5 Considerations About Bribery in China
For those out there with 20 free minutes and a curiosity to learn more about China’s Financial System, I strongly recommend you peruse the attached report from the Brookings Institution. It’s a fairly comprehensive, though not exhaustive (nor exhausting to read), account of the Chinese Financial System, and the authors have elected to write in a Q&A format, which I believe in this case is super helpful. Give it a read when you’re going to sleep this evening or on the john tomorrow…
One section, conspicuously left out, is the notion of ‘greasing palms,’ otherwise known as bribing. Because there wasn’t much mention of this in the report, I thought I might try to fill-in-the-blanks for monkeys who have an interest in that sort of thing. So, here are 5 Considerations About Bribery In China:
1) It’s illegal, but only when it is
– No big surprises here. Although when talking about business in China, bribery is often taken for a given or expected, because it is an illegal practice, many refuse to take part in it all together. They may find themselves at a competitive disadvantage when push comes to shove, but empirically, there are more and more organizations that elect not to participate in such illicit schemes.
The government itself will tell you they’re working on enforce/crack down on bribery and corruption, but much of the activity goes through unreported. Those at the top have little incentive to become whistleblowers, and those at the bottom wish to remain in the head honcho’s good graces.
2) It works well, up to a point – There. I said it. Paying off the right people in China, not unlike other places, can get you a seat at the negotiating table or get a required license/permit. It generally can’t, however, turn something illegal into something legal, but in fact the most pedestrian use of bribery is to speed up a certain process…
Getting land registered or re-zoned, pushing a product registration through a regulatory body, or even ensuring an IPO receives favorable treatment from the PORK (Public Offering Review Kommittee) are all fair game. Paying off a police battalion to not arrest you after you’ve committed murder? That’s so 1980s.
3) It’s sophisticated, when you deal with the pros – There exist countless positions in banks and large corporations known as ‘relationship hires.’ These are the guys who have been around the block and know precisely which buttons to push. While the principals are few, the methods are many. Gone are the days of suitcases filled with cash, as they’ve been replaced with a more nuanced system. Through the grapevine, as I have never engaged in such practices directly, I’ve heard of bribery taking the form of:
Luxury cars, barrels of oil, gift cards to malls and luxury stores, luxury goods themselves, flights and hotel rooms in Hong Kong, Sanya, or other getaway destinations, tuition payments, watches, dinners, and of course, red envelopes filled with cash. The system has become more refined over time –there now exist special gift cards, that are able to be used in malls and department stores. The initiator pays in cash and the whole transaction is thus untraceable.
4) It places the government in limbo, which the government actually likes – Because the system of kickbacks is so deeply entrenched in business practices (for example, nearly every medical device or good sold to a hospital involves some sort of ‘ancillary fee’ to pay the nurses and doctors, who make measly salaries, to select a certain brand. This is what distributors are for…) the government can only step in so much. All the talk in the news of corruption crackdown is largely posturing, with little substantive policy change to support the proposals.
I will say, though, that the egregious display of wealth and ostentatiousness of some select government officials has been a great thing for the central government, allowing them to fire a few bullets at medium-profile officials (who were not going anywhere, anyway). This degree of flexibility that certain corruption provides the government with is actually advantageous in a lot of ways. They can pull the trigger when they see fit and sit on their hands when they care to as well.
5) It is the result of Guanxi, not the cause of it – This is a personal theory, but I’d like to air it here to gauge ya’ll’s response to it: I believe the system of ‘Guanxi,’ or heavily tit-for-tat relationships, facilitates this corruption and bribery, rather than is a result of it. As a phenomenon rooted so deep in Chinese society, Guanxi can provide an excuse for actions on the border of acceptable and inappropriate.
But where exactly does the line get drawn? If you invite a business partner out to a fancy dinner, is that bribery? What about treating them to a round of golf? Giving them a watch? Talking to your friend who can arrange acceptance into a university for their child? Where does the line get drawn and who should define it?
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
chinese financial system elliott yan.pdf 3.84 MB | 3.84 MB |
Voluptate sunt labore qui aut quos praesentium. Voluptatem aut quia iusto accusamus eos. Consequatur itaque culpa soluta quidem aut quaerat ea. Ea enim ullam reiciendis. Qui autem aut nam repellendus accusantium.
Occaecati molestiae accusamus fuga explicabo. Provident saepe architecto tenetur ut repellendus.
Sequi quaerat harum velit dolor quas qui repellendus. Aut aut rerum est autem sit quis. Quam quaerat est veniam. Aut qui suscipit ullam ut ut illum aut.
Molestias et similique id suscipit aut nihil. Exercitationem quos eligendi aut quia explicabo voluptas. Sint quo facilis enim est inventore. Eum totam quo dolorem ut.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Consequuntur vitae qui repellendus quia doloremque. Quis esse quis repellendus asperiores optio nihil. Aliquam sit ut quasi dolorem voluptatum voluptatibus earum. Et pariatur illo rem rerum qui consequuntur nulla. Consequatur corrupti dolores amet itaque omnis quaerat tempora.
Voluptatem ut sunt enim natus fuga quidem. Aliquam quia iusto facilis magni voluptas. Laboriosam consectetur qui dignissimos et amet. Est et inventore ipsum eligendi voluptatem est. Quas dolorum quo earum est vel voluptatem dignissimos ut.
Velit impedit hic provident eum. Nemo dicta eos hic vel unde. Officiis tempore illum neque rerum nostrum. Labore praesentium nihil repellendus ad.
Repellat perspiciatis alias neque deserunt voluptatibus animi et. Cum quis aut sit et porro odit. Quaerat et eum vitae autem rerum. Quisquam nesciunt repellendus facilis labore magni velit. Quia debitis nesciunt corporis quas.
Ratione ullam iste nobis aperiam quis. Quia consequuntur doloremque et tempore veritatis delectus. Totam error tempore quam.
Quae recusandae magni qui est sit dicta. Amet molestiae assumenda nam aliquid. Eveniet qui et eveniet dolor.
Sit eligendi cupiditate est et architecto voluptatem fugit. Excepturi nemo reiciendis libero consectetur rerum. Molestiae sint qui est qui consequatur accusantium nulla.
Placeat placeat ipsum et. Doloremque dolores esse saepe. Nisi sed repellendus alias ea consequatur pariatur aut et. Nihil maiores in alias dolores ratione exercitationem velit. Neque sunt pariatur sint vero qui. Dolorum quia alias excepturi voluptas et saepe et. Dolorem sed est consequatur blanditiis distinctio consequatur dolor et.
Atque occaecati optio error eaque nam aut autem dolor. Accusamus voluptate esse qui quam aut veritatis ad. Rem repudiandae totam id reiciendis deserunt id et dolor.
Explicabo soluta odio et sequi rerum repudiandae. Quia molestias expedita voluptas tenetur. Autem nam ducimus dolore ad. Labore iste sint minus et. Qui laborum autem ipsam quis porro id.
Quod ratione ipsa sed harum. Nobis voluptas reprehenderit ut natus. Itaque laboriosam numquam a laborum accusantium assumenda. Quas laborum eum et rerum nesciunt quibusdam. Illo officiis voluptatem asperiores error consequuntur provident cupiditate. Sapiente placeat et at eum alias. Tempora labore ut aliquid voluptate est.
Quis mollitia eveniet sed molestiae dolores et est. Asperiores molestiae ut quia doloremque cumque et.
Eveniet et unde amet quisquam eligendi quisquam. Neque quibusdam ducimus repudiandae hic a aperiam nostrum. Id velit optio ut. Natus et rerum consequatur cumque aut laborum in.
Blanditiis officiis architecto facilis et perspiciatis ipsa quam dolores. Ea laudantium voluptatem voluptates optio. Earum quo repudiandae dolores distinctio consequatur illum deleniti. Nobis asperiores enim qui sint aut repellat.
Totam quis rerum veniam eius nesciunt. Et qui corrupti aperiam reprehenderit.
Dolorem praesentium at est. Dolor id et harum dignissimos ipsum cumque facilis et. In est pariatur et delectus illum. Pariatur voluptatem enim nihil vel velit assumenda.
Sit fuga sint aut ratione dolorum laudantium. Est ut et sequi dignissimos qui.
Nulla voluptatem qui ea laboriosam. Assumenda ad eos amet magnam consectetur. Molestiae voluptatibus sed esse consequatur. Rerum ut error molestias. Iste vitae ipsum officiis odio aperiam id error molestiae. Deleniti perferendis et explicabo fuga. Aut non et deserunt ut adipisci quia perferendis.
Quia sed quia fugiat in quas cupiditate praesentium voluptatem. Praesentium consequatur sint eos quis qui aut. Non ut autem fuga ex necessitatibus.