Citi M&A vs. GS/MS/JPM
I summered in a BB coverage group as a sophomore and received a return offer for next summer. While the fit was good, it was a mediocre experience and I'd like to explore other opportunities. That said, I have another offer with Citi M&A that seems great. I've networked with the group extensively and think I'd perform well. Does anyone know how the group stacks up against coverage groups at MS, GS, or JPM? I'm in talks with all three firms, but I don't think I have the leverage to get MS M&A or GS TMT/FIG. Any input is appreciated.
Citigroup is coming stronger and better after several years of mediocre performance (08-11). In announced Global M&A deals is 3rd as of October 2014, FICC S&T 2nd after JPM, ECM US 1st, FX S&T 1st beating DB so far this year. If you have a Bloomberg terminal in your school you can check the rankings out. Only problem is their building is pretty old :s hahaah http://cdn1.valuewalk.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Regional-MA.jpg
Good Luck
I'd say pretty much all coverage groups at GS are better, they don't really have any weak ones. That's an incredible internship for a sophomore, so you're definitely in a good position to leverage that.
I'd echo taquito. You can see for yourself: http://fn.dealogic.com/fn/MARank.htm.
Citi M&A has incredible momentum, and I'd take it over most of the bottom tier coverage groups at GS/MS/JPM. This year, it's been second to only MS M&A, and GS doesn't have a dedicated M&A execution group.
That being said, I think the following groups might be traditionally stronger: GS TMT/FIG/CRGH, MS M&A, Sponsors, Media&Comm, JPM M&A, Sponsors
Citi is killing it this year. But again, past performance is not indicative of future deals.
Since when has ytd league table rankings been the way to pick a job?
I would go with Citi M & A over any coverage group at GS barring TMT/FIG/CRGH. M & A is also one if not the top group at Citi so seems like a no brainer to me to go with Citi M & A.
are you kidding
Clearly, GS TMT/FIG/CRGH are above Citi M & A in terms of prestige and exit opportunities from what I can remember from my time in IB. Having said that I still feel Citi M & A triumphs the slightly inferior GS coverage groups such as Industrials or Nat. Resources in terms of exit opportunities and prestige. Things may have changed over time since I am not in IB anymore. M & A is also a broader skill set and hence, I have a personal preference for M & A. I still standby what I said above.
If your goal is the buyside (probably a pretty safe assumption), I'd take pretty much any GS coverage group over Citi M&A and a decent amount of MS/JPM groups over Citi M&A as well. Sure Citi has killed it in the league tables but that's almost entirely irrelevant in the context of buyside recruiting.
I'm at one of these banks so I'll weigh in. I always like to caution you kiddos on here - a lot of posts like this are a matter of personal opinion and are by no means definitive. Now that that caveat is out of the way, groups I would take at GS/MS/JPM over Citi M&A:
GS: All except NatRes (Others will disagree with me here, this one is more personal preference), Real Estate, SSG MS: M&A, Sponsors, Media & Comm., Power/Utilities, Tech (Menlo) JPM: M&A, Sponsors, LevFin, Healthcare, FIG, TMT
@"thatsWACC" I know this is unrelated to the question you asked, but I am a sophomore and very interested in Citi. Would you mind sharing how you attained an SA spot as a sophomore?
I would appreciate it, thanks.
Look at top PE firms and you can actually see the Inv. professional backgrounds. Yes a lot of them come from GS, MS but there are still a lot of people from Citi, CS etc etc etc.... Trust me if you will be working 90 hours a week on average make sure you like the people - there is nothing worse than being stuck and working with an asshole that changes his mind every 10 minutes.
One more comment, I disagree with the guy who said the rankings are not important. Working on live deals is where you get to learn the most. Creating pitch books that nobody looks at, wont give you the same exposure and learning experience as a live deal. Whats the point of going to a bank that has great reputation but you are not getting any live deals..... Its all about exposure.
When you are working on live deals you will be able to work with professionals from other banks, vp's, md's from other groups at your bank... I know several analysts who got their HF/PE positions by knowing a vp or md they worked with, travelled, assisted on a live deal. Many of these MD's go to these large PE/HF/BB and usually bring people they trust with them..
just my opinion....
Ultimately any offer you take either Citi/GS/CS/DB/ms etc etc etc all are great banks, and you create your own opportunities. Don't think just because you are in ms m&a you are set for life. Try to enjoy what you do and the people around you.
actually for buyside placement, being in MS M&A will essentially set you up for life. I have a personal friend in that group and trust me, the love he gets from headhunters is crazy. I'm guessing it's similar for other groups at GS/BX M&A/R&R as well.
Sure megafund placement is still up in the air since they take so little to begin with but the opportunities will be laid out for you if you are in MS M&A. Trying to get into PE (not just megafunds but all varieties) from MS M&A is the equivalent of aiming for an IB job from Wharton - it's pretty much guaranteed as long as you put in some effort. With that said they get worked HARD so be warned.
How did this thread become about MS M&A? Take any group at GS/JPM/MS over Citi. Bank name trumps group 100% of the time.
I will go with GS/JPM/MS over Citi but the most relevant things in my opinion are the culture and the people. If you fit well and people like you, you will have a better experience, like the job and perform better. If you perform well, senior people will try to have you on their live deal and this will give you higher exposure and higher ranking. Higher ranking and exposure will give you more flexibility both in the firm and outside the firm. If you end up working with people you don't like it gets very difficult to suck it up fore more than 2 years and you will not be able to deliver.
People are way too focused on deal experience here. Once you get out of college you realize that buyside recruiting starts 6 months after you start at your desk (so most likely before you announce a deal no matter what firm you are in) and headhunters basically use prestige of name and school to decide who gets interviews. GS will no deal experience trumps Citi M&A with several closed deals if your end goal is to get a good PE or HF job
I was under the impression that GS doesn't even have product groups anyways, and that it's all handled by coverage groups.
Just to chime in, from a recruiting perspective, GS is still usually preferred over non M&A MS. Citi M&A has amazing placement (TPG and Oaktree, etc.)
However, I'd take most GS groups over Citi M&A. Citi M&A over non M&A MS. Citi M&A over non M&A MS JPM.
Also to speak generally, most firms still prefer MS over JPM. The closer lumping is more like GS/MS but that's just my opinion from what I've seen.
totally agree with you!
This!
My opinion.
Would accept almost any group from either GS/MS over Citi M&A. Not a bash -- great experience at Citi. But for recruiting brand name trumps deal experience -- I realize that doesn't make sense and is the wrong way to run things, but it is the reality.
Excepturi excepturi omnis fuga ut. Sed modi qui quam enim et animi quis. Consequatur voluptate dolorum inventore et quia voluptatem dolor. Nulla nobis accusamus minus ipsa repellendus exercitationem animi. Aut est iure consequuntur soluta fuga dolor.
Nobis corporis veritatis rerum eaque et. Est et repellat et et reiciendis sit. Corrupti accusantium sapiente accusamus. Rerum ullam commodi est consequatur possimus sint. Praesentium eum aperiam debitis quo. Placeat et delectus perferendis sint explicabo veniam mollitia.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Non alias fugiat nostrum tenetur perferendis dicta ut. Error ex neque sit et. Aut perferendis atque voluptates consequatur beatae similique aperiam. Earum enim autem vel itaque porro.
Eligendi perspiciatis unde et tempora. Debitis repudiandae reiciendis asperiores quis enim quis. Voluptas quas sit recusandae id quia totam dolores tempora. Doloribus in nobis cupiditate illo odio qui. Odio hic omnis tenetur vel.
Natus necessitatibus totam tempora doloribus quia. Quis iure qui soluta eligendi nostrum. Eaque sed aut molestiae et ipsum suscipit. Veniam expedita ut dolorem vel possimus nostrum praesentium. Consequatur culpa est voluptas vero quo laboriosam suscipit.