How soon can one switch jobs?

I graduated this past May and started work. I realize my current HF job is definitely not what I want to do. It's been just over 5 weeks since I started. How soon is it acceptable to reach out to other firms and try to find a different job?

What's the best move for me to try? Should I reach out to investment banks now since this is the start of recruitment season for them? Do they look at recent graduates?

For context, I graduated from a top Ivy and my HF works in a very specific niche.

 

Not in the OP's situation, but does the one year guidance also apply when you're going back to school? Considering starting graduate studies a month or two before meeting the one year mark in my role (though might stay on part time at my firm), and it seems like a bit of a waste to put off the degree by another year just to make some threshold.

 

If you are going back to school then the 1 year rule doesn't necessarily apply, of course 1 year is still better but its not a big deal. You got into the school so you should go, people understand that. I agree, it would be silly to wait for the next school year just to be at your firm for a year.

However, working for a year before grad school would definitely help with recruiting after. You will have more legitimacy over people who just had 3 month internships for example.

 

I left my first gig after 7 months to go back to school. Why wait any amount of time once you know that pursuing another degree is your next step. I took the extra months to go travel. IMO, no one cares when/why you left a job go back to school and most wouldn't even give it a second thought

 

I'm in this situation. I have been at my boutique for about 10 months now and am getting ready to lateral. It sucks but it can be worth it. If you can get another job before a year, then by all means do it. The year rule goes both ways, its expected from your current employer and from the hiring company. Why would they hire someone who just started another job and is already trying to leave after 5 weeks? From their view, you could do the same thing to them. Its a risk on their end and they probably won't give you an offer unless you have a really good story to back it up. So by all means you should try and change jobs starting now, but just be prepared if you get rejected/questioned a lot about why you are leaving so soon.

 

Ignore the posts giving you a bright line rule like "one year" - 365 days at a job isn't exactly a long tenure anyway.

People understand that you're young with evolving interests and opportunities. The important thing is to make sure you (1) are making the best decision, (2) can actually explain why your moves make sense in a future interview and (3) avoid making too many moves too soon. Weigh the costs and benefits of switching early and do what is in your best interest.

Just note that your issue isn't just deciding whether or not to make a switch. before you even have that opportunity, you'll need to come up with a good explanation that makes your future employer comfortable you won't ditch them soon too.

 
Best Response

In this case I actually disagree with most of the advice to stick around for a year. Life is short, and if this job isn't a fit then find something else. I think you just admit to the next employer that you made a mistake. You got into the job, and it wasn't at all what you were expecting. I think most people should get that.

 

What if an offer letter to join Goldman TMT as an analyst magically appears in his inbox? Still 18 months?

All things being equal, switching jobs isn't good. But even 6 months is too long if you have a better opportunity available. it's a cost benefit analysis.

In general I think bright line rule here would be stupid and you should view things on a case by case basis

 

Anything less than a year looks bad. Two years is probably ideal unless you just really hate what you are doing. It's more common for people to move around nowadays than in the past. Advice from my old man, seasoned banking professional - risk mgmt, is two years minimum looks better than one.

 

At my old firm which supposedly encouraged mobility suggested that someone stay on 2 years (or at least 1 year) before the move. Having said that, it takes time for positions to open up, so starting to network internally soon and allowing different people to know you: 1) exist, 2) have a relevant background and skillsets from prior internships and 3) interested in open positions with them, would be a good start.

I would wait a bit since 6 months is not that long, but if its fairly obvious the future looks bleak for your current group, I think people will understand why you're looking. Just make sure you have a good story to support your long-term interests or fit for IB, otherwise it comes off as you seeking 'any port in a storm'.

 

I'd be hard pressed to hire someone with less than a year at their last stop, but maybe that's just me.

Two things: first, when layoff time comes, the guys that joined most recently tend to get picked off first, they just don't have the relationships/loyalty/history to protect them.

Secondly, bonuses tend to get announced in December and paid in January. I'd start chatting guys up and letteing them know that you're potentially a guy on the move in November/December, and tracking where bodies are dropping in January.

 

alright, thanks...one issue is that my only experience on my resume that is somewhat like IBD is my internship in distressed debt, but this was way back in fall 2010 before my main junior summer internship....after that all my work experience has been in markets/trading....I do have a story and all for why I want to move to IBD, but if someone judges me purely based on my resume, they will not see any IBD experience for the past year and a half atleast....I am more than willing to restart as a 1st year in IBD and go through the training program etc, but would the very markets focused resume be an auto-ding? feeling pretty pigeonholed right now.

 

I would try a little harder to get exposed to the things you think you're missing. 6 months isn't even long enough to conclude that an attempt to fix the problem has failed, let alone decide that it's time to bounce. If you wanted to be a trader, and you have a trader title, keep pushing to get a definitive idea of how / when / if you'll actually be trading, i.e. when will you have an account in your name, a specified capital limit, p&l targets, defined comp structure based on trading results, etc.

 

Thanks for the response dude. You make a good point that I should try to get exposure to the more interesting areas first, or even if I decide to leave, I should try to get that exposure while I'm still here.

What I'm most concerned about, though, is getting slotted into a supporting role, making it harder to switch down the road if I don't have a successful pnl record or the right experience.

Maybe I should just sit tight until the end of the year, and if I'm not working on relevant, revenue-generating things by mid Jan or so, then try applying elsewhere. Or am I wrong, and is it actually easier to find openings now since its kinda still during on-campus recruiting season? Who knows...

djfiii:
I would try a little harder to get exposed to the things you think you're missing. 6 months isn't even long enough to conclude that an attempt to fix the problem has failed, let alone decide that it's time to bounce. If you wanted to be a trader, and you have a trader title, keep pushing to get a definitive idea of how / when / if you'll actually be trading, i.e. when will you have an account in your name, a specified capital limit, p&l targets, defined comp structure based on trading results, etc.
 

It's not job jumping if you have the credentials to show that you could do better than the job you have now, people like other people with a drive as long as it's not backed by just plain unfulfilled content. Just make sure to subtly slide that into any interviews.

 

4 months seems to short and any interviewer will be wary that you will be equally likely to work a short stint for them and leave.

If you are unsatisfied with your job after 4 months, you should work with your boss to improve the role. It sounds like they didn't have a firm view of your responsibilities when they created the role. Talk to them about what you would like to do more of / less of, and how to improve the role. I would suggest you do this at the 1 year mark.

I get the sense that you don't have a great answer to what you'd like to do differently, but instead just want an FA job at a different company- you mention financial firms, internet firms, campbell soup - so you want to be an FA at another firm in the same geography?

I think you'd have difficulty getting interviews, as you aren't straight out of school but you don't have meaningful experience. If you did land interviews, "Why are you leaving your current role?" would be a top question and I think it is all but impossible to give a solid answer. You haven't worked there long enough to have a solid list of fair dislikes, and you haven't been there long enough to try and make changes.

1 year is an appropriate time frame. You learned some stuff, you had a review, you suggested changes to make the role more appealing, you came to realize the specific type of work wasn't for you -- you can't do that in four months.

 
grosse:
4 months seems to short and any interviewer will be wary that you will be equally likely to work a short stint for them and leave.

If you are unsatisfied with your job after 4 months, you should work with your boss to improve the role. It sounds like they didn't have a firm view of your responsibilities when they created the role. Talk to them about what you would like to do more of / less of, and how to improve the role. I would suggest you do this at the 1 year mark.

I get the sense that you don't have a great answer to what you'd like to do differently, but instead just want an FA job at a different company- you mention financial firms, internet firms, campbell soup - so you want to be an FA at another firm in the same geography?

I think you'd have difficulty getting interviews, as you aren't straight out of school but you don't have meaningful experience. If you did land interviews, "Why are you leaving your current role?" would be a top question and I think it is all but impossible to give a solid answer. You haven't worked there long enough to have a solid list of fair dislikes, and you haven't been there long enough to try and make changes.

1 year is an appropriate time frame. You learned some stuff, you had a review, you suggested changes to make the role more appealing, you came to realize the specific type of work wasn't for you -- you can't do that in four months.

This is a great answer and much appreciated, it’s not that I’m unsatisfied I guess I feel underutilized with most of my work and slightly bored. I was thinking the 9-12 month range is an goof time to begin searching, but wanted to get a grasp on some other thoughts since this is my 1st real job. The reason I listed those companies is because they are large set firms, in my geographic location offer positions I quality for. Also because they are places with set FA positions rather than a newly created roll. But I will definitely take that into consideration and continue to work hard and learn, then in 6-8 months down the road meet with my Boss to discuss my role some more. Thanks again

"When a defining momnet comes alone, you either define the moment or the moment defines you..." - Tin Cup Talent is hitting a target no one can hit. Genius is hitting a target no one can see.
 

i don't think it's THAT big of a deal to jump out of a job 4 months into it, as long as you stay a few years at your next job, and you have a decent explanation for an interviewer as to why you made the jump so quickly. however if this happened multiple times, it would definitely raise some red flags to hiring managers.

Money Never Sleeps? More like Money Never SUCKS amirite?!?!?!?
 

That is also true, honestly if you look across the field I would like to know the % of people that stay longer then 1 year at their first job, by their choice

"When a defining momnet comes alone, you either define the moment or the moment defines you..." - Tin Cup Talent is hitting a target no one can hit. Genius is hitting a target no one can see.
 

We had a recent candidate say he/she "felt like the smartest person in the current group." Needless to say, he/she did not make it the next round. You can be smart and proud of your accomplishments but always be humble. If you're going to drop something like that when you're supposed to be at your best, you're probably going to be a treat to work with later.

If you "outgrow" your responsibilities, that means you're perfectly OK waiting for me to give you direction and don't want to bring ideas to the table. In lean groups, you don't want someone who's not asking for more work at all times. It's the sad truth but you're better off riding out the remainder of your first year.

Also, if you have

 

@shorttheworld - its a 30k jump on my base. going from 70k ---> 100k base. Bonus will be a bit smaller but not by much. I was expecting about 20% at my current firm, and I've been told I can expect around 10% at the new place, but an extra week of vacation.

-MBP
 

I should also add that growth at this new place will be considerably faster. I really want to take the offer. I also know that a similar opportunity will open up in a few years, and I'm wondering if its better to wait and not piss people off, as it is a small industry.

-MBP
 

Take the new offer, no one will ask. People will move for just a 10K bump, let alone a huge 30K on base. Plus you don't even need to mention that you worked at the original firm on your resume. You can just start it out on this new firm. People understand if you are moving for better pay and opportunity in growth. Your boss will only think that you are an idiot for not taking a better opportunity. After all - it's human instincts.

 

I'm sure you've considered it... but what are the longer term (read: 1-3 years) prospects? Do you feel like you will advance faster at your current gig? If so, does the comp even out or surpass the other firm in the timeframe you're considering to be a consultant?

For example, I have been headhunted for industry positions that pay 30+% above my base currently, but I know I can make it to the next level in 1 to 1.5 years, outearn, and surpass that 5% annual salary increase in a very short time.

 

@consultant09. The new firm is much more well know (PwC/EY), whereas my current firm is highly acclaimed for what it does (probably best in the world), but not well known in general (most people I know have never heard of it).

I think specifically for my field, my current firm has a better reputation, but growth prospects within the company are not great.

On top of that, I'm not too sure I want to go to B-School. I already have a masters in financial engineering.

-MBP
 

Have you considered talking to your current boss about the situation and letting her know that, while you love the work and people at [current firm], the salary increase from your new offer will put you in a much more financial stable situation for your current stage in life and is really making you consider [new firm].

Put the ball in your current firm's court to raise your salary and if they can't match it/promote you/give more growth opportunities to your liking, then take the new job. Now you would have included the current firm in the process and let them know that you wanted to find a way for it to work out at your current firm.

Proboscis
 

^ I would be cautious with the above recommendation of asking for higher salary first year in the current firm...more of a dangerous move. Statistically, most people who accept the raise at current firm and stayed after showing the current firm they had another offer will most likely end up unhappy because you now just un-stabilized the relationship in your group. Your group will feel like you are a threat that will move anywhere for money and have no loyalty...aside from that even if you stayed and got a higher salary...you will most likely be the first one to let go in a downturn, because they can offer someone else to do your job for your current salary.

 
kbluearmor7:
^ I would be cautious with the above recommendation of asking for higher salary first year in the current firm...more of a dangerous move. Statistically, most people who accept the raise at current firm and stayed after showing the current firm they had another offer will most likely end up unhappy because you now just un-stabilized the relationship in your group. Your group will feel like you are a threat that will move anywhere for money and have no loyalty...aside from that even if you stayed and got a higher salary...you will most likely be the first one to let go in a downturn, because they can offer someone else to do your job for your current salary.

That's true - great consideration that I didn't think of.

Regards

Proboscis
 

Thanks for the comments pitchbook and kbluearmor.

I have to say that I agree with kbluearmor on this one. I know for a fact that my current firm won't match the salary or even come close to it. If they did, they would be paying me more than people who have been here 5 years. They also know that I know this and I think they might feel like I'm just playing games with them.

Another problem that I didn't really mention earlier is that the new firm wants me to start as soon as possible if I accept (which I definitely will), and want me to give my current firm 2 weeks notice. I am heavily involved with a huge project right now and I want to give them a month's notice so that I can get another person fully up to speed before I leave. I really don't want to screw over my current team because I really like them, but I also don't want to piss off my new boss. How do you think I should go about this problem?

-MBP
 

If your new firm wants to start ASAP, there isn't much negotiations you can do...and I would not advise notifying your current firm of your leave first then accepting the offer at the new firm. Also, do not feel obligated that you owe anything to your current firm. No need to feel bad walking out in middle of a project. If they value you enough they will beg and pay you to stay, if they don't they will just let you go. From the legal perspective, once they get the 2 week notice, they can't force you to stay so don't worry about it. And if you are a highly valued worker, they will always say they will happy to have you back sometime in the future.

 

It depends on the people you are going to meet with. But if I were to interview you, I'd ask why you want to switch so quickly after only one month of work. Maybe you are not getting along with colleagues? (team work) Or you have no clue about what you want to do? If so, how can I be sure you will stay in my firm for more than two years? (commitment) That being said, it at least will raise some questions and you'd better be able to figure out how to spin the story well. Hope that helps.

 

Giving the recruiter a call and asking how this year's crop of hires is doing would be weird.

Seems like you have a chance to call the recruiter and explain that you made a mistake, want to pursue this position now, and ask for any steps you can take to get there. I don't think you necessarily cold apply off the bat, you have a warm entry. Use it.

MM IB -> Corporate Development -> Strategic Finance
 

Quo ipsa qui maxime odit omnis minus totam. Pariatur odio officia explicabo.

Vitae molestiae culpa aut rerum ipsam enim. Quos aliquam doloremque quia laboriosam. Autem pariatur enim quod ad. Quia saepe sed accusantium ab accusantium odio. Nihil distinctio quo voluptatum quis rem sit aut.

Saepe quia voluptatem fuga quo aliquid eligendi in ipsam. Earum atque consequuntur iure optio neque ut ducimus. Magnam dicta incidunt explicabo rerum.

 

Eum ex veritatis rerum suscipit dolorem expedita. Omnis magnam est eum maxime sint officia ea.

Esse hic nihil doloremque nisi dolorum culpa ullam. Quisquam est molestias repellat quis doloribus iusto consectetur. Nulla velit itaque fuga odio. Molestiae velit necessitatibus harum omnis ipsa assumenda dolores. Blanditiis ut praesentium nemo asperiores deserunt error.

Et aut illo doloribus magni a minus. Officia quis quaerat consequatur quod ut. Exercitationem occaecati rerum qui dolores similique. Facere ea quibusdam dolor earum dolores aut.

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.
 

Doloremque cum corrupti sunt voluptatem dolores blanditiis. Qui consectetur quis voluptates non. Est provident dicta sit molestiae adipisci consequatur. Ducimus est et voluptatem eos voluptas tenetur. Id vel fuga dolor omnis magnam dolorem sed.

Voluptatem in omnis aut ipsa voluptas voluptas eaque. Perspiciatis quaerat nobis sed ut. Nobis soluta quo perspiciatis eos quae perspiciatis ullam.

Repellat vitae quis cum. Doloribus eligendi magnam consectetur eos iste voluptas sed. Sed iure quia et nihil magni. Qui fugiat illum fugiat quisquam sint.

[Comment removed by mod team]

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Hedge Fund

  • Point72 98.9%
  • D.E. Shaw 97.9%
  • Magnetar Capital 96.8%
  • Citadel Investment Group 95.8%
  • AQR Capital Management 94.7%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Hedge Fund

  • Magnetar Capital 98.9%
  • D.E. Shaw 97.8%
  • Blackstone Group 96.8%
  • Two Sigma Investments 95.7%
  • Citadel Investment Group 94.6%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Hedge Fund

  • AQR Capital Management 99.0%
  • Point72 97.9%
  • D.E. Shaw 96.9%
  • Citadel Investment Group 95.8%
  • Magnetar Capital 94.8%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Hedge Fund

  • Portfolio Manager (9) $1,648
  • Vice President (23) $474
  • Director/MD (12) $423
  • NA (6) $322
  • 3rd+ Year Associate (24) $287
  • Manager (4) $282
  • Engineer/Quant (71) $274
  • 2nd Year Associate (30) $251
  • 1st Year Associate (73) $190
  • Analysts (225) $179
  • Intern/Summer Associate (22) $131
  • Junior Trader (5) $102
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (249) $85
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
4
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
5
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
6
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
7
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
Linda Abraham's picture
Linda Abraham
98.8
10
numi's picture
numi
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”