BCG NY vs McK Toronto
Choosing between these two locations. Not really sure what to do, but have been told that NY quality of work and people trumps mck brand
Trending Content - Management Consulting Forum
Career Resources
BCG NYC for sure. No question.
If you truly feel the fit is stronger at one firm or the other, go for it. The difference in brand/prestige between the two is much narrower than the difference between those cities though.
BCG NY unless you have a strict preference for Toronto.
Thanks for the comments. Is it that the work and calibre of people in ny is just higher because the office is so competitive?
Yup thats true. NY also tends to have a much wider client base and deeper industry focus while Toronto is a bit narrower in terms of the industries you see actual work being done.
@"Caseyjnolan" Did you already receive offers for these places? If so, are you undergrad, MBA, ADH?
Not yet, just trying to figure out where it makes sense to apply. I know ppl at both who can pass my info along.
Considering you DON'T have the offer in hand... apply to both then revisit this decision should you get an offer. I, however, would also say BCG NYC, although I'm a bigger advocate of offices in cities with significantly lower COL than NY.
What is COL?
cost of living?
.
Assuming you could get staffed somewhere, wouldn't you want your base to be a city that's cheap as hell? I'm staffed in NYC but based in the south and this is one of the best situations you could ask for. If you're rarely going to be home, might as well make home an affordable situation.
Most of the consultants I know based in NYC don't have a tremendous amount of travel either, which kills some of the biggest perks of the job (alternative travel, expense account, hella points, etc.)
Depends on where you are in your career/private life. All the travel is exciting during your early 20s, but the further you advance, the more you will appreciate having a local client base, which will give you the option to spend an evening at home with your family at least once in a while. So unless it's for a business analyst role which is anyway only 2 years, I would always advise to pick a city as a base where you actually want to live.
In terms of the McK staffing model: Yes, theoretically it's totally flexible and you can be staffed across offices. Reality is a bit different. In order to get staffed on attractive client engagements, you need to build a network of partners who know who you are, like to work with you, and take an active interest in your development. That's much more difficult across offices.
In terms of NYC vs. Toronto: Of course, NYC has a greater reputation. More competitive office (speaking of McK). On the other hand, it's not like in banking where NYC plays in a completely different league. Likelihood of promotion, likelihood of partner election, and compensation are not higher in NYC than in Toronto.
And finally, in terms of the application process (speaking about McK, but I'm sure BCG is the same): Unless the people you know are extremely senior, all they will be able to do is pass your info along. So it's not like because you know someone your chances of making it through the application process will be in any way better. As you might imagine, there are regularly requests from senior clients to favorably consider the application of their son/daughter/nephew whatever, and if we were to lower our standards in these cases, we would open a door for sub-par applicants. Therefore, if you end up deciding you want NYC, why don't you apply to McK NYC?
Qui sint architecto corrupti nesciunt. Deserunt et voluptatem magni voluptas nobis in perferendis placeat. Rem omnis distinctio ex voluptatum vel. Temporibus ratione quibusdam non quibusdam ex aut enim consequuntur.
Vel aut doloremque vel quaerat dolor voluptatem officiis. Voluptatum suscipit omnis praesentium. Aut qui atque praesentium iste iure deserunt in quis. Ad hic iure provident est ea necessitatibus alias dolor. Occaecati accusantium et qui fuga.
Modi incidunt labore voluptatem in fugiat aut ea. Officiis est magnam voluptatem iusto sed beatae. Non dicta distinctio non laboriosam itaque iste quo. Explicabo ut enim et corrupti sit provident. Porro id aut molestiae debitis magnam.
Eligendi molestiae repellendus et quaerat et itaque possimus. Veniam omnis officia dolorum dolor omnis. Sint neque est aliquid nemo voluptatem autem est. Ut unde ipsa doloribus.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...