How much does pre-MBA work experience affect post-MBA employment opportunities?

Rank: Monkey | 62

I'm wondering how much pre-MBA work experience affects post-MBA employment opportunities. For example, do the majority of those who get management consulting jobs post-MBA already have consulting experience? What about those who get IB associate gigs? Were most of them ibankers before they went to b-school?

So what I really want to know is if I don't have relevant work experience prior to getting my MBA, do I still have a good shot at getting an IB or management consulting job post-grad?

Comments (32)

 
Jan 31,2013

Prior experience always helps but the 2 careers you mentioned are two that quite commonly hire direct from top MBA programs without previous experience. Many people go to b-school to switch careers into I-Banking or consulting. If you want something more specialized like PE or VC without prior experience you are probably out of luck. But if you want to be an IBD Associate they have roles specifically for new hires direct from school.

Free Consultation

Vantage Point MBA's clients are accepted to the top MBA programs at a 3x higher rate than the average acceptance rates. Request a consultation with their team to learn how they can help you gain admission to your dream schools. Learn more.

 
Jan 31,2013

Most IB associates do not have pre-MBA IB experience.

MM IB -> TMT Corporate Development

 
Feb 28,2013
SECfinance:

Most IB associates do not have pre-MBA IB experience.

Does this change thier role/responsibilities compared to those MBA who did come from IB pre-MBA?

 
Feb 28,2013
Cmoss:
SECfinance:

Most IB associates do not have pre-MBA IB experience.

Does this change thier role/responsibilities compared to those MBA who did come from IB pre-MBA?

Do they do different work than people with pre-MBA IB experience? No.

MM IB -> TMT Corporate Development

 
Jan 31,2013

Pre-MBA work experience largely determines where you do your MBA. Where you do your MBA largely determines what options you will have.

 
 
Feb 28,2013

No, it doesn't make a difference. I know first-years at my school with interviews at the top firms from all walks of life.

 
Feb 28,2013

Keep in mind that the "advice" you get on this board is often times coming from high schoolers and college kids who have no relevant experience to what you are asking, and use the "I know a guy" analogy to support baseless claims.

Obviously the job you have before business school impacts recruiting. You are competing for the same jobs not only against people from your school, but other MBAs (even some from presumably higher ranked schools). You need to put yourself in the best possible position. Suck it up and put in a little more effort for the few months you have left before you start bschool.

 
Feb 28,2013

How likely are you to get promoted if your employer probably knows that you'll be leaving? If there's a real chance of being promoted, I'd go for it.

NB I don't have an MBA.

 
Feb 28,2013

I'd say take the promotion and work for three months. You're about to go on a 2-year sabbatical from work with ample time to do anything you please. You'll likely regret not taking it once recruiting kicks off.

CompBanker

Free Consultation

Vantage Point MBA's clients are accepted to the top MBA programs at a 3x higher rate than the average acceptance rates. Request a consultation with their team to learn how they can help you gain admission to your dream schools. Learn more.

 
Feb 28,2013

Ib and consulting are fine. PE and other buy side gigs will require per MBA experience

 
Jul 31,2017

I am a Strategy Consulting Manager that did not have consulting experience (or a 700!) before I went for my MBA. It's absolutely doable. The one piece that i'd provide caution on is how you use your interest in pursuing consulting in your MBA application story - it's not a real differentiator in the application process. I worked with an admissions consultant (springboard admissions but there are tons out there) to help me turn my interest in pursing consulting into a compelling story for admissions. She also helped me after I was admitted to start up my networking game with MBB (for freeeee).

All in all, this is doable... but I also had help that I found pretty valuable.

 
Feb 28,2013

For either MC or IB, if the banks and the consulting firms come to your school, then recruiting is a structured game - just talk to 2nd year students and the placement office. No pre-MBA experience required for either to the best of my knowledge.

 
Jul 31,2017

<3 year isn't too helpful with recruiting in a pool of 5 years pre-mba average. Job details in reality don't matter unless your school isn't a serious recruiting target

M7 MBA, iBanking. Top MSF grad. AntiTNA. Truth is hard to hear! But... :
DickFuld: Yeah....most of these people give terrible advice.:
 
 
Jul 31,2017

Congratulations on the M7 school! I can't speak for MBA job postings, but in general, the years of experience are just guidelines, definitely not set in stone.

 
Jul 31,2017

Exactly right. "Minimum" usually means "ideal" in the recruiter's eyes. For reference: the job I have right now said minimum 2-3 yr exp to be considered and I had zero when I applied.

 
 
Jul 31,2017

Also interested in this. Was wondering the likelihood of breaking into VC if you come from a non-banking background pre-mba and was recruiting out of a top 3 bschool. For example, let's say you worked in tech at a VC portfolio company, or came from a renewable energy background as a solar asset developer.

 
Jul 31,2017

It's an interesting path to VC. VC is definitely an art not a science and also very small and tight nit. A solid start up track record and a pedigree/background that could've easily gotten you into banking or consulting is the really the only "sure fire" way. The best VC's are really good at making things and/or selling them or at least identifying people who can.

I've tried to lock down an answer on this and no one will give a straight answer inside the industry. So I guess my guess is as good as the next guy.

Ace all your PE interview questions with the WSO Private Equity Prep Pack: http://www.wallstreetoasis.com/guide/private-equit...

 
Jul 31,2017

VC is a bitch to get into sometimes. I tend to think finance skills are less important as compared to XYZ skills depending on the shop. I managed to talk to a partner at a decent sized VC shop in Philly and he wasn't feeling my all finance background. If I was a premed student who did something random after UG I probably would have been more interesting.

 
Jul 31,2017

Here's the best post I've seen on entry level VC positions.

http://www.adventurista.com/2008/04/vc-pre-mba-hir...

Ace all your PE interview questions with the WSO Private Equity Prep Pack: http://www.wallstreetoasis.com/guide/private-equit...

 
Jul 31,2017

thanks for the input guys. my question is more related to which would make a more "qualified" post-mba vc out of the following two:
1) 2 years banking, 2 years pre-mba vc (essentially two junior level jobs), or
2) 4 years banking (i.e. getting promoted, having some management skills and more client interaction, etc)
of course i am assuming that the business school for both paths is the same.

based on the comments, it sounds like vc's look for a little more well-rounded experience for their post-mba roles, but just wanted to confirm (anywhere i can find numbers to back this up?)

thanks again!

 
Jul 31,2017
nodiggity:

thanks for the input guys. my question is more related to which would make a more "qualified" post-mba vc out of the following two:
1) 2 years banking, 2 years pre-mba vc (essentially two junior level jobs), or
2) 4 years banking (i.e. getting promoted, having some management skills and more client interaction, etc)
of course i am assuming that the business school for both paths is the same.

based on the comments, it sounds like vc's look for a little more well-rounded experience for their post-mba roles, but just wanted to confirm (anywhere i can find numbers to back this up?)

thanks again!

Pre-mba VC experience will UNQUESTIONABLY give you a better shot at post-mba positions than 4 years in banking will. I'd also say it isn't true that VCs like more well-rounded backgrounds. They all want something a little bit different in their associates, and even the same firm can want something different across different hires.

With that said, the one universal thing that will help you with VC recruiting is having a network. That is huge, and you will build that up in a big way as a pre-mba associate. That, and if you only have banking experience + mba, your chances will be very very slim. Even though they all want something different, that is very rarely a background that is desirable. Keep in mind that I'm not endorsing pre-mba associate path as the best way to break into VC post-mba, but between these two options it really isn't close.

 
Jul 31,2017

near impossible to get into partner-track post MBA position in VC these days. your best bet is to do banking, MBA, then PE....VC industry is rapidly contracting if you haven't heard...

 
Jul 31,2017

Some of the comments on thread have been quite insightful. Could I have a shot at a good VC firm in few years with the following path: MBA from NYC focused schools like CBS/Stern and then 2-3 years in Investment Banking (something like technology group). Maybe also do internships at NYC based startups while at school. Could this open up VC options if network well? Thanks.