TN Visa - CRE - Canada to USA
Curious to know if anyone from Canada's been able to make the jump to the states via TN visa as an economist. Alot of the Canadians I know in the states have been able to make an internal transfer however all of them I know are consultants for MBB/Big 4.
nontargetnewbie, pure crickets, that's where I come in. Any of these useful?
You're welcome.
The economist title is very strict now (ie. financial analysts don't qualify anymore). Here's the memo.
https://www.uscis.gov/news/news-releases/uscis-issues-clarifying-guidan…
I recently got "kicked out" because of it lol. MBB and Big 4 can use the TN easily because management consultants and accountants are eligible jobs under TN. Hope that helps.
Tell us more about the denial? Did you apply to USCIS directly or via border? What was your title and what kind of organization?
Thanks in advance!
Applied at the border. My title was "research analyst" for a CRE firm. I was doing a lot of CRE underwriting.
The officer who denied me argued that "Economists" now have to work strictly on researching the economy. The most common roles are in non-profits and governments.
I'm pretty sure he was simply going off the USCIS website profile for economists when denying me. He even showed my the USCIS webpages that he just printed out. It was pretty funny but frustrating.
Anyhow I've moved on from the whole ordeal.
i see alot of guys in IB that move across the border though...some of my friends do have economist minors however i'm wondering how the rest get across esp the ones that go for a summer internship
Now there is a special visa called the L1 for companies with offices in both countries, which has different requirements than TN. IANAL so do your own research.
How hard is it to go from US to Canada? My girlfriend keeps trying to get us to move to Vancouver but I keep telling her its impossible.
Canada's immigration system is really straight forward compared to the US. There's a points system. How easy or hard to immigrate depends on how many "points" you get.
Moved to States a few years ago, took six months before landing first job. Was in CRE finance at prominent shop in Canada but couldn’t land anything because 1) most US companies didn’t want to deal with visa issues 2) preferred local candidates 3) RE is quite relationship driven so pretty hard to start from scratch, 4) TN categories such as management consulting and economist are the most heavily scrutinized professions. Ended up as landing a job as an Accountant which was kind of a step down but it worked out. Now I have much better and more options since I networked my butt off and have tangible US experience. Once people know you personally it becomes much easier to vouch and refer you to opportunities. In long run I think it paid off as not many Canadians do this. The States is such a bigger pond such that salaries and opportunities are generally better. In hindsight should’ve tried targeting Canadian firms with US operations. I’m still very careful divulging my work status given the current political environment.
Interesting approach. Did you go to school for accounting? What's your educational background? I assume you're still on TN visa?
Ex quis alias molestias nemo minima. Pariatur repellat et eos modi vel aut quia. Laboriosam sint tempora ullam.
Aut voluptatem voluptatem ut tempora eos. Quas doloremque quibusdam eum expedita rem nihil at excepturi. Est voluptatibus error deleniti libero numquam. Aut neque consequuntur eligendi suscipit sed.
Animi quaerat et fugiat fugit. Ex libero hic illo minus aut sint est repudiandae. Ex eveniet aut provident distinctio quia et officiis autem.
Veritatis harum veritatis necessitatibus amet voluptatum consequatur molestiae. Ut non voluptatem rem corporis ad perferendis voluptas. Veniam facere quo tempore neque dicta ipsam sit. Mollitia doloremque omnis minima.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...