Comments (65)

Best Response
Apr 12, 2010

Never

    • 2
Apr 12, 2010

+1 for never

You would do better off getting an off-the-rack at a department store.

    • 1
Apr 12, 2010

Macy's Alfani. Look it up.

    • 1
Dec 27, 2012
WallStreetKid:

Macy's Alfani. Look it up.

^this

Apr 12, 2010

When they have the "buy one suit, get three months inventory FREE!" sale.

Learn More

Side-by-side comparison of top modeling training courses + exclusive discount through WSO here.

Dec 27, 2012

I'm not a big fan of Jos Banks, the fit is just always off in some wierd way. It sucks because they always have the best deals (ie-3 for 1)

Dec 27, 2012

Jos. A Bank is always having a sale. Wait until they have a three for one sale. Or just shop at Men's Wearhouse.

Meanwhile, Jos. Abboud & Hart-Schaffner-Marx @ Macy's= $350/suit and last 50% longer than Joseph A Bank. Probably because they are made by adults in the US. Done.

Dec 27, 2012
IlliniProgrammer:

Jos. A Bank is always having a sale. Wait until they have a three for one sale. Or just shop at Men's Wearhouse.

Meanwhile, Jos. Abboud & Hart-Schaffner-Marx @ Macy's= $350/suit and last 50% longer than Joseph A Bank. Probably because they are made by adults in the US. Done.

IP,

Is the Hart-Marx in store only?

Dec 27, 2012

I bought a few suits from Jos. A Bank. Their cut fits me well, but they are not great suits past the "entry" level. The biggest problem I've had with them was not the suit, but the "master tailor" (their words, not mine) at their stores suck. I bought 3 suits during their 3-1 sale, had them tailored at the same time. The result was 3 suits with each with a different arm length. I was more than a little ticked. The suits that I have from them will get me by for another year or 2 tops. By then I should be able to afford something nicer.

Dec 27, 2012

Find a good tailor that isn't in house at Jos. A Bank, take them to said tailor, end up with a good looking suit.

They have some slimmer fit suits at Jos A, that fit a bit better. They wont last you forever, but are good for your money.

Dec 27, 2012

I don't know, don't look at price and equate lasting. I have a black label RL that got elbow holes from the wear. Luckily I know a good tailor.

More expensive = more delicate. If you are a monkey working the keys every day, get something cheap and durable.

Apr 12, 2010

lol i think Jos a Bank suits are fine...their buy 1 get 2 free sale is good.

Btw..the ad right on WSO is not bad for Filene's basement: http://www.filenesbasement.com/campaign/april_suit...
Or just check Nordstrom rack, a lot of designer suits at steep discounts. Or try a Brooks Brothers outlet store

Dec 27, 2012

They give away more shit than the Salvation Army which, coincidentally, is where all of their clothing belongs.

If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses - Henry Ford

Dec 27, 2012
happypantsmcgee:

They give away more shit than the Salvation Army which, coincidentally, is where all of their clothing belongs.

So true. There are no "deals" to be had at Jos. A Banks. Shorttheworld? More like short JOSB. The company was actually sued in NY court for misleading advertising that things were "on sale."

http://www.fool.com/investing/small-cap/2004/09/16...
Joseph A. Bank is, however, acceptable if you are a commercial banker.

Dec 27, 2012

Whatever, I will take it. Just get the shit tailored.

Dec 27, 2012
Nobama88:

Whatever, I will take it. Just get the shit tailored.

Fuck that noise.

Dec 27, 2012

lol, you pretentious fucks.

Dec 27, 2012

I'm not pretentious.. I just hate their suits. It has nothing to do with the name or the price or even the fact that people say their suits are low quality. I just legitimately have never liked the 2 suits I bought from them.

I'd rather goto Macys and find a decent Ralph Lauren suit for under $500.

Dec 27, 2012

One of my shirts from Jos. A Bank already has these small holes on the collar. I only had the shirt for a little longer than 3.5 years. I mean, you'd think they'd be pretty decent, but the reality is that I'm considering writing them off completely and focusing on Brooks Brothers, Macy's etc. and if I really want to get a good quality shirt, tie, suit, etc. go to Saks Fifth Avenue.

Dec 27, 2012
TraderDaily:

One of my shirts from Jos. A Bank already has these small holes on the collar. I only had the shirt for a little longer than 3.5 years. I mean, you'd think they'd be pretty decent, but the reality is that I'm considering writing them off completely and focusing on Brooks Brothers, Macy's etc. and if I really want to get a good quality shirt, tie, suit, etc. go to Saks Fifth Avenue.

You paid like 30 bucks for a dress shirt and you're pissed it only lasted 3 and a half years? What the fuck did you expect?

If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses - Henry Ford

Dec 27, 2012
happypantsmcgee:
TraderDaily:

One of my shirts from Jos. A Bank already has these small holes on the collar. I only had the shirt for a little longer than 3.5 years. I mean, you'd think they'd be pretty decent, but the reality is that I'm considering writing them off completely and focusing on Brooks Brothers, Macy's etc. and if I really want to get a good quality shirt, tie, suit, etc. go to Saks Fifth Avenue.

You paid like 30 bucks for a dress shirt and you're pissed it only lasted 3 and a half years? What the fuck did you expect?

lol. Not much, but Jos A Bank pushes themselves as Brooks Brothers lite. Where do you prefer to get your shirts/ties/suits? Thoughts on Brooks Brothers?

Dec 27, 2012
happypantsmcgee:
TraderDaily:

One of my shirts from Jos. A Bank already has these small holes on the collar. I only had the shirt for a little longer than 3.5 years. I mean, you'd think they'd be pretty decent, but the reality is that I'm considering writing them off completely and focusing on Brooks Brothers, Macy's etc. and if I really want to get a good quality shirt, tie, suit, etc. go to Saks Fifth Avenue.

You paid like 30 bucks for a dress shirt and you're pissed it only lasted 3 and a half years? What the fuck did you expect?

I'm glad someone else was the asshole loud enough to say it. Honestly, how hard is it to get Brooks Brothers? They're the staple. You should build from there, my friend.

Dec 27, 2012

The free stuff sucks...you should try other tailors like Crown, Raja etc.

Apr 12, 2010

Nordstrom's Rack is really good, especially for shirts but I don't know if they have stores everywhere

Dec 27, 2012

My Jos A Bank suit got totally destroyed (the shoulder pads got loosen) after dry cleaning for three times. I would really stay away from them. Also the Men Warehouse. I am sticking to only Brooks Brothers and Charles Tyrwhitt, and I am not willing to pay more than suits from those stores.

Dec 27, 2012

I have one Jos A Bank suit and one BB suit. I can definitely tell the Jos A Bank suit is worse quality, but I don't mind it too much. If you don't wear a suit multiple times a week I think Jos A Bank is fine. It should be noted that I do have the highest quality that JSB sells too. I prefer my BB suit but until I bought it my JSB was fine for interviews, career fairs, etc.

The bottom line is that fit is king. It's better to get a cheaper suit and spend the money on a good tailor than to get a ballin suit and get a shitty fit.

Dec 27, 2012

what if i get a joseph Abboud suit from Mens Wearhouse would it still be low quality?

Dec 27, 2012
MrBroadway:

what if i get a joseph Abboud suit from Mens Wearhouse would it still be low quality?

You have to look through the label to see what it is being made out of (wool, cotton, etc.). And really know the quality of the fabrics. And also try wearing to make sure that the suit fits perfectly.

Dec 27, 2012

Never got a a Jos A Bank suit but I have gotten a bunch of shirts when they have their usual sales. Bought a few a got them tailored and they now fit real well and were cheaper then most BB or CT shirts I get

Dec 27, 2012

I know this is an old thread but I agree with this. I have tailored travelers shirts from Jos A Bank and I may try the slim fit travelers for dress shirts. The cost is great and the shirts are decent.

Dec 27, 2012

Just wondering how do you guys find a good tailor? How much does it usually cost to get a shirt tailored?

Dec 27, 2012
helpmepleasethx:

Just wondering how do you guys find a good tailor? How much does it usually cost to get a shirt tailored?

Word of mouth for me. The one I usually go to charges $15 to tailor a shirt. This also out in the suburbs, in NYC/Hoboken I've been quoted at $25+ (not worth it IMO)

Dec 27, 2012
American Psycho:

I went through the 3-for-1 bologna special and I have to say it was one of the worst experiences. I should have bought one quality suit instead. Tailoring was not very good and the fits they have in my opinion are too loose.

We tried to warn you...

Dec 27, 2012

Go to a real tailor and have them fixed up...they will be fine

Dec 27, 2012

bump for the mere reason that this sale is currently on again

Apr 12, 2010

Second the never.

Unless you're one of the lucky few who catches their Arbor Day buy one suit get 3 suits, 6 shirts and 8 ties free sale. Can't beat that with a stick.

If you ever see some Ethiopians with bloated stomachs in a polyester suits.... you're witnessing the generosity of yours truly.

Dec 27, 2012

Nice. I got bored one day at the mall with my family and wandered into a Jo Banks, mainly because I'd never been in one and wanted to see what it was about, and somehow walked out with so much goddamn stuff, like 3 suits, lord knows how many shirts and ties, and I think underwear and socks for a thousand bucks or so that it felt comical. They're not the greatest quality but they're not absolutely horrible. I think I bought the higher end line though. They're good travel suits when you're visiting a warehouse or production facility or a company in East Jesus where even the execs are wearing polo's and hardly own suits and you don't want to ruin a good suit by spilling coffee, wine or food when the plane hits turbulence. But I'm pretty sure they'll fall apart after a year of wear and tear and some dry cleaning. And then I'll use them as kitchen rags.

Apr 12, 2010

^^^ LMAO. The best thing I've read all day. Thanks Marcus.

But no seriously. This is a PSA for all incoming male bankers: Instead of getting 4 crap suits get 2 good ones. Granted I'm a female and now nothing about fit, Hugo Boss, Brooks Brothers and Armani make any guy look good....instantly! I have yet to pay full price for a suit for myself nor for a guy I was "styling". Brooks Brothers doesn't seem to be doing so hot with the recession so you can get some great deals. There is no Nordstrom Rack in Manhattan. Wall Street is not a fashion show but at the same time please don't buy suits at JC Penney, Sears, Old Navy, etc

Nov 12, 2012
moneyneversleeps2:

There is no Nordstrom Rack in Manhattan.

I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure the Nordstrom in Union Square is Nordstrom Rack.

Dec 12, 2012
duffmt6:
moneyneversleeps2:

There is no Nordstrom Rack in Manhattan.

I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure the Nordstrom in Union Square is Nordstrom Rack.

There is absolutely a Nordstrom Rack in Union Square. It's on the southeastern corner of the square, so I think 14th and Park (or whatever Park changes to down there).

Apr 12, 2010

Getting a cheap suit (200-500) and getting it well tailored can do miracles as opposed to buying a relatively more expensive Hugo Boss or such off the rack.

Apr 15, 2010

That implies that one isn't getting the nicer suit well tailored either...

Apr 15, 2010

The second you incoming guys pull your first all nighter you will think back on this conversation and laugh...and cry.

Apr 15, 2010

Just buy the suit when it is on sale or go to Banana Republic or something. I own suits from all price ranges and if you get them tailored they will look 10x better than an un-tailored expensive suit. Additionally, realize that really expensive suits tend to be made with better, but also delicate. You are going to be beating the shit out of these suits early on and those 2 grand suits will rip/tear/wear really fast. Get the baller suits when you start meeting clients.

Apr 15, 2010

A good time to buy something from there might be tomorrow. Everything is 50% on Friday only.

Apr 30, 2010

Bump! I think I'll be picking one up for the buy one get two free special..

It's running until May 1st if anyone's poor and interested like myself, heh.

"Salesmen and traders are wild, cunning, aboriginal creatures who advise money managers about deceiving their bosses and finding new strip bars; their favourite phrase is, "Fuck you." IBankers eat fruit. Salesmen and traders eat meat, preferably fried."

May 9, 2010

If I WERE a 1st year analyst. The buy 1 get 2 free would be hard to pass up... Even if they last a year or two, its worth it to have 3 suits for under a grand.

Just get them tailored and then you wont care when you beat the shit out of them and they tear.

May 17, 2010

Never.

Even Brooks Brothers would be a better choice, and they run plenty of specials as well. Even off-the-rack dept stores have some nice Hart Marx suits on sale around this time.

Dec 12, 2012
matt:

Never.

Even Brooks Brothers would be a better choice, and they run plenty of specials as well. Even off-the-rack dept stores have some nice Hart Marx suits on sale around this time.

+1 for Hart Marx. They are made by Hickey, mostly in the US, and what I would recommend to someone who has a limited suit budget.

May 17, 2010

Jos. A Bank has a deal right now. Buy 1 suit, get 1 suit free, plus get 2 dress shirts and 2 silk ties for free.

May 18, 2010

If you have the money, get it made-to-measure. Otherwise, local tailors might prove to be diamonds in the rough, too.

May 18, 2010

@pruf: problem is I am pretty short on cash due to a combination of very illiquid investments and a habit of going to tropical countries whenever I get a chance lol

Also, next Monday (May 26) they are having a sale where the $750 suits will go for about $350, the $500 ones will go for $250, etc... the numbers might not be exact but a buddy of mine just sent me the flyer they gave to employees. Seems like a good deal since I don't need 2 shirts and 2 ties right now and I only need one suit (2 suits, 2 shirts, 2 ties for ~$800 versus 1 suit for $350)

May 18, 2010

Can you forward the flyer? Thx

Nov 12, 2012

Best sale that I have found and took advantage of is buy 1 get 4 free. This sale doesn't occur very often so be sure to act when it does.

Dec 11, 2012

Listen, they do have some nice lines, AND some crap lines. But your best bet is to wait for the 70% off sale, usually in june, and then again last half of December. This way, you get to buy what you want, in any quantity you want. Now on the other hand, I just, today, bought 4 suits for the price of one, and got 75 bucks off as well. 4 suits for 300 dollars. I bought the lighter summer suits, but idc where you are or what you do, theres no way you can beat that deal, even if they rip and tear after 7-10 wears, I still have either the pants or the coats to carry on and use. Its unfortunate that they have no concept of value added selling. I don't hate this place, coming from a former brand whore that spent a lot of zeros in the past, I'll take 4 suits for 300-700 anyday over a tumbler of scotch and ONE suit for 2900.

Simply put, look good, stay fresh, and invest that money into tailoring and 3 more suits. This way you always look brand new and get to have fun hunting a good deal. Stay thirsty my friend.

Feb 20, 2019
Comment
    • 1
    • 1
Feb 21, 2019
Feb 21, 2019
Comment

My soul is highly leveraged