Was surprised by the amount of people who suggested buying cigars for a boss in the "Gift for a boss" thread. I'm planning on buying some mild cigars for a friend whose wife is having a baby and have done some research -- have come up with Ashton Classic, Rocky Patel Connecticut, Montecristo Classic or White, and Oliva Connecticut.
Anyone have any good suggestions for cigars that they like?
| +50 | Interviews Are So Fake | 33 | 4h | |
| +33 | 2024 UK Election - Tories finished? | 21 | 1d | |
| +29 | ADHD ! | 13 | 2h | |
| +28 | Being Christian in investment banking | 14 | 2d | |
| +27 | Non-Competes Banned | 34 | 3m | |
| How do I become Sigma | 15 | 1d | ||
| +19 | Moelis has the cutest Analysts? | 4 | 2d | |
| +18 | Best NYC neighborhood for single 30M | 12 | 3d | |
| +16 | Underage intern, drinking? | 7 | 2d | |
| +13 | Secretive vs Universal Prestige? | 7 | 2d |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
Cubans
I'm not sure if I've had Montecristo White, but I've had the rest - they are all fine. I generally go with Cohiba's though. In my opinion the Dominican Cohibas that you can get in the states are great (and not overly expensive).
I'm not even close to a cigar conoisseur, but I do enjoy one every so often.
To the guy who said cubans - Cubans can be very good, but just because they're from Cuba doesn't necessarily make them better. Cuba has some great cigars, but the other islands have largely caught up to their quality. Their mystique is mostly due to the trade embargo.
Disagree. The Cubans I've had lasted significantly longer and had a stronger taste, in a good way. Literally, got a regular corona and it lasted 1.5-2 hours, with normal smoking, about double what Dominicans, Honduran, Jamaican or Nicaraguan.
Don't get me wrong, I rarely have a cigar I don't enjoy (though I research more than most, even on $5-10 cigars), but Cubans are still a step above from my personal experience.
Agreed, the Cohiba brand manufactured in the US aren't actually Cohibas. They're actually made by US General Cigar Company, and they suck imo. I've had the Cohiba Espendidos and can say that they really do live up to their name. But since we can't get those in the US, I would recommend Ashton or Romeo Y Julieta like the other poster. Just make sure that whatever you get, you don't open or if you do, stick them in a humidor. Cigars dry out pretty quick and make for an awful taste when they do.
If you can't get authentic Cubans, go with Ashton, Romeo Y Julietta or Punch IMO.
I've had R&J ("Real", I think) before and liked them also. I'll look into Punch as well, thanks.
Yea, the real ones are amazing. Even the ones sold in the U.S. are solid, better than Cohiba IMO.
Of all the ones you mentioned, I prefer Rocky Patel the most - The Decade is one of my favorite mid-tier, non Cuban cigars. I would also second the poster who mentioned non-Cuban Cohibas.
Whatever brand you go with, just ensure that your box is fresh and humidified. Make sure you're getting it from a reputable place that takes care of their inventory. There's nothing worse than getting a nice box of cigars, opening it, and finding out that they are dried out.
Dutch Masters
Authentic Cubans are overpriced for what they are, in my opinion at least. I really like Rocky Patels, and I think they're a better cigar outright in addition to being much less expensive.
Oliva Serie V Ligero Especial torpedo... an absolutely astounding smoke
I would recommend anything from the Ashton family. Aroma De Cuba's are pretty solid and arent quite as expesive as Ashtons and are very attractive to look at (about 10-15 per stick). Otherwisem, you can rarely go wrong with anything from Rocky Patel.
+1 on the Ashtons.
VSG is mindblowing. Also Liga Privado, though not as well known as the Ashtons.
Padron; Ashton VSG; Davidoff
Is Davidoff worth the price? Looked at Classic #2's, gets good reviews, but more expensive than Rocky Patel, R&J, etc. Also, a smaller cigar... 6x38.
I always play it safe and just buy them black and milds
Terrific advice. Related: flavored Philly Blunts
Add Swishers and Optimos. Brings me back to my high school days.
Padron1926-Serie - # 9
Ashton fan here. The VSG and wood wrapped ones are great. If you are in NYC, I'd also recommend the special edition Montecristo NYC, which is maybe my favorite ever.
hmmmm... i thought cigars were like wine, "great taste" is highly subjective... i would suggest going to a reputable store and getting a recommendation on "brand names"...
A year ago or so a WSO user was about to start a cigar business. Have not seen him here for a while thou ...
I personally like this cigar for a mild 1.5-2 hour smoke- a href="http://www.stogiefresh.com/journal/Cigar_Journal/Cigars/Entries/2011/11…">Gurkha Cellar Reserve 15
I personally like this cigar for a mild 1.5-2 hour smoke- Gurkha Cellar Reserve 15
Is cigar consider less unhealthy than cigarettes? How do people view an analyst smoking a cigar?
You can't really chain smoke a cigar, and it's not something you do often. A cigarette won't hurt you - but smoking a handful everyday for years will.
As for smoking as an analyst, you can't really smoke indoors (and if you are in NYC, not in public spaces, near buildings...basically you need to go to Hoboken to light up). Your superiors aren't likely to see you smoking a cigar, so it doesn't really matter.
Ashton classic or Montecristo white is probably your best option, both have relatively mild flavor profiles.
I am assuming you are a not a smoker yourself- but if your friend is generally a fan of milder sticks stay away from anything without a Connecticut wrapper. Connecticut wrappers are the lightest in color so if you are buying a stick that is dark and oily that is most certainly NOT a mild cigar. Also, get a bigger cut of a cigar- smaller cigars that are either too short or too narrow will burn hotter and in tandem have a stronger/more intense/much worse flavor to their smoke.
Stay away from cohiba or the gurkha. Cohibas are great but stronger than the two selections above. If you can find cuban montecristo whites, you are in the clear.
When in doubt, go to a good cigar lounge (not the corner store) and ask for help, store owners often can match you perfectly.
Its just stupid to pay for something that kills you
Quick, let's gather a list of everything else we pay for that could "kill us."
There has to be more
I knew I would receive that answer.
Whatever, we will all die anyways. That's the attitude.
LMFAO
Get him a box of any of the more popular brands people have mentioned above. You can't go wrong with most of them. I smoke on a regular basis and thoroughly enjoy coronas with a mild flavor from either Davidoff, Montecristo, or Romeo y Julieta (Cuban or otherwise). Most recently I've smoked and liked Fernando Leon Family Reserve by La Aurora and San Cristobal Elegancia. It's a guessing game as to what he might like but definitely wouldn't do something too big or with too much flavor as a gift.
There is some misinformation in this thread. Just because a cigar has a lighter wrapper does NOT make it a mild smoke. Montecristo Whites are more toward the medium-full to full end of the spectrum. A mild smoke would be a Macanudo Cafe etc. This also goes the other way, a maduro (dark) wrapper is not always a heavier ie. fuller bodied smoke. Partagas is a solid line and you really cannot go wrong with anything in their stable. I prefer a heavier smoke, so i like the Black line and also the Spanish Rosado. The Macanudo I mentioned before is a solid, light smoke. another one to try would be the 5 Vegas Gold... (thats Cinco Vegas). Skip the U.S. Cohibas, its a rookie mistake. You can get far far far better smokes for less.
If you want more, PM me. I can give you alot of insight into the world of cigars. Family owns a shop.
It's good to be Canadian when it comes to cigars. I try to go to Cuba at least once a year and restock my humidor, but like people have said most cohibas, r&j cedritos and montecristo número 4 are personally my favourites. As an Analyst/intern I smoke/smoked cigars all the time (office had a balcony type lounge you could access from the bullpen) and noone ever said shit (just don't smoke an esplendido that will take 2 hours)... Quite the opposite actually - always gave a topic of conversation with MDs or even clients. My biggest issue is that even buying the top brands in Cuba it will still set you back a couple of hundred bucks... I think I paid 350 for my esplendidos? (Here they are like 750) Can't remember from the last time I went and montecristos are usually around 150... Sure they last a while and are amazing but if you are starting out there are some decent cigars you can buy for much lower prices... I don't know what prices are like in the US but Canada is pretty expensive overall even for the cheapest brands...
I don't know about you ... but I get heluva horny having a cigar! And bold ... bold enough to wear a pinstriped suit and unzip my fly walking the streets of NYC.
Uh...okay.
TBH you'd probably be the norm if you did this in Times Square/Hipster territory (AKA Williamsburg/East Village/Nether regions of NYC)
I'm glad I'm not the only that finds it weird he gets horny when putting that kind of shaped thing in his mouth
Appreciate the responses. Probably going w/ Ashton Classic. Though, other suggestions are welcome for future reference...
I like Arturo Fuente and Cohiba's for a daily/casual smokes, and Pedron 1926 series for special occasions
Nestor Miranda Art Deco's are very good and aren't overly expensive.
If they really aren't into cigars that much you could get them a box of Acids.
Best Cigar for the money right now is CA 2012 cigar of the year, Flor de las Antillas Toro. 1. You can get it for about 7 bucks and it is an excellent smoke for the money. usually perfect draw, construction, and burn. Flavor strength is medium. The flavor is mildly peppery with various woody undertones.
For a gift just get Davidoff #1. Box of 4 will set you back about $65.
Is it cheesy to buy your MD cuban cigars for his birthday (Originally Posted: 05/24/2013)
(srs)
Nemo beatae similique voluptatem laborum veniam. Saepe quod doloremque sit voluptatem at. Voluptatibus possimus itaque quaerat repudiandae possimus aliquid accusantium.
Voluptatibus beatae recusandae deserunt facilis suscipit velit. Totam culpa voluptas laborum quia. Et consequatur eaque culpa fugit.
Nulla veniam odio a ut corrupti assumenda. Non perferendis quos quos ea minima. Distinctio ratione velit similique quaerat ratione distinctio sunt. Id blanditiis possimus aspernatur assumenda voluptatum. Quia aliquam ut quo sint error.
Voluptatum velit esse beatae et est. Id qui vel et rem delectus. Dolorem sit dolore alias asperiores ullam. Ut ut incidunt facere architecto inventore aut. Qui commodi atque veritatis. Eos voluptas ipsam autem qui maiores distinctio. Consequuntur vero incidunt consequatur tenetur.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Consectetur doloremque sint laboriosam occaecati molestiae qui culpa. Reiciendis voluptatem deleniti animi sapiente illum. Voluptatibus quo quis et sed adipisci error.
Dicta molestiae beatae placeat sint quasi et. Et dignissimos incidunt tempore nisi repellendus distinctio facere. Corrupti voluptatibus in vel hic minus omnis.
Et non quia at reiciendis. Omnis sunt suscipit suscipit dolores sit dicta dolorum voluptatem. Fugit et ducimus odit facilis facere sed eum. Labore quidem commodi possimus in excepturi animi. Dolores odio porro nulla.