Banking Scene in Asia - what's the future?

I've been following league tables in Asia for a while, and it seems that they have become increasingly dominated by Chinese banks (not just CICC and Citic, but also places like GF Securities, Haitong securities). This has been true for ECM and DCM for a while, but it seems that in recent years this effect has been seeping into advisory/M&A as well.

What does this mean for all the BBs in Asia? (we already know Barclays is out, DB probably likely to follow). The banking scene in Asia in general? What's the landscape going to be like 5-10 years down the road? Which banks/BBs are best positioned to be the king of Asia in the long run?

Any discussion is welcomed.

 
Best Response

A tedious and pedantic comment from me - Asia is a diverse place and not one banking market. Japan is largely a segregated market, as is Korea. You could broadly classify China + Singapore + Hong Kong as the China-facing market, with Hong Kong and Singapore also serving as regional hubs for teams working into Southeast Asia. India is a separate market itself, serviced mainly from IB branches based in India, some out of Singapore. Then you have the Middle East, which is mainly covered out of Dubai and Abu Dhabi. I'm not sure who covers the 'stans - likely the same as the Middle East.

Each of these markets has its own dynamics.

(edit) You can also break the China market down between the entirely internal Chinese market (driven out of Shanghai, Beijing, HK to a lesser extent, some presence in Shenzhen) and the China outward facing market. The latter is mainly run through Hong Kong, with Shanghai occasionally making noises about linking into the international market.

In the golden years between around 2006 - 2010, when it was all about China IPOs and thick, chunky rivers of money were constantly streaming through Hong Kong, Hong Kong was a great place to be. I was working in IPO-centered IB and I doubt I will ever get all-in comp in my life that will match what I made each year during those halcyon days, either on a pre- or post-tax basis.

Those were magical days and we shall not see their likes again, at least in China-based banking. (/edit)

[/pedantry]

Those who can, do. Those who can't, post threads about how to do it on WSO.
 

Yes, I understand that Asia is a broad term.

I was mostly asking about HK/China focused banking, and how the local Chinese players will change the game (since LTs already clearly show that the days when BBs dominated are over).

I guess my main question boils down to this: what's special about the BBs that will make them survive as local Chinese players become more sophisticated? If the locals charge a lower fee and deliver services that are just as good as the BBs, what's the incentive to go to a BB? And which BB has the best business in Asia right now?

 

One big theme now is cross-border M&A (but it's overwhelmingly unilateral--Chinese companies scooping up assets overseas). As the political situation getting more unclear and economy faltering, rich people (and rich firms) are pulling all kinds of stunts to put their money overseas. Besides shops like CITIC and CICC, the boutiques (financial advisors) that have international background or management team are stacking papers.

Within the mainland, CICC is in decline since MS pulled out and their chief economist left for CITIC and the good old days when they were the only bankers who speak English are gone. Now boutiques (like China Renaissance) and american/HK advisory shops are cutting a huge share of the cross-border business. Don't get me wrong, they are still a top shop, especially in terms of entry-level compensations, training and exit ops, but they are not as glamorous as they used to be.

CITIC's edge over CICC is their retail brokerage service. In china, investment banks provide services for retail mom and pop investors, they have branches (like your neighborhood Wells Fargo) where people trade their retail shares and open their equity investment accounts. Some branches gets so big that they became the contact point for bigger clients, like IB clients and big corporates. But there's a very clear distinction if you've been to both CITIC and CICC's offices, with the CITIC a lot less "westernized", more bureaucracy, less structured training and stuff.

If the current trend continues, American/ European banks are not going to do well, period. The government just doesn't like them. If they want to sound like they are becoming more open minded, they are going to give the business to HK firms (HSBC and etc.).

Local firms who are smart enough to put focus on TMT and healthcare are getting the payoff now. GF securities, Huatai Securities and several others are now growing dramatically.

Just my random input.

 

pay is the same. bonuses may differ depending on performance of group/region. as far as i know, hours are the same as new york.

to work at a BB in Tokyo, you need to be a native speaker of japanese and business level in English (IBD). i can't imagine anyone getting hired in Tokyo as an analyst without being fluent in Japanese.

Hong Kong and Non-Japan Asia--work is done primarily in English so I'm not sure how necessary it is to speak an Asian language. obviously an advantage if you were being placed into a country coverage group.

if you're interested in ibanking in Tokyo, check out www.careerforum.net.

 

you can easily get a job in sales & trading in japan without speaking any japanese. for pure banking, though, you have to not only be fluent but native, and understand all the cultural nuances, etc. but you can definitely get jobs selling japanese bonds to non-japanese investors, and make big, big money, with an expat package that includes housing and a daily stipend. I know, b/c I did it, and there were tons of westerners there who didn't speak any Japanese. Great gig.

 

probably can't do it as an analyst, but definitely as an associate, as long as you've done great work and can offer something to justify it. there's a huge demand for english speakers who can reel in investors from the UK, Australia, and North America, and at the same time a lot of experienced people don't want to drop everything and live in a far off country away from their family, etc. so as an associate, i think you could do it.

 

League Table credits can be misleading because many times pure Chinese firms tag along on big deals as silent joint bookrunners and take no fees for deal credits. Clients usually insist that a couple of China banks get included on mandates because of senior relationship and quid pro quo for cheap loans. HSBC and StanChart dominate capital markets deals, but their fees are really small compared to the norm in the US/Europe. But when it comes to high-fee, complex deals that span cross-border and actually make money for the firm, traditional strongholds like GS/MS/JPM/ML/UBS take the crown.

Ugh the FBI still quotes the Dow... -Matt Levine
 

A few key things you should prepare going into the process:

  1. Know why you want to do banking. What's your purpose, interests and goals in doing i-banking? Also, why Hong Kong and not NY?

  2. Have a good understanding of the technical stuff such as valuation and general financial concepts.

  3. Have a few good reasons why you want to work for the firm you are applying to.

 

From what several of my friends in Asia tell me:

  • Chinese investment banks are slowly dominating most Asia Pacific investment banking activity. Previously (2006 - 2011) US/EU investment banks were the key gatekeepers to the capital markets but that's no longer the case - Chinese IBs (CITIC, Guotai, CICC, GF and a bunch of others) are dominating the space, even the ECM area where traditionally US/EU IBs were the main service providers. You can verify this by looking at ECM/DCM league tables where you can barely see any US/EU banks. Can't pinpoint the exact reason - some say it's cuz the Chinese gov wants domestic banks to rise to the intl platform, but regardless such is the case.

  • Wealth Management is where it's at for Asia. UBS/Citi/CS (the top 3 WM players in Asia) are all investing heavily into the WM space. Heard competition is absolutely insane there but given the growth of millionaires & wealth in Asia, WM is hands down definitely where it's at for Asia.

  • US/EU IBs still come into play for Cross-Border M&A, but keep in mind that's usually far few and between. 2016 is an exception with a flurry of Cross Border deals (ChemChina/Syngenta, KraussMaffei, the dropped deal with Marriott/Starwood and etc.) but that is more an anomaly than the norm.

  • Several guessed that in the long term, only the top 3-4 BBs will be profitable and thrive in Asia, with the bulk of Chinese IB deal flow going to Chinese IBs, and US/EU banks only tapped for the occasional cross-border M&A advice (or if it's a large company, for an IPO in a Western exchange).

Keep in mind this is strictly only for IB activity - other financial services just as cash management, transaction services, treasury services etc (aka. the stuff that Citibank dominates and is best known for) will continue to thrive and be profitable.

Array
 

You don't want to work in Asia... in NY, if I was lucky, I could leave the office before midnight most of the time, and, if I wasn't lucky, I could walk in the next morning at 11:00am and no one would say a word. In Asia, it is commonplace to work until 4:30 every night, and you're still expected to be in at 9 on the dot the next morning. (Guess where I am now? Guess what time it is now?)

 

My best advice for you is to make sure that you speak English like a native speaker. What struck me the most about SA hiring in Asia was that they almost exclusivley hired people who spoke English as if it was their mother tongue (with very few exceptions). Naturally, most of the people hired for SA positions were kids from Asia going to school in the US....so you already have that. I know people get annoyed when the topic of speaking fluent English is brought up, but from what I can tell it is definitley a deciding factor. Your Master is two years, right? So just apply for SA for next summer and specify you want to work in China or HK.

Regarding b2's comment....he is definitley right about the hours. Some people really seem to live in the office.

 

for housing allowance..around 15K HKD - 20K HKD per month, but rumor has it that some banks will cut it. for meal allowance, it's 150HKD -200HKD per night...so yea, HK IBD earns much more than the ones in NYC..esp tax rate in HK is 10 percent compare to 35%+ in NYC.

 

3.4 from non target - getting into top MM -- good luck! If I were you, spend your efforts on boutique banks that specialize in cross-boarder transactions (with the majority flowing from China to US/vice versa)

 

Et aliquid est sed nemo minima voluptatibus. Accusantium sint eligendi earum veritatis. Voluptatum velit non modi voluptates eligendi quia aliquam quis.

Quis fugit omnis iure quas et quibusdam. Ex porro occaecati eaque eum unde sequi qui neque. Quo fuga harum quaerat pariatur ut repudiandae.

Aut enim ipsum dicta enim qui magni. Aperiam nostrum dignissimos illum. Vero quam ex magni sit deleniti odio. Voluptate et sit ab consequatur.

Perspiciatis voluptatem id alias fugit. Voluptatem blanditiis at quisquam corrupti pariatur atque. Quae dolores dolor fugit et vero non.

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.
 

Sint dignissimos corrupti molestiae sed. Sunt cum nisi et est architecto qui. Sit adipisci iure totam ipsa rerum dolores. Vitae iure at tempore.

Iure reprehenderit expedita placeat est quod aut. Et et tempore repellendus eos non. Velit natus quo vero soluta enim quia. Sit magnam doloremque sit cum illum repellat ipsam. Temporibus molestiae unde accusamus.

Labore unde aspernatur sunt molestias eveniet. Blanditiis veniam officia iure ex assumenda qui. Nihil et tenetur fuga dolorem quibusdam aliquid velit. Vel iste facere dolor velit. Quis sit nemo alias eos doloribus vel dolorem. Nihil omnis sunt autem molestiae. Veniam rem cum sint facere tempore.

Et consectetur in facilis. Id qui accusantium omnis nesciunt. Tenetur libero voluptatem sed accusamus enim quia. Dolor doloremque ex exercitationem fugiat error dolorum distinctio. Ut odit cupiditate architecto porro nihil deleniti adipisci eveniet.

 

Consequatur eos rerum voluptatem non voluptatum assumenda est porro. Ut atque repudiandae totam occaecati. Voluptas vitae minima veritatis consequatur laboriosam.

Quasi voluptate aperiam esse consequatur doloremque nulla dignissimos. Eos qui quia blanditiis fugiat iste laboriosam consectetur. Eum consectetur atque quaerat omnis nostrum numquam aperiam ipsa. Enim adipisci et eveniet facilis.

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. (++) 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (202) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (144) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
6
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
7
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
10
numi's picture
numi
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”