No return offer from T2 for MBA internship

HIQ111's picture
Rank: Chimp | 10

Currently finishing up my summer internship at T2 consulting firm (ATK, S&, LEK, ACN) and just found out that I am not getting a return offer. The feedback during the return offer call was a bit more direct than any feedback during the internship. It was not a matter of effort, attitude, or culture, but there were some concerns about performance. I sort of expected that given I come from a non-traditional background (military, non-profit, TFA) and this was my first experience in the corporate world.

Just looking for general advice. Has this happened to anyone on here? I'm hoping to re-recruit for consulting full-time and know I need to be able to explain this well, just hoping that it is not a huge red flag. Also wondering if it is even common for employers to ask if you have a return offer?

Comments (5)

Aug 7, 2019

Undergrad level and at MBB, but likely same story

https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forums/need-advice...

Aug 7, 2019

If you re-recruit for consulting no one is gonna give a fuck. It's 100% understandable (expected?) to recruit again if you didn't do the summer at MBB so don't worry about the question.
1. Focus on re-recruiting
2. With offer in hand think on how to set yourself for success

Aug 8, 2019

Listen - a lot of people recruit again full time anyways. Honestly nobody will ever know. Just come up with a two line reason for rerecruiting (I'm more interested in xyz, which you specialize in...) or something like that. If they even ask.

ATK/S&/LEK experience is a huge plus on the resume. You'll likely get interviews anywhere you want for full time (that is recruiting at OCR, that is). ACN similar to a slightly lesser extent; you might not have an auto-interview at all firms but you should be fine.

Take a few corporate interviews just to be safe; similarly, it will be a positive indicator for them. There are a few corporates outside of tech that paid $150k+ all in when I was in school.

    • 1
Aug 9, 2019

I appreciate the help.

If asked directly whether I had a return, I will probably just say something along the lines of "I do not, its a competitive process in a small firm and not all interns got return offers, my project team was great and are willing to serve as references...learned a ton...I still want to do consulting..." I do not plan to mention any of the specific feedback unless asked, but let's be real consultants always give feedback and areas for improvement, so I do not think this will matter much.

If it doesn't come up directly, I think it is easy to just talk around it like you said.

Aug 12, 2019
Comment