Summer Investment Analyst

Status
Group/Division/Type
Investment Research
City
Chicago
Interviewed
February 2014
Overall experience
Very Positive
Difficulty
Difficult

General Interview Information

Outcome
No Offer
Interview Source
College / University / On Campus Recruiting
Length of Process
Less than 1 month

Interview Details

What did the interview consist of?
Phone Interview
Group Interview
Please describe the interview / hiring process.
Brief snapshot followed by more in depth explanation:

Snapshot:
- Legendary value investing firm with about $30bn split between its record holding sequoia fund and two or three hedge funds. Not much is known about them but these guys are really about as good as it gets so do your homework and show some respect, you arent walking into a BB IBD interview, Ruane is another animal
- Flat hierarchy, even summer interns work autonomously (stress your ability to do so in your interview/opposite structure of banking)
- Intellectual environment, they look for the most thoughtful and intelligent candidates, this seems to be the most important factor to them
- Learn value investing and demonstrate passion for investing
- THIS PLACE WILL SET YOU UP FOR LIFE, so seriously, if you have not at least read "The Intelligent Investor" before interviewing, you do not even deserve it

In-Depth
Applied through campus recruiting (I think they only recruit HYP, I could be wrong, but I also know that they do take a look at online applicants to find hidden gems so this is one of the few places where the resume drop is not a black hole). Interview consisted of an explanation of the firm structure (legendary MF and a couple hedge funds with investment analysts working collaboratively across each fund). Was asked to pitch a stock. Questions were very personal, the interviewer really wanted to get to know my personality and was trying to assess hidden potential. Two weeks later went to the office (50th floor of the Solow Building nicest office I have ever seen) and had three 2 on 1 interviews with managers of the various funds. Questions were deceptively simple, such as which company CEOs would you like to meet, or what would you do if you were king of a random country. Also was asked about books that I had read, and was given a brief case (how many windows in your dorm room building). Word of caution, Ruane is packed with incredibly smart people. The whole interview literally felt like they were trying to feel out my intelligence, thoughtfulness, and how well my personality and analytical skills were suited for a value investor (I swear these guys summed me up in seconds). As for advice, KNOW VALUE INVESTING. I mean indoctrinate yourself in the concept. Read the intelligent investor (as many books as you can your hands on really) and tailor your answers to the principles of value investing (particularly your stock pitch). THIS FIRM WILL SET YOU UP FOR LIFE, they only take one intern in each office (possibly one total depending on what they think of the talent), but if you really understand value investing and you are near genius with strong social skills and a good personality, then you have as good a chance as any. If I could emphasize one thing, they care much more about your approach, and your potential, than the exactness of your answers (correctly recounted firm metrics far less important than understanding the business segments, why the firm is positioned to continue generating ROE, why sell-side analysts are wrong etc). Demonstrate your independence, passion for investing, understanding of value investing, and be interesting, and then of course hope the stars will align.
Overall Company Rankings
Blurred content of Overall Company Rankings Blurred content of Overall Company Rankings

Want Access to these Ruane Cunniff & Goldfarb Overall Company Rankings?

  • Free 1 month access by adding just 1 salary datapoint here
  • REAL salary bonus data across 1,000+ companies
  • Plus free 1 month access to 10,000+ interview insights

Was this interview insight helpful?

How many stars would you give to this interview insight?

3 Votes | Avg: 5

$50m+
Est Annual Revenue

Other Interview Data

Associate (Vice President)
Goldman Sachs, CHICAGO, 2016
Trader (Vice President)
HSBC, New York, 2022
Vp (Vice President)
Morgan Stanley, New York, 2021
Vp (Vice President)
Morgan Stanley, New York, 2021
Quantitative Strategist (Vice President)
Morgan Stanley, NA, 2020

Unlock WSO Database

1 month free. Add your own pay data.