Equity Sales vs. High-Grade Corporates Trading
Which would you rather do? Please assume the bank has equal strengths in both groups
Which would you rather do? Please assume the bank has equal strengths in both groups
+32 | Help: GS SF S&T vs JPM NY S&T | 22 | 8h | |
+15 | Full Time Timeline | 1 | 3d | |
+13 | Iron Ore Trading? | 12 | 2d | |
+12 | Job roles with more client experience | 1 | 5d | |
+12 | Tips for a beginning commodities trader? | 1 | 4d | |
+9 | Question on SA 2025 SnT timings | 1 | 19h | |
+9 | I had my superday friday afternoon, when do you think I will hear back? | 1 | 5d | |
+9 | Best programming languages to learn for energy trading | 1 | 5d | |
+7 | Questions as a college freshman | 2 | 4d | |
+4 | Bulge Bracket Sales and Trading rankings | 12 | 15h |
Career Resources
thats not even close, HG Corporates Trading...
I'd do HG Corporates
they are 2 totally different choices. what would you rather do? dont ask a board full of high school seniors what sounds cooler on your business card when talking to girls who dont know what youre talking about in the first place.
Was that aimed at me?
Regardless, you are correct that they are two very different roles. On one hand, you have equity sales... a role that is quickly becoming less and less relevant (with computer platforms accounting for more and more volume). Ask any experienced trader (or almost anyone) in the industry if they think you should start in equities or a fixed income product. The majority, if not all, would say go with FI. Also, we can sit here and argue all we want but everyone knows the truth... it is FAR easier to start in trading and transition to sales (if you don't like trading) than vice versa.
By equity sales I did not mean "sales-trading". I meant equity-sales - they are two very different things. In equity sales you pitch ideas etc to portfolio managers and buy-side analysts, there will always be a demand for this regardless of what happens with technology. However, sales-traders on the other hand may become less needed as trading becomes more automated. To me both equity sales and HG corporate bond trading both sound cool but for different reasons of course. I wanted get other people's thoughts and opinions as well.
HG Corps...IMO a FI background provides a better platform off which to launch a career. Plain vanilla equity sales....it doesn't take too much salesmanship to sell common stock
I appreciate your opinion but I have to disagree that it doesn't take too much salesmanship to sell common stock. Clients are portfolio managers that are being inundated with long/short equity ideas from several different sales guys every day all stressing the urgency of their ideas and why action is necessary. People only buy stocks for one reason, to make money, and the sales guys that have the best money making ideas are going to be the ones that are more successful. This is difficult regardless of what the product is.
As far as launching a career goes, good money making sales guys can work at hedge funds in their respective products, whether that be equities, fixed income, derivatives, or anything else.
PM's get paid 2/20 to generate their own ideas/alpha. By the time a PM makes the decision to go long/short a common stock they have done their own research and may not even talk to a salesperson to execute.
I think if the sales group that you are considering has a heavy tilt towards a research-intensive sales process then it may be rewarding and a good launching pad for a career in finance. However all firms have dedicated research and strategy departments to produce alpha generating ideas. I'm not sure how much research/strategy experience you would get sitting on an institutional equity sales desk. Having a deep research/strategy background will make you a more compelling candidate for buyside opportunities.
If the goal is exiting to the buyside, I still think the experience in FI trading would be more valuable (disclaimer - I am a FI professional and have some bias here)
Again I appreciate the comments, but I'm not sure how familiar you are with what equity sales guys do, again I'm not talking about sales-traders, I'm talking about institutional equity salesmen. I have worked as a junior person on an equity sales desk and the senior sales guys are constantly pitching the banks best ideas all day long to PM's (both from research as well as their own ideas) - most PM's do not generate their own equity ideas - I've made calls on behalf of the desk to all different types of PM's to ask what they want more of and they all say to call with more ideas. They get paid 2/20 to pick the best ideas not necessarily to come up with them on their own. There's no way they can keep track of everything that's going on out there - even with internal research. A sales guy's job is to convince them of why his idea is the best.
When I originally posted this question - what would you rather do, equity sales or hg trading - I wasn't aware that so many people don't even know what equity sales guys do - or even that many of the better ones become PM's of l/s equity funds if they leave the sell side. Thanks anyways for trying to help though.
Let me ask a follow-up question. Are you selling cash equities, equity derivatives or both. In a market like Equities, where things are very transparent and most products trade on exchanges, it's very tough to add value or generate sales credits. If you're structuring exotic equity derivatives, there is a lot of opportunities to add value.
I think Corporates trading is the better of the two options. Just keep in mind it's not what it used to be. TRACE has made the market much more difficult to trade in.
Ea autem ad assumenda. Ullam error illo non minima quia laudantium consectetur repudiandae. Alias facere unde amet neque molestias exercitationem occaecati. Quia natus quis dolorum maxime culpa veniam provident.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...