Just landed an MS gig...what to do?

Hey All,

I've been reading posts on this forum and have found them particularly helpful. In fact, it is because of IBoasis that I started valuing the usefulness of networking early on which led me to land an SA position with a BB this summer...so for this I say thanks to you all!

But excessive networking has kind of put me in a tough position. I was recently talking to an alum of my school who is a top top (in fact, huge)shot at MS. We established rapport quickly and he asked about my summer plans. I told him about my offer for the summer with a BB and he was thoroughly impressed as I am only a freshman...(and a from a non-target too...so to all it can be done!)

Anyway, right on the spot, he told me to come work for his group next summer as a soph. I should be excited, right...???! But I couldn't.

I'm a Goldman lover. I've been dreaming of Goldman all my life and have already started prepping to apply for their scholarship for excellence this fall. As such, when he blurted out the invitation, I showed no sign of excitement and stammered an "I'll think about it..." He sounded extremely disappointed to say the least and now I feel awful.

Should I accept his offer? I want Goldman badly as a sophomore. Also, I don't feel like postponing it to my junior year as I'm thinking of branching out to get a junior year internship with a very respectable hedgefund or more ideally, an internship with Blackstone.

What should I do?

 

I don't understand...is there anything wrong with Goldman?

I've met a couple of their recruiters and they all seemed really nice. I also liked all the Goldman analysts and associates I've met so far. The firm culture is fantastic and their TMT group, a group I'm really interested in is stellar. Also, MS has no scholarship program. I actually do need the money as I am not so well off.

 

There's a student22 out there that could probably give you some pointers. Like you, he's a Goldman Lover, a real aficionado of The Firm's worship-worthy perfection. Definitely a real asset to this online community.

 

Err, no one's anti-Goldman. See, you sound incredibly naive, for starters. Further, consider that many people here would kill to have a position at Morgan Stanley offered to them as a sophomore and have it at their finger tips while you take it so nonchalantly in hopes of holding out for some honors program at Goldman. So think about it in those terms rather being "pro" or "anti" anything.

 

I guess I'll stop being anal and say yes to the alum...

another factor I'm probably trying to run away from (I just realized) is that I don't want to be stuck at MS. First, he's an alum, second, I have to work in his IBD group, third he'll most probably expect me to return as a junior...I don't want to lose my freedom to choose firm options...

frankly speaking when he gave me the offer, I don't think he was thinking short term- I think he was envisioning me joining the firm long term and I don't want to feel trapped

 
Best Response

It really has nothing to do with Goldman or against Goldman. It has everything to do with how you present this great opportunity. Imagine someone coming to you and saying "my dad gave me this brand new Porsche but I've had my eye on this Ferrari...should I take it back?"

MS is an absolutely fantastic firm to have on your resume as a sophomore. Bird in hand. It's a sure thing...Goldman on the other hand is not. You can always go for GS your junior year, or BStone if that is your ultimate goal. Your contact at MS should understand that you need to try different things in order to make a decision.

 
GameTheory:
It really has nothing to do with Goldman or against Goldman. It has everything to do with how you present this great opportunity. Imagine someone coming to you and saying "my dad gave me this brand new Porsche but I've had my eye on this Ferrari...should I take it back?"

MS is an absolutely fantastic firm to have on your resume as a sophomore. Bird in hand. It's a sure thing...Goldman on the other hand is not. You can always go for GS your junior year, or BStone if that is your ultimate goal. Your contact at MS should understand that you need to try different things in order to make a decision.

Very well said.

 

Sorry I just don't think you will get much sympathy or non-sarcastic advice for worrying about being 'stuck' at a top-tier firm. Especially when you are having these worries as a FRESHMAN.

What do you want us to tell you exactly? Don't be so quick to write off firms who aren't as 'lovable' as Goldman. Having a network in place at MS could be valuable to you for the future. And I'm sure the alum realizes that you are clearly very new to the industry and won't exactly jump to a full-time offer.

Just keep an open mind and enjoy your tough decision.

 

is the OP serious?

You don't even have to apply to get MS...anyone else will jump at such an opportunity

Also, your networking skills must be way up there somewhere- I take it that whoever gave you an offer must be an MD or ED and for you to impress someone of that caliber as a freshman, you must look/sound pretty darn impressive.

Listen, take MS. If you are as smart as you sound, this issue shouldn't even be a dilemma for you. Unless you'll rather return to your freshman summer BB in your sophomore year after a potential GS rejection- in which case you'll be screwed- no GS, no MS and you'll have pissed a Wall Street big shot off-

If this happens, please let IB oasis know so I can laugh my head off-

 

First of all, let's not tell people to kill themselves. He asked a question. It doesn't matter if he's a bit naive---he's a sophomore in college, for heaven's sake. He's LEARNING. Let's help a brother out.

Giglander---I think you don't understand the value of what you've gotten here, probably because it has come so easily. You got very, very lucky, and I think you should embrace it with both hands. Take the deal, now, before anyone changes his mind.

About your concern about being locked into MS forever: That is not how it works. Firms like it when you have relevant experience. You will be a BETTER Goldman candidate because of the MS internship. In fact, that may be the ONLY way that you can get a junior position there from a non-target school. You are not locked in, by an internship, ever. And getting more experience in your chosen field is always good.

I say: Do it!

 

Goldman is an animal and no one can deny that, but to say no to MS for a sophomore year internship would be just stupid. Goldman takes very very few sophomores for summer interns, although you have a great chance being a girl and a BB summer internship under your belt. Goldman is an amazing place, but passing up MS for the possibility of Goldman would be like passing up a blowjob for the possibility of getting laid. Just not a smart thing to do.

 

I pass on blowjobs all the time, but take the MS gig. Clearly someone important likes you and will take the time to make sure you have a great experience. There's always GS next summer and of course they won't be unimpressed by your sophomore MS internship.

 

guys, this is a joke. don't you really realize he is just having fun? Look at all the "interests" he had in common iwth the interviewers. He must be the most well-rounded person in the world. And correct me if I am wrong, but I don't know any of the top top (in fact, huge)shots at MS to be from non-targets. And an average MD will not be able to single handedly hire you, because of HR.

The head of a group in my bank wanted to hire more people from his alma mater, but HR wouldn't let him.

 

i was talking about a post that was deleted.

anyway, i agree with the meritocratic system. keeping that in mind, dont make generalizations like that if you dont want people to see you as an ignorant jackass. your original post only mentioned minorities in general.

and finally, Goldman's SFE seems like its geared towards outstanding kids, regardless of what school they go to, plus they have a cutoff GPA so giglander is obviously qualified if she is preparing herself for this merit. as for going to a non-target - again, this means nothing if you have what it takes to make into banking - i.e. skills, perseverance, etc.

 
moneyinthabank:
i was talking about a post that was deleted.

anyway, i agree with the meritocratic system. keeping that in mind, dont make generalizations like that if you dont want people to see you as an ignorant jackass. your original post only mentioned minorities in general.

and finally, Goldman's SFE seems like its geared towards outstanding kids, regardless of what school they go to, plus they have a cutoff GPA so giglander is obviously qualified if she is preparing herself for this merit. as for going to a non-target - again, this means nothing if you have what it takes to make into banking - i.e. skills, perseverance, etc.

Well, I do apologize then for sounding like an ignorant jerk. I meant to point out to the original poster that since she doesn't have a high GPA and doesn't go to a target school yet landed a BB internship as a freshman (something it's nearly impossible to do even as a top student from an ivy), her race was probably a large factor in her landing the internship. Given that, I think she should be very thankful for being afforded this opportunity, and not go around complaining about how she really wants to work for Goldman Sachs.

I also pointed out that Blackstone doesn't hire people from non-targets for their M&A group. Ever. At least at the undergrad level. They recruit at like 5 schools for the M&A group.

Also, the scholarship for excellence requires a 3.4 GPA...that's a below aveage GPA for the average IVY intern at a BB (non-targets are generally required to have much higher GPAs than that). Although it is quite possible that the AVERAGE GPA of interns in this scholarship program is sky high, but we have no way of knowing that nor the original poster's GPA unless she volunteers it (although we do know it's not really high, as she says this in one of her posts).

 
dav3100:

I also pointed out that Blackstone doesn't hire people from non-targets for their M&A group. Ever. At least at the undergrad level. They recruit at like 5 schools for the M&A group.

Not sure how accurate it is-but someone mentioned in one of the threads that Blackstone did take a guy from Canada, from Richard Ivey I think. Blackstone doesn't recruit anywhere in Canada, so there was clearly a connection there..

 

if you have a BB internship your freshman summer and then a MS internship your sophomore summer, you are already way ahead of everyone else that's your age, and probably can't be in a much better position to recruit for Blackstone. you think they really care whether your sophomore internship was from GS or MS? they'd be impressed either way.

and just because you agree to work for MS over the summer does not mean you agreed to work for them full time. thats not how it works.

 

lol. "It can be done!" hahah. yeah right. Even with handicaps such as affirmative action quotas and the like, this is impossible. Maybe if you're native american. But even that's a stretch - native americas are too awesome to dabble in something as massochistic as banking.

t-bag his goldnut sacs. HAHAHAHA that made my day.

1.) you're a GS tool 2.) ms is just as amazing as GS, and is gunning closer each year to gs, especially with the return of the Mack (i'd be surprised if you even knew who i was talking about) 3.) for someone that loves goldman so much i'm surprised you're fickle enough to jump ship to Blackstone.

Give up now. For someone that says you're a lover of a company, your loyalty sure doesn't sound too strong. I don't care if you're persistent and do your research - you're a tool, and will just follow the crowd to the next big thing, t-bagging those goldnut sacs. try making decisions for yourself - it might feel refreshing.

 
werdwerd:
lol. "It can be done!" hahah. yeah right. Even with handicaps such as affirmative action quotas and the like, this is impossible. Maybe if you're native american. But even that's a stretch - native americas are too awesome to dabble in something as massochistic as banking.

t-bag his goldnut sacs. HAHAHAHA that made my day.

1.) you're a GS tool 2.) ms is just as amazing as GS, and is gunning closer each year to gs, especially with the return of the Mack (i'd be surprised if you even knew who i was talking about) 3.) for someone that loves goldman so much i'm surprised you're fickle enough to jump ship to Blackstone.

Give up now. For someone that says you're a lover of a company, your loyalty sure doesn't sound too strong. I don't care if you're persistent and do your research - you're a tool, and will just follow the crowd to the next big thing, t-bagging those goldnut sacs. try making decisions for yourself - it might feel refreshing.

Hey I'm glad someone finally caught that goldnut sacs joke. And I think everyone knows that Return of the (John) Mack is by Mark Morrison... it's a classic

 

oh yeah, forgot to mention too before I make my exit:

werdwerd: "ms is just as amazing as GS, and is gunning closer each year to gs, especially with the return of the Mack (i'd be surprised if you even knew who i was talking about)"

ehmmm...no offense but I think you must have a very exaggerated sense of self going on...

thanks for all your inputs~!(racist/otherwise)

 
giglander:
oh yeah, forgot to mention too before I make my exit:

werdwerd: "ms is just as amazing as GS, and is gunning closer each year to gs, especially with the return of the Mack (i'd be surprised if you even knew who i was talking about)"

ehmmm...no offense but I think you must have a very exaggerated sense of self going on...

thanks for all your inputs~!(racist/otherwise)

HAHAHAHAHA I just crapped my pants. How in the hell does someone land a gig without knowing the fucking current ceos name much less the history of the bank. Gig you are full of shit sister.

 

just in case you were too slow to figure it out:

"ehmmm...no offense but I think you must have a very exaggerated sense of self going on..."

simply means...knowing who John Mack is, or in any case, playing a pun with his name and alluding it to mark morrison's song and assuming that only an exclusive group of people "in the know" (whatever that means) know what you're talking about means you rate yourself too highly.

I believe I can safely assume that any high schooler genuinely interested in IB should know who Mack, Blankfein, O'Neal, Dimon, etc are...

 

hahahaha, this whole thread had me cracking up...IF this whole story is actually true, I think giglander must be that rare exception that's hot as hell yet still somehow smart, and that she used her womanly charms to seduce the MD into giving her the internships. Everybody is right...there's just no way this could happen otherwise.

 

Architecto atque est enim occaecati enim facere tempora. Libero in enim modi maiores vel dolorem.

Expedita blanditiis aut nemo esse dolorem voluptatem. Eum veritatis voluptas eligendi pariatur unde. Id nostrum id qui quaerat natus dolorem voluptatem.

Voluptas voluptatem ea odio minima libero nam. Maxime nihil non praesentium aut aut non incidunt. Officia et optio exercitationem hic ut quos facilis. Id in ratione qui ut voluptates. Voluptate consequatur dolor qui rerum saepe numquam.

 

Omnis sint ut dolorem ipsa excepturi earum. Accusamus quisquam deleniti blanditiis non ullam quia rem ullam. Culpa eos ut laboriosam sed sed aperiam. Impedit occaecati quo placeat optio aperiam nobis similique. Ipsa earum consequatur corporis sint nisi esse quia.

Vitae cupiditate sapiente praesentium aliquid. Atque optio esse et tenetur cumque ea. Aliquam cum et iste. Aut facilis quia voluptatum soluta in et aut amet. Consectetur odit ut eligendi deserunt vel vero aut.

Sed dignissimos eum ea distinctio sapiente sit. Quia eos quo dolores beatae aut quis. Aspernatur sed debitis nam doloribus ullam aspernatur ut. Asperiores repudiandae ea voluptatum id vitae.

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (87) $260
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (14) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (146) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
4
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
5
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
6
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
7
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
8
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
9
numi's picture
numi
98.8
10
Kenny_Powers_CFA's picture
Kenny_Powers_CFA
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”