• Sharebar

I was out last night having drinks with a few energy traders at a HF I am applying to for an entry level position. Clearly these guys make a lot of money especially the owner.

After some drinks one of the traders said, "Listen this is an opportunity of a lifetime, I made a $1.5mm bonus last year and this year it will be closer to $2mm." On top of that his base is 150k

The fund is not in a big city, or wealthy area, and adjusted for cost of living that's more like $4-5mm bonus in NYC and 350k base.

With the opportunity in 2 years to become a trader I obviously was shocked at that number.

Is that a real figure? or was that booze and bullshit talking?

The WSO Advantage - Hedge Funds

Financial Modeling Training

IB Templates, M&A, LBO, Valuation. Learn More.

Wall St. Interview Secrets Revealed

30,000+ sold & REAL questions. Learn More.

Resume Help from HF Pros

Land More Interviews. Learn More.

Find Your HF Mentor

Realistic HF Mock Interviews. Learn More.

Comments (20)

  • Asatar's picture

    I dont think you can adjust $2mm up to $5mm for 'cost of living'. The more money you earn, the less effect CoL differences have.

  • pgaap1919's picture

    Maybe Cost of living wasn't the best comparison but quality of lifestyle on 2mm here would be easily equivalent to $4-5mm in NYC. A $500,000 house here is brand new, 4 bedroom, 5,000 sq feet, 3 car garage, and comes with acres of land. Compare that to what you would live in in NYC. Going out to dinner would cost half if not 1/4 of what a nice dinner would cost in NYC.

  • Walkio's picture

    Mix of both, I guess. Energy Traders make crazy amounts of money.

  • ReadLine's picture

    Great.

    Re: COLA though- a lot of people would prefer $2M and living in NYC over $2M and living in a small city. Many people are happy in a small apartment vs. a house.

  • Bondarb's picture

    the numbers arent unrealistic but understand that those guys have to make money trading to get paid...ie could easily be a 0 next year if things dont go right. And 2MM in NYC is certainly enuff to live very very well indeed as long as you dont have a bunch of kids.

  • In reply to Walkio
    gammaovertheta's picture

    Walkio:
    Mix of both, I guess. Energy Traders make crazy amounts of money.

    The majority of energy traders don't make bank. They're comp is extremely performance based, which means that the average trader and below (ie 50% of all energy traders) do pretty poorly. If I had to guess, it sounds like this shop is having a good couple years or the guy is bullshitting OP. If they truly had a long-run winning strategy, they'd probably offer a higher salary as percentage of all-in comp
  • In reply to gammaovertheta
    Bondarb's picture

    gammaovertheta:
    Walkio:
    Mix of both, I guess. Energy Traders make crazy amounts of money.

    The majority of energy traders don't make bank. They're comp is extremely performance based, which means that the average trader and below (ie 50% of all energy traders) do pretty poorly. If I had to guess, it sounds like this shop is having a good couple years or the guy is bullshitting OP. If they truly had a long-run winning strategy, they'd probably offer a higher salary as percentage of all-in comp

    150k base salary is pretty standard for any hedge fund trader/PM even at places that have been around for decades...I wouldnt expect a PM to get more then that. and it doesnt even matter because this "salary" is likely a draw where u owe it back if u dont make any money...ie if u get paid out 15% of PnL ur first 1MM just covers your draw and then you start making more money after that. I think this guy probably had a good couple of years, had a few drinks, and was shooting his mouth off but the numbers dont sound absurd to me.

  • ATrad's picture

    pgaap1919:

    After some drinks one of the traders said, "Listen this is an opportunity of a lifetime, I made a $1.5mm bonus last year and this year it will be closer to $2mm." On top of that his base is 150k

    Is that a real figure? or was that booze and bullshit talking?

    Well... those numbers are possible. Energy markets can be very profitable, but that bonus is not the average.

  • HedgeHog's picture

    Just do the math, if he's running money at a Hf, he could conservatively get 10% of his profits (assuming the Hf charges 20%). If he's running 100m (realistic amt) and a good year is +20% gross (20m revenue) there's the 2m right there. Running more money and/or a higher payout, all the better. Nice position to have...

  • BTbanker's picture

    I'm guessing this is in Texas/Oklahoma.

  • jimz's picture

    The bonus is realistic. However given how energy funds didn't do to well this year. I am surprised about the bonus numbers. From looking at your previous thread, I think you should take this offer. These guys are doing something well, seeing how must energy funds are going to finish in the negative or barely positive.

  • In reply to Bondarb
    brandon st randy's picture

    Bondarb:
    the numbers arent unrealistic but understand that those guys have to make money trading to get paid...ie could easily be a 0 next year if things dont go right. And 2MM in NYC is certainly enuff to live very very well indeed as long as you dont have a bunch of kids.

    2MM/year at NYC tax rate will leave the guy around 1 MM after taxes.
    In PE with equivalent performance one gets to keep 1.6MM out of the 2MM aka 8MM out of 10MM by year 5/profit distribution). And then there are other tricks that one can pull to further reduce the taxable amount via IRA etc. as Romney demonstrated.
    I guess from a tax perspective PE/RE is advantageous over HF.
    Assuming that capital gain tax rate goes back to 20% and top marginal rate for $1m+ income back to 39.6% which will be in the case of 2013 in all likelihood.

    Also many thanks for pointing out that for a trader/PM the base salary is basically a draw on trade profits. This is similar to how how brokers get draws from their firm which are then deducted from the commissions once they start closing sales.
    This type of arrangement makes it fair and equitable for both sides. It also means that the new trader needs to start making money for the firm soon else his employer might not feel comfortable keeping paying him "draws" for much longer.

    Too late for second-guessing Too late to go back to sleep.

  • Bondarb's picture

    Bonuses of employees in PE funds are taxed as ordinary income I think. I really think only the principals are tax advantaged but i could be wrong.

  • In reply to Bondarb
    brandon st randy's picture

    Bondarb:
    Bonuses of employees in PE funds are taxed as ordinary income I think. I really think only the principals are tax advantaged but i could be wrong.

    Right. Bonus are ordinary income but I was referring to carried interests, hence the 5 year profit distribution period.
    Sorry about the confusion. I think 2 MM/year bonus would be rather rare in PE except C-level folks at mega-funds. Most of the money come from carried interests during distributions.

    Too late for second-guessing Too late to go back to sleep.

  • In reply to brandon st randy
    Bondarb's picture

    brandon st randy:
    Bondarb:
    Bonuses of employees in PE funds are taxed as ordinary income I think. I really think only the principals are tax advantaged but i could be wrong.

    Right. Bonus are ordinary income but I was referring to carried interests, hence the 5 year profit distribution period.
    Sorry about the confusion. I think 2 MM/year bonus would be rather rare in PE except C-level folks at mega-funds. Most of the money come from carried interests during distributions.

    I believe at a HF if you are the general partner (ie the principal) you also get the carried interest rate...however indiviudual PMs are paid as ordinary income.

  • In reply to Bondarb
    ky0ung's picture

    To unlock this content for free, please login / register below.

    Connecting helps us build a vibrant community. We'll never share your info without your permission. Sign up with email or if you are already a member, login here Bonus: Also get 6 free financial modeling lessons for free ($200+ value) when you register!
  • SirTradesaLot's picture

    adapt or die:
    What would P.T. Barnum say about you?

    MY BLOG

  • hosken's picture