• Sharebar

Let's rank the top 10 business schools (with an IB/Private Equity focus + Prestige on the Street - not necessarily based on US News and the World rankings)

1. Harvard

2. Stanford

3. Wharton

4. MIT

5. Chicago

6. Columbia

7. Northwestern

8. Tuck

9. Stern

10. Michigan

What do you think?

Comments (43)

  • Dan Bush's picture

    harv, stan, whar are a tie
    mit,chic,col are a tie for 2nd
    nw,tuck are tie 3
    corn, yale are tie 4

  • zala rules's picture

    Dan, I hate to bash your alma mater, but Yale b-school is not the #9 MBA program in the nation.

    As far as the OP: Pretty good list, the important thing is that you realize most published MBA rankings are a fucking joke.

    It looks like you got the top 10 right, and I'm not gonna quarrel what order any of them should be in (HWS, though, are always in the top 3). Other decent/okay b-schools are Haas, UCLA, Darden, Cornell.

  • Wasting Time's picture

    Like Zala said "rankings are a fucking joke."

    I could find you schools that are not even well ranked (by USNEWS) like Washington U, Georgetown U, Vanderbilt U, Emory U, and Notre Dame that put a lot of people into the IB/Consulting stage.

  • ps757's picture

    STern should be in top 5 given the number of offers its graduating class gets - esp in BBs

  • jd243's picture

    HBS & Stanford GSB will present you with opportunites that no other school can. That being said, Wharton is a popular third. You can't go wrong with any of those other top few, but after that, you're wasting your time. You're kidding yourself if you believe a Wash U or Georgetown MBA is going to stack up to the others in terms of the opportunities.

  • ZiggyMon's picture

    Outside of US;
    London Business School and INSEAD are also considerd quite good. Aren't they?

  • sea_ennui's picture

    I think you'll find the Wall Street Journal rankings quite surprising:

    2005

  • zala rules's picture

    sea_ennui: this is exactly what i was talking about. most published MBA rankings, especially the WSJ's, are shit.

  • In reply to zala rules
    sea_ennui's picture

    zala rules:
    sea_ennui: this is exactly what i was talking about. most published MBA rankings, especially the WSJ's, are shit.

    Which ranking do you think is the most accurate? Most people seem to think US News.

  • In reply to sea_ennui
    zala rules's picture

    sea_ennui:

    Which ranking do you think is the most accurate? Most people seem to think US News.

    I don't want to quibble over who belongs exactly in which spot, but it looks like they got the top 3 right and they diddn't put anyone in the top 10 that doesn't belong there. THat's more than a lot of the other dumbass magazines can say.

  • ZiggyMon's picture

    I think WSJ's rankings suck.

    Harvard should definately be among the top 5. Whereas, they didn't even put it in top 10.

  • MonkeyBusiness's picture

    Does anyone know whether or not a MSc in Accounting and Finance from LSE would hold as much clout as some of the big name MBA's?

  • MetalJack's picture

    sea_ennui didn't even post the latest rankings. They aren't much different but,

    2006 Rank 2005 Rank Business School
    1 2 University of Michigan (Ross)
    2 1 Dartmouth College (Tuck)
    3 3 Carnegie Mellon University (Tepper)
    4 8 Columbia University
    5 7 University of California, Berkeley (Haas)
    6 4 Northwestern University (Kellogg)
    7 6 University of Pennsylvania (Wharton)
    8 9 University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (Kenan-Flagler)
    9 5 Yale University
    10 12 Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Sloan)
    11 13 University of Chicago
    12 17 Duke University (Fuqua)
    13 11 University of Virginia (Darden)
    14 14 Harvard University
    15 10 University of Southern California (Marshall)
    16 18 Cornell University (S.C. Johnson)
    17 16 New York University (Stern)
    18 15 Stanford University
    19 19 University of California, Los Angeles

  • abmohan's picture

    How do recruiters see Canadian schools like Rotman (Toronto), Ivy (Western), Schulich (York), Queens, UBC and McGill?

  • MH's picture

    Yeah, FT rankings look realistic to me too.

  • MH's picture

    Yeah, FT rankings look realistic to me too.

  • In reply to MH
    ismailjh's picture

    Agreed. As long as you realize that the rankings from US NEWS & WR are not a finality.

  • IB2PWM's picture

    I thought Anderson (UCLA) would be higher... That's a really good program.

  • fp175's picture

    I went to Stanford as an undergrad. The GSB absolutely was flooded with all top firms. I don't see how a recruiter survey could rank it out of the top 10, they are all there.

  • In reply to fp175
    MonkeyBusiness's picture

    Well just because recruiters go to the uni to do info sessions doesn't mean a large number of the graduates/undergraduates actually land jobs there...LOL..

    Granted Stanford's absence is a bit of head scratcher...

  • In reply to sea_ennui
    bonuseason's picture

    Isn't Yale very non-profit Co oriented? I have heard that Corp. Finance isn't even on the Yale radar.

  • In reply to bonuseason
    mikerose31's picture

    Corp Finance is on the radar - Yale SOM revamping image, 40% of grads in last class went into Finance.

  • citi_banker_06's picture

    Fit is most important, I think. Go where you feel you can enjoy your location, the other B-school students, and other aspects of your next two years of study. Rankings are not the only think to consider.

  • iwannabeabanker's picture

    Are there any notable schools in the south or west that appeal to the banking industry.

  • BABanker's picture

    That being said, if you want to do banking, I would not go to those schools first. They recruit there to a degree, but not like they do the Northeast Corridor.

    There's a probably a few others, that some banks go to, but I would not recommend this as the primary option.

  • Kimbo Slice's picture

    8 schools were part of the recent London Banking Days interviews. Tuck was not one of them.

  • bryoves27's picture

    can anyone go indepth in a review of CMU's Tepper School of Business? it seems like it's ranked very hilgy in some rankings and much much lower in others. I know some of our programs are ranked very highly (several in the top 10) can any recruiters give me some insight on Tepper?

  • In reply to abmohan
    cdn monkey's picture

    Just to weigh in on cdn schools, the major difference between u.s. and canada is that business undergrad programs are wildly popular in canada and these schools focus a lot of their attention on their undergrad programs.

    The only school that gets BB U.S. firms recruiting for jobs on wall street is Ivey (Western). And that is mainly for the undergrad program - not the mba program.

    Consulting is a different story but for IB, they're only good if you want to work in canada.

  • RSCap22's picture

    You can't label one school as being the route to sucess. If you go to any of the top 20 schools, work hard and make morally correct decisions I am pretty sure you'll be able to retire comfortably well before 98% of the people who shape the person you are now, considering this is a group in their early to late 20's at best for the majority.

    Oh and if you associate success soley with net worth, I pity you... I'm not going to preach but good looks and money don't alone bring self-worth or personal satisfaction. Your youth, will forever have an impact on your life as much as you might want to seperate youself from it or not.

  • cutter's picture

    Where do you folks figure Cornell's program ranks?

  • In reply to sea_ennui
    ten pin ted's picture

    Seem to fit with what most people think

  • In reply to cutter
    Kimbo Slice's picture

    To unlock this content for free, please login / register below.

    Sign In with Facebook Sign In with Google

    Connecting helps us build a vibrant community. We'll never share your info without your permission. Sign up with email or if you are already a member, login here Bonus: Also get 6 free financial modeling lessons for free ($200+ value) when you register!
  • DiscoZ's picture

    Metals & Mining I-Banker

  • ExGSBanker's picture