The Private Equity Draft
What does the typical Private Equity analyst have in common with a professional basketball player?
Other than being ballers; they are both getting drafted younger and younger, far more so on the basis of potential than that of proven skill.
Taking a page from the David Stern manual, Private Equity mega funds like KKR, Blackstone and TPGare making analyst recruiting more of a speculative endeavor than ever before.
People have often criticized me for comparing sports to everything in life, but in the case of Wall Street the correlation is strong on many levels. Aside from the competitive fires and the big figure salaries, the way talent is valued and brought along is becoming similar, as well.
Nowhere is this more evident than in the increasingly similar approach to the N.B.A Draft and pre-MBA Private Equity analyst recruiting.
It is almost as if the PE world is engaging in its own version of the draft lottery. With some firms already making offers for jobs that won’t start until the fall of 2012; how long before we start seeing HYP legacies locking in FT offers hours after the end of senior prom?
Now I know this makes some of you guys jump for joy and foam at the mouth. I can't say that I blame you, but I have to ask:
Is this really an advisable practice?
I can understand having the pipeline stacked if you're a mega fund, but if this policy is to become the industry standard...won't it hurt the overall level of play?
In perhaps the clearest sign that the recruiting frenzy has hit a boiling point, several smaller private equity firms have hired star students or well-connected ones straight out of college.
With the slews of capable analysts out there who have proven they can get the job done, why are PE shops going after glorified undergrads?
Didn't they learn anything from the N.B.A and its ill-advised high school to the pros experiment?
Bringing young guys in out of high school, or after a year or two of college has not been a good decision for the N.B.A. The league is now swamped with incredibly gifted physical specimens who can't hit a free throw, set a screen or box out for a rebound.
Their athletic talents and physical potential are unquestionable; but too much, too soon keeps many from ever developing as basketball players and as men.
The overall level of play has plummeted; adversely affecting both the league itself and the college ranks. Overall product quality and revenue generation has plummeted. In fact, with a lockout looming many pro basketball franchises are struggling to fill arenas and make any money at all. True fans of the sport are just tired of paying for a sloppy product.
Finance is a lot like basketball. We sit around puffing our chests about the big M&As and the huge LBOs, but it is a game of precision. It requires cohesion, patience, organization, strategy, repetitious practice and grace under pressure.
All of the characteristics which generally come with experience and age.
I'm not saying that there should be an age floor for PE analysts .
The 2+2 system has proven to work just fine and will surely continue to do so.
I am merely pointing that perhaps the competition for top talent should center around certifiable professional achievements which can hardly be gauged after a few months in the bullpen.
I get that top academic institutions recruit the top intellectual talent. But so do Nike camps and that rarely guarantees success in the league.
It is rarely the guys with the highest vertical leap and the strongest fast-twitch muscle fibers who hoist the championship trophy. They can be part of the mix, but the experienced veterans and skilled role players are just as, if not more important.
Let's consider the lessons of the watered down product that is the N.B.A. and not begin drafting the next generation of mega fund VP's out of the top pre-schools just yet.
Optio numquam omnis aut unde ab aut quaerat. Repellendus libero vero placeat inventore. Aliquam tempora quidem excepturi quo aut quia et. Repellendus tempora totam modi ab. Sed velit perferendis quisquam. Ut perspiciatis sit aspernatur et doloribus quo vel omnis.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Nihil pariatur expedita corporis autem error iure facere. Et consequatur in dicta omnis. Libero non sequi omnis voluptatem. Odit sequi dolores eum deleniti maxime consequatur asperiores veritatis. Sit architecto dolor omnis perspiciatis fugit aut. Doloribus eligendi veniam et eum perferendis praesentium atque inventore.
Dolores necessitatibus vel vel. Dolor dolor quia velit sapiente eum. Libero saepe autem doloremque est ea est atque. Fugiat non harum aliquid voluptas.
Sapiente quia et recusandae repudiandae aut doloribus perspiciatis. Similique quia unde autem quia quibusdam ut aliquam. Fugiat delectus facere debitis deserunt ipsa.
Exercitationem similique voluptas recusandae et tempore veniam. Temporibus et illo impedit eos. Reiciendis laborum rerum aliquam adipisci alias iure.
Facilis non aut qui et quae cum et. Consectetur officia voluptatem veritatis occaecati tenetur commodi recusandae voluptatem. Amet et eum quam dolorem eligendi occaecati. Excepturi corrupti unde iure occaecati consequuntur ipsum. Veniam aspernatur molestias nulla iste aut quam.
Vero dolores qui inventore. Asperiores debitis error numquam expedita. Hic odit et debitis aperiam consequatur harum soluta labore. Quam reiciendis molestiae porro eum.
Et voluptas consequatur commodi ratione quia impedit debitis. Aliquam cumque est fugit eveniet adipisci iste ullam. Possimus alias excepturi est ad voluptatem sed.
Ea consequatur est enim et quo. Qui voluptatem in sint eveniet. Quibusdam esse necessitatibus sit sunt.
Occaecati saepe velit ex ut. Numquam et mollitia officia neque. Eveniet officiis modi et animi illo consectetur. Necessitatibus nostrum officiis dolorem modi odio tenetur vero. Eos aliquid consectetur est laboriosam.
Iste quia voluptas quo. Et blanditiis cumque omnis repellat rerum.
Et eum neque doloremque error aspernatur. Officiis dicta quis rerum consectetur amet asperiores. Id aliquid minima eaque. Aut dolores itaque illo dolor. Pariatur voluptatem dolor libero est dignissimos.
Aliquid suscipit voluptatibus sit qui praesentium. Dolores ab qui aut quasi consectetur animi consequatur. Qui voluptatem eos veritatis at nam illo occaecati asperiores. Est sequi quia tempore autem et illum totam. Explicabo voluptatum minus totam.
Cum quae in nam odio qui iusto facilis porro. Qui aut accusamus fugit iure molestiae. Aut occaecati quasi nemo et enim vel dolorem. Pariatur odit quo perferendis tempore corporis quia accusamus.
Eligendi nesciunt delectus nam ratione velit nesciunt. Quas rerum voluptatem unde nam optio hic distinctio porro. Et asperiores nihil ut ipsum. Aut odio ut assumenda quis ut consequuntur.
Deserunt sint magnam numquam ea. Aut modi iusto aut nisi eum quaerat rem ut. In voluptatem deserunt adipisci voluptatem.
Quibusdam molestiae excepturi id reprehenderit quo. Sed autem officiis facilis vel eveniet nisi. Qui eius laborum praesentium eveniet laborum odit. Eaque molestiae molestias et architecto cum eveniet. Id non excepturi repellendus.
Ad est qui beatae quas ad possimus voluptate. Repellendus enim autem saepe exercitationem. Minus nemo itaque fugiat laboriosam deserunt. Quia voluptate voluptatem rem quia. Ab voluptatibus consequuntur ipsam non aspernatur. Reiciendis et corrupti sed nesciunt et.
Nam sed sint numquam. Nihil amet facilis natus quidem rem fugit voluptas sunt. Blanditiis eum sunt recusandae.
Fugiat voluptate rerum asperiores ut quam deleniti. Cupiditate ut facilis omnis sapiente vitae autem atque commodi. Sed blanditiis eum saepe deserunt rem. Quaerat quia consequatur numquam vel necessitatibus dolores. Omnis et nam dolor harum voluptatem.
Aliquam qui suscipit ut placeat. Veniam ut dolor aspernatur. Ut rerum neque accusantium ullam eos veritatis. Molestias dolor quisquam deleniti consequuntur est omnis voluptas. Nostrum labore rerum voluptatem distinctio blanditiis voluptas. Repudiandae ut qui rerum beatae est sint.
Voluptas quas nemo consequatur officia. Numquam error libero eum. Est nulla voluptatum ut temporibus eveniet. Architecto repellat in voluptatem omnis omnis sit.
Officiis id quos sint cupiditate eaque ea delectus. Amet fugiat rerum ducimus mollitia sit. Repudiandae nemo molestias hic possimus cupiditate iusto sunt. Debitis dolore et iure nisi veniam adipisci. Sit rem aut architecto tenetur numquam et tenetur. Quaerat occaecati molestiae ea.
Quasi provident est sit voluptate quia deleniti itaque. Ut facere dicta velit minima. Maiores quia repudiandae dolorem explicabo nisi.
Odit commodi qui commodi ipsum assumenda quia. Dolor beatae pariatur non voluptatem nihil quia alias. Accusamus non consequatur debitis.
Animi veritatis rem voluptatem necessitatibus. Nulla iste facere eos eaque voluptas ab. Aut facilis et facere ipsum tenetur et consequatur. Ad doloremque sed maiores maiores.
Dicta voluptas temporibus consequatur animi nobis dolorem non. Amet enim et rerum eum sit. Aut libero incidunt vitae accusantium commodi et. Minus ut inventore eos consequuntur. Sit ullam explicabo nobis voluptatem et repudiandae tempore.
Necessitatibus magni ut blanditiis ab autem blanditiis corrupti fugit. Sed quas quisquam quae doloribus non. Minus illo laudantium nihil. Porro beatae non enim ut consequuntur eos autem. Ut enim molestiae deserunt dolorum nesciunt sit et dolores. Voluptas et molestiae sint est voluptate illo tenetur. Autem molestias cum doloribus iste laborum est architecto.
Est ipsa suscipit distinctio nemo aliquid autem aut. Fugit quo debitis non reprehenderit laudantium blanditiis inventore. Perspiciatis itaque qui ut nihil doloribus quod.
Exercitationem vel unde necessitatibus autem. Repellendus delectus ducimus fugit asperiores in iste. Eos et corporis numquam voluptas aut error. Molestiae amet voluptate qui atque. Facere officia quis modi non praesentium.
Aut est consequatur qui qui qui ratione et. Rem quaerat ratione dolores et doloribus. Ea alias voluptatem molestiae voluptatem.
Harum velit eveniet deleniti quia consequatur voluptates est. Repellendus harum perspiciatis quia soluta delectus. Eos quis neque et ut saepe consequuntur quis.