Hardest interview questions?

Wanted to get an updated thread on hardest interview/technical questions so i can gauge where my own technical knowledge is at and practice more (will recruit for 2022 SA). Some threads on this are quite old (like the most extensive thread is 2008?). Help us monkeys out with some tough q's!

 

not sure why this got MS (I am not OP). I'm from a lower ivy and I got a similar "there's a Harvard kid waiting outside....why you?" question as well. It was definitely a difficult and memorable question to close the interview that forces you to really advocate for yourself coherently.

 

Yeah - you can't really in terms of of Grades/Extracurriculars...

Maybe spin it, sure he's great on paper, but doesn't mean he will fit into the specific team - or talk about the things you've overcame to get where you are/talk about the things you have that he doesn't. Being honest (i.e. saying that you should hire the Harvard kid) is conceding defeat - might look bad depending on your interviewer.

But if you can indirectly answer the question by showing your strengths, you manager to sell yourself while not answering the " Why should I hire you over him?"

 

Speaking as a non target who didn’t have a perfect GPA and worked in BO out of UG:

Because top Ivy->BB->MF is the perfect linear of a progression. Not to say that candidate didn’t work hard for where he is, however I’d argue that it’s the most risk adverse career path. That’s what they’re expected to do and never had to make a real choice on it. What happens when they get asked to manage risk or have to face the music on important decisions?

Idk it’s a gamble of a response but on the fly I’d spin it to show that a scrappy kid could be a better fit. Obviously backfired If the interviewer did any of the above

 

How about this? Ignore the label, I am an An2 in FIG M&A.

“Actually, I think he/she may be able to do the job just as well as I, in fact, as far as going through the motions and executing tasks/instructions is concerned IB is not cognitively taxing, so you could just as well hire someone who hasn’t been to college and possibly pay them less. If anything, the Harvard alumnus outside the door is likely to be brilliant and smart, and more likely to get bored in this job, and given the options available to them, not likely to stay.

I on the other hand offer the perfect middle-ground between the college dropout and a top tier academic. Unless, you want to be spending your time re-recruiting in a few months, go with me”.

 

Because that kid has probably had everything handed to him in his life, once he faces a controversial life event, or any form of adversity, he’ll crumble and melt down because he’s been living a spoon-fed perfect life, compared to others who have been through the struggles and are 10x are going to be able to handle that adversity, and can take criticism

 

Answers to the Harvard question: - 4.0 GPA and captain of the team means he has no social life or he never sleeps. I may have a 3.6, but I got to know my peers, sleep, and read XYZ novel about finance/banking.

-Harvard has a lot of students, I got to know my professors at my smaller school, I put three down as my references.

  • Harvard is expensive, I went to No Name University because being debt-free after undergraduate/graduate was way more important to me than getting a Name-Brand Degree. I think for the long term.

  • I worked my ass off all throughout high school to get the SAT and ACT, Harvard is notorious for buying your way in. I have the brains and social skills to come from nothing to Harvard. A lot better than daddy's money.

Of course, be more polished, but you get the idea.

 

I always ask my interviewers where they went to college and how they joined the firm. If he went to Harvard, I think you can still be charming and say the same things. As a Harvard grad, he knows they are true.

 
Most Helpful

Guys, guys, guys... your answer should not focus at all on that candidate or Harvard. You should be answering like a politician, don't you dare try to directly answer the question or literally compare yourself to this hypothetical candidate.

Just go back into your wheelhouse, "What you are getting when you hire me is A, B, and C. I had great conversations with people on this team while doing informational interviews and can see myself succeeding here over the long term. I'm humble, persistent and hardworking..." If you've already gone through strengths and weaknesses, you can throw in "I acknowledge that I have some room to grow and develop in some of the areas we have discussed but I am making great progress there and I am confident that I would make a positive addition to the team."

This is the same shit that banks have to do on bakeoffs when the client says "We just heard from Goldman. Why should we hire you [BAML]?" You don't really think the higher prestige option always wins out? Why? Because of specific fit to this situation, personal connections, social fit, or other reasons... same as in recruiting as in pitches. Talking directly about Harvard or Goldman would be giving them headspace and you want to completely gloss over it as if the interviewer didn't even mention it. If they really care about it, they will ask you again and more directly.

This question is purely to make you uncomfortable and see how confident you are in yourself.

If they really press you, and sometimes senior bankers get really cheeky ("No, really, the guy is in the waiting room. Why not the Harvard varsity captain?"). This is situational but if you have nothing to lose... throw a Hail Mary right back, "Brad? He's a great guy, we've gotten on well together at the Starbucks before we came in today. Hire us both, we each bring a very different and complementary life experience to the team, and I would look forward to working together with him"

Be excellent to each other, and party on, dudes.
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

What did you say as a weakness lol? If it wasn't incredibly retarded, that's extremely unprofessional of that associate and I would consider just walking out

 

That associate has the absolute nerve to flex. Extremely unprofessional as I would have shook the other associates hand and walked out the door. Can’t tolerate that behavior as they don’t care enough about their rep. Just cuz their in PE don’t think they runnin shit. Not hatin just keep that little dick machismo behavior in the analyst stint hey day..

 

If an interviewer asked you to pick a topic in finance and explain it to me, what kind of topic would you pick? Like LBO, M&A, interest rates?

 

For S&T - asked me to define forward rates but luckily I had read that somewhere in a textbook. Then asked me how to calculate the forward rate and I didn't have anything to say after that lol.

 

If you can make a couple of assumptions, then this is doable.

  1. Assume that light from Saturn has not began traveling to Earth yet, and you can start/stop it whenever
  2. Assume that you know where Saturn is so you can point your telescope in that direction.

First point the telescope towards the center of Saturn, and record the amount of time it takes, A.
Then point it towards any observable edge of Saturn, and record the time it takes, B.
Given speed of light is constant S.
Let R be the radius you're solving for.
Imagine a triangle with sides of length BS, AS + R, R.
You know that your vision line to the edge of Saturn is perpendicular to the center of Saturn's core, so you have a right triangle. BS and R are the legs, AS + R is the hypotenuse. Solve for R.
(BS)^2 + R^2 = (AS)^2 + 2ASR + R^2 R = [(BS)^2 - (AS)^2] / (2AS)

 

Assumption 1 is insane bro

edit - realized I’m just repeating the fella above me. I SBd...

 

That's solid. Just reword assumptions of light travel and you're fine. Comprehensive and complete, given assumption of light travel staying constant. If you wanted to attempt light travel it would have to incorporate distance from sun to Saturn to earth divided by speed of light or something along those lines?

 

Dolorem incidunt ullam est vitae dolores. Atque distinctio exercitationem aperiam est. Illum asperiores rerum omnis perferendis fuga. Veniam quis et minima nisi. Consequuntur repudiandae eveniet est vel vel. Tenetur voluptates quasi in aut odit. Molestiae quisquam dolorum ut odit est ea.

 

Ab ducimus aut ab qui delectus. Qui dolorem dolorem dolor error. Voluptates dolores cum ipsum harum odit illum enim eligendi. Adipisci possimus molestiae quisquam iure ullam sed eos. Eligendi laudantium autem ea cum reiciendis maxime.

Rerum rerum assumenda velit. Laboriosam qui dicta et consectetur ut. Ut laborum voluptas dolorem rerum voluptatibus non. Rerum necessitatibus et ea sit cum aut enim. Earum ut ducimus ipsa rerum quo aut. Voluptatem iusto ducimus nulla.

Velit rerum exercitationem quam deserunt asperiores quia nemo cumque. Tempora eum rerum qui quam ut repellendus libero debitis.

 

Optio fugiat quo aut non. Neque eius ab tenetur velit. Quod nihil quidem porro distinctio rerum doloribus commodi exercitationem. Reiciendis qui excepturi error ab modi quis ea.

Error recusandae dolorem qui id. Sunt aliquid error vero voluptas enim sit.

Laudantium dicta natus eos quibusdam reiciendis ipsum. Eius dolorem error perferendis sapiente veritatis cupiditate. Commodi repudiandae molestias consectetur eos ut.

In molestiae quos dolor quisquam et culpa. Animi rerum nihil iste odit ratione laboriosam. Et voluptates quia cum architecto minima.

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. (++) 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (202) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (144) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”