Craziest Counter Offer You've Ever Extended?

babybaboon's picture
babybaboon - Certified Professional
Rank: Gorilla | banana points 725

Like the subject line, what is the craziest counter off you returned to a company after being extended one? Did they accept? Could be $, bonus, other benefits...

Consulting Case Interview Course

  • 2,037 questions across 209 consulting firms. Crowdsourced from over 600,000 members.
  • 11 Detailed Exclusive Cases developed by a McKinsey Associate and 10+ hours of video.
  • Trusted by over 1,000 aspiring consultants just like you.

Comments (4)

Most Helpful
Aug 8, 2018

This is regarding residential so it's probably not what you're looking for. But it's still funny nonetheless.
Price: best and final, don't even bother if you're not offering over asking price
Terms: my clients need infinite time to find their replacement home, meanwhile you cannot cancel the contract on the basis of finding something else
DD: 7 days to complete all inspections and due diligence, 17 days to get full loan approval, buyers must waive appraisal contingency
Misc: buyers to pay for all termite inspection AND repairs, my client's concession capped at $200 (no, I didn't miss a 0)

We had 14 offers on this property within 3 days. Got someone to accept all those terms and offer $52,000 over. Closed it up.

Little rant: clients still weren't completely happy. I got them a new car in terms of how much the buyers paid vs what my clients expected. I cant think of a worse counter offer to submit to buyers. Some people will never be happy.

    • 3
Aug 8, 2018

Apologies on the OP, it wasn't super clear. Was asking in terms of an offer a company has extended you for employment at their firm.

This is funny nonetheless.

Aug 8, 2018

I interviewed with a non-profit home-builder about a year ago for Director of Development. I knew they were looking in that $125-140,000 range. The interview went really well and they asked me toward the end what my salary expectations were--I said $200,000. You could almost see the blood drain from their face--I half expected them to call security. Suffice it to say a hard offer never came.

My reasoning was fourfold--I'd have to increase my hours worked from 40 presently to 60-80; the job was slightly out of my expertise level so I wasn't 100% sure I'd be successful and might end up fired; every new job comes with it risk that you won't like the job or your boss or that your boss won't like you; and the commute into the city suuuucks--I f*cking hate D.C. area public transportation. (As an aside, leave it to a non-profit to set up shop in a hyper-expensive office building in downtown D.C., paying $70 psf for the privilege. I definitely found that to be a bit offensive.)

Aug 9, 2018