Who would you hire?
HF
Tags:
(Senior Monkey, 89
Points)
on 6/15/10 at 3:10am
3.9+ EE, CS majors & math finance minor
w/o finance internships
3.75 econ
w/ entrepreneurial internships
3.6 business (finance conc) & stats major & math finance minor
w/ consulting internship
sounds super insecure but whatever






entrepreneurial.....internshi
entrepreneurial.....internship? I don't get it, so he interned with a start-up, or did he start up his own business?
1. 3.75 econ w/ entrepreneurial internships
2. 3.6 business (finance conc) & stats major & math finance minor w/ consulting internship
3. 3.9+ EE, CS majors & math finance minor w/o finance internships
lots of details
lots of details missing
assuming same school? Target ? ivy? non -target?
for the internships, it depends on the brand name. A consulting internship can mean mckinsey or it can mean a small no name shop...
The question by the OP is easy to answer:
brand name schools matter
brand name internships matter (though you cant be doing crap or back office division)
More "brand names" you have, the better
semi-target entrepreneurial
semi-target
entrepreneurial as in started a small "company" that really didn't go anywhere
...what position is this
...what position is this for
and resume/experience is only half the game
The kid with the best
The kid with the best personality.
7S wrote: ...what position is
...what position is this for
tradinggg
3.9+ EE, CS majors & math
3.9+ EE, CS majors & math finance minor
w/o finance internships
>> Probably the hardest majors of the group with the best gpa, but would guess the worst personality by far since he probably spent 95% of college in front of a computer instead of having fun.
3.75 econ
w/ entrepreneurial internships
>> Probably the weakest of the group based on what you gave, any minors? Finance classes would help but a lot of Econ majors do more theoretical material which isn't as applicable
3.6 business (finance conc) & stats major & math finance minor
w/ consulting internship
>> Stats definitely helps, would likely get a few brain busters for trading interview
Overall depends on personality though, if you all get the interview it's almost entirely on what they think of you during the interview.
I'm pretty sure EECS guy is
I'm pretty sure EECS guy is having fun... would the other two resumes be thrown out in comparison to this guy?
I'd hire the guy who had
I'd hire the guy who had enough self confidence not to ask this question
Modeling Training
Finance Interviews Guide
Resume Review