Do Startup Tech Companies Have Too Much Power?
With the recent Airbnb lawsuit with the city of New York, AirBnb is really throwing their weight around. Airbnb is looking to deregulate the house-sharing industry in the city, as NYC has recently implemented a new law that would require homeowners to be verified with the city prior to listing on the app.
This Isn't The First Time
Airbnb sued the city of San Francisco over the EXACT SAME LAW claiming that the new regulation put in by the city, requiring Airbnb to verify that their hosts have been registered with the city, was unconstitutional.
Nothing came of the lawsuit, with Airbnb settling but ultimately accepting SF's legislation. Interestingly however, Airbnb rentals in SF fell off a cliff during the duration of their lawsuit. I'm not sure if those are related.
Nor Are They The Only One
Uber successfully squashed a class action lawsuit in Ontario, Canada, where the plaintiffs, Uber drivers, were looking for employee status so they could be covered under the Ontario Employment Standards Act.
Uber has been having a lot of issues with its acceptance in large cities, namely Toronto, where complaints of increased traffic congestion are growing. Taxi drivers are protesting, public transport groups are lobbying government, and Uber is generally just finding it difficult to combat the old-fashioned industry. Granted they are doing amazing in terms of user growth, their perception amongst the rest of the industry is overwhelmingly negative. A trend that we are seeing in several of these revolutionary startup ideas.
A Unique Business Model That Governments Aren't Ready For
A private taxi company which doesn't own a single vehicle? Done.
A global accommodation platform that doesn't own a single sq. ft of real estate? Done.
A food delivery platform that doesn't cook a single meal? Done.
Clearly the times they are a-changing, with companies like Airbnb, Uber, and Grubhub, taking their respective industries and turning them on their heads. As companies of this sort start increasing in size, we are witnessing their growing pains, and their competitors trying to force them out. The legislation, competition, and infrastructure, all need to adapt quick with these technological advancements. I've never been a fan of governments regulating where they don't need to, and I believe both the Airbnb and Uber situations are examples of that. If these companies were left to their own devices, and new innovation was encouraged amongst others, we would be seeing a revolution in the dinosaurs that are their respective industries.
Should someone be strapping ankle chains on these innovative companies?
I haven't really thought of something like Uber or AirBnB, and not to hijack this thread, but this is certainly the case with a social media platform like Facebook, Twitter, etc. Naturally limiting hate speech is good, but it's dangerous for for these large firms to ultimately become the arbiters of what becomes free speech.
It's because we aren't talking about the absolute size of these entities for some reason. Everyone is just all "Woo, Apple and Amazon touched a trillion!" Apple, last I checked, has more CASH on hand than most of the GDPs of the countries in the world. Apple has more CASH on hand than the GDPs of Egypt, Portugal, New Zealand, etc. They are in your home and they collect data on everything you possibly do in order to sell it back to you or to someone else. They are at mind-boggling size..
Private companies (in the sense that they are not govt. owned) can do whatever they want. The first amendment is about the government stifling free speech. If Facebook wants to ban every single user/ news website that leans conservative (or vice versa) then they can do so, it's their product and they are allowed to manage it as they see fit. Maybe you should worry about the morons out there that believe whatever they read on FB. I am about sick of the outcry for government intervention, it's the opposite of what makes this country great.
Edit: Now if the government wants to restrict their collection of user data as a violation of privacy laws that is a different story. But they don't really want that, they want access to that data so they can provide it to the NSA for their illegal surveillance which was authorized by the unconstitutional patriot act.
I do, I'm just saying that there's usually less accountability with a company's practices than holding a congressman/govt department to account, but neither is particularly easy to do. I guess I'm more worried about people increasingly using it as their sole information source and not reading a newspaper or more than one news source.
You must be a leftist looking to take my lucky charms and cocoa puffs because you brought up the obvious fact that start-ups have a lot of questionable power.
I'm curious to see when companies like Amazon and Google will be broken up. The data they have creates an unbeatable feedback loop for the product development side that nobody can really compete against.
Because of the average age of a meaningful government official (Senate/House/Judiciary/Executive/Etc, I don't see how it could be anytime soon. They likely don't understand it/care to learn about it as they didn't grow up with it. Also, the older you are, the more likely you are to vote. Their older constituents aren't going to make a stink about it so why target profit centers that make the economy look good on an issue that won't get them reelected?
Correct.* "What's a Facebook?" *
When can we stop calling massive multi billion dollar companies startups?
When they start making some profit.
Cumque est sequi ut id voluptatem facere perspiciatis. Architecto debitis et reprehenderit voluptates. Quo consequuntur hic magni id rerum. Debitis neque quos accusamus repudiandae facere velit. Aperiam laborum qui et laborum assumenda. Molestiae porro reprehenderit neque explicabo quos sed.
Qui ut alias quia tempore. Culpa iusto commodi fugiat. Ipsa vero maiores delectus ipsa excepturi et animi.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...