Make-or-Buy Decision

A strategic choice that businesses face when deciding

The Make-or-Buy Decision is a strategic choice that businesses face when deciding whether to produce a good or service or purchase them from an external supplier.

There are many factors to consider when making this decision, including transaction costs, capital investment, economies of scale, and the impact on the company's competitive advantage.

Decision Making: The Key to Make or Buy

When companies evaluate whether to make or buy a product, there are a number of factors to consider. Ultimately, the make or buy decision depends on a number of factors, including cost, quality, delivery, and the company's capabilities

There are a few key factors you need to consider when making a make-or-buy decision:

A. Producing the good or service in-house or using an outside supplier

B. The relevant costs associated with each option

C. The impact on company resources

Let's take a closer look at each of these factors:

A) Producing the good or service in-house or using an outside supplier: 

When making a make-or-buy decision, you need to consider whether it makes more sense to produce the goods or services in-house or to use an outside supplier. 

Here are a few things you need to take into account when making this decision:

  • The cost of materials.

  •  The cost of labor.

  •  The cost of overhead.

  •  The experience and expertise of your team.

  •  The impact on company resources.

There are benefits to both making and purchasing goods or services. 

1) The benefits of making vs. buying include control over the quality, cost, and delivery. 

2) The benefits of buying vs. making include access to specialized skills and knowledge, economies of scale, and flexibility. 

B) The relevant costs associated with each option:

  • Reduce decision time by assessing relevant costs for each option

  • Identify hidden costs in both options

  • Make more informed decisions about where to allocate your resources

C) The impact on company resources: 

When making a make-or-buy decision, you also need to consider the impact on company resources. 

Making goods or services in-house can give companies more control over quality and production. It can also lead to lower costs in the long run, as companies can take advantage of economies of scale.

However, outsourcing production can be faster and less risky than investing in new machinery and equipment. 

Consider all factors influencing decision-making factors 

• In-house production may be more expensive, but it can offer greater quality control and less risk

• Outsourcing can be less expensive, but it may come with greater risks in terms of quality and delivery.

Key factors will minimize the risk of your make-or-buy decision.

The first is to consider whether the company has the internal resources to produce the product or service in-house. This includes evaluating things like whether the company has the necessary equipment, labor, and expertise.

Another important factor is to consider the impact that is producing the product or service in-house will have on the company's existing operations. This includes things like whether it will disrupt current production, lead to increased costs, or require new staff training.

It's also important to think about the potential risks and rewards of making or buying the product or service. 

For example, if the company decides to make the product itself, there is always the risk that something could go wrong during production and lead to loss of sales or even damage to the company's reputation.

However, if the company buys the product from an outside supplier, there is always the risk that the supplier could fail to meet the company's quality standards or delivery deadlines.

By considering all these factors, companies can make the best decision for their needs and minimize the risks associated with either making or buying a product or service. 

Specific Situation: How to make the best decision? 

When it comes to business, many factors go into the make-or-buy decision. This decision can be difficult to make, but it is important to consider all aspects before deciding what is best for your company.

Making the best decision for your specific situation can be difficult. There are many factors to consider, and it's often hard to know the right choice. The make-or-buy decision is a classic example of this.

The best decision depends on the specific situation relevant to several factors.

1. Product cost: Make sure to calculate the long-term and short-term costs of both making and buying the product. In some cases, it may be more cost-effective to buy the product instead of making it yourself.

2. Time: If you need the product immediately, it may not be worth your time to make it. However, if you have enough time to wait for the product to be made, it may be worth your while.

3. Quality: If you need a high-quality product, it is probably better to make it than to buy it yourself. However, if you are willing to sacrifice quality for cost, you may be able to save money by buying the product.

4. Calculate risk: If you are not sure how well the product will sell, it may be better to buy it instead of making it. This way, you can test the market expenditure before investing a lot of money into production.

5. Expertise: If you do not have the expertise to make the product, it is probably better to buy it.

When making the make-or-buy decision, it is important to consider all of these factors. By doing so, you can ensure that you are making the best decision for your company.

Real-world scenarios: Make-or-buy decisions

There are many examples of real-world scenarios where the make-or-buy decision was made. Some companies outsource the production of goods not central to their business, such as office supplies. Others choose to make products that are essential to their business, such as computer chips.

Examples of real-world scenarios where the make or buy decision was made:

Situation: You are a small business owner who is expanding your product line. You have the option to either make the new products yourself or buy them from another company. 

Decision: After careful consideration, you decide to buy the products from another company. This decision is based on several factors, including cost, quality, and availability. By buying the products, you are able to focus on other aspects of your business, such as marketing and sales.

External factors: outsourcing acquisition

Outsourcing production can be a great way to save time and money, but it's important to weigh the risks carefully before making a decision.

When making the make-or-buy decision, businesses should carefully consider all the factors involved in order to make the best choice for their specific situation.

There are pros and cons to outsourcing production. Pros include lower costs, access to new technology and expertise, and increased flexibility. Cons include the loss of control over quality and the production process and the reliance on another company.

Firstly, quality control may be an issue when working with an external supplier. There may be language barriers or cultural differences that make it difficult to communicate expectations and ensure that products meet the required standards.

Secondly, there is always the risk that the supplier may not be able to meet deadlines or may experience other issues that disrupt the production process. This can lead to delays and additional costs and damage the company's reputation if products are not delivered on time.

Thirdly, there is a financial risk involved in outsourcing production, as the cost of materials and labor may fluctuate. This can lead to unexpected expenses and make it difficult to budget production costs.

Finally, there is the risk that the supplier may not be able to meet future demand if the company's product is successful. This could lead to shortages and frustrated customers.

Evaluating Decisions: Cost and Benefits 

Outsourcing production can be a great way to save time and money, but it's important to weigh the risks carefully before making a decision.

When making the make or buy decision, businesses should carefully consider all of the factors involved in order to make the best choice for their specific situation.

Outsource Inhouse

Pros include lower costs, access to new technology and expertise, and increased flexibility. Cons include the loss of control over quality and the production process and the reliance on another company.

Key Takeaways

The make-or-buy decision is a strategic business decision that companies make all the time. The goal of the decision is to find the most efficient and effective way to produce or acquire a product or service.

There are several factors that companies must consider when making a make-or-buy decision, including:

  1. The cost of production

  2. The availability of resources

  3.  The company's core competencies

  4.  The impact on the company's competitive advantage

There are benefits to both making and purchasing goods or services. 

  • The benefits of making vs. buying include control over the quality, cost, and delivery. 

  • The benefits of buying vs. making include access to specialized skills and knowledge, economies of scale, and flexibility. 

The make-or-buy decision is not always easy to make, but it is important to consider all of the factors before making a final decision.

Accounting Foundations Course

Everything You Need To Build Your Accounting Skills

To Help You Thrive in the Most Flexible Job in the World.

Learn More

Researched and Authored by Jason Luu | LinkedIn

Reviewed and Edited by Sakshi Uradi | LinkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources: