finance opportunities: NYC vs. Chicago
ST
Tags:
(Orangutan, 292
Points)
on 3/15/10 at 1:28pm
Obviously NYC has more finance jobs due to its size. But do you guys think that the finance opportunities and networking in NYC is THAT much better than Chicago?





hands down NYC
hands down NYC
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I tend to think of myself as a one-man wolfpack
Buyside strongside
rooster wrote: hands down
hands down NYC
investment banking yes, but can the same be said for trading and hedge funds?
NYC
NYC
aside from prop trading, it's
aside from prop trading, it's easily NYC. more jobs and better networking available. hate to sound elitist, but the brightest ivy league kids do tend to move to NYC while Chicago mainly gets the big 10 alumni.
i would agree with you guys
i would agree with you guys on the nyc for i-banking for sure because there is more there and more hedge funds as well. It's the same for trading though.
jjc1122 wrote: aside from
aside from prop trading, it's easily NYC. more jobs and better networking available. hate to sound elitist, but the brightest ivy league kids do tend to move to NYC while Chicago mainly gets the big 10 alumni.
NYC does get the ivies, true, but you are assuming that all the best and brightest from every area of the country go to ivy league schools. Let me be the one to burst your bubble: they don't. And while ivies are certainly among the most competitive schools, the fact is that the top 100 students at University of Illinois are almost certainly as smart and talented as the top 100 Columbia or Dartmouth or Yale. People attend ivies because they're smart, but also because they have rich parents. Don't discount the latter characteristic as a primary driver of the student population at these schools. And its just different out east. If you're a top student with rich parents in NY or MA, where are you going to go, Binghamton? UMASS? Rutgers? Obviously not because those schools kinda suck, with apologies to any WSO alumni.
Not the case in the Midwest or west Coast where you have loads of public and private options, including the relatively cheap in state option. Unlike the shit public universities out east (UVA excepted), the Big 10 schools are by and large very very good schools. For kids in Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Califonia, etc. the college picture is quite different. So when a firm in Chicago "gets the big 10 alumni" its not like it was with a tear in their eye. The fucking MD is probably from a Big 10 school. And he's making just as much cash as any of the MDs anywhere else in the firm.
Full disclosure: I went to an Ivy league school
NYC hands down
NYC hands down
jhoratio wrote: jjc1122
aside from prop trading, it's easily NYC. more jobs and better networking available. hate to sound elitist, but the brightest ivy league kids do tend to move to NYC while Chicago mainly gets the big 10 alumni.
NYC does get the ivies, true, but you are assuming that all the best and brightest from every area of the country go to ivy league schools. Let me be the one to burst your bubble: they don't. And while ivies are certainly among the most competitive schools, the fact is that the top 100 students at University of Illinois are almost certainly as smart and talented as the top 100 Columbia or Dartmouth or Yale. People attend ivies because they're smart, but also because they have rich parents. Don't discount the latter characteristic as a primary driver of the student population at these schools. And its just different out east. If you're a top student with rich parents in NY or MA, where are you going to go, Binghamton? UMASS? Rutgers? Obviously not because those schools kinda suck, with apologies to any WSO alumni.
Not the case in the Midwest or west Coast where you have loads of public and private options, including the relatively cheap in state option. Unlike the shit public universities out east (UVA excepted), the Big 10 schools are by and large very very good schools. For kids in Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Califonia, etc. the college picture is quite different. So when a firm in Chicago "gets the big 10 alumni" its not like it was with a tear in their eye. The fucking MD is probably from a Big 10 school. And he's making just as much cash as any of the MDs anywhere else in the firm.
Full disclosure: I went to an Ivy league school
I agree that the midwest has better state schools than the northeast. I disagree though on your assertion that the top students at a big 10 school are on the same level as the top students at ivies. There's a reason why top financial firms and top graduate programs recruit so heavily from the ivies, especially harvard, princeton, wharton, yale.
Regarding money, it's true that there's a fair share of rich kids at these schools, but most students get financial aid. The ivies have gotten very serious about getting talented students from middle and working class backgrounds. Harvard and Princeton for instance give out need-based grants to students whose parents cannot afford the price tag.
Look, I'm not bashing the big ten; michigan and northwestern are great schools and illinois has a solid engineering program. But with regards to finance, NYC still gets the cream of the crop. This is just anecdotal, but the only chicago firms that top ivy kids would take over NYC are citadel, getco, and the chicago office of elite consulting firms like mckinsey.
you'll have a much better
you'll have a much better experience in ny. also have to consider that resources in satellite offices are limited (graphics / pitchbook production / etc.)
jhoratio wrote: jjc1122
aside from prop trading, it's easily NYC. more jobs and better networking available. hate to sound elitist, but the brightest ivy league kids do tend to move to NYC while Chicago mainly gets the big 10 alumni.
NYC does get the ivies, true, but you are assuming that all the best and brightest from every area of the country go to ivy league schools. Let me be the one to burst your bubble: they don't. And while ivies are certainly among the most competitive schools, the fact is that the top 100 students at University of Illinois are almost certainly as smart and talented as the top 100 Columbia or Dartmouth or Yale. People attend ivies because they're smart, but also because they have rich parents. Don't discount the latter characteristic as a primary driver of the student population at these schools. And its just different out east. If you're a top student with rich parents in NY or MA, where are you going to go, Binghamton? UMASS? Rutgers? Obviously not because those schools kinda suck, with apologies to any WSO alumni.
Not the case in the Midwest or west Coast where you have loads of public and private options, including the relatively cheap in state option. Unlike the shit public universities out east (UVA excepted), the Big 10 schools are by and large very very good schools. For kids in Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Califonia, etc. the college picture is quite different. So when a firm in Chicago "gets the big 10 alumni" its not like it was with a tear in their eye. The fucking MD is probably from a Big 10 school. And he's making just as much cash as any of the MDs anywhere else in the firm.
Full disclosure: I went to an Ivy league school
Very well put. I totally agree. I attended a small private school but most of my friends attended large state schools and I have met a ton of top notch, genuine genius level people...although none wanted to work in finance. And, for what it's worth, many friends from HS had 4.0+ GPAs and it seems the more wealthy attended Ivies or well regarded private schools where as the equally qualified yet less affluent went to state schools.
Regards
"The trouble with our liberal friends is not that they're ignorant, it's just that they know so much that isn't so."
- Ronald Reagan
cphbravo96 wrote: jhoratio
aside from prop trading, it's easily NYC. more jobs and better networking available. hate to sound elitist, but the brightest ivy league kids do tend to move to NYC while Chicago mainly gets the big 10 alumni.
NYC does get the ivies, true, but you are assuming that all the best and brightest from every area of the country go to ivy league schools. Let me be the one to burst your bubble: they don't. And while ivies are certainly among the most competitive schools, the fact is that the top 100 students at University of Illinois are almost certainly as smart and talented as the top 100 Columbia or Dartmouth or Yale. People attend ivies because they're smart, but also because they have rich parents. Don't discount the latter characteristic as a primary driver of the student population at these schools. And its just different out east. If you're a top student with rich parents in NY or MA, where are you going to go, Binghamton? UMASS? Rutgers? Obviously not because those schools kinda suck, with apologies to any WSO alumni.
Not the case in the Midwest or west Coast where you have loads of public and private options, including the relatively cheap in state option. Unlike the shit public universities out east (UVA excepted), the Big 10 schools are by and large very very good schools. For kids in Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Califonia, etc. the college picture is quite different. So when a firm in Chicago "gets the big 10 alumni" its not like it was with a tear in their eye. The fucking MD is probably from a Big 10 school. And he's making just as much cash as any of the MDs anywhere else in the firm.
Full disclosure: I went to an Ivy league school
Very well put. I totally agree. I attended a small private school but most of my friends attended large state schools and I have met a ton of top notch, genuine genius level people...although none wanted to work in finance. And, for what it's worth, many friends from HS had 4.0+ GPAs and it seems the more wealthy attended Ivies or well regarded private schools where as the equally qualified yet less affluent went to state schools.
Regards
Yes, there are smart kids at state schools. And some of them do turn down ivy league schools to attend them. But the cream of the crop still flock to the top ivies, along with MIT and Stanford. Very few people turn down schools like harvard or yale to attend illinois or ohio state.
I know a kid who turned down
I know a kid who turned down a full ride to Dartmouth for Illinois... (full ride due to sports)