Backup Withholding

Backup withholding is the practice of withholding taxes on certain types of income before tax season.

Author: Christy Grimste
Christy Grimste
Christy Grimste
Real Estate | Investment Property Sales

Christy currently works as a senior associate for EdR Trust, a publicly traded multi-family REIT. Prior to joining EdR Trust, Christy works for CBRE in investment property sales. Before completing her MBA and breaking into finance, Christy founded and education startup in which she actively pursued for seven years and works as an internal auditor for the U.S. Department of State and CIA.

Christy has a Bachelor of Arts from the University of Maryland and a Master of Business Administrations from the University of London.

Reviewed By: Himanshu Singh
Himanshu Singh
Himanshu Singh
Investment Banking | Private Equity

Prior to joining UBS as an Investment Banker, Himanshu worked as an Investment Associate for Exin Capital Partners Limited, participating in all aspects of the investment process, including identifying new investment opportunities, detailed due diligence, financial modeling & LBO valuation and presenting investment recommendations internally.

Himanshu holds an MBA in Finance from the Indian Institute of Management and a Bachelor of Engineering from Netaji Subhas Institute of Technology.

Last Updated:August 7, 2023

Most investors will have diversified portfolios to streamline multiple income sources. Not only does this diversity of income ensure that if one investment fails, an investor will not lose all their income, but it will also allow them to access more types of income.

These are asset appreciation, dividends, interest, rent, commissions, gambling, etc. All these sources of income provide an investor with a multitude of income. Although these sources are considered income, most are filed separately on tax returns.

For example, dividends have their section of a tax return form, while some forms of cash are considered regular income. This creates a complicated tax filing system for an investor with multiple income choices. 

An investor may miscalculate or forget an income that they earned. This could lead to investors spending more cash than they think they have. A miscalculation like this could lead investors to owe taxes they no longer have the money to pay.

This is where backup withholding comes from. Backup withholding is a form of tax that is levied on investment income. This rate is a single rate established by the federal government, specifically the IRS.

This tax is taken or withheld when an investor withdrawals a certain type of investment. The prophet game from this investment is then taxed at the rate established and withheld from the investor and given directly to the government.

The solution comes from the very problem stated above. When an investor spends more cash while disregarding the tax on their investments, when it comes to paying tax, the investor will not have enough to pay off any tax owed.

This creates a large problem for the IRS. When an investor can't pay tax, the IRS must go through the lengthy process of collecting that tax through repositioning assets and selling those assets. This process takes a long time and often isn't worth the tax owed.

Backup holding allows investors to ensure they don't forget the taxes they owe and that the IRS will not have to deal with collecting any taxes that were not paid. These problems often occur due to the nature of investment tax and tax season.

Because investment taxes are often taxed, the second Investments are received. For things like selling stocks or receiving dividends, I tax the second the investor receives them, but they are all listed once during tax season.

This creates a window word that investors can use all of the cash received from these Investments without regarding the taxes they would have to pay in the future. This often causes investors to spend all of the profits they made from Investments without saving any for taxes.

With backup withholding, investors will lose a portion of the profits they make from investments and have a smaller short-term income, but it will save them the hassle of needing to calculate and pay any taxes during tax season.

Key Takeaways

  • Backup withholding is the practice of withholding taxes on certain types of income before tax season.
  • The IRS can require you to withhold taxes.
  • You can be required to withhold if you use the incorrect TIN or enter other incorrect information.
  • The best way to avoid withholding is to double-check your tax returns and file them correctly.

Backup Withholding Importance

Backup withholding is crucial for the financial stability of an investor. When an investor is deemed to be risky, the IRS will force a taxpayer to withhold to make sure that the taxpayer will faithfully pay their taxes. 

Some of the important ones are:

1. Stability
By getting rid of this possible roadblock in the future, all the remaining profits from your investments are completely free to be used however you wish. This often is used to buy even more assets to invest in.

Note

It is important to ensure that you will not owe taxes during tax season, the assets you have bought with your investment profits will not have to be sold to make up any lost taxes.

Most smart investors would use this system to their advantage. I'm making sure that your Investments stay tax-free. It ensures that your assets will not have to be sold and that they will stay and accumulate wealth throughout the years. 

2. Simplicity
Although financial stability is a benefit of this type of system, not only will withholding these taxes improve your future outlook and safeguard you from any possible tax mistakes, but it will also make filing taxes much simpler.

This can speed up the process of filing your tax returns. Most citizens will spend most of their time filing taxes by calculating the taxes owed.

Note

By prepaying these taxes, you will have files and access to all the taxes you have paid before and still owe.

Why Are Investors Required To Withhold?

There are multiple reasons why investors may have backup withholding applied to them. These include when an investor has not met the rules regarding taxpayer identification numbers or TIN. 

Investors also may be forced to use backup withholding if they did not provide a correct TIN number or if they had not reported dividend interest or other forms of investment income to the IRS.

Another common reason why withholdings are required is that you or your broker have not reported dividend or interest income from Investments.

Although all these problems are less common than they used to be due to the automated reporting of investment income from brokerages or accounting services online. 

The services will automatically send all notices of income through investments to the IRS through your social security number and other identification.

Although these occurrences are rare, they still do happen. It's important to ensure you are current about all rules and regulations regarding backup withholding. All these situations are different and entail different things for an investor.

Let us understand why investors are required to withhold:

1. Withholding due to incorrect information 
The most common reason for an investor to be required to withhold tax is that the taxpayer question did not provide the correct TIN or they failed to report interest dividend or patronage dividend income.

These qualities make a taxpayer seem as if they are irresponsible in their taxes. Failing to provide the information necessary to calculate taxes shows the IRS that an individual is not financially responsible for paying taxes properly. 

Therefore, in most scenarios, the taxpayer will be required to withhold tax to ensure they don't miss any tax payments when they must file taxes.

Note

Under the IRS, this is known as a BWH-B program.

2. Withholding due to unreported income 

Although this is less common, the IRS also can require you to withhold if you or your broker does not report income in the form of dividends or interest. 

Dividends and interest are filed separately on your tax returns and, therefore, are subject to different taxes. If they're not properly filed or given to the IRS, it makes the process of filing taxes much more difficult. 

This problem has become less widespread due to the advancement of brokerages and pocket stock trading. Brokerages now, especially those with large investors, will often have automatic reporting or mobile apps that investors can use to file, look at, and calculate tax.

Note

Under the IRS, this is commonly known as the BWH-C program.

3. Exempt status 
Most US citizens are exempt from backup withholding. Backup withholding is generally reserved for taxpayers who have proven that they are financially unwise with the income they get from Investments.

Because of this risky nature, the IRS will tend to require these taxpayers to backup Withhold to make sure they can pay their taxes during tax season.

As long as you file your tax form correctly with your tax identification number or TIN, you will not have to worry about backup withholding.

How To Avoid Backup Withholding

The simplest way to avoid Backup withholding is to ensure all your tax returns are in order and filed correctly. This means using your correct TIN and ensuring all taxable income is written down on your tax returns.

If this is not doable, it is in your best interest to backup withholding. Some people's lives are chaotic; others may be behind in taxes or asset income. If this is the case, the IRS will notify you of needing backup withholding.

If you are currently backup withholding, the only way to get rid of it is to begin filing your taxes correctly. Ensure you are using the correct TIN, have listed all your income, and have calculated your tax accurately.

This may take a few years, and a few tax returns before the IRS revokes the backup withholding requirement for you. The IRS needs to ensure you can pay your taxes without having to withhold any. Properly paying your taxes for the next few years proves that.

Note

Hiring an accountant could be a good option if you simply can't file taxes yourself.  You can also try selling some assets to simplify your income stream to simplify filing your taxes.

Summary

In summary, Backup withholding is a policy the IRS will use to ensure that unreliable taxpayers will pay their taxes on time and ensure that the IRS will be able to collect taxes during tax season.

Backup withholding works by immediately collecting taxes whenever an investor obtains a stream of income from an asset or securities. 

Because assets and securities can spring up income throughout the year, it makes it more difficult to keep track of compared to a regular job or stream of income. This increases the likelihood that a taxpayer could forget these pieces of income or disregard them entirely.

The IRS doesn't like tracking taxpayers when they fail to pay taxes. This starts a long goose-chase of selling assets and trying to make back losses. 

To counter this, the IRS requires taxpayers that fail to write down sources of income to withhold taxes.

To avoid this requirement, it should be noted that the main reasons why a taxpayer will be required to backup withhold is that they use the incorrect TIN number on their tax return or they failed to report any income from assets.

Research and Written by William Hernandez-Han | LinkedIn

Reviewed & Edited by Alexander Bellucci | LinkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources: