Residual Dividend Policy

What is a Residual Dividend Policy?

The Residual Dividend Policy involves a company establishing its capital budget and allocating funds to profitable projects. After fulfilling these capital expenses, any leftover profits, referred to as 'residuals,' are subsequently given to shareholders as dividends.

This approach differs from fixed dividend policies like the stable dividend policy or constant payout ratio policy, which maintain a set dividend payout irrespective of the company's investment prospects.

Under this policy, companies allocate funds to capital expenditures using their earned profits before distributing dividends.

Consequently, annual dividend payments to investors may fluctuate based on available earnings.

Due to various factors, including uncertainties in the capital market, it's uncommon for companies to adopt a pure residual dividend policy.

Instead, most businesses tend to favor smoother dividend policies, which involve regular dividend payments that are somewhat tied to the company's past and present earnings.

Understanding A Residual Dividend Policy

This policy is employed by companies seeking a flexible and dynamic strategy for managing their financial resources.

Unlike fixed dividend policies, which commit to a predetermined distribution to shareholders, the residual dividend policy enables a company to prioritize its growth and expansion investments before contemplating dividend disbursements.

The residual dividend plan works by prioritizing capital expenditure (CapEx) using the company’s earnings before allocating any remaining cash for dividend payments.

In this method, organizations usually fund capital expenditures (CapEx) by utilizing a mix of debt and equity from their capital framework.

The effectiveness of a residual dividend plan is often measured using the return on average assets (ROA) metric, which is calculated as net income divided by total assets. This metric is a key factor in analyzing management decisions and the success of a residual dividend plan.

Shareholders and the investment community must scrutinize how well a company utilizes its assets to generate additional income. A positive outcome, reflected in an improved ROA ratio, is a testament to effective capital allocation. 

For example, if a company invests in capital expenditure (CapEx) and achieves increased productivity or improved operating efficiency, the ROA ratio improves, resulting in higher returns. This is likely to be perceived positively by shareholders, thus affirming their acceptance of the remaining dividend approach.

On the other hand, if a company undergoes reduced profits and upholds an identical degree of financing for capital expenses (CapEx), the dividends given to shareholders might decline.

The impact of the ROA ratio may indicate operational challenges, leading to a more critical analysis of the firm’s approach to capital allocation and the effectiveness of the reserved allocation strategy.

Requirements for a Residual Dividend 

Several factors must be considered in order for a residual dividend policy to be effectively implemented, including:

1. Earnings Allocation and Utilization: When a business generates earnings, it either retains them for internal use or distributes them as dividends to stockholders. Retained earnings can be utilized for current business operations or to acquire assets, a necessity for any company's continuous operation and potential growth.
2. Asset Management and Strategic Growth: Business managers assess operational and growth-related asset requirements, considering upgrades and replacements over time.
3. Dividend Irrelevance Theory: Investors don't care whether they get their returns from a company through dividends or capital gains. The theory suggests that investors see both forms of returns as equally valuable, making the residual dividend policy less impactful on the company's market value. From this perspective, the residual dividend policy is designed under the premise that it does not impact the company's market value significantly, as investors allegedly value dividends and capital gains equally.
4. Passive Calculation and Market Value Impact: The application of the residual dividend policy involves a passive calculation. Companies opting to use retained earnings to finance capital expenditures (CapEx) typically align with the residual policy. It results in dividend payouts for investors that are often inconsistent and challenging to predict.
5. Consistency and Predictability: Companies using the residual dividend policy often result in inconsistent and unpredictable dividend payouts for investors due to their reactive nature.

Residual Dividend Model

The following includes the residual dividend model:

Dividends = Net Income – (Target Equity Ratio x Total Capital Budget)

Where:

• Dividends represent the amount available for distribution to shareholders.
• Net Income is the total earnings after all expenses.
• Target Equity Ratio is the desired proportion of equity in the capital structure.
• Total Capital Budget is the overall budget for capital expenditures.

Components of the Residual Dividend Model

The Residual Dividend Model consists of several key components:

1. Net Income: The model begins with the company's net income. Net income is the total earnings after subtracting all expenses, taxes, and financial obligations.
2. Capital Budget: Allocation of funds for crucial investments in projects, acquisitions, or other capital expenditures essential for business growth.
3. Total Equity: The total equity is calculated based on the company's predetermined target capital structure, considering the mix of debt and equity desired.
4. Residual Earnings: The residual earnings are determined by deducting the total equity from the net income, signifying the remaining funds available after fulfilling the capital budget obligations.
5. Dividend Payout: The residual earnings are then considered for dividend distribution. The company decides whether to distribute the entire residual or a portion of it to shareholders in the form of dividends.
6. Dividend Payout Ratio: This ratio is calculated by dividing the residual dividend by the net income, providing insights into the proportion of earnings distributed to shareholders and the company's dividend distribution practices.

Residual Dividends Example

To better understand the concept, an example is necessary. Here is an example of how the policy works:

1. Capital Budget and Debt-Equity Split: XYZ Corporation initiates a capital budget of $10,000,000 for strategic initiatives and expansion projects. With a commitment to maintaining a 50-50 debt-equity split, the company strives to uphold this ratio in its overall capital structure.

2. Net Income Projection: In forecasting the fiscal year's net income, XYZ anticipates reaching $7,000,000.

3. Total Equity Calculation: Total equity is computed by determining 50% of the capital budget, resulting in $5,000,000 (half of $10,000,000).

4. Determining Residual Dividend: To ascertain the residual dividend, subtract the total equity from the net income, leading to a calculated value of $2,000,000 ($7,000,000 - $5,000,000).

​​Dividends = Net Income – (Target Equity Ratio x Total Capital Budget)
= $7,000,000 - $5,000,000
=$2,000,000

5. Calculating Payout Ratio: The dividend payout ratio is then derived by dividing the residual dividend by the net income: 

  $2,000,000 / $7,000,000 = 28.57%

6. Different Scenarios:

• Case A - Net Income Decrease: In a scenario where the net income decreases to $5,000,000, and total equity remains at $5,000,000, the entire amount is retained, resulting in a 0% dividend payout ratio.
• Case B - Net Income Increase: If net income rises to $9,000,000 while maintaining total equity at $5,000,000, XYZ Corporation experiences a resulting residual dividend of $4,000,000 ($9,000,000 - $5,000,000). This gives us a 44.44% dividend payout ratio.

In both cases, XYZ Corporation adeptly adjusts its dividend payments, responding to fluctuations in profitability while steadfastly upholding a 50-50 balance between debt and equity in its overall financial structure.

Residual Dividend Policy vs. Smooth Dividend Policy

Let's consider some key differences between a Residual Dividend Policy and a Smooth Dividend Policy.

Residual Dividend Policy vs. Hybrid Dividend Policy

Let's consider some key differences between a Residual Dividend Policy and a Hybrid Dividend Policy:

Advantages of a Residual Dividend Policy

This policy provides companies with a strategic advantage through the flexibility to allocate capital, allowing them to prioritize their growth plans and optimize earnings before distributing dividends. Some of them include:

1. Flexibility in Capital Allocation: Allows for flexibility in allocating capital for growth initiatives before distributing dividends and supporting strategic investments.
2. Optimal Use of Earnings: Ensures that earnings are efficiently utilized for funding projects with positive net present value (NPV) before returning value to shareholders.
3. Adaptability to Business Conditions: Adapts well to varying business conditions, as dividend payouts are contingent on the availability of residual earnings.
4. Attracting investors: This can attract investors who are looking for potential capital and periodic income, as share ownership is linked to the company’s performance.
5. Financial reserves: Facilitates the retention of financial resources for reinvestment, helping the company to take advantage of growth opportunities.
6. Positive Tax Implications: Holding back profits for reinvestment could result in favorable tax consequences. By postponing the distribution of dividends, shareholders might be able to delay tax payments on their profits until they decide to sell their shares, potentially gaining from reduced rates of capital gains tax.

Disadvantages of a Residual Dividend Policy

The policy, though flexible, poses challenges such as uncertain payouts, investor expectation management issues, and vulnerability to market volatility, impacting the company's perceived stability and stock attractiveness. Some of them include:

1. Uncertain Dividend Payments: Results in unpredictable and variable dividend payments may not be suitable for investors relying on stable income.
2.  Investor Expectation Challenges: Requires effective communication to manage investor expectations due to the fluctuating nature of dividends.
3. Market Fluctuation Effect: Being exposed to fluctuations in the market might result in unpredictable dividend amounts, which could potentially influence the performance of the company's stocks.
4. Investor misperception risk: Investors may view the company as unpredictable or unstable, affecting the value and attractiveness of its investments.
5. Effective use of cash: If projects with positive NPV are rare, there is a risk of underutilization of cash that can be distributed to shareholders.
6. Limited Dividend Stability: This does not provide the same dividend stability as other plans, making it less attractive to income-focused investors.

Researched and Authored by Rani Thakur | LinkedIn

Reviewed and Edited by Mohammad Sharjeel Khan | Linkedin

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:

• Accretive
• Collateral
• Demonetization
• EBITDAR
• Hope Credit