Would you tell an MD you got other offers?

lifeboat's picture
Rank: Orangutan | 357

Hello fellow monkeys,

I'll put you in perspective then I'll seek your knowledge. I networked my way to an MD of BB and had the opportunity to get a coffee with him. Two weeks later I received a call from the bank telling me that they wanted to have an interview with me. I went to the interview and everything went great, I meet the team and I meet this MD again. He told me the position was not yet open, and that there would probably be a second round with other prospective candidates but that there were some members of the team on a trip and that I would have to come back to meet them. I have not heard from him in two weeks.

Point is, imagine if I were to have a full-time offer to do financial consulting and an internship offer to do institutional coverage, would you send him an email saying you got these two offers to see if he moves with regards to this internship?

I am eager to believe they are having a high workload due to the deals they are working on.

Comments (10)

Apr 25, 2018

Hey lifeboat, I'm here to break the silence...any of these links help you?:

  • Should I tell an MM I got an offer from about an offer I got from GS? (SA) it. Last week I got an SA offer from GS in a slightly different role but same division. GS has told me ... told me I should receive something in 1-3 weeks, but also asked me who I got my other offer from. As GS ... more), but how should I present this to the MM I got the first offer from? Should I just go out and tell ...
  • Managing Director (MD) vs. Executive Director (ED) I don't think he could get you an offer. Maybe at a smaller firm it would be possible, but not a large ... President. Therefore it is the step before reaching Managing Director. In Europe: an Executive Director is ... Executive Director and Managing Director? Thanks. Difference between Executive
  • Which would you rather be? A US Senator or an MD? Which would you rather be? A US Senator or an MD in <span ... Governor, or Mayor (e.g. of NYC)? MD managing director Senate ... title="investment banking division ">IBD at a BB? How about other political appointments like Congressman, ...
  • Advice from an ex-IB MD- DON'T make these mistakes the desk. I'll tell you the story of a MD I used to know. Lets call him FD. Now FD was a great ... to get instant gratification, I wanted my boss to tell me I had done a great job. I would rush into ... 'wow you are so fast'. I was feeling pretty satisfied. I got the affirmation I needed. I was just ...
  • Some Observations from an MD manager) is almost entirely an accumulated sum of the wisdom, knowledge and experience you gain doing ... assistant treasurer you built a model with as an analyst could well be the CEO when you are an MD. 8. ... firms, across all products including M&A. 1. You are your deal experience Your ability to be an ...
  • I-Banking Brainteasers Qs Source 2. Three envelopes are presented in front of you by an interviewer. One contains a job offer, the ... brainteasers /three-envelopes-are-presented-in-front-of-you-by-an-interviewer-one-contains-a-job-offer-the ... other two contain rejection letters. You pick one of the envelopes. The interviewer then shows you the ...
  • Advice from an ex-IB MD- The Importance Of Failure how to make VP 3. Advice from an ex-IB MD- why aren't you getting those interviews? 4. Advice ... failed at. Let me give you the bigger ones that come to mind. I got a D in a Math class in my first ... quarter in college; I only got one banking job offer when I graduated in 1999;in my mid twenties I tried ...
  • More suggestions...

Or maybe the following WSO members have something to say: @jalexandermarley @jvoorhees @omalleypf

Hope that helps.

Apr 29, 2018

Do you have the FT offer 100% confirmed? If so, yes. But it depends on which you really prefer. If you're split 10:90 between the FT and internship but are tempted to take the FT just because it's FT then no - taking a job you wouldn't like isn't great. If you're 50:50 then email him and see if he can meet in person. 1. It's better to tell him face-to-face 2. If you word it well, it won't come off as 'I have another offer so hurry or I'm gone' but make it come off as 'You've been in this position, the offer is a burning one (even if it isn't) and whilst I like your firm, I also have to think about my future'.

He could: 1. hurry his ass up or explain why there has been a delay or 2. make it seem like you're pressuring him and tell you to piss off.

Whether you take the risk or not depends on which firm you prefer.

    • 1
Apr 29, 2018

Thanks for the input. I had to accept the offer (or reject it) for coverage before Monday Morning and so I have accepted it. Usually, interns are not able to stay in the bank after the internship and so they are quite permissible if you get other offers. Do you think following up with the MD saying I already got this offer would be fair enough?

I think I will reject Financial Consulting should I get the offer as I prefer to do banking.

Apr 29, 2018

I think so

    • 1
Best Response
Apr 29, 2018

Once you really have an offer, of course follow up. For one, offers are usually time sensitive, so you would not want to be left hanging with nothing if something doesn't work elsewhere you're looking. And for another, if you're more serious about this role at the B.B., you would want to know your status before making any final decisions.

If you haven't heard from the bank in a little while, this could be normal. Larger organizations usually have a process to put potential candidates through before any decisions are made. Once you have serious updates on your side, you will normally get in touch with other firms to let them know.

In this case, you might say that you have an offer but you're still very interested in the MD's firm. You'd like to know your status or timeline. They can expedite the process if they're serious about you, so definitely let them know of competing offers if they're your first choice.

    • 2
Apr 29, 2018

Thanks for the input. I ended up accepting the coverage position. I will email this MD tomorrow to see what is the status of the position. Do you think this is all right?


Apr 29, 2018
    • 2