Asset-Based Valuation
It calculates a company's worth by subtracting its liabilities from its assets.
What Is Asset-based Valuation?
Asset-based valuation is a valuation approach that focuses on how much the business is worth after paying out all its outstanding obligations.
The general idea behind the concept is that the business is worth what it owns minus what it owes.
A more practical way to consider this is to see how much an owner would get for its assets if they sold them on the open market today after paying off all of its liabilities.
- Asset-based valuation calculates a company's worth by subtracting its liabilities from its assets.
- Unlike stockholders' equity, it emphasizes market values over book values, which can be depreciated.
- It is ideal for asset-heavy industries like construction and farms, where asset appreciation is significant.
- It is useful for distressed companies to determine liquidation value after liabilities.
- Unlike income-based and relative valuation approaches, it focuses more on the tangible asset value than future income or market comparisons.
Calculating Asset-Based Value
The steps of calculating the value of the firm using the asset-based valuation are very straightforward:
- The first step is to identify all the balance sheet and non-balance sheet assets and liabilities you want to use in the calculation.
- Then, thorough market research will be conducted to estimate the fair market values of the balance sheet items. The estimations are then used to update book values to reflect fair market values, incorporating adjustments for depreciation or appreciation where necessary.
- Finally, find the business value by subtracting the liabilities' fair value from the asset's fair value.
Where Is The Asset-based Valuation Method Appropriate?
As a method, the asset-based valuation is not appropriate in all cases. Still, there are three primary situations in which the technique is applicable:
- Construction Companies: One issue with these types of businesses is that their margins are very tight. This means that even a tiny economic event can completely change their profitability, so income is not a good measure.
In contrast to tight margins, these businesses are asset-heavy and have a lot of machinery. Therefore, the asset-based valuation method, which derives the value from the firm's assets-liabilities, is the most applicable in these situations. - Farms: Farms are another place where the asset-based approach is used. The most profitable component of these types of businesses is land appreciation. On the contrary, the income from the farms isn't substantial. Therefore, it's better to value them based on their assets.
- Distressed Companies: The valuation method aims to determine the price the buyer would pay for all assets at their fair value after subtracting the liabilities. Therefore, the process can be used if the company is liquidated and sells its assets.
Pros And Cons Of Asset-based Valuation
The use of asset-based valuation has several pros and cons. Let’s take a look at some of them:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| The formula of just taking the assets and subtracting liabilities is simple. | Assets like the PP&E are challenging to value because often, the information about the asset's price might not be available on the market. |
| One can decide which assets or liabilities to include in the calculation. | Often, the values of the formula components are subjective. |
| One can determine what measuring metrics to use when valuing formula components. | The value of many intangibles not on the balance sheet, like brand, loyalty, and reputation, is so difficult to quantify that analysts either value them subjectively or leave them out of the calculation. |
| Estimates the fair values of assets and liabilities versus book values. | The value of the business is often much higher than the sum of individual assets. |
Asset Valuation vs. the Income-Based Approach vs. Relative Valuation
Asset-based valuation is just one method of valuing a business. Another is the income-based approach. Let’s understand how each differs from each other:
Income-Based Approach
While asset-based valuation focuses on the balance sheet when determining value, the income-based approach focuses on how much income the firm is or will be generating.
The income-based approach includes several specific valuation methods, as detailed below.
| Method Name | Idea | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Discounted Cash Flow | How much are the future cash flows worth today? | The method calculates the firm's free cash flows (the cash left for investors). It then discounts them to the present and sums them up to arrive at the value. |
| Dividend Discount Model | How much are the dividends the firm pays in the future worth today in terms of stock price? | The dividends are forecasted in the future based on the forecasted growth rate. Then, they are discounted to present value, arriving at the stock price. |
| Residual Income Model | Serves as a measure to determine the economic profitability of a business by assessing how well it generates additional value over its required returns. | Calculates the value of a company by determining the excess income it generates after accounting for the cost of capital, using the formula |
Relative Valuation Approach
In contrast to asset-based valuation, the relative valuation method focuses on how much firms are valued on the market versus what they are worth intrinsically.
There are two primary methods of relative valuation. They are both listed below:
| Method Name | Idea | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Comparable Companies | The method focuses on the companies in the same industry. | The calculation is based on finding the average multiple of any financial metric for different companies and then applying it to find the target company's value. |
| Precedent Transactions | The valuation focuses on how much was paid to acquire similar companies in the industry. | The average purchase price will be identified as the target company's value. |
Asset-Based Valuation FAQs
While the asset-based approach is utilized, it is not commonly employed.
The general reason is that businesses report their assets at book values rather than fair values, which are difficult to estimate.
Therefore, many analysts perceive the asset-based approach as the last resort.
Still, the method is very widely used when valuing private companies. The analyst can more easily demand fair values for smaller private companies.
The regular balance sheet shows the book values of items; therefore, we get stockholders' equity when we subtract the book value of assets from the book value of liabilities.
Although the asset-based valuation approach concerns balance sheet items, it is interested in their market value rather than their book value.
Imagine an asset purchased for $100. In two years, after depreciation, its book price decreased to $50. Still, we determined the cost to be $80.
Book values are rarely updated after acquisition, and depreciation is merely an estimation, making them unsuitable for determining an asset’s current market value.
Another aspect is that many assets, primarily intangible, are expensed on the income statement but never on the balance sheet.
Adding these items to the calculation is vital for determining a fair price for the business.
Each individual asset helps the business maintain its operations, but there is more to what makes a company a business.
Other essential components include intangible factors like brand reputation, customer relationships, and intellectual property, which contribute significantly to overall worth beyond physical assets.
A business's value considers its ability to generate future cash flows, strategic positioning, and market conditions, making it a much broader measure than the simple sum of individual asset prices.
Free Resources
To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:
or Want to Sign up with your social account?