Capital Markets in Real Estate firms–What do they exactly do?
Hi, I was wondering what exactly a capital market division in a big real estate firm (i.e. Newmark Knight Frank, CBRE, etc) would do. Do they perform similar functions to Capital Markets divisions in IBs like MS or CS? I am trying to learn about this industry, and it would be great if someone could explain what capital markets division in these real estate firms would usually do.
From experience in Australia, the capital market teams at CBRE and Knight Frank typically are the facilitators/brokers between capital transactions, i.e when a vendor sells an asset, they represent the vendor to interest parties.
I see, so they share a similar role to that of CM divisions in IBs, right? or is it different?
Different. - Capital Markets in IB tend to focus on raising debt/equity capital. - work with REITs to raise capital for new acquisitions
I guess its more like M&A analyst who are given a directive by a PE firm that they want to sell an operating company in their fund. Running an auction process, data room access etc. Except real estate acquisitions are considerably less complicated than acquiring a firm.
Are you familiar with a real estate broker, this is literally the most professional way of calling.
Calling RE Brokerage as Capital Markets, is like calling a Bank Teller a Liquidity Services Coordinator
Harsh but true
Made me LOL
LOL
Especially when we're talking about Knight Frank...
There are two main types of Capital Markets Divisions within a Real Estate Investment Bank, also referred to as a Commerical Brokerage - Investment Sales (IS) and Debt/Equity Placement (D/E). IS are the brokers responsible for selling an asset and the D/E brokers are responsible for facilitiating the financing transactions with either debt or equity providers. Another more detailed-oriented subset is also Mergers and Aquisitions of real estate firms, however that is more commonly (95%+) handled by investment banks (BB/MM) or large RE Capital Market Brokerages/Investment Banks like Eastdil Secured, HFF/JLL, etc.
JLL isn't a RE investment bank and you can't claim brokerage houses are RE investment banks either. Investment sales is not true capital markets. Debt & equity guys are more so capital markets than IS, but still not truly there. Look up to see what anon VP said about RE brokerage, it's on point.
True capital markets in CRE are the guys involved in the securitization of mortgage bonds, trading them on the secondary and knowing how to price those bonds. That's true capital markets, not "brokerage" aka sales.
Think what he was more referring to the fact that JLL does have an actual IB/M&A division. Even more so after their acquisition of HFF.
So how do you discern whether or not a capital markets role is moreso brokerage or actual RE securitization?
If you don’t use Bloomberg terminal, you are not in capital market, it is that simple
What is/isn't "investment banking" and "capital markets" is usually a dick measuring contest for corporate finance hardos/analysts who have convinced themselves that IB only gets done at the bulge bracket banks. In reality, their job description is very similar to an RE cap markets analyst. You will work for a lead banker/broker/producer whose main job is to bring deals in the door and make a market (connect buyers with sellers and capital sources with capital users).
In both jobs, you'll spending a ton of time making meaningless pitch books in powerpoint that no one will read, underwriting deals in excel, running due diligence and coordinating closing. The only difference is really the "asset" that is transacting. Investment Bankers are brokers too in the purest sense of the word.
While the securitizing of loans doesn't happen at RE brokerages, book-running doesn't happen on the deal teams at Investment Banks either, and neither of those positions are particularly sexy or financially lucrative. Whether you're actually the firm packaging securities or not, that piece of the puzzle is still getting "outsourced" in a way.
The barriers to entry in real estate capital markets are generally much lower. Those that call RE Cap Mkts not true capital markets are more defending the culture of high brow finance than the content of the actual work itself.
There are certainly tiers in RE Cap Markets - Eastdil, HFF/JLL, CBRE, followed by: Walker Dunlop, Cushman, Berkadia, NorthMarq After that, I would say that the sophistication level has a pretty steep drop off, much steeper than your typical Investment Banks - but generally speaking, at the top level, the work is similar with the biggest differences being the asset that is marketed and probably the hours expectations/size of the analyst pools.
Completely agree with Mister Shhh. One additional nuance is with agency lending (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, etc.) for which the capital markets intermediary actually originates the loan and holds it on their balance sheet until it is securitized with the other loans in the pool. The broker is temporarily the lender, then sells the loan (to Freddie Mac for example), and is retained to service the loan (e.g., collect payments, manage borrower requests, run inspections), hence the title "Seller/Servicer."
This can be upwards of 50% of a firm's capital markets debt business depending on their focus and other lending activity. The Seller/Servicer designations that allows companies to do this business can be thought of like taxi medallions in NYC given that they're finite and how they function.
Yeah, the super lean team is doing billions in deals. The producer gets a fee. There are fees for seller/servicer or DUS (which is more complicated), interest when sitting in the warehouse line, servicing the loan, etc.
"$1 of agency debt is the equivalent of $7 somewhere else."
Not sure if it is 1:7, but I heard that all summer and the most successful/office head producers are usually on the debt side, mostly multi-debt, most of that multi-debt? Agency.
Porro explicabo repudiandae dolorem velit sunt natus odio. Labore sunt quod repellat eligendi cum facilis quidem qui. Culpa blanditiis praesentium esse nostrum sed omnis.
Aut facere consequatur pariatur corrupti rerum quae maxime consequatur. Nihil beatae et aliquid quas voluptas laudantium incidunt.
Laborum rem aliquid dicta sit. Nihil culpa illo modi possimus necessitatibus. Eius et officia ex ipsum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...