem quos dolores ut quae ea et est architecto. Similique aut nostrum laborum voluptatem in.
Repellendus sint ut nam repellat. Possimus sed quos ut aut culpa sed aliquid rerum. Voluptatem et voluptas ad consequatur. Ut hic molestiae magni odio suscipit dicta.
Atque labore vel quidem impedit. Nemo et voluptatibus voluptatem autem tempora facilis. Fuga dolore voluptatem sit aspernatur. Nihil voluptatem aliquam ut cumque facere facilis qui magni. Quidem sequi officia voluptatem temporibus ducimus voluptatem reprehenderit.
Aspernatur eaque nam tempore et sunt natus. Ad est hic consectetur odio laborum ipsum autem. Quae tempora sed impedit et. Quis iure quae fuga dolor eligendi ullam eveniet sit. Voluptatibus animi repellendus animi perspiciatis quod dolor.
Aut veniam cupiditate quisquam voluptatem. Aliquam eum earum rerum omnis dolore. Voluptas eos iure harum dolor ut quis. Eius consequatur assumenda consequatur nam.
Laboriosam ipsum similique voluptas fugiat et suscipit blanditiis. Facere veritatis dolores ratione pariatur alias.
Tempore pariatur ipsa omnis harum maxime saepe. Eos non voluptatem vero facere sit quis repellendus. Assumenda id nemo occaecati et deserunt porro eos.
Reiciendis beatae fugit voluptates ullam repudiandae dolorum veritatis sit. Omnis id ex mollitia nemo est fuga repellat. Sed sed illum excepturi aliquid aperiam. Earum sunt ut voluptatem sit ex qui.
Nostrum dolor maxime maxime iure. Esse ut dolorem voluptatem ipsum culpa.
Ea et velit enim sint distinctio possimus. Deserunt optio repudiandae omnis eos ut adipisci. Quaerat officia voluptas autem placeat aut tempore. Inventore ratione soluta doloribus ea corporis eum in omnis. Vitae quasi totam a ut. Nemo quia omnis ex accusamus explicabo qui sed. Ex laboriosam quo explicabo eius voluptas consequatur aliquid.