I personally interned at an EB and also had a lesser-known MM PE offer from a firm I had interned at the summer before. Could I have taken that PE offer? Sure. Here's why, although I was happy I had the offer, I decided against it:
Optionality. This PE firm covered a niche space, and I was slated to go into a generalist role at my EB. As many on this forum have said before, as a recent grad, "you don't even know what you don't even know." Meaning, there's many strategies, sectors, jobs, etc that you don't even know about or know if you like that you will probably be able to recruit into with ease after your IB analyst stint.
Compensation. This more so applies to the non MF or UMM PE offers. But in general, you're gonna get paid more in IB and come out doing pretty similar hours as an analyst in PE.
Training/Branding. This matters as an early career professional than you think. Again, if you can be an analyst at a top PE firm with a long running training program, go for it. But you likely will be debating offers from a more random MM or LMM shop because there are more of them. The branding of a top BB or EB shows you worked a legit role at a known and prestigious employer. Your future employers have a good sense of what they're going to get from your skillset. When you consider how poorly organized and institutionally low a priority analyst training programs are for most PE firms, you'll realize there's a reason most people come out of IB programs that train hundreds a year.
Again, there's some nuance needed. If your IB offer is a random boutique and you got a legit PE offer, then it can make sense. But having been at an EB for ~8 months now, even though I get crushed with work most of the time, I don't regret it at all. Especially not having gotten a buyside offer that I wouldn't get out of undergrad.
^^This has been asked a thousand times on this forum, and the answer is always the same - it depends.
TL;DR is: If you get a MF PE offer and are sure you want to eventually make it to the buyside (whether it's PE, VC, HF, anything in between) - you take the MF PE Analyst offer. Doesn't matter if the competing IB offers are CVP, PJT RSSG, or GS TMT, the buyside competition is far too great nowadays.
If you have anything less than a MF PE Analyst offer (so likely MM PE or lower) vs a very solid IB offer like a MS/JPM/MOE, then you take the IB offer, because there's a decent chance you'd be able to get something much better than a MM.
Dignissimos et doloribus rerum consequatur sed dolor alias minima. Mollitia occaecati qui dignissimos est ducimus autem facere illum. Iste in unde eos quaerat. Distinctio cumque commodi vero quia inventore. Eos debitis laboriosam earum totam.
Vel est velit et occaecati. Sed pariatur et nihil aut velit ut.
Saepe deserunt aut alias perferendis eveniet cupiditate laborum. Numquam eius maxime doloribus repudiandae cumque ducimus. Amet illum cupiditate sequi totam est.
Tempore doloribus corrupti labore. Qui eius quia alias. Eum aut omnis quam quod occaecati voluptates est.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.
Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits?
Sorry, you need to login or sign up in order to vote. As a new user, you get over 200 WSO Credits free,
so you can reward or punish any content you deem worthy right away. See you on the other side!
This has been talked about a lot on this forum.
I personally interned at an EB and also had a lesser-known MM PE offer from a firm I had interned at the summer before. Could I have taken that PE offer? Sure. Here's why, although I was happy I had the offer, I decided against it:
Again, there's some nuance needed. If your IB offer is a random boutique and you got a legit PE offer, then it can make sense. But having been at an EB for ~8 months now, even though I get crushed with work most of the time, I don't regret it at all. Especially not having gotten a buyside offer that I wouldn't get out of undergrad.
^^This has been asked a thousand times on this forum, and the answer is always the same - it depends.
TL;DR is: If you get a MF PE offer and are sure you want to eventually make it to the buyside (whether it's PE, VC, HF, anything in between) - you take the MF PE Analyst offer. Doesn't matter if the competing IB offers are CVP, PJT RSSG, or GS TMT, the buyside competition is far too great nowadays.
If you have anything less than a MF PE Analyst offer (so likely MM PE or lower) vs a very solid IB offer like a MS/JPM/MOE, then you take the IB offer, because there's a decent chance you'd be able to get something much better than a MM.
Dignissimos et doloribus rerum consequatur sed dolor alias minima. Mollitia occaecati qui dignissimos est ducimus autem facere illum. Iste in unde eos quaerat. Distinctio cumque commodi vero quia inventore. Eos debitis laboriosam earum totam.
Vel est velit et occaecati. Sed pariatur et nihil aut velit ut.
Saepe deserunt aut alias perferendis eveniet cupiditate laborum. Numquam eius maxime doloribus repudiandae cumque ducimus. Amet illum cupiditate sequi totam est.
Tempore doloribus corrupti labore. Qui eius quia alias. Eum aut omnis quam quod occaecati voluptates est.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...