Revenue Recognition Principle

What is the Revenue Recognition Principle?

The revenue recognition principle determines the method and timing by which revenue is recorded and recognized as an item in a company's financial statements. Theoretically, there are numerous times when businesses could recognize revenue. 

Generally speaking, revenue is thought to be more critical to the organization and to pose a dependability risk the earlier it is recorded. One of the areas of accounting that is most prone to bias and manipulation is revenue recognition.

Given the degree of judgment required, it is believed that a sizable fraction of all accounting fraud is caused by problems with revenue recognition. It's crucial to comprehend the principle while reviewing financial statements.

According to this rule, revenue should only be recorded after earned and not until the associated currency has been received. For its typical charge of $100, a snow removal firm might clear the parking lot of a business. 

Even if it doesn't anticipate receiving money from the customer for a few weeks, it can record the revenue as soon as the plowing is finished. The accrual basis of accounting considers this idea.

A variation in the scenario is when the same snow plowing service gets paid $1,000 in advance to shovel a customer's parking lot over four months. 

To reflect the rate at which it is earning money in this situation, the service should recognize an increment of the advance payment for each of the four months covered by the agreement.

A generally accepted accounting standard (GAAP) called revenue recognition specifies the particular circumstances under which revenue is recognized and how to account for it. 

Revenue is typically realized when a significant event occurs, and the corporation can quantify the financial amount.

Understanding the Revenue Recognition Principle

As its name implies, this principle is an accounting principle utilized in both IFRS and GAAP and outlines the precise circumstances under which a company must recognize revenue. 

Any corporation conducting operations internationally must adhere to either IFRS or GAAP standards for the principle. The foundation of any corporate performance is revenue. 

The sale is the keystone. Regulators are aware of how alluring it may be for businesses to stretch the boundaries of what constitutes income, particularly when not all cash is collected until the task is finished. 

Attorneys, for instance, bill their clients according to billable hours and then present the invoice. Clients are frequently billed by the percentage of completion by construction managers.

Revenue accounting is quite simple when a product is sold, and the revenue is recognized when the customer makes a purchase. However, accounting for income can become challenging when a business takes a long time to develop a product. 

This principle can therefore be disregarded in several circumstances. As a result, analysts prefer that all companies adopt industry-wide standards for this principle. 

When examining line items on the income statement, having a standardized revenue recognition rule makes it easier to compare businesses similarly. A company's income recognition policies should not change over time to allow for analyzing and examining past financial data for seasonal trends or discrepancies.

According to the ASC 606 principle, revenue must be recorded when promised products or services are delivered and are worth the same as what the company anticipated they would receive in exchange. 

The accrual accounting characteristic known as the recognition of revenue principle states that revenues must be recorded on the income statement in the period they are realized and generated, not necessarily when cash is received. 

Realizable refers to a situation when a customer has received products or services, but payment is still anticipated in the future. Earned revenue represents the money that has been spent on goods or services that have been rendered.

For the revenue-generating activity to be included in revenue for the relevant accounting period, it must be finished or almost finished.

Additionally, there needs to be some assurance that the generated revenue payment will be received. The matching principle also mandates that revenue and related costs must be reported in the same accounting period.

fundamentals Of Revenue recognition Principle

The revenue generated by a sale must be recorded for it to appear on the income statement when a company makes a sale. This brings up the issue of when that revenue should be recognized. 

The recognition of revenue principle explains that for a corporation to record the income from a transaction and, in essence, when it may be considered "earned," certain requirements must be completed.

The Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) include the recognition of revenue concept, which is a crucial feature of the accrual basis of accounting (GAAP). 

To eliminate inconsistencies and provide a more robust framework to direct businesses in their accrual accounting, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) recently unveiled a new set of guidelines relating to the recognition of revenue. 

These guidelines are intended to provide a more robust framework for businesses. You must complete the following five steps to achieve the recognition of the revenue process:

1. Sign a contract with a client.
2. Concur on the company's responsibilities under the contract.
3. Concur on the transaction's cost.
4. Distribute the cost among the commitments.
5. Fulfill the contract's requirements and accurately report the revenue.

It's significant to note that obtaining money for the goods or services given is not one of these five conditions. 

The difference between the accrual basis of accounting and the cash basis of accounting, which mandates that revenue is recognized after a cash payment is received, will be discussed in greater detail later.

Different techniques for recognizing revenue

There are numerous formats for recognition of revenue that numerous businesses kinds can use. It makes sense that businesses would differ in how they finally record their revenue since real estate agents have a completely different business strategy from apparel merchants. 

Whatever approach a business takes must adhere to the same rules to comply with the principle. The following are some of the popular techniques for recognition of revenue:

Sales-Based Method

When both parties concur on the terms of the transaction, in this format, the entire revenue for sale is recognized. Businesses that offer pre-produced goods frequently employ this technique. 

In other words, there is merely a transfer of title following the transaction and no necessary work. As a result, generating revenue has already started, and it is finished with the contract's execution.

Installment Strategy 

For certain businesses, it's unlikely that they'll get paid in full for sale at the moment the service is provided. In these circumstances, they might decide to report the revenue in installments if they anticipate getting paid in cash.

Finished-Contract Approach

This is a common approach used by software companies, which primarily works in short-term implementations. With this approach, the total revenue for a particular project is recorded once it is finished.

Percentage Of Completion

The completed contract method may not be feasible logistically for contracts with extensive durations, such as those in the construction industry. 

The percentage-of-completion approach is then used by businesses to calculate the amount of revenue that has been earned over a given period of time-based on the work completed and the costs invested.

Revenue Recognition Principle requirement

It makes sense that money is the lifeblood of every enterprise. Higher sales show improved performance for the business. As a result, businesses may attempt to change their accounts to reflect a more extensive collection of income. 

To accurately portray the company's performance to investors and shareholders, the regulators have established rules that corporations must follow while compiling their annual reports for disclosure. 

Analysts and investors can compare similar accounting principles to determine whether a company is performing better than its competitors if a predetermined standard must be adhered to.

Criteria For Recognizing Revenue

According to IFRS, the following five criteria must be met to recognize the phenomenon of recognition of revenue on sales of goods:

• The vendor has transferred risks and profits to the buyer.
• The sold goods are not under the seller's control.
• It is reasonably assured that the goods and services will be paid for.
• The revenue can be accurately calculated.

Costs associated with generating the revenue can be calculable.

1. Performance 

Performance is the subject of Conditions (1) and (2). It takes place when the seller has completed the transaction to the extent necessary for him to receive payment.

2. Collectability

Collectability is referenced in Condition (3). A reasonable expectation of payment for the performance must exist for the seller. If the seller is not entirely certain they will receive the cash, an allowance account must be kept.

3. Measurability

The terms Measurability and (4) and (5), respectively. According to the matching principle concept, the seller is required to match the revenues and expenses.

For the Sale of Goods, Revenue Recognition

Most of the time, revenue is realized after a product is delivered when it is sold. Because all five requirements are satisfied at the time of delivery, Whole Foods, for instance, may illustrate this since they record income when clients purchase groceries from them.

Revenue will be recognized at delivery as follows:

The matching principle states that expenses must be taken into account when revenue is recognized for:

Recognizing Revenue Before and After Delivery

The IFRS guidelines for sales of goods prohibit recognition of revenue before delivery. However, recognition of revenue upon delivery is permitted under IFRS.

As mentioned above, the fifth criterion for recognition of revenue is broken in cases when there are doubts regarding the costs related to future costs.

For instance, the conditions are not met if a business cannot accurately project the expenses of a future warranty on a particular product. Revenue may be recognized once the fifth requirement has been satisfied.

Other justifications for recognition of revenue post-delivery include circumstances in which the revenue cannot be accurately estimated (such as contingent sales), unquantifiable refunds, uncertain collectability of receivables, and dangers of ownership reverting to the seller (consignment sales).

Methods for revenue recognition

The procedures for recognizing revenue in an income statement have been described.

1. Finalized Contract Approach: According to this procedure, a transaction's associated revenue is only recorded after completion. This strategy is typically used when there is doubt about getting money from the client.
2. Installation Approach: The seller records the transaction using the installment method when the consumer is given the option to pay for the good or service over a long period.
3. Method of Cost Recovery: According to the cost recovery approach, revenue is only recognized after the consumer has paid the cost factor of the sale in cash.
4. Method of Completion Percentage: Every accounting period that the contract is active allows the seller to record a gain or loss relating to the transaction. This approach is typically used while managing lengthy projects.

Accounting for Revenue Recognition Principle

When there is a question about whether a client will make a payment, the seller should make an allowance for doubtful accounts in the amount by which it is anticipated that the customer would default on its obligation to pay. 

If there is a good chance that no payment will be made, the business shouldn't record any revenue until the payment has been made.

Additionally, if a company receives payment in advance from a client, this payment is recorded as a liability rather than income under the accrual basis of accounting. It cannot classify the payment as revenue until all work required by the contract with the customer has been done.

When cash payment is received, you must record revenue using the cash basis of accounting. For instance, in the situation above, even though the snow plowing business may get money from the customer a few weeks after the operation is finished, it won't record revenue until that point.

Accounting for Revenue in Complex Situations

It can be challenging to determine the precise timing of when revenue should be recognized in many sectors since recognizing revenue involves so many different activities. 

The five-step approach for obtaining revenue recognition under generally accepted accounting principles applies to almost all sectors. 

These actions are described below. 

Step 1: Link the Contract with a Specific Customer

Due to the strong relationship between recognition of revenue and contracts, the contract serves as a key component of revenue recognition. 

Linking contracts to revenue recognition offers a practical framework for determining the timing and amounts of revenue recognition because revenue is frequently recognized during a contract at various periods in time.

Step 2: Note Contractual Performance Obligations

A performance obligation is the unit of account for the products or services a customer has been contractually promised. 

The contract's performance requirements must be specified in detail. Since revenue is seen as recognizable when goods or services are given to the consumer, this is crucial for understanding it.

Step 3: Determine the Price of the Transaction

The contract's assessment of the transaction price. The consideration the client must pay in exchange for receiving products or services is known as the transaction price. Depending on the conditions, the provisions of some contracts may result in a price that can change. 

The contract could include discounts, rebates, fines, or bonuses. Based on the seller's standard operating procedures, corporate guidelines, or public pronouncements, the customer may also reasonably anticipate that the latter will offer a price reduction. 

If so, choose the technique that produces the amount of consideration most likely to be paid and base the transaction price on either that amount or the probability-weighted expected value.

Step 4: Match the Price to Performance Obligations

The next stage is to assign the transaction prices to the performance obligations after the contract's transaction prices and related performance requirements have been determined. 

The fundamental guideline is to assign that price to a performance obligation that best captures the consideration the seller anticipates being due upon fulfilling each performance obligation.

Step 5: Recognize Revenue as Obligations are Fulfilled

The revenue is recorded as soon as the customer receives the goods or services. When the client gets control over the goods or services, this transference is thought to have taken place.

When the seller has the right to payment, when the customer has legal possession of the transferred asset, and when the consumer accepts the asset are signs that obligations have been met. 

Other signs include the transfer of ownership by the seller and the customer's acceptance of the substantial risks and benefits of ownership in connection with the item.

Journal entries for the revenue recognition principle

Some of the entries are:

Deferred revenue and deferred COGS are utilized in place of crediting revenue and debiting COGS. These deferred accounts are closed to actual revenue and COGS once revenue is recognized.

The Principle and the Installment Sales Method

Installment sales are extremely typical in which things are offered with a deferred payment schedule, and payments are made later after the consumer has already got the goods. According to this procedure, income cannot be reported until the consumer has paid.

Advantages of revenue recognition

The advantages of this are numerous. The three primary ones are as follows.

Understanding Of Profits

You may more efficiently and accurately determine how lucrative your company has become as well as the losses component, thanks to revenue recognition. Your ability to balance profits and losses is demonstrated by your profit and loss margin. 

By looking at the profit and loss margin over time, you may better understand how your business has been performing for that period and how your profits have improved or declined over time. 

This provides you with information about your company's financial health, which you may use to make improvements.

Precise Accounting Records

Recognizing and accurately documenting income ensures that your accounting records are dependable for financial reporting. For a complete picture of your company's financial status, the accuracy of accounting records is essential. 

As a business owner, you want to make choices that will support growth in your revenue and reduce losses along the way. Understanding the principle can help ensure that any adjustments you make to your company will be dependable.

Assists With Finance

When you require finance, recognition of revenue may be of assistance. For instance, lenders, creditors, and investors will value the fact that you recognize your revenues because it will help them decide whether or not to provide you with financing. 

These people will be eager to give you long-term loans if your company is stable and to provide you with money so you may increase your profits. They are also more inclined to make investments in your company. Therefore, adhering to revenue recognition is essential if you require finance.

Examples Of Revenue Recognition Principle

Example 1

On December 31st, BOOSH Bowling Alley sold one of its assets to another participant for $100,000. The asset was purchased on January 20 but not delivered until January 31. 

The transaction occurred on December 31, but the purchase wasn't made until January. Therefore the revenue wasn't realized until January 20.

Example 2

PWD offers several services and performs consulting work for Apex. It performed $10000 worth of work in December, but Apex only paid for the consulting services in January. 

As a result, PWD should record the revenue in December since it performed consultancy services in December, even if the payment did not occur until January, by the recognition of the revenue principle.

Example 3

Dresser has several retail locations across the world where it sells apparel. On June 1st, a consumer made a clothing transaction and paid with his credit card. 

Although the transaction took place in June, the credit card company only received payment in July. 

According to the recognition of revenue principle, the purchase made with a credit card is recognized as cash; as a result, Dresser should record the revenue in June.

Example 4

A cleaning business called XYZ Ltd. has agreed to offer services to a client. The business accepted a one-year advance payment of its monthly cost of Rs. 300. 

Since the cleaning provider has not yet rendered the service, this advance payment is seen as deferred revenue expenditure and should be handled as a liability. 

Only after the cleaning business delivers the monthly service as promised to the client does the advance payment, which is, in fact, undeserved, become an asset.

Other instances include

1. paying rent in advance,
2. paying software license fees in advance each year,
3. purchasing insurance in advance, and
4. paying for newspaper subscriptions in advance.

Example 5: Recognizing revenue for companies that sell tangible items

In-store sales of bags and purses are made by a company named Fab Purses. When a consumer first enters your business in the morning, they immediately fall in love with a handcrafted bag. Then, she purchases the purse for $100 cash and departs. 

As soon as you gave her the bag, you immediately received the sum in your hands, making this a case of earned income. Therefore, this payment will be recorded as income in your records.

Another possibility is that someone purchases 5 of your purses for $25,000 after spotting them and ordering them after paying $25,000 for each bag. There is a contract in place, and it states that they will pay the $25,000 in one go after you deliver the 5 handbags to them. 

You will write $25,000 as accrued income rather than as a complete payment. Each time you finish a purse and ship it to a customer, $5000 will be added to your earned revenue.

Only once the purses have been finished and delivered to your customer will you be able to count $25,000 as earned income.

recognized Vs. accruing Vs. deferred revenues

When discussing revenue recognition, the words recognized, accrued, and deferred revenue are frequently used. Here are some definitions and instances of the terms.

Recognized Income

Earned revenue is another name for recognized revenue, which is the amount of money your company receives as payment for goods or services it delivers. You will write recognized revenue as income when you enter it into your accounting records. 

Let's imagine that you operate a physical bakery in New York. A client enters and purchases a red velvet cake. He uses his debit card to make a quick payment or pays cash upfront. Because you received the money right away after delivering the red velvet cake to the customer, this is earned income.

Accrued Income

Another phrase frequently used in recognition of revenue is accrued revenue. Accrued revenue is distinct from earned revenue because it refers to situations in which you have given the good or service but have not yet been paid. 

Since the consumer owes you money, it is listed as a receivable on the balance sheet. Consider the scenario where you must accomplish a task that will take a year. The accrued revenue is reported periodically throughout the year, most likely monthly. 

Even though the payment hasn't arrived, you should still record the accrued revenue. This is typically the case for companies that accept full payment once a project is finished.

Deferred Revenue

Compared to collected and earned revenue, deferred revenue is different. For example, when a consumer pays you, but you haven't yet given them the goods or services, this is known as deferred revenue. 

Because the good or service hasn't yet been delivered, deferred income is viewed as and reported as a liability. In this way, the customer owes it to your company. Consider subscription services like Amazon Prime and Netflix as an example. 

Before their current subscription expires or if they want to keep using the service, customers must pay for the subscription. Since the service will be given once the payment has been received, the prepayment constitutes delayed income.

Which businesses need to worry about the Revenue Principle?

This isn’t reserved for a few businesses as it is important for all types of businesses. However, some businesses need to think about revenue recognition more than others because of how they operate and provide products and services to their customers. 

Subscription-based businesses, such as those which provide memberships require proper recognition of revenue. It should matter to businesses that collect a retainer which is an agreement whereby the customer pays upfront and then gets access to the services offered by the business.

Businesses that will be providing a service for the long term need to pay special attention to the recognition of revenue. For example, if you are in the construction business, you will charge your clients upfront before the work begins. 

You will have to reach milestones along the way, and the complete construction can take months, depending on the particular construction. Correctly recognizing revenue is vital to ensure you are recording and balancing your books precisely. 

If you are still confused, you can take an expert's help. A financial professional can help you figure out if you should be thinking about recognition of revenue or not.

Which Industries Should Be Concerned About Revenue Recognition?

Recognizing revenue is necessary for organizations, not just a select few. However, according to how they run their businesses and the services they offer their clients, certain companies must consider recognition of revenue more than others. 

Businesses that accept retainers—a payment made in advance in exchange for access to the company's services—should be concerned about recognition of revenue.

Companies that plan to offer a service for a long time should pay close attention to the recognition of revenue. For instance, if you work in the construction industry, you would charge your clients upfront before the work starts. 

You will have to accomplish checkpoints along the road, and depending on the construction, it may take months to finish. Recognizing revenue properly is essential to guarantee that you are accurately recording and balancing your books. You can seek the advice of an expert if you're still unclear. 

You can get assistance from a financial expert in determining whether or not you need to consider recognition of revenue.

Principle of revenue recognition for the provision of services

The accounting treatment of building contracts is a crucial aspect of service provision. These are agreements for building a single item or a group of related assets, such as substantial ships, office complexes, and other projects that often last for several years.

According to IFRS, revenue for services rendered over a long period should be recognized based on the percentage of completion method or progress towards completion. These contracts come in two varieties: cost-plus and fixed pricing.

In fixed-price agreements, the builder or contractor accepts a price before work starts. Therefore, the contractor is responsible for any risks.

In cost-plus agreements, the project's actual costs and a profit margin determine the price. The completed contract method is another option for businesses that report under ASPE.

The completed contract technique, as opposed to the percentage of completion method, only permits revenue recognition upon contract completion.

ASC 606 of the Accounting Standards Codification

The Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 606 – Revenue from Contracts with Customers was released by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) simultaneously on May 28, 2014. 

A standard framework for recognizing revenue from client contracts is provided by ASC 606. The previous guideline was sector-specific, which led to a patchwork of rules. 

The revised recognition of revenue standards is more open and independent of industry. It enables better financial statement comparability across various businesses thanks to standardized recognition processes.

The updated recognition of revenue principle can be satisfied in five steps:

• Determine the terms of the customer agreement.
• Determine the duties of performance under the contract.
• The price or consideration for the transaction should be determined.
• Allocate the agreed-upon sum as payment for the contract's duties.
• When the performing party fulfills the performance obligation, income is recognized.

How Does GAAP Require Revenue Accounting?

According to the recognition of revenue principle, a component of accrual accounting, revenues must be recognized following generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). 

This means that rather than necessarily occurring when cash is received, revenue is recorded on the income statement in the period it is realized and earned. For the revenue-generating activity to be included in revenue for the relevant accounting period, it must be finished or almost finished. 

Additionally, there needs to be some assurance that the generated revenue payment will be received. The matching principle also mandates that revenue and related costs must be reported in the same accounting period.

What Is ASC 606: Accounting Standards Codification?

A standard framework for recognizing revenue from client contracts is provided by ASC 606. The previous guideline was sector-specific, which led to a patchwork of rules. The revised revenue recognition standard is more open and independent of the industry. 

It enables better financial statement comparability across various businesses thanks to standardized recognition of revenue processes.

What Must Occur to Comply with the Revenue Recognition Principle?

The updated recognition of revenue principle requires five steps to be followed:

1. Identifying the contract with the customer; 

2. Identifying contractual performance obligations; 

3. Calculating the amount of consideration/price for the transaction; 

4. Allocating the calculated amount of consideration/price to the contractual obligations; 

5. Recognizing revenue when the performing party fulfills the performance obligation.

Example:

In June, XYZ Company sold $400,000 worth of goods to customers on credit. In July, $80,000 was collected and in October, $200,000 was collected. The COGS is 80%.

Using the installment sales method, the journal entries would be:

June:

July:

October:

Revenue Recognition from contracts

The recognition of revenue from contracts is covered by IFRS 15. The following contracts are specifically excluded from the recognition of revenue principle:

• Lease Agreements, as defined by IAS 17.
• Insurance contracts that comply with IFRS 4.
• Financial instruments that follow IFRS 9 specifications.

Following are the different phases in recognition of revenue from contracts:

1. Identify the contract

For a contract to exist, each of the following conditions must be met:

• Both counterparties must have approved the contract.
• It is necessary to be able to identify the point of transfer for both products and services.
• Payment conditions can be determined in detail.
• The contract must contain some business element.
• The likelihood of money collection exists.

2. Defining the performance requirements

The requirements for performance must be clear and understandable.

The following requirements must be fulfilled:

• The product or service purchaser must get something from their purchase.
• The contract must include information on the seller's goods or services.

3. Calculating the transaction's cost

• The contract must expressly state the transaction price.
• As a result, the majority of contracts have a fixed sum. However, this is not required.

4. Linking the transaction price to the obligations for performance

Based on the solo selling prices mentioned in the contract, the transaction price for one or more performance obligations needs to be distributed.

5. Recognition of revenue based on performance

The recognition of revenue principle's criteria 1 and 2 must be met to recognize revenue for various performance commitments at a single point in time or with time.

How every department is affected by Revenue recognition

Employees who aren't directly involved in accounting tasks typically don't pay much attention to them. For instance, some sales managers and representatives only focus on receiving the client's approval and don't need to worry about what occurs next. 

However, the sales and finance teams, as well as every employee and investor in the organization, place a high value on how the revenue from that sale is recognized.

The recognition of the revenue concept has repercussions that extend to all areas of an organization. The income statement displays a genuine picture of the company's financial health in real time when revenue is recorded accurately and on time. 

The ability of a corporation to budget for different departments may be impacted if too much or too little revenue is reported during a particular accounting quarter.

For instance, if excessive income is recorded, a department can believe it has more resources than it does, overspend, and put the business in a vulnerable cash flow position.

A business may lose out on additional resources that could have been used to accelerate growth if it ends up with more cash than anticipated as a result of under-recognized revenue.

One of the most crucial factors for financial analysts to consider when assessing a firm's health is total revenue. 

According to analyst valuations, which are partially based on total revenue, an organization's stock price, ability to attract investment capital, the likelihood of mergers and acquisitions, capacity for borrowing, and other factors may all change.

Final Thoughts

Employees of all sizes of businesses should be aware of the recognition of revenue principle. 

They now have a comprehensive insight into the financial health of their company thanks to this knowledge. It also enables people to understand the effects of their actions, regardless of whether they are in charge of finalizing a deal or completing it.

It is essential to comprehend the income recognition principle and account for it correctly. Understanding the actual degree of economic activity within a corporation is made easier by the accrual principle of recognition of revenue in accounting.

The postponed principle of accounting prevents unearned income from being treated as an asset and ensures that assets and liabilities are correctly reported. It is essential to comprehend the income recognition principle and account for it correctly.

The recognition of revenue principle, as its name implies, is an accounting standard used in both IFRS and GAAP that outlines the precise circumstances under which a company may recognize revenue. Since the recognition of revenue is crucial for any company to demonstrate better performance, there is a possibility that it may be incorrect. 

As a result, standards have been established to guarantee that all companies abide by the rules, and analysts can compare organizations based on those rules.

Researched and authored by Deeksha Pachauri | linkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:

• Accounts Receivable Turnover Ratio
• Cost of Goods Manufactured (COGM)
• Fraud Triangle
• Nash Equilibrium
• Retained Earnings